Is aldosterone the missing link in refractory hypertension?: aldosterone-torenin ratio as a marker of inappropriate aldosterone activity

Transcription

1 (2002) 16, Nature Publishing Group All rights reserved /02 $ REVIEW ARTICLE Is aldosterone the missing link in refractory hypertension?: aldosterone-torenin ratio as a marker of inappropriate aldosterone activity PO Lim 1, RT Jung 2 and TM MacDonald 3 1 Department of Cardiology, Wales Heart Research Institute, University of Wales College of Medicine, Heath Park, Cardiff CF14 4XN, Wales, UK; 2 Department of Endocrinology, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, University of Dundee, Dundee DD1 9SY, UK; 3 Hypertension Research Centre, Department of Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics, University of Dundee, Dundee, UK Use of the random aldosterone-to-renin ratio (ARR) as a reliable marker of inappropriate aldosterone activity has led to primary aldosteronism (PA) being increasingly diagnosed in hypertensive patients. At least 10% of hypertensives have been found to have PA, the majority of whom presumably have bilateral adrenal hyperplasia or idiopathic hyperaldosteronism as an aetiology for PA. Whilst these patients clearly have excess aldosterone activity, they have in common many features that are found in hypertensive patients in general, amongst which include heightened angiotensin II adre- nal sensitivity. Whether these individuals belong within the spectrum of essential hypertension is being debated, but is probably irrelevant clinically since they appear to respond favourably to spironolactone treatment. In addition, there is recent evidence suggesting that these patients overexpress a key enzyme involved in aldosterone production, the aldosterone synthase, the activity of which appears to relate to its genotypic variation. (2002) 16, DOI: /sj/jhh/ Keywords: primary aldosteronism; aldosterone-to-renin ratio; hypertension Background The prevalence of primary aldosteronism (PA) quoted in most standard medical textbooks is less than 2% within the hypertensive population. This figure is based on the small number of hypertensive patients who exhibit frank hyperaldosteronism with complete laboratory findings of hypokalaemic alkalosis, suppressed renin activity and excessive aldosterone production. The current debate relates to whether hyperaldosteronism could manifest without necessarily fulfilling the above-described triad. Conn 1 who first described PA as a distinct disease entity in 1964 proposed that PA might be diagnosed in the absence of low potassium levels. He enthused that the prevalence of PA could be as high as 20%, since nodules were commonly found in post-mor- Correspondence: Dr PO Lim, British Heart Foundation Clinical Lecturer in Cardiology, Department of Cardiology, Wales Heart Research Institute, University of Wales College of Medicine, Heath Park, Cardiff CF14 4XN, UK. limpo cf.ac.uk This paper has been presented as a debate in the British Hypertension Society Annual Scientific Meeting, Oxford Received 20 August 2001; accepted 11 October 2001 tem examination of adrenal glands obtained from hypertensive subjects. 2 More recently, with the introduction of aldosterone-to-renin ratio (ARR) as a marker of inappropriate aldosterone activity, the need for laboratory excess aldosterone to diagnose PA has also been dropped by some investigators. 3 Furthermore, even within the normal population, plasma aldosterone levels varies widely according to age and salt intake, and subjects with PA may have plasma aldosterone levels falling within a range that is perceived to be normal. 4 To overcome this problem, a functional definition of PA has been adopted, ie the failure of plasma aldosterone to suppress in response to salt loading which confirms the diagnosis without the need to have clearly elevated levels of plasma or urinary aldosterone. 3,5 8 Not surprisingly, this broader definition has caused some controversy, as many more hypertensive patients are included within the bracket of PA, who would in the past have been labelled under the descriptive heading of low renin essential hypertension (LREH).

