ASSISTED DYING: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT.

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "ASSISTED DYING: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT."

Transcription

1 ASSISTED DYING: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT. November 2014

2 CONTENTS Dispelling the myths Protecting the vulnerable Widespread support Safeguarding medical practice Developing palliative care Reassuring numbers References CONTACT US. Dignity in Dying, 181 Oxford St, London, W1D 2JT Assisted dying: Setting the record straight

3 DISPELLING THE MYTHS. An assisted dying law is needed. The current law does not work turning a blind eye to compassionate amateur assistance to die is no substitute for a safeguarded assisted dying law. The Supreme Court has warned Parliament that this issue must be addressed. Every two weeks somebody from the UK travels to Dignitas to die and for every person that does this, ten more dying people end their lives at home. The Assisted Dying Bill is based on the law in Oregon, USA, which has been operating safely for 17 years; it is not based on the laws in Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg or current practice in Switzerland, which are all much wider in scope and do not contain as many safeguards. Comparison to these laws is misleading. Terminally ill people need the security and protection of a safeguarded law, they also deserve an informed debate when lawmakers are determining what end-of-life choices should be available. In order for this to be achieved some common myths need to be dispelled. 3

4 PROTECTING THE VULNERABLE. MYTH VULNERABLE PEOPLE WOULD BE AT RISK UNDER AN ASSISTED DYING LAW. In jurisdictions where assisted dying is legal there is no evidence that potentially vulnerable groups such as the over-85s, disabled people, people of lower socio-economic status and those with mental health problems are adversely affected. In fact, these groups are underrepresented in the figures for those who have an assisted death. 1 The Assisted Dying Bill would only allow terminally ill, mentally competent adults to have an assisted death. MYTH PEOPLE MIGHT BE PRESSURED OR COERCED INTO CHOOSING AN ASSISTED DEATH. An assisted dying law would empower and protect dying people. Under the current law dying people are potentially vulnerable as there is no investigation into the circumstances of a person s death until after they have died. Under the proposed Bill, two doctors would be required to independently assess the patient and their medical history, including exploring reasons for the request and the possibility of coercion. The patient would have to raise the request themselves and if eligible administer the life-ending medication themselves. The patient would be able to change their mind at any point. MYTH AN ASSISTED DYING LAW WOULD BE THE START OF A SLIPPERY SLOPE. The Assisted Dying Bill is based on the law in Oregon, USA. There have been no cases of abuse of the Oregon law and no calls to widen its limited scope after 17 years of safe practice. Critics quote the laws in Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg but these were much wider in scope than the Assisted Dying Bill when they were introduced. Unlike the laws in the Benelux countries, the Assisted Dying Bill would not legalise voluntary euthanasia, nor would it legalise assisted suicide for people who are not terminally ill. The law you enact is the law you get. MYTH IN BELGIUM CHILDREN CAN RECEIVE ASSISTANCE TO DIE, THIS COULD HAPPEN IN THIS COUNTRY. The Assisted Dying Bill is not in any way based on the law in Belgium. Only mentally competent, terminally 4 Assisted dying: Setting the record straight

5 ill adults who meet all the eligibility criteria and safeguards would be able to receive assistance to die under the Assisted Dying Bill. MYTH PEOPLE IN OREGON WHO ARE DEPRESSED HAVE HAD AN ASSISTED DEATH. A level of appropriate sadness is normal in terminally ill patients. 2 An inconclusive study from Oregon found that whilst some requesting patients presented some symptoms associated with depression, the indicators used to measure depression in the study were also the side effects of many typical terminal illnesses (loss of appetite, fatigue and difficulty sleeping). 3 The safeguards of an assisted dying law mean that dying people who may have depressive disorders would be identified and referred to an appropriate specialist. Where there is any doubt about whether a person has mental capacity, assisted dying would not be granted. MYTH IF TERMINALLY ILL PEOPLE SHOULD NOT SUFFER, WHY SHOULD A CHANGE IN THE LAW NOT APPLY TO THE CHRONICALLY ILL? The Assisted Dying Bill focusses on the subjective quality of a person s death, not the quality of a person s life. Restricting an assisted dying law to people who are not expected to live longer than six months allows the upfront criteria of the law to be clearly defined, which in turn means the law can be safeguarded and vulnerable people protected. People who request assisted dying do not want to die, they want choice and control over the manner and timing of their death. Under the proposed Bill, 2 DOCTORS would be required to independently assess the patient 5

6 WIDESPREAD SUPPORT. MYTH POLLS SHOW THAT WHEN PEOPLE ARE PRESENTED WITH EVIDENCE, SUPPORT FOR ASSISTED DYING FALLS. Polling shows that when presented with both sides of the argument, a large majority (69%) of people continue to support assisted dying and opposition to a change in the law does not rise. 4 The opinion poll commissioned by CARE (Christian Action Research and Education) used to justify the claim that support falls only contains arguments opposing assisted dying and is therefore neither a reliable nor balanced representation of the debate. 5 MYTH RELIGIOUS PEOPLE ARE OPPOSED TO ASSISTED DYING. Only 18% of people who identify themselves as religious oppose a change in the law on assisted dying. 6 A number of senior religious figures such as the former Archbishop of Canterbury Lord Carey, and Archbishop Desmond Tutu have spoken out in support of assisted dying. MYTH DISABLED PEOPLE ARE OPPOSED TO ASSISTED DYING. 79% of disabled people support assisted dying. 7 Disabled people would not be eligible for assistance to die under the Assisted Dying Bill unless they were terminally ill and met all of the safeguards. A number of well-known disabled people such as Professor Stephen Hawking have spoken out in support of assisted dying. MYTH THE MEDICAL PROFESSION IS OPPOSED TO ASSISTED DYING. Medical opinion is divided, yet 57% of doctors feel that assisted dying legislation with upfront safeguards would be the best way to protect terminally ill patients who want to die. 8 Furthermore, 40% of GPs would want the choice of an assisted death for themselves. 9 61% of GPs think that medical bodies should adopt a position of neutrality on assisted dying. 9 The Royal College of Nursing, Royal College of Psychiatrists and Royal Society of Medicine all have a neutral position on the issue. The fact is that I have changed my mind. The old philosophical certainties have collapsed in the face of the reality of needless suffering LORD CAREY 6 Assisted dying: Setting the record straight