2 154 High prevalence of primary aldosteronism Previous efforts in using plasma potassium and renin levels to screen for PA were relatively unrewarding Since hypertension could be cured by removing a Conn s adenoma, the emphasis was to look for PA with this specific aetiology in mind. This ignored bilateral adrenal hyperplasia (or idiopathic hyperaldosteronism (IHA)) which was less amenable to surgical treatment unless functional lateralisation could be demonstrated, 11,12 despite being another common cause of PA. The bias against diagnosing IHA was that an obvious clinical syndrome of hyperaldosteronism had to be present followed by exclusion of an adrenal adenoma. 7 This explains the preponderance of PA cases due to Conn s adenoma by two-thirds to three-quarters over and above that of IHA in most PA series prior to the introduction of ARR as a screening test. 6,13 16 However, with the shift in PA definition to that of assessing the lack of aldosterone suppressibility, IHA is more readily diagnosed and the use of ARR 7,17,18 as a screening tool has precipitated this. In fact, hypertensive patients with poorly suppressible aldosterone secretion in response to salt loading were described nearly three decades ago. These subjects would now be diagnosed as having PA Equally important, it is now accepted that Conn s adenoma, which is predominantly made up of fasciculata type cells, is not the only cause of aldosterone-producing-adenoma (APA). APA of glomerulosa type cells has recently been described. 22 The pathophysiology differs depending whether hyperaldosteronism is due to APA made up of fasciculata or glomerulosa type cells. The fasciculata cell type APA is corticotropin-responsive and is associated with production of high levels of hybrid steroids such as 18-hydroxy-cortisol/corticosterone and 18- oxocortisol/corticosterone. 23,24 This is also seen in the much rarer form of PA, the glucocorticoidremediable aldosteronism (GRA). 25 However, the APA of glomerulosa cell type is angiotensin II sensitive, a feature which it shares with IHA and essential hypertension. The ARR is increasingly being adopted to help identify hypertensive patients with possible PA, and its use is the reason why a higher prevalence of PA is being recognised worldwide The use of ARR to detect PA was first proposed in a National of Health Conference in Bethesda, Maryland, USA in At this meeting, Mitchell et al 4 reported that in five patients with PA, the mean ARR was grossly elevated to 2235 (plasma aldosterone pmol/l, plasma renin activity (PRA) ng/ml/hr) in comparison with other hypertension subgroups and normotensive volunteers who had ARRs well below 600 on ad libitum dietary salt intake. Volume loading with 2 litres of saline 0.9% over 4 hours did not significantly alter the ARRs in the control groups, whilst elevating the mean ARR in patients with PA to nearly 7500 thus further increasing the discriminative power of ARR in detecting PA. Hiramatsu et al 30 introduced into clinical practice the use of ARR in screening for PA. They screened 348 untreated hypertensive patients and found that nine patients had ARRs greater than 2085 who proved to have APA with subsequent tests. The ARR in these patients were persistently greater than 1668 despite changes to dietary salt intake and repeat blood tests at different times of the day. In comparison, in 323 patients with essential hypertension, ARRs were persistently less than 556 despite changes in salt intake and drug therapy (hydralazine, methyldopa and -blocker). Gordon et al 31 extended the use of this index to screen for PA and reported that PA might be much more prevalent. This had obvious clinical implications. When ARR was used in an unselected hypertension clinic population, this group was picking up 52 cases of PA per year from Our group in Dundee, like others, initially thought that this high prevalence of PA might be restricted to the Australian population, however between May 1995 and January 1997, we screened 495 hypertension clinic referrals using an ARR threshold of 750. We found 16.6% (77) of 465 patients with complete data for ARR had an elevated ratio. One patient had previously had an APA resected and presented with recurrent hyperaldosteronism. We hospitalised 45 of these patients for the salt loading with fludrocortisone (FST) over 4 days, and 41 out of 45 (91%) had plasma aldosterone 140 pmol/l following FST suggesting PA. One patient with a negative FST was subsequently proved to have a right-sided APA detected on CT scanning and confirmed by adrenal scintigraphy. This screening exercise thus suggested a minimum PA prevalence of 9.2% (43/465) in the Dundee hypertension clinic population. We carried out a further exercise in a general practice and found that 14.4% had ARR 750, and these were the patients with worse blood pressure control despite being on multiple antihypertensive therapy. 32 Others have since reported similarly high prevalence of PA. 29 See Table 1. The controversy of idiopathic hyperaldosteronism Some studies have shown that the body sodium is not expanded in patients with IHA in contrast to those with Conn s adenomas. 33 This finding questioned the validity of IHA as a distinct diagnostic entity, 34 and there was even a suggestion that hyperaldosteronism plays no part in maintaining hypertension in this PA subgroup. 35 Whilst it is undeniable that at one end of the spectrum of IHA cases, the clinical and laboratory features of hyperaldosteronism are clearly present, the lack of an expanded body sodium in some IHA cases is an apparent paradox which can be explained. Experimental studies have shown that sodium retention and volume

3 Table 1 Screening for primary aldosteronism in the hypertensive population using the aldosterone-to-renin ratio 155 Study reference n K + ARR Raised Proven PA Comments threshold ARR (minimum prevalence) Hiramatsu whole range % 2.6% Minimum ARR threshold 556 Hamlet whole range % 8.2% Medical therapy continued Gordon normal % 8.5% 79% on treatment when ARR was measured. 26 with raised ARR with repeat testing. Brown normal % 2.7% Therapy stopped for 3 days Lim whole range % 9.2% Medical therapy continued, single random ARR Rayner whole range % 8.0% 5 APA Loh whole range % 4.6% Plasma aldosterone 417 pmol/l at screening expansion are short-term phenomena with aldosterone excess. The maintenance of hypertension relates more to a raised systemic vascular resistance in the longer term following mineralocorticoid escape Excess sodium would thus eventually be eliminated via pressure natriuresis 40 and the release of natriuretic factors. 41,42 It is likely that the aldosterone effects in IHA are more insidious, allowing these adaptive mechanisms to take place leading to a new body sodium and fluid equilibrium. 43 In an observational study, 39 a patient with IHA who previously responded to spironolactone had this treatment stopped. It was clearly demonstrated that his blood pressure rose together with an expansion in body fluid volume and increased exchangeable sodium as similarly observed in patients with APA. Thus, the lack of demonstrable increased body sodium is of little relevance in deciding whether hyperaldosteronism is present or not. Furthermore, the positive correlation between blood pressure and exchangeable sodium observed in patients with APA 33 reverses if these patients are left untreated for a more prolonged period. 43 Another argument was that, in contrast to resected Conn s adenoma, hyperplastic nodules obtained from patients with IHA do not produce aldosterone in vitro. 33,44 This point is again of little relevance in practice as inappropriate hyperaldosteronism is clearly present in some patients with IHA. This might be related to an enhanced degree of adrenal angiotensin II sensitivity. Furthermore, aldosterone production in Conn s adenoma in vivo relates to corticotropin secretion and this fact could question the autonomous nature of aldosterone secretion which would explain why plasma aldosterone may not always be persistently elevated in some patients with APA. 14 Aldosterone-to-renin ratio as a marker of inappropriate aldosterone activity A single random ARR greater than 1500 almost certainly indicates the presence of hyperaldosteronism. The issue is whether hyperaldosteronism varies in degree within the hypertensive population in general and whether ARR could also be a marker of this. It is known that, within the hypertensive population, the degree of plasma aldosterone suppression in response to salt loading is impaired compared with the normotensive population. 45 Beretta-Piccoli et al 46 reported that body sodium in hypertensive patients changed with age and correlated with blood pressure. Interestingly, these findings had some parallels with regard to ARR when applied to the hypertensive population. Komiya et al 47 observed that ARR related positively to age and plasma sodium concentration in 741 patients with essential hypertension, relationships which were not detectable using plasma aldosterone levels. 