7 SAFEGUARDING MEDICAL PRACTICE. MYTH ASSISTED DYING WOULD VIOLATE THE HIPPOCRATIC OATH. The Hippocratic Oath is generally considered incompatible with contemporary medicine and has widely been replaced by the Declaration of Geneva. A conscientious objection clause in the Assisted Dying Bill means that healthcare professionals who do not want to participate in the assisted dying process can choose not to. MYTH ASSISTED DYING WOULD DAMAGE DOCTOR- PATIENT RELATIONSHIPS. The dying person would have to raise the issue of assisted dying themselves. An assisted dying law would promote detailed discussion between patient and doctor about end-of-life care and treatment choices. In Oregon, only 1 in 10 terminally ill patients who discuss assisted dying with their doctor go on to take the life-ending medication. 10 USA OREGON In Oregon, only 1 IN 10 terminally ill patients who discuss assisted dying with their doctor go on to take the life-ending medication 7

8 SAFEGUARDING MEDICAL PRACTICE. CONT MYTH A CHANGE IN THE LAW WOULD MAKE IT EASIER FOR DOCTORS LIKE HAROLD SHIPMAN TO KILL PATIENTS. Harold Shipman was a convicted murderer. His crimes have nothing to do with a change in the law on assisted dying. Furthermore, patients are already being assisted to die. Approximately 1,000 people die every year in the UK through illegal and unregulated voluntary euthanasia. 11 A recent survey found that 37% of doctors believe there are circumstances where some healthcare professionals in the UK are actively assisting terminally ill patients to die. 8 Legislating for this practice would provide much needed upfront safeguards that would protect patients and healthcare professionals. MYTH DOCTORS CANNOT ACCURATELY PREDICT IF SOMEONE IS EXPECTED TO DIE WITHIN 6 MONTHS. Assessing a person s life expectancy is something that is routinely asked of doctors in many areas of their work. Evidence shows that where there are errors in prognosis they are far more likely to be over-estimates of life expectancy. 12 The assumption underlying concerns around prognosis is that patients are eager to die. This is not true, illustrated by the fact that in Oregon assisted dying patients wait an average of 7 weeks between their first request and ingesting the lifeending medication. Additionally, 40% of the patients who are eligible and get the life-ending medication do not take it, rather they die from their underlying illness Assisted dying: Setting the record straight

9 DEVELOPING PALLIATIVE CARE. MYTH AN ASSISTED DYING LAW WOULD NEGATIVELY IMPACT PALLIATIVE CARE. There is no evidence that assisted dying laws negatively impact the development of palliative care. Oregon is rated amongst the best states in the USA for the quality of palliative care % of patients who have an assisted death in Oregon are enrolled in hospice care. 14 The Oregon Hospice Association initially opposed assisted dying, but later acknowledged that: There is no evidence that assisted dying has undermined Oregon s end-of life care or harmed the interests of vulnerable people % Of patients who have an assisted death in Oregon are enrolled in hospice care MYTH IF PALLIATIVE CARE IS IMPROVED THERE WOULD BE NO NEED FOR ASSISTED DYING. Many dying people still suffer despite receiving the best possible palliative care. Research shows that even in hospices approximately 2% of dying people receive no relief of pain in the last three months of their life. 16 However, suffering encompasses much more than just pain. Loss of autonomy, being less able to engage in enjoyable activities and loss of dignity are the most frequently cited reasons for requesting an assisted death in Oregon, and these cannot necessarily be relieved by supportive or palliative care. MYTH A DIGNIFIED DEATH CAN BE ACHIEVED THROUGH PALLIATIVE SEDATION. Concepts of dignity are subjective. Many terminally ill people do not want to die in what they see as a medically induced coma, they want choice and control at the end of life, and to be able to communicate with loved ones as they approach their final moments. Why exit in the fog of sedation when there s the alternative of being alert and truly present with loved ones? LORD DHOLAKIA. 9

10 REASSURING NUMBERS. MYTH AN ASSISTED DYING LAW WOULD RESULT IN MORE PEOPLE DYING. No more people would die but fewer people would suffer. Using data from Oregon we estimate that there would be approximately 1,000 assisted deaths in England and Wales each year. 13 This equates to one death every 8 to 9 years per GP practice. MYTH THE NUMBER OF ASSISTED DEATHS HAS INCREASED RAPIDLY IN STATES IN THE USA WHERE ASSISTED DYING IS LEGAL. Claims that there have been significant increases in the number of people having an assisted death obscure the fact that when legislation is passed the number of people using the law is extremely low. In Oregon, following a small and steady increase, figures have stabilised over the past five years. In states in the USA where assisted dying is legal, assisted deaths account for approximately 0.25% of total deaths Assisted dying: Setting the record straight MYTH THERE IS NO NEED TO CHANGE THE LAW FOR SUCH A SMALL NUMBER OF PEOPLE. Although the number of assisted deaths would be relatively small, the number of people that would take comfort from knowing that the option is there if they need it is much higher. In Oregon, 1 in 6 dying people speak openly with their friends and family about the option of assisted dying, yet only 1 in 500 go on to request assisted dying and take the life-ending medication % Have an assisted death. 1 IN 6 Dying people in Oregon speak openly to friends and family about whether assisted dying might comfort them.

11 REFERENCES. 1. Battin et al (2007) Legal physicianassisted dying in Oregon and the Netherlands: evidence concerning the impact on patients in vulnerable groups J. Med. Ethics 2007;33; Ganzini L, Dobscha S (2003) If it isn t depression Journal of Palliative Medicine 6(6): Ganzini L, Goy E, Dobscha S (2008) Prevelance of depression and anxiety in patients requesting physicians aid in dying: cross sectional survey BMJ 4. YouGov (2014) 5. ComRes (2014) 6. YouGov (2013) 7. YouGov (2013) 8. Medix (2014) 9. medeconnect (2014) 10. Oregon Health Authority Oregon s Death with Dignity Act (2014) and Tolle et al (2004) Characteristics and Proportion of Dying Oregonians Who Personally Consider Physician-Assisted Suicide The Journal of Clinical Ethics 15(2): Seale C (2009) End-of-life decisions in the UK involving medical practitioners Palliative Medicine 23: Christakis NA & Lamont EB (2000), Extent and determinants of error in doctors prognosis in terminally ill patients: prospective cohort study, BMJ; 320: and Stiel et al (2010) Evaluation and comparison of two prognostic scores and the physicians estimate of survival in terminally ill patients Supportive Cancer Care 18: Morrison RS, Meier DE, Augustin R, Souvanna P (2011) America s Care of Serious Illness: A state-by-state Report Card on Access to Palliative Care in our Nation s Hospitals Joint publication by Centre to Advance Palliative Care and National Palliative Care Research Centre 14. Oregon Health Authority Oregon s Death with Dignity Act (2014) 15. Jackson A/Oregon Hospice Association (2006) The reality of assisted dying in Oregon APPG on Compassion in Dying, House of Lords, Office of National Statistics. (2013, July). National Bereavement Survey VOICES Q31 Retrieved from ons.gov.uk/ons/publications/re-referencetables.html?edition=tcm%3a Oregon Health Authority Oregon s Death with Dignity Act (2014) and Washington State Department of Health Death with Dignity Act Report (2014) 18. Tolle et al (2004) Characteristics and Proportion of Dying Oregonians Who Personally Consider Physician-Assisted Suicide The Journal of Clinical Ethics 15(2):

12 CONTACT US. Dignity in Dying, 181 Oxford St, London, W1D 2JT

ASSISTED DYING: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT.

ASSISTED DYING: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT. ASSISTED DYING: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT. August 2015 DISPELLING THE MYTHS. 82% OF THE GENERAL PUBLIC 79% OF RELIGIOUS PEOPLE 86% OF DISABLED PEOPLE SUPPORT THE CHOICE OF ASSISTED DYING FOR TERMINALLY

More information

Medical Aid-in-Dying 4348 Waialae Avenue #927 Honolulu, HI phone CompassionAndChoices.org

Medical Aid-in-Dying 4348 Waialae Avenue #927 Honolulu, HI phone CompassionAndChoices.org Medical Aid-in-Dying 4348 Waialae Avenue #927 Honolulu, HI 96816 800 247 7421 phone CompassionAndChoices.org What Is Medical Aid in Dying? Medical aid in dying is a safe and trusted medical practice in

More information

Ethics, Euthanasia, and Education. B Robert September 30, 2015

Ethics, Euthanasia, and Education. B Robert September 30, 2015 B Robert September 30, 2015 Definitions Summary of decision Ethical implications for physicians Discussion Definitions Euthanasia the administration of lethal drugs with the explicit intention of ending

More information

Physician Assisted Death and Voluntary Active Euthanasia

Physician Assisted Death and Voluntary Active Euthanasia Physician Assisted Death and Voluntary Active Euthanasia Ken Brummel-Smith, MD Charlotte Edwards Maguire Professor of Geriatrics Florida State University College of Medicine 1 Definitions Physician-Assisted

More information

Bonnie Steinbock, PhD University at Albany (emerita) Distinguished Visiting Professor, CUHK Centre for Bioethics Dying Well Workshop 2 2 nd December,

Bonnie Steinbock, PhD University at Albany (emerita) Distinguished Visiting Professor, CUHK Centre for Bioethics Dying Well Workshop 2 2 nd December, Bonnie Steinbock, PhD University at Albany (emerita) Distinguished Visiting Professor, CUHK Centre for Bioethics Dying Well Workshop 2 2 nd December, 2015 Includes both physician-assisted suicide (PAS)

More information

Understanding Medical Aid in Dying

Understanding Medical Aid in Dying Understanding Medical Aid in Dying REBECCA THOMAN, M.D. COMPASSION & CHOICES Relevant to the content of this CME activity, Dr. Thoman indicated she has no financial relationships to disclose. Who We Are

More information

Physician aid in dying: Where do we stand?

Physician aid in dying: Where do we stand? Physician aid in dying: Where do we stand? N. Rose Gaston, MSW, LGSW St. Croix Hospice Learning objectives To develop a better understanding of PAD legislation and practice. To become aware of the attitudes

More information

ASSISTED DYING IN OREGON

ASSISTED DYING IN OREGON ASSISTED DYING IN OREGON Twenty years of a safe and effective law The Death with Dignity Act is widely considered a success in Oregon. It s part of how the state defines itself: as pioneering, stubbornly

More information

Support for the End-of-Life Option Act: Improving Care and Promoting Choice at the End of Life. Michael J Strauss, MD, MPH

Support for the End-of-Life Option Act: Improving Care and Promoting Choice at the End of Life. Michael J Strauss, MD, MPH Support for the End-of-Life Option Act: Improving Care and Promoting Choice at the End of Life Michael J Strauss, MD, MPH 1 Summary The Act has strong provisions to protect patients. The act will relieve

More information

Euthanasia Philosophy of Medical Ethics series

Euthanasia Philosophy of Medical Ethics series Philosophy of Medical Ethics series Program Support Notes by: Laura Beilby Teacher of Philosophy and Religion Produced by: Classroom Video Ltd Commissioning Editor: Dee Powell Classroom Video Ltd 2011

More information

Background. Yet, as a nation, we find it hard to talk about and harder still to help people dealing with a bereavement.

Background. Yet, as a nation, we find it hard to talk about and harder still to help people dealing with a bereavement. A better grief 2 A better grief Background We all experience bereavement and grief at some stage in our lives. Seventy-two per cent of us have been bereaved at least once in the last five years, according

More information

End-of-life decisions

End-of-life decisions Ethics End-of-life decisions Views of the BMA Contemporaneous and advance refusal of treatment Withholding and withdrawing life-prolonging medical treatment Assisted dying: euthanasia & assisted suicide

More information

Responding to Requests for Hastened Death. Dr Douglas McGregor Medical Director Victoria Hospice December 7 th 2015, UBC Division of Palliative Care

Responding to Requests for Hastened Death. Dr Douglas McGregor Medical Director Victoria Hospice December 7 th 2015, UBC Division of Palliative Care Responding to Requests for Hastened Death Dr Douglas McGregor Medical Director Victoria Hospice December 7 th 2015, UBC Division of Palliative Care June 2014 February 2015 BUT Tuesday 1 st December Quebec

More information

PUBLIC BRIEFING ON THE APM S POSITION ON ASSISTED SUICIDE

PUBLIC BRIEFING ON THE APM S POSITION ON ASSISTED SUICIDE PUBLIC BRIEFING ON THE APM S POSITION ON ASSISTED SUICIDE The Association for Palliative Medicine represents over a 1000 specialist doctors in the UK working in hospices and the NHS. We remain overwhelmingly

More information

Responding to Requests for Hastened Death in an Environment Where the Practice is Legally Prohibited

Responding to Requests for Hastened Death in an Environment Where the Practice is Legally Prohibited Responding to Requests for Hastened Death in an Environment Where the Practice is Legally Prohibited Timothy E. Quill MD, MACP, FAAHPM Palliative Care Division, Department of Medicine Rochester, New York

More information

In Search of Gentle Death: The Fight for Your Right to Die with Dignity

In Search of Gentle Death: The Fight for Your Right to Die with Dignity Page 1 of 5 In Search of Gentle Death: The Fight for Your Right to Die with Dignity Richard N. Côté Mt. Pleasant, SC, Corinthian Books, 2012, xiv + 405 pp., US$29.95, ISBN 9781929175369 hbk, 9781929175437

More information

Medical Aid in Dying A Year of Change

Medical Aid in Dying A Year of Change Medical Aid in Dying A Year of Change Howard Lim, MD, PhD, FRCPC Chair, Gastrointestinal Tumour Group Program Director, Medical Oncology Residency Training Program Clinical Associate Professor, University

More information

Consultation on Legislative Options for Assisted Dying

Consultation on Legislative Options for Assisted Dying Consultation on Legislative Options for Assisted Dying A submission to the External Panel by the Canadian Hospice Palliative Care Association October 9, 2015 Sharon Baxter Executive Director Sbaxter@bruyere.org

More information

STATEMENT OF THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF SUICIDOLOGY: SUICIDE IS NOT THE SAME AS PHYSICIAN AID IN DYING

STATEMENT OF THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF SUICIDOLOGY: SUICIDE IS NOT THE SAME AS PHYSICIAN AID IN DYING Executive summary The American Association of Suicidology recognizes that the practice of physician aid in dying, also called physician assisted suicide, Death with Dignity, and medical aid in dying, is

More information

Integration of MAID into Palliative Care

Integration of MAID into Palliative Care Integration of MAID into Palliative Care James Downar, MDCM, MHSc (Bioethics), FRCPC Critical Care and Palliative Care, University Health Network and Sinai Health System Associate Professor, Dept. of Medicine,

More information

Legislative Background: Medical Assistance in Dying (Bill C-14, as Assented to on June 17, 2016)

Legislative Background: Medical Assistance in Dying (Bill C-14, as Assented to on June 17, 2016) Legislative Background: Medical Assistance in Dying (Bill C-14, as Assented to on June 17, 2016) JUNE 2016 Information contained in this publication or product may be reproduced, in part or in whole, and

More information

Prof Kamm s discussion

Prof Kamm s discussion Tse Chun Yan Prof Kamm s discussion Justifies PAS by three arguments: The Four-Step Argument The Alternative Four-Step Argument The Eliminative Argument Prof Kamm s discussion Disagrees with Gorsuch in

More information

The Business Committee of the Thirty-first General Synod has recommended this proposed resolution be sent to a Committee of the General Synod.

The Business Committee of the Thirty-first General Synod has recommended this proposed resolution be sent to a Committee of the General Synod. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 The Business Committee of the Thirty-first General Synod has recommended this

More information

David Campbell, PhD Ethicist KHSC Palliative Care Rounds April 20, 2018

David Campbell, PhD Ethicist KHSC Palliative Care Rounds April 20, 2018 David Campbell, PhD Ethicist KHSC Palliative Care Rounds April 20, 2018 Explore the ethical arguments for and against respecting Advance Directive requests for MAID Identify the philosophical complexities

More information

MEDICAL ASSISTANCE IN DYING: LEGAL FACTS ON THE THREE OUTSTANDING AREAS

MEDICAL ASSISTANCE IN DYING: LEGAL FACTS ON THE THREE OUTSTANDING AREAS 1 MEDICAL ASSISTANCE IN DYING: LEGAL FACTS ON THE THREE OUTSTANDING AREAS Executive summary While the Federal Government set out the circumstances under which persons can access medical assistance in dying

More information

Bill C-407: An Act to Amend the Criminal Code (Right to Die with Dignity)

Bill C-407: An Act to Amend the Criminal Code (Right to Die with Dignity) Bill C-407: An Act to Amend the Criminal Code (Right to Die with Dignity) CANADIAN BAPTIST MINISTRIES INFORMATION BULLETIN and DISCUSSION PAPER Prepared by Lois Mitchell (PhD) Public Witness and Social

More information

SAMPLE. Certificate in the Principles of End of Life Care PALLIATIVE CARE. Workbook 1. NCFE Level 2 ADVANCE CARE PLANNING COMMUNICATION SKILLS

SAMPLE. Certificate in the Principles of End of Life Care PALLIATIVE CARE. Workbook 1. NCFE Level 2 ADVANCE CARE PLANNING COMMUNICATION SKILLS NCFE Level 2 Certificate in the Principles of End of Life Care COMMUNICATION SKILLS UNDERSTANDING GRIEF AND LOSS PALLIATIVE CARE CARE PLANNING CYCLE ADVANCE CARE PLANNING Workbook 1 This section of the

More information

Experience internationally of the legalisation of assisted dying on the palliative care sector

Experience internationally of the legalisation of assisted dying on the palliative care sector PALLIATIVE CARE AUSTRALIA Experience internationally of the legalisation of assisted dying on the palliative care sector FINAL REPORT 28 October 2018 212 Clarendon Street East Melbourne Victoria 3002 I

More information

SUBMISSION ON EXPOSURE DRAFT OF THE MEDICAL SERVICES (DYING WITH DIGNITY) BILL Prepared by COTA National Office

SUBMISSION ON EXPOSURE DRAFT OF THE MEDICAL SERVICES (DYING WITH DIGNITY) BILL Prepared by COTA National Office SUBMISSION ON EXPOSURE DRAFT OF THE MEDICAL SERVICES (DYING WITH DIGNITY) BILL 2014 Prepared by COTA National Office August 2014 COTA Australia GPO Box 1583 Adelaide SA 5001 08 8232 0422 www.cota.org.au

More information

Dugan, Andrew. In U.S., Support Up for Doctor-Assisted Suicide. Gallup Inc. Gallup, 27 May Web. 7 Jan Terminology. Death with Dignity.

Dugan, Andrew. In U.S., Support Up for Doctor-Assisted Suicide. Gallup Inc. Gallup, 27 May Web. 7 Jan Terminology. Death with Dignity. Dugan, Andrew. In U.S., Support Up for Doctor-Assisted Suicide. Gallup Inc. Gallup, 27 May 2015. Web. 7 Jan 2017. Terminology. Death with Dignity. Death with Dignity National Center and Death with Dignity

More information

in March, The Oregon Death With Dignity Act passed a referendum in November,

in March, The Oregon Death With Dignity Act passed a referendum in November, SAMPLE ARGUMENTATION PAPER (p. 66) Research Question: Should assisted suicide be legal? Assisted Suicide: Rights and Responsibilities A woman suffering from cancer became the first person known to die

More information

End-of-life decisions

End-of-life decisions End-of-life decisions Views of the BMA August 2009 Background to BMA policies Contemporaneous requests for and refusal of treatment Incapacitated patients Proxy decision-makers Advocates/IMCAs Advance

More information

Talking Points on Assisted Suicide Legislation (These may be helpful for brief bulletin ads and pastor s columns.)

Talking Points on Assisted Suicide Legislation (These may be helpful for brief bulletin ads and pastor s columns.) Talking Points on Assisted Suicide Legislation (These may be helpful for brief bulletin ads and pastor s columns.) The term death with dignity is insulting and biased. There is nothing remotely undignified

More information

2. Euthanasia Bill to be Brought to House Sooner Rather than Later says Quebec MP

2. Euthanasia Bill to be Brought to House Sooner Rather than Later says Quebec MP 1. First in Australia, now perhaps Germany - ERGO 2. Euthanasia Bill to be Brought to House Sooner Rather than Later says Quebec MP - LifeSite News 3. After death: then what? - The Times(UK) 4. Chain of

More information

Death with dignity: the debate in England

Death with dignity: the debate in England Death with dignity: the debate in England Anne Slowther Associate Professor Clinical Ethics Warwick Medical School The concept articulated in the title of this conference, death with dignity can have many

More information

alone seen a corpse. The case of Monica was very different. For the first time, I became

alone seen a corpse. The case of Monica was very different. For the first time, I became Maia Lauria Issues of Life and Death Ethical Reflection Hospice and Palliative Care I first stumbled upon the issue of palliative care during a particularly hard time in my life. I was twenty years old,

More information

2017 National Association of Social Workers. All Rights Reserved. 1

2017 National Association of Social Workers. All Rights Reserved. 1 2017 National Association of Social Workers. All Rights Reserved. 1 Palliative Care 101 for Social Workers in Aging Karen Bullock, PhD, LCSW June 15, 2017 NASW Virtual Conference Learning Objectives Overview

More information

THE WORLD MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, INC. WMA STATEMENT ON ORGAN AND TISSUE DONATION

THE WORLD MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, INC. WMA STATEMENT ON ORGAN AND TISSUE DONATION THE WORLD MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, INC. WMA STATEMENT ON ORGAN AND TISSUE DONATION Adopted by the 63rd WMA General Assembly, Bangkok, Thailand, October 2012 PREAMBLE Advances in medical sciences, especially

More information

Advance Statements. What is an Advance Statement? Information Line: Website: compassionindying.org.uk

Advance Statements. What is an Advance Statement? Information Line: Website: compassionindying.org.uk Information Line: 0800 999 2434 Website: compassionindying.org.uk This factsheet explains what an Advance Statement is and how to make one. It is for people living in England and Wales. If you live in

More information

Considering MAID in Severe, Refractory Mental Illness

Considering MAID in Severe, Refractory Mental Illness Considering MAID in Severe, Refractory Mental Illness September 15, 2017 Justine Dembo, MD, FRCPC Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre Lecturer, University of Toronto Justine.dembo@mail.utoronto.ca Disclosures

More information

Deciding whether a person has the capacity to make a decision the Mental Capacity Act 2005

Deciding whether a person has the capacity to make a decision the Mental Capacity Act 2005 Deciding whether a person has the capacity to make a decision the Mental Capacity Act 2005 April 2015 Deciding whether a person has the capacity to make a decision the Mental Capacity Act 2005 The RMBI,

More information

Assisted dying on the basis of suffering

Assisted dying on the basis of suffering Assisted dying on the basis of suffering concerns, from mental illness Legitimate specious arguments Mind, Medicine & Morals the ethics of psychiatry and mental health care, Graduate papers session, July

More information

Author s response to reviews. Title: Attitudes towards assisted dying are influenced by question wording and order: a survey experiment.

Author s response to reviews. Title: Attitudes towards assisted dying are influenced by question wording and order: a survey experiment. Author s response to reviews Title: Attitudes towards assisted dying are influenced by question wording and order: a survey experiment Authors: Morten Magelssen (magelssen@gmail.com) Magne Supphellen (Magne.Supphellen@nhh.no)

More information

Active and Passive Euthanasia

Active and Passive Euthanasia Active and Passive Euthanasia 1. Active vs. Passive Euthanasia: Imagine two cases: Withdrawn Treatment Jack is suffering from a terminal disease. He has two weeks to live, and is in extreme, incurable

More information

OREGON HOSPICE ASSOCIATION

OREGON HOSPICE ASSOCIATION OREGON HOSPICE ASSOCIATION DEMENTIA DILEMMA: The Good, The Bad & The Maybe Sue D. Porter, MBA, MSB Founding Executive Director PEACEFUL DEATH DIGNITY CHOOSE OWN TERMS COMFORT NO PAIN CONTROL TIMING END-OF-LIFE

More information

Medical Oncology Group of Australia position statement and membership survey on voluntary assisted dying

Medical Oncology Group of Australia position statement and membership survey on voluntary assisted dying doi:10.1111/imj.13951 Medical Oncology Group of Australia position statement and membership survey on voluntary assisted dying Christos S. Karapetis, 1,2 Brian Stein, 3,4 Bogda Koczwara, 1 Rosemary Harrup,

More information

In Support of Physician Assistance in Dying

In Support of Physician Assistance in Dying 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 The Executive Council has recommended this resolution be considered in the

More information

End-of-Life Decision-Making

End-of-Life Decision-Making End-of-Life Decision-Making Ian Anderson Continuing Education Program in End-of of-life Care Sense of Self and Decision-Making! Our sense of self is shaped by our families, past experiences, our sense

More information

The Palliative Care Journey. By Sandra O Sullivan Clinical Nurse Manager 1 St Luke's home

The Palliative Care Journey. By Sandra O Sullivan Clinical Nurse Manager 1 St Luke's home The Palliative Care Journey By Sandra O Sullivan Clinical Nurse Manager 1 St Luke's home Aims 1. To provide an overview of what palliative care involves. 2. Identify, at what stage should Dementia be acknowledged

More information

Death and Dying. Thanatology

Death and Dying. Thanatology Death and Dying Thanatology Study of death and dying, especially the social and emotional aspects It reveals: the reality of hope in death. choices in dying. affirmation in mourning. reaffirmation of life.

More information

Quality of Life (F309 End of Life) Interpretive Guidance Investigative Protocol

Quality of Life (F309 End of Life) Interpretive Guidance Investigative Protocol 483.25 Quality of Life (F309 End of Life) Interpretive Guidance Investigative Protocol 2 483.25 End of Life Each resident must receive and the facility must provide the necessary care and services to attain

More information

Article ID: WMC00971 ISSN

Article ID: WMC00971 ISSN Article ID: WMC00971 ISSN 2046-1690 Euthanasia Corresponding Author: Mr. Mohamed Najimudeen, Associate Professor, Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Melaka Manipal Medical College, Malaysia, Jalan Batu Hampar,

More information

GENERAL HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS AND SPECIALISTS IN PALLIATIVE CARE: DO THEY FIND EACH OTHER?

GENERAL HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS AND SPECIALISTS IN PALLIATIVE CARE: DO THEY FIND EACH OTHER? GENERAL HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS AND SPECIALISTS IN PALLIATIVE CARE: DO THEY FIND EACH OTHER? Philip J Larkin Professor of Clinical Nursing ( Palliative Care), UCD and Our Lady s Hospice and Care Services,

More information

Catholic Medical Quarterly Volume 61(3) August

Catholic Medical Quarterly Volume 61(3) August CATHOLIC MEDICAL QUARTERLY AUGUST 2011 THE LIVERPOOL DEBATE ON ASSISTED DYING A SPEECH BY LORD ALTON OF LIVERPOOL GIVEN IN NOVEMBER 2010. An unhappy feature of the current assisted dying debate is the

More information

Teaching mobility Iasi

Teaching mobility Iasi Teaching mobility Iasi Véronique Fromont May 2013 RN, MSc 30-5-2013 Program Introduction Structure - Legislation LEIF Care for patient Care for caregiver Students evaluation IP Feedback 30-5-2013 Introduction

More information

Physician Assisted Death (PAD) - Practical and Ethical Implications in the Hospice Setting and in the Home

Physician Assisted Death (PAD) - Practical and Ethical Implications in the Hospice Setting and in the Home 1 Physician Assisted Death (PAD) - Practical and Ethical Implications in the Hospice Setting and in the Home Andrew Mai MD CCFP (PC) Medical Director Hospice Care Ottawa Ethics Symposium on PAD September

More information

End of Life Choice Bill. New Zealand Medical Association. Submission to the Justice Select Committee. February Dr Kate Baddock.

End of Life Choice Bill. New Zealand Medical Association. Submission to the Justice Select Committee. February Dr Kate Baddock. End of Life Choice Bill New Zealand Medical Association Submission to the Justice Select Committee February 2018 Dr Kate Baddock NZMA Chair NZMA PO Box 156 Wellington 6140 Phone: 04 472 4741 nzma@nzma.org.nz

More information

Palliative Care Asking the questions that matter to me

Palliative Care Asking the questions that matter to me Palliative Care Asking the questions that matter to me THE PALLIATIVE HUB Adult This booklet has been developed by the Palliative Care Senior Nurses Network and adapted with permission from Palliative

More information

[Excerpted from: Carter v Canada (Attorney General), 2012 BCSC 886 (CanLII)]

[Excerpted from: Carter v Canada (Attorney General), 2012 BCSC 886 (CanLII)] Impact of Legal Physician-Assisted Dying on Palliative Care [Excerpted from: Carter v Canada (Attorney General), 2012 BCSC 886 (CanLII)] [686] A number of the defendants experts express their concern that

More information

HPNA Position Statement Palliative Sedation at End of Life

HPNA Position Statement Palliative Sedation at End of Life HPNA Position Statement Palliative Sedation at End of Life Background Patients at the end of life may suffer an array of physical, psychological symptoms and existential distress that, in most cases, can

More information

Quality of Life (F309 End of Life) Surveyor Train the Trainer: Interpretive Guidance Investigative Protocol

Quality of Life (F309 End of Life) Surveyor Train the Trainer: Interpretive Guidance Investigative Protocol 483.25 Quality of Life (F309 End of Life) Surveyor Train the Trainer: Interpretive Guidance Investigative Protocol 2 483.25 End of Life Each resident must receive and the facility must provide the necessary

More information

Discussion. Re C (An Adult) 1994

Discussion. Re C (An Adult) 1994 Autonomy is an important ethical and legal principle. Respect for autonomy is especially important in a hospital setting. A patient is in an inherently vulnerable position; he or she is part of a big and

More information

Suicide Prevention Month Community Edition Presented by Aimee Johnson, LCSW & Karon Wolfe, LISW-S

Suicide Prevention Month Community Edition Presented by Aimee Johnson, LCSW & Karon Wolfe, LISW-S Suicide Prevention Month 2017 Community Edition Presented by Aimee Johnson, LCSW & Karon Wolfe, LISW-S 1 Overview Objectives Veterans and VA Facts about suicide Myths/realities about suicide The steps

More information

PART one. The Palliative Care Spectrum: Providing Care Across Settings

PART one. The Palliative Care Spectrum: Providing Care Across Settings PART one The Palliative Care Spectrum: Providing Care Across Settings Chapter 1 An Introduction to Palliative Pharmacy Care Jennifer M. Strickland To palliate means to alleviate. Palliative care, as the

More information

Dementia: involves a progressive loss of cerebral functions. The most common form of dementia is Alzheimer s.

Dementia: involves a progressive loss of cerebral functions. The most common form of dementia is Alzheimer s. Death Forms of Cognitive Disability Locked-In Syndrome: the level and content of consciousness may be normal, but the patient is so severely paralyzed that the patient may appear to have diminished or

More information

Pacific University College of Health Professions Interdisciplinary Case Conference: Palliative Care. March 5, 2010

Pacific University College of Health Professions Interdisciplinary Case Conference: Palliative Care. March 5, 2010 Pacific University College of Health Professions Interdisciplinary Case Conference: Palliative Care March 5, 2010 Learning Objectives Discuss the philosophy of palliative care and the role of various disciplines

More information

Ruth Caleb. Recognising the Importance of Prioritising Mental Wellbeing in Higher Education

Ruth Caleb. Recognising the Importance of Prioritising Mental Wellbeing in Higher Education Recognising the Importance of Prioritising Mental Wellbeing in Higher Education Ruth Caleb Head of Counselling, Brunel University London Chair of the UUK / Mental Wellbeing in HE Working Group What is

More information

Euthanasia, Physician-Assisted Suicide and End of Life Care. Position Statement

Euthanasia, Physician-Assisted Suicide and End of Life Care. Position Statement BACKGROUND Euthanasia, Physician-Assisted Suicide and End of Life Care Position Statement 1. As the peak medical professional society for the healthcare of and advocacy for older people, Euthanasia and

More information

End of Life Option Act: One Year. Susie Crandall Hospice East Bay. CAHSAH CHAPCA Annual Conference & Expo May 22 24, 2018, Monterey, CA

End of Life Option Act: One Year. Susie Crandall Hospice East Bay. CAHSAH CHAPCA Annual Conference & Expo May 22 24, 2018, Monterey, CA End of Life Option Act: One Year Susie Crandall Hospice East Bay Play the 2018 Conference Post to Win Game for a chance to win different prizes each day! 1 Session Objectives 1. Understand what has led

More information

Patient's Rights and End-of-Life Decisions: The Albanian Experience

Patient's Rights and End-of-Life Decisions: The Albanian Experience Article ID: WMC004335 ISSN 2046-1690 Patient's Rights and End-of-Life Decisions: The Albanian Experience Corresponding Author: Mrs. Brunilda Bara, Researcher, Judicial and Documentation Department, Constitutional

More information

Euthanasia. Types of Euthanasia. Types of Euthanasia. Current doctrine (law, AMA) Types of Euthanasia

Euthanasia. Types of Euthanasia. Types of Euthanasia. Current doctrine (law, AMA) Types of Euthanasia QC (Quickly Considered) Definition of death Euthanasia An ethical question, not a medical one. (Why?) What should the criteria be? Once we know that, medical expertise can apply it. What is so essential

More information

living in fear, dying in despair how can we help? MB ChB, FCFP, MSc Pall Med

living in fear, dying in despair how can we help? MB ChB, FCFP, MSc Pall Med living in fear, dying in despair how can we help? LIZ GWYTHER MB ChB, FCFP, MSc Pall Med SAMA CONFERENCE 18 SEPTEMBER 2015 This presentation Palliative care principles Relief of suffering Pain management

More information

Homelessness is associated with poorer physical and mental health, and higher mortality rates 3.

Homelessness is associated with poorer physical and mental health, and higher mortality rates 3. Marie Curie Response Scottish Parliament s Local Government Committee Inquiry into Homelessness Marie Curie believes everyone has the right to palliative care. We believe that there are homeless 1 people

More information

GIVING DEATH A HELPING HAND

GIVING DEATH A HELPING HAND GIVING DEATH A HELPING HAND INTERNATIONAL LIBRARY OF ETHICS, LAW, AND THE NEW MEDICINE Founding Editors DAVID C. THOMASMA DAVID N. WEISSTUB, Université de Montréal, Canada THOMASINE KIMBROUGH KUSHNER,

More information

A Brief Analysis of the Report of the Special Joint Committee on Physician-Assisted Dying

A Brief Analysis of the Report of the Special Joint Committee on Physician-Assisted Dying A Brief Analysis of the Report of the Special Joint Committee on Physician-Assisted Dying On February 25, the Special Joint Committee on Physician-Assisted Dying released its report to Parliament. The

More information

Palliative and end of life care

Palliative and end of life care Palliative and end of life care Position statement Date April 2017 Contents 1. Palliative care... 1 2. Reducing unnecessary and futile treatments... 7 3. Euthanasia (or physician-assisted suicide)... 8

More information

International comparative

International comparative International comparative report on terminal care system Taeko Nakashima Institute for Health Economics and Policy Senior Researcher IHEP Institute for Health Economics and Policy At first Respect to self-determination

More information

Caring Even When We Cannot Cure

Caring Even When We Cannot Cure CHA End-of-Life Guides PALLIATIVE AND HOSPICE CARE: Caring Even When We Cannot Cure The Catholic Health Association has developed this guide in collaboration with physicians, nurses, theologians and ethicists

More information

Consultation on Carers Legislation

Consultation on Carers Legislation Consultation on Carers Legislation Background The Scottish Youth Parliament welcomes the opportunity to respond to these proposals. As the democratically elected voice for Scotland s young people, we seek

More information

Oregon s experience with aid in dying: findings from the death with dignity laboratory

Oregon s experience with aid in dying: findings from the death with dignity laboratory Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. ISSN 0077-8923 ANNALS OF THE NEW YORK ACADEMY OF SCIENCES Issue: Rethinking Mortality: Exploring the Boundaries between Life and Death Oregon s experience with aid in dying: findings

More information

Mental Capacity Implementation Programme. Mental Capacity Act 2005

Mental Capacity Implementation Programme. Mental Capacity Act 2005 Mental Capacity Implementation Programme Mental Capacity Act 2005 The Presentation Is an Overview and Will Cover: Part one - background and key policy Why we needed the act and who it affects The Mental

More information

What happens if I cannot make decisions about my care and treatment?

What happens if I cannot make decisions about my care and treatment? Information Line: 0800 999 2434 Website: compassionindying.org.uk What happens if I cannot make decisions about my care and treatment? This factsheet explains how decisions are made about your care or

More information

Is Medical Assistance In Dying A Platitudinous Medical Treatment? Vatican 2017

Is Medical Assistance In Dying A Platitudinous Medical Treatment? Vatican 2017 Is Medical Assistance In Dying A Platitudinous Medical Treatment? End-of-life decisions: Compassionate use and conscientious objection Prof. Leonid A. Eidelman, MD President-elect, World Medical Association

More information

Decision-Making Capacity

Decision-Making Capacity Decision-Making Capacity At the end of the session, participants will be able to: Know the definition of decision-making capacity; Understand the distinction between decision-making capacity and competency;

More information

However, the SPPC holds the view that in contemplating legislating in this area MSPs should give careful regard to:-

However, the SPPC holds the view that in contemplating legislating in this area MSPs should give careful regard to:- Submission by the Scottish Partnership for Palliative Care to Margo MacDonald MSP s consultation on the proposal for an Assisted Suicide (Scotland) Bill This submission starts by setting out some background

More information

EUTHANASIA, ASSISTED SUICIDE AND THE PROFESSIONAL OBLIGATIONS OF PHYSICIANS

EUTHANASIA, ASSISTED SUICIDE AND THE PROFESSIONAL OBLIGATIONS OF PHYSICIANS EUTHANASIA, ASSISTED SUICIDE AND THE PROFESSIONAL OBLIGATIONS OF PHYSICIANS Lucie White Euthanasia and assisted suicide have proved to be very contentious topics in medical ethics. Some ethicists are particularly

More information

All-Party Parliamentary Group on Motor Neurone Disease

All-Party Parliamentary Group on Motor Neurone Disease All-Party Parliamentary Group on Motor Neurone Disease Inquiry into Access to Specialist Palliative Care for People with Motor Neurone Disease in England Call for Evidence 8 December 2009 Introduction

More information

Submission to the Inquiry into end of life choices in the ACT

Submission to the Inquiry into end of life choices in the ACT Submission to the Inquiry into end of life choices in the ACT Australian Psychological Society APS contact: Heather Gridley Manager, Public Interest h.gridley@psychology.org.au 03 8662 3327 March 2018

More information

BRAIN DEATH. Frequently Asked Questions 04for the General Public

BRAIN DEATH. Frequently Asked Questions 04for the General Public BRAIN DEATH Frequently Asked Questions 04for the General Public Neurocritical Care Society BRAIN DEATH FAQ s FOR THE GENERAL PUBLIC NEUROCRITICAL CARE SOCIETY 1. Q: Why was this FAQ created? A: Several

More information

Palliative Care & Hospice

Palliative Care & Hospice Palliative Care & Hospice Kenneth Brummel-Smith, M.D. Charlotte Edwards Maguire Professor, Department of Geriatrics Florida State University College of Medicine 1 Diane Meier, MD Director, Center to Advance

More information

On Withdrawing Care from the Dying Patient in Israel

On Withdrawing Care from the Dying Patient in Israel On Withdrawing Care from the Dying Patient in Israel Anat Asayag The purpose of this article is to examine the prohibition on stopping continuous medical treatment as decreed by the Dying Patient Act,

More information

A s s i s t e d S u i c i d e & E u t h a n a s i a

A s s i s t e d S u i c i d e & E u t h a n a s i a A s s i s t e d S u i c i d e & E u t h a n a s i a Cape Town - April 18, 2016 St. Mary s Cathedral Pastoral Centre Dr. Jan Jans Associate Professor of Ethics Tilburg School of Humanities Preamble To please

More information

!This booklet is for family and friends of anyone who.!these decisions may be related to treatment they re

!This booklet is for family and friends of anyone who.!these decisions may be related to treatment they re MENTAL CAPACITY ACT INFORMATION What is the Mental Capacity Act? The Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) was implemented by parliament in 2007 and is a vitally important piece of legislation for England and

More information

Essential Palliative Care Skills For Every Clinician

Essential Palliative Care Skills For Every Clinician Essential Palliative Care Skills For Every Clinician Tools for Assessment and Management of Serious Illness for Primary Care Providers Comprehensive Curriculum Self-Paced Fully Online 03012018 Online,

More information

VA Edition 1 S.A.V.E.

VA Edition 1 S.A.V.E. VA Edition 1 S.A.V.E. December 2017 A little housekeeping before we start: Suicide is an intense topic for some people. If you need to take a break, or step out, please do so, with one condition Let me

More information

Hospice Basics and Benefits

Hospice Basics and Benefits Hospice Basics and Benefits Goal To educate health care professionals about hospice basics and the benefits for the patient and family. 2 Objectives Describe the history and philosophy of the hospice movement

More information

SUICIDE PREVENTION FOR PARENTS/COMMUNITY & FRIENDS

SUICIDE PREVENTION FOR PARENTS/COMMUNITY & FRIENDS SUICIDE PREVENTION FOR PARENTS/COMMUNITY & FRIENDS Know the Signs You be the one to make a positive difference Produced by the SHS Guidance Senator Angels Department Dispelling Myths Suicide Fact People

More information

Please take time to read this document carefully. It forms part of the agreement between you and your counsellor and Insight Counselling.

Please take time to read this document carefully. It forms part of the agreement between you and your counsellor and Insight Counselling. Informed Consent Please take time to read this document carefully. It forms part of the agreement between you and your counsellor and Insight Counselling. AGREEMENT FOR COUNSELLING SERVICES CONDUCTED BY

More information

Psychiatric Criminals

Psychiatric Criminals SUBJECT Paper No. and Title Module No. and Title Module Tag PAPER No.15: Forensic Psychology MODULE No.20: Human Rights and Legal Trials in case of FSC_P15_M20 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Learning Outcomes 2.

More information

Constraints on Harming and Health Care I: The Doctrine of Doing and Allowing

Constraints on Harming and Health Care I: The Doctrine of Doing and Allowing John Dossetor Health Ethics Centre Health Ethics Seminar University of Alberta October 21, 2016 Constraints on Harming and Health Care I: The Doctrine of Doing and Allowing Howard Nye Department of Philosophy

More information