48 A recent study reported by Schlaich et al 49 involving young adults with mild hypertension suggested that there was a linear relationship between poor plasma aldosterone suppression with deterioration of left ventricular diastolic function in response to salt loading. This is consistent with the view that the blood pressure effect, 38,50 as well as cardiac adverse effects 51 of aldosterone are salt dependent, or are unmasked only in the presence of excess salt. As mentioned above, plasma aldosterone in itself does not correlate with blood pressure in hypertension. However, we have data that suggest that ARR does correlate with blood pressure in the hypertensive population. 52 In 119 (66 males) hypertensive subjects with mean age of 48 (s.d. 12) years assessed off drug therapy, ARR (log transformed) significantly and positively correlated with 24-h systolic ambulatory blood pressure (r = 0.22, P 0.05) and clinic systolic blood pressure (r = 0.19, P 0.05). As an indicator of inappropriate aldosterone activity the ARR may allow the effect of aldosterone on blood pressure to be evaluated and perhaps guide drug therapy. Aldosterone-to-renin ratio as a guide for drug therapy The PRA response to oral frusemide has been used to guide drug treatment in the past Further

4 156 studies however failed to consistently relate blood pressure lowering effect of many drugs; spironolactone, 56 thiazide diuretics, 57,58 nifedipine, 59 and methydopa 60 to renin status. ARR might be more reliable in this respect in isolating patients with inappropriate aldosterone activity who would respond favourably to aldosterone antagonists. Many patients with PA retain their renin responsiveness, thus the frusemide stimulation test, though specific, lacks sensitivity in detecting PA. This perhaps explains the above conflicting data. 61 We have treated with spironolactone 28 (12 males) hypertensive subjects with a mean age of 55 (s.d. 10) years and ARR greater than 750 who failed to suppress their plasma aldosterone in response to salt loading. 62 These subjects were followed up for a mean period of 12.9 (7) months. Spironolactone in doses of 25 to 50 mg significantly reduced the need for antihypertensive drugs by 0.5 (95% CI 0.1 to 1.0), P = 0.02, as well as reducing blood pressure (systolic blood pressure 15 mm Hg (CI 5 to 25), P = and diastolic blood pressure (mm Hg) by 8 mmhg (CI 4 to 13), P = 0.001). Forty-eight per cent achieved blood pressure 140/90 mm Hg and 13/27 (48%) were treated with spironolactone monotherapy. Three patients complained of breast tenderness and only one patient was intolerant of spironolactone at the doses used. The favourable blood pressure lowering effects of spironolactone in hypertensive patients with a raised ARR has similarly been observed by others. 63 Nevertheless, the results of these observational studies will need to be confirmed in a larger randomised trial. The introduction of more specific mineralocorticoid receptor blockers will perhaps improve drug tolerance for this group of patients in the near future. Conclusions Random ARR is a simple and worthwhile test to help detect hypertensive patients with PA so that optimum management can be offered. One in 10 hypertensives may have PA. Ideally this test should be offered to all patients as this test has a high diagnostic yield, or at the very least should be done in patients with either resistant hypertension or those needing more than two antihypertensive agents for blood pressure control. This strategy will likely result in a reduction in long term morbidity and mortality in many patients with otherwise undiagnosed PA and poor blood pressure control. References 1 Conn JW. Plasma renin activity in primary aldosteronism. JAMA 1964; 90: Longo DL, Esterly JA, Grim CE, Keitzer WF. Pathology of the adrenal gland in refractory low-renin hypertension. Arch Pathol Lab Med 1978; 102: Gordon RD. Mineralocorticoid hypertension. Lancet 1994; 344: Mitchell JR et al. Renin-aldosterone profiling in hypertension. Ann Intern Med 1977; 87: Dunn PJ, Espiner EA. Outpatient screening tests for primary aldosteronism. Aust NZJ Med 1976; 6: Hambling C et al. Primary hyperaldosteronism evaluation of procedures for diagnosis and localization. QJ Med 1993; 86: Young WF, Jr. et al. Primary aldosteronism: diagnosis and treatment. Mayo Clin Proc 1990; 65: Bravo EL et al. The changing clinical spectrum of primary aldosteronism. Am J Med 1983; 74: Jose A, Kaplan NM. Plasma renin activity in the diagnosis of primary aldosteronism: failure to distinguish primary aldosteronism from essential hypertension. Arch Intern Med 1969; 123: Streeten DH, Tomycz N, Anderson GH. Reliability of screening methods for the diagnosis of primary aldosteronism. Am J Med 1979; 67: Banks WA, Kastin AJ, Biglieri EG, Ruiz AE. Primary adrenal hyperplasia: a new subset of primary hyperaldosteronism. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1984; 58: Blumenfeld JD et al. Diagnosis and treatment of primary hyperaldosteronism. Ann Intern Med 1994; 121: Gordon RD et al. Clinical and pathological diversity of primary aldosteronism, including a new familial variety. Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol 1991; 18: Ignatowska-Switalska H et al. Evaluation of plasma aldosterone to plasma renin activity ratio in patients with primary aldosteronism. J Hum Hypertens 1997; 11: Lins PE, Adamson U. Plasma aldosterone-plasma renin activity ratio. A simple test to identify patients with primary aldosteronism. Acta Endocrinol (Copenh) 1986; 113: Weinberger MH, Fineberg NS. The diagnosis of primary aldosteronism and separation of two major subtypes. Arch Intern Med 1993; 153: Lim PO et al. High prevalence of primary aldosteronism in the Tayside hypertensive clinic population. J Hum Hypertens 2000; 14: Gordon RD et al. High incidence of primary aldosteronism in 199 patients referred with hypertension. Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol 1994; 21: Helber A et al. Evidence for a subgroup of essential hypertensives with non-suppressible excretion of aldosterone during sodium loading. Klin Wochenschr 1980; 58: Collins RD et al. Abnormally sustained aldosterone secretion during salt loading in patients with various forms of benign hypertension; relation to plasma renin activity. J Clin Invest 1970; 49: Grim CE, Peters TJ, Maher JF. Low renin hypertension: a state of inappropriate secretion of aldosterone. J Lab Clin Med 1971; 78: Gordon RD, Hamlet SM, Tunny TJ, Klemm SA. Aldosterone-producing adenomas responsive to angiotensin pose problems in diagnosis. Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol 1987; 14: Biglieri EG, Schambelan M. The significance of elevated levels of plasma 18-hydroxycorticosterone in patients with primary aldosteronism. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1979; 49: Gordon RD, Klemm SA, Tunny TJ, Stowasser M. Pri-

5 mary aldosteronism hypertension with a geneticbasis. Lancet 1992; 340: Lifton RP et al. A chimaeric 11 beta-hydroxylase/aldosterone synthase gene causes glucocorticoidremediable aldosteronism and human hypertension. Nature 1992; 355: Brown MA, Cramp HA, Zammit VC, Whitworth JA. Primary hyperaldosteronism: a missed diagnosis in essential hypertensives? Aust NZJ Med 1996; 26: Eng PH et al. Aldosterone to renin ratios in the evaluation of primary aldosteronism. Ann Acad Med Singapore 1997; 26: Kreze A, Jr. et al. Occurrence of primary aldosteronism in a group of ambulatory hypertensive patients. Vnitr Lek 1999; 45: Rayner BL, Opie LH, Davidson JS. Primary hyperaldosteronism: How common is it in patients with severe hypertension? J Hypertens 1999; 17 (Suppl 3): S177[P3.77]. 30 Hiramatsu K et al. A screening test to identify aldosterone-producing adenoma by measuring plasma renin activity. Results in hypertensive patients. Arch Intern Med 1981; 141: Gordon RD et al. How common is primary aldosteronism? Is it the most frequent cause of curable hypertension? J Hypertens Suppl 1993; 11 (Suppl 5): S310 S Lim PO. Primary aldosteronism in general practice. Lancet 1999; 353: Davies DL et al. Aldosterone and its stimuli in normal and hypertensive man: are essential hypertension and primary hyperaldosteronism without tumour the same condition? J Endocrinol 1979; 81: 79P 91P. 34 Brown JJ et al. Are idiopathic hyperaldosteronism and low-renin hypertension variants of essential hypertension? Ann Clin Biochem 1979; 16: Baer L et al. Pseudo-primary aldosteronism. An entity distinct from true primary aldosteronism. Circ Res 1970; 27: Schalekamp MA, Wenting GJ, Man in t Veld AJ. Pathogenesis of mineralocorticoid hypertension. Clin Endocrinol Metab 1981; 10: Wenting GJ, Man in t Veld AJ, Derkx FH, Schalekamp MA. Recurrence of hypertension in primary aldosteronism after discontinuation of spironolactone. Time course of changes in cardiac output and body fluid volumes. Clin Exp Hypertens [A] 1982; 4: Bravo EL. Aldosterone and other adrenal steroids. In: Zanchetti A, Tarazi RC (eds). Handbook of Hypertension. Elsevier Science Publishers: Amsterdam, 1986; pp Distler A, Just HJ, Philipp T. Studies on the mechanism of aldosterone-induced hypertension in man. Clin Sci Mol Med 1973; 45: Firth JD, Raine AE, Ledingham JG. The mechanism of pressure natriuresis. J Hypertens 1990; 8: Gaillard CA et al. Enhanced natriuretic effect of atrial natriuretic factor during mineralocorticoid escape in humans. Hypertension 1988; 12: Yamaji T et al. Plasma levels of atrial natriuretic peptide in primary aldosteronism and essential hypertension. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1986; 63: Wenting GJ, Man in t Veld AJ, Verhoeven RP, Derkx FHM, Schalekamp MADH. Volume-pressure relationships during development of mineralocorticoid hypertension in man. Circ Res 1977; 40: I163 I Kaplan NM. The steroid content of adrenal adenomas and measurements of aldosterone production in patients with essential hypertension and primary aldosteronism. J Clin Invest 1967; 46: Clinical conference: essential hypertension: new concepts about mechanisms. Ann Intern Med 1973; 79: Beretta-Piccoli C et al. Relation of arterial pressure with body sodium, body potassium and plasma potassium in essential hypertension. Clin Sci 1982; 63: Komiya I et al. An abnormal sodium metabolism in Japanese patients with essential hypertension, judged by serum sodium distribution, renal function and the renin-aldosterone system. J Hypertens 1997; 15: Reubi FC, Weidmann P. Relationships between sodium clearance, plasma renin activity, plasma aldosterone, renal hemodynamics and blood pressure in essential hypertension. Clin Exp Hypertens 1980; 2: Schlaich MP et al. Relation between the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system and left ventricular structure and function in young normotensive and mildly hypertensive subjects. Am Heart J 1999; 138: Pedrinelli R. Dietary sodium change in primary aldosteronism. Atrial natriuretic factor, hormonal, and vascular responses. Hypertension 1988; 12: Sato A, Suzuki Y, Saruta T. Effects of spironolactone and angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor on left ventricular hypertrophy in patients with essential hypertension. Hypertens Res 1999; 22: Lim PO, Donnan PT, MacDonald TM. Aldosterone to renin ratio as a determinant of exercise blood pressure response in hypertensive patients. J Hum Hypertens 2001; 15: Carey RM, Douglas JG, Schweikert JR, Liddle GW. The syndrome of essential hypertension and suppressed plasma renin activity. Normalization of blood pressure with spironolactone. Arch Intern Med 1972; 130: Spark RF, Melby JC. Hypertension and low plasma renin activity: presumptive evidence for mineralocorticoid excess. Ann Intern Med 1971; 75: Karlberg BE, Kagedal B, Tegler L, Tolagen K. Renin concentrations and effects of propranolol and spironolactone in patients with hypertension. Br Med J 1976; 1: Sundsfjord JA, Odegaard AE. Renin levels and spironolactone treatment in general practice: similar blood pressure lowering effect of spironolactone in low and normal renin patients. Eur J Clin Invest 1977; 7: Drayer JI et al. Intrapatient comparison of treatment with chlorthalidone, spironolactone and propranolol in normoreninemic essential hypertension. Am J Cardiol 1975; 36: Ferguson RK, Turek DM, Rovner DR. Spironolactone and hydrochlorothiazide in normal-renin and lowrenin essential hypertension. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1977; 21: Henry M, Wehrlen M, Pelletier B, Capron MH. Spironolactone versus nifedipine in essential hypertension. Am J Cardiol 1990; 65: 36K 38K. 60 Solheim SB, Sundsfjord JA, Giezendanner L. The effect of spironolactone (Aldactone) and methyldopa in low and normal renin hypertension. Acta Med Scand 1975; 197:

6 Lim PO, Brennan GM, Jung RT, MacDonald TM. Diagnosing primary aldosteronism with frusemide stimulation test in hypertensive patients with raised aldosterone to renin ratio. Med Biochem 1999; 1: Lim PO, Jung RT, MacDonald TM. Raised aldosterone to renin ratio predicts anti-hypertensive efficacy of spironolactone. A prospective cohort follow-up study. Br J Clin Pharmacol 1999; 48: Brown MJ. Matching the right drug to the right patient in essential hypertension. Heart 2001; 86: Hamlet SM, Tunny TJ, Woodland E, Gordon RD. Is aldosterone/renin ratio useful to screen a hypertensive population for primary aldosteronism? Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol 1985; 12: Loh KC et al. Prevalence of primary aldosteronism among Asian hypertensive patients in Singapore. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2000; 85: