TOBACCO Lessons from the Battles of a Half Century. Charles Gardner, MD, CCFP, MHSc, FRCPC MOH, Simcoe Muskoka District Health Unit September, 2013

Transcription

1 TOBACCO Lessons from the Battles of a Half Century Charles Gardner, MD, CCFP, MHSc, FRCPC MOH, Simcoe Muskoka District Health Unit September, 2013

2 Acknowledgements Insights and background materials from discussions with the following: Robert Kyle, MOH Durham Region, former TSAG member David Butler-Jones, Chief Public Health Officer of Canada John Garcia, Assoc. Prof. and Dir., School of Public Health, U of Waterloo; former Dir. of the Health Promotion Branch, ON. Min of Health Kate Manson-Smith, ADM of Health Promotion Division, MOHLTC Michael Perley, E.D., OCAT Richard Schabas, MOH, HPEHU; former CMOH ON.

3 One-Billion Deaths may occur globally in the 21st century from tobacco use (WHO, 2008) 100 million deaths in the 20 th century Cigarettes are the only legal product that, when used as intended, are lethal Despite this, things have really changed since 1964 (or even 1984) Majority of adult males (including physicians) were smokers Smoking at board of health meetings and at Ministry / MOH meetings Smoking in all indoor public places No real restrictions on tobacco marketing activities

4 The Breadth of Health Impacts of Tobacco: Surgeon General s Report 2010

5 The rise and fall of tobacco use and disease

6 Progress: Tobacco mortality has declined relative to other risk factors Source: SEVEN MORE YEARS: The impact of smoking, alcohol, diet, physical activity and stress on health and life expectancy in Ontario. Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, Public Health Ontario

7 Taking stock of the present status of tobacco control in Ontario Research, surveillance and KE Strategies Prevention, Protection, Cessation National, provincial and municipal legislation Litigation Local public health programs (Ministry funded) NGO advocacy / public education Healthcare system supports for cessation Public support for the above But ongoing dedicated opposition from the industry and thus despite 60 years of evidence supporting action, 1/5 adults still smoke; 13,000 deaths annually in Ontario

8 Some key questions re tobacco and its history 1. How did we get here? Understanding the basic dynamics of an industry-driven epidemic 2. Where do we go from here? Understanding the political challenges of implementing effective practices 3. What lessons can be applied to other leading preventable cause(s) of death? Identifying transferable lessons regarding other prominent causes of chronic disease

9 Phases of the Tobacco Epidemic PHASE I: Consolidation of the Cigarette Industry and Early Controversies PHASE II: Era of Good Feeling; Cigarettes Promoted by Governments PHASE III: The Gathering Storm of Health Concerns PHASE IV: Regulatory Hesitancy PHASE V: Tobacco as Social Menace PHASE VI: The Future Neoprohibitionism versus harm reduction? Source: Local Tobacco Control Coalitions in the United States and Canada: Contagion Across the Border? Stephanie J. Frisbee, PhD, and Donley T. Studlar, PhD. Presented at: 11th Annual Conference of the Canadian Political Science Association May 16 18, 2011, Wilfrid Laurier University, Waterloo, ON

10 Research: Early Concerns Early health (and moral) concerns: loathsome to the eye, hatefull to the nose, and harmefulle to the braine, King James I, 17th century Scientific reports as early as 1912 re lung cancer Concerns in the 1920s to 1940s Reader s Digest in 1924; Science in 1938 (Johns Hopkins biostats study reduced longevity); small study in Germany in 1939 re increased lung cancer with smoking; Departments of Pensions and National Health in 1940

11 Research: The Evidence Gathers 1947 Norman Delarus (Canadian), case (50) control study re lung cancer Evart Graham (USA), JAMA, case (605) control study re lung cancer (author quit smoking after study, but died of lung cancer in 1957) Bradford Hill, Richard Doll, BMJ, 20 British hospitals, case control study, lung cancer Richard Doll et al. Commencement of a 50-year-long cohort study on male physicians in the UK

12 29 reports in all latest one in landmark first report Based on 7,000 articles relating to smoking and disease Very guarded language Citation of antecedent work Dramatic increase in tobacco use and lung cancer (from 3T in 1930 to 41T in 1962) over past century No relationship with education urban more than rural Cancer of lungs, etc., probably COPD, heart disease, LBW babies, fires Habituation, not addiction

13 Surgeon General Reports: Progression 1979 Much more strident language The largest preventable cause of death An addiction Reductions in use 1986 Involuntary smoking hazards ETS restrictions in 40 states and in DC 96 percent of businesses have adopted smoking policies Restrictions may reduce tobacco use evaluation needed

14 Research / Analysis Ontario Council on Health Report, Smoking and Health in Ontario: A Need for Balance,1982 USEPA, 1992 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council in 1997 California EPA, 1997 United Kingdom Scientific Committee on Tobacco and Health, 1998 WHO, 1999 Actions will Speak Louder than Words,1999 US National Toxicology Program, 2000 Protection from secondhand tobacco smoke in Ontario, OTRU, 2001 Evidence to Guide Action, PHO, 2010 The Tobacco Strategy Advisory Committee (TSAG) report and recommendations, 2010

15 The Industry s Response Some historic milestones Macdonald Tobacco established in Montreal in 1858 Cigarette rolling machine in 1881; safe matches in 1890s Ability of T. industry to remain healthy while its customers get sick one of the most amazing marketing feats of all times Jake Epp, 1996 Tremendous wealth 19.7 billion in duty paid in 2010 in the Americas (BAT Managing the Challenges in the Americas ) Present companies in Canada Imperial Tobacco Rothmans, Benson & Hedges Inc. JTI-MacDonald Corp James Albert Bonsack's cigarette rolling machine, invented in 1880 and patented in (Wikipedia)

16 The Industry s Response Deliberate deception Public declaration of responsibility as a ruse Sponsorship of scientific opposition Denial of the health impacts Personal responsibility arguments Marketing to youth (and denying it) Marketing to recruit new smokers (and denying it) Policy manipulation Political involvement prominent politicians as tobacco executives Voluntary code re marketing as a means of forestalling legislation (effective in the 1970 s) Threatened withdrawal of sponsorship as means of coercion Contraband tobacco Undermining price as a control measure Legal challenges Supreme Court re the Tobacco Products Control Act

17 Knowledge Exchange and Grass-roots Advocacy in Canada / Ontario Canadian Cancer Society newsletter in 1951 citing the emerging evidence Canadian Public Health Association Advocacy positions in 1959, 1988, and 2011 Seeking elimination (under 1%) by 2035 Canadian Medical Association concluded in 1961 smoking causes lung cancer Non Smokers Rights Association, and the Canadian Council on Smoking and Health, (now the Canadian Council for Tobacco Control) founded in 1974 Physicians for a Smoke-Free Canada formed in 1985 Ontario Campaign for Action on Tobacco (OCAT), 1992 Ontario Tobacco Research Unit, 1993 Ontario Medical Association: advocacy paper for smoke-free legislation (2003), cars and children (2004)

18 History of TC and Public Health in Ontario No tobacco control in the Mandatory Health Programs and Services Guidelines until years after the Surgeon General s report The first CMOH Report, 1991, was on tobacco control Mandatory Health Programs and Services Guidelines Guidelines in 1989, and 1998 Structure: Outcome objectives re smoking rate reductions, smoke-free homes, tobacco vendor compliance (re Tobacco Control Act) Actions: consistent with today s local tobacco control mandate Liaison, school curriculum, smoke-free policies in workplaces, cessation, regulatory efforts re secondhand smoke Ontario Public Health Standards 2008 Chronic Disease Prevention Structure: broad process outcomes, Societal and Board Objectives details in protocols

19 Historic Government Roles Tobacco promotion Agricultural R&D, subsidies Provision (military) Tobacco control Regulation of manufacturing (such as the 2005 cigarette ignition propensity regulations) Sales (age, vendors / vending) restrictions Marketing / advertising / packaging (plain) / warnings (graphic) Taxation Research Cessation supports Location of use restrictions Litigation Partnerships Public awareness and de-normalization (Prohibition)

20 Government Response: Federal For 80 years (between 1908 to 1988) the Federal Government did not pass tobacco control legislation despite more than 20 private members bills in the 1960s Resolution to ban tobacco, 1903 and 1904 second reading only Legislation: 1908 Tobacco Restraint Act - prohibited sales under Non-Smokers Health Act (private members bill) and Tobacco Products Control Act - prohibited advertising; charter challenge with sections ruled unconstitutional 1993 Tobacco Sales to Young Persons Act prohibited sales under Tobacco Act still in effect; disclose product content, prohibited sale to youth, prohibited mail-order and vending machines, warning labels, restricted advertising Taxation increases in 1980 s, reduction in ,000 additional deaths Graphic packaging in 2000 and 2012 Tobacco farms quota buyout in 2008 More than doubled Ontario s crop

21 Government Response: Provincial (Ontario and others) For 98 years (1892 to 1990) the provincial government of Ontario did not pass tobacco control legislation Legislation: Prohibition of sale to minors BC in 1891, ON (age 18) and NS in 1892, NB in 1893, NWT in Smoking in the Workplace Act - minimum areas for nonsmoking (not enclosed and separately ventilated) 1994 Tobacco Control Act - Ontario s first general tobacco control statute prohibition of sale in pharmacies and vending machines, to minors, allowed municipal bylaws for smoke-free spaces prohibited in healthcare facilities, pharmacies, schools and colleges and in other retail and institutional settings Tobacco program funding: $4 M in 1995, $10M in 1999, to $60 M by 2006, to $47.8 M by 2011 Provincial government suits BC in 2004, Supreme Court support Manitoba, Sask. Que., PEI, NS, NB have launched suits Enabling legislation in Ontario and Alberta

22 Smoke-Free Ontario Act and Strategy, 2006 Comprehensive, multi-level and intensive strategy: training, mass media, planning infrastructure (such as TCANs), local programs, research and evaluation programming and 40% of SFO funding for local public health (previously only cost-shared funding) Banning smoking in enclosed public places and workplaces Banning the display of tobacco products at the point of purchase (i.e. powerwalls) Strengthening restrictions on selling tobacco products to young people Expanded services and infrastructure to help smokers quit Created and funded programs, including a peer-to-peer infrastructure, to prevent youth from starting to smoke Funded extensive awareness and social marketing initiatives Funded research capacity and training supports for health system workers

23 Ontario since 2009 Banned smoking in vehicles when children under 16 are present Passed legislation to allow the government to to sue tobacco companies to recover past and ongoing healthcare costs due to tobacco-related illness Passed legislation to address the supply of flavoured cigarillos to young people MOHLTC Action Plan, 2012 to have the lowest tobacco use in the country According to 2006 Health Canada figures, legal sales of cigarettes in Ontario fell by 31.8 percent, or by approximately 4.6 billion cigarettes, since 2003

24 Local Public Health and NGO Advocacy in the 1990s / 2000s Toronto: Bylaw in 1979 prohibiting smoking in retail stores, elevators, escalators, service lineups Bylaw in 1993 requiring workplace smoking policies Bylaw in 1997 enclosed, separately ventilated DSAs rescinded Smoke-free bylaws in 2000 / 2002: Waterloo Region, Toronto, Ottawa Other municipalities such as Simcoe County, District of Muskoka; Cornwall a noted success in eastern Ontario Most of the provincial population covered by smoke-free bylaws in early 2000s - Set the stage for the SFOA Much leadership, partnership and support from NGOs OCAT in particular working closely with local public health

25 Local Public Health and NGO Advocacy in the 1990s / 2000s Toronto: Bylaw in 1979 prohibiting smoking in retail stores, elevators, escalators, service lineups Bylaw in 1993 requiring workplace smoking policies Bylaw in 1997 enclosed, separately ventilated DSAs rescinded Smoke-free bylaws in 2000 / 2002: Waterloo Region, Toronto, Ottawa Other municipalities such as Simcoe County, District of Muskoka; Cornwall a noted success in eastern Ontario Most of the provincial population covered by smoke-free bylaws in early 2000s - Set the stage for the SFOA Much leadership, partnership and support from NGOs OCAT in particular working closely with local public health

26 The Impact of Government Decisions Past-Year Smoking, by grades 7-12, Ontario, Source: 2012 Smoke-Free Ontario Strategy Evaluation Report, Ontario Tobacco Research Unit:

27 OTRU Report 2012 Progress, however change too slow to achieve government s & TSAG s goals Protects most Ontarians most of the time from ETS in indoor public places Changing social climate and reducing use among youth YSS report 1/3 youth remain susceptible However, no reduction in adult smoking in 5 years took 10 years to reduce by 5% Protection: Reduction in ETS exposure over 5 years 26% still exposed at work, and 32% still on restaurant patios 11% of aged 12 to 19 still exposed in homes (not tracked in multiunit dwellings & likely much higher)

28 OTRU Report 2012 Prevention: Reduction in youth smoking (1/2 reduction over 6 years) Still 25% aged 20 to 24 smoke Need to focus on high-risk schools / youth who also have a high prevalence of other risk behaviors Cessation: In recent years no change in the proportion of smokers intending to quit, or in the number of cigarettes smoked daily Train health professionals in providing cessation support through TEACH, RNAO and PTCC Intention to quit not increasing Provincial cessation supports only reaching 5% of smokers Need to double annual quit rate from 1.3% in order to achieve TSAG target of 5% reduction over 5 years Need the multiple strategies in TSAG to achieve the provincial goal of the lowest smoking in Canada Source: OTRU review,

29 Ontario and other provinces Current Smoking (Past 30 Days), by Jurisdiction, Ages 12+, 2010 Note: Vertical lines represent 95% confidence intervals. Source: Canadian Community Health Survey Source: 2012 Smoke Free Ontario Strategy Evaluation Report. The Ontario Tobacco Research Unit. November 2012

30 Priority Populations Current Smoking (Past 30 Days), by Education, Ages 18+, Ontario, 2001 to 2011 Source: 2012 Smoke Free Ontario Strategy Evaluation Report. The Ontario Tobacco Research Unit. November 2012

31 Priority Populations Current Smoking (Past 30 Days), by Occupation, Ages 15 to 75, Ontario, 2009/10 Note: Vertical lines represent 95% confidence intervals. Source: Canadian Community Health Survey 2009/10. Source: 2012 Smoke Free Ontario Strategy Evaluation Report. The Ontario Tobacco Research Unit. November 2012

32 The Impact of Smoke-Free Public / Work Places (and the need for smokefree patios) Christine, please include Figure 12: Exposure to SHS at Restaurants or Bars, Ages 15+, Ontario, 2005 to 2010 from 2012 Smoke Free Ontario Strategy Evaluation Report. The Ontario Tobacco Research Unit. November 2012

33 Contraband Tobacco Figure 4 Source: The Canadian Tobacco Market Place. Estimating the volume of Contraband Sales of Tobacco in Canada; Updated April Physicians for a Smoke-Free Canada.

34 Moving Forward in Ontario: Tobacco Strategy Advisory Group (TSAG) BUILDING ON OUR GAINS, TAKING ACTION NOW: ONTARIO S TOBACCO CONTROL STRATEGY FOR Based on EVIDENCE TO GUIDE ACTION PHO Advice to government: Tobacco Control System Committee to advise the province on SFO renewal implementation Targets to be achieved by % reduction in tobacco use Reduce ETS ban smoking on restaurant and bar patios, and allow smoke-free leases in the Residential Tenancies Act Increase quitting rates and reduce reuptake rates Ban new tobacco products Reduce tobacco disease by 6.5%

35 TSAG Implementation Numerous Recommendations Whole of government approach Supply strategies Price, promotion, new product prohibition, reduced production, divestment Demand strategies Prevention, cessation, protection (MUDs), social marketing Research, address disparities, prevent government interference, dedicated adequate funding, litigation Strategies commenced: 16 Strategies awaiting commencement / uncertain status: 32 (though 3 are being addressed by local public health, municipal government or the federal government)

36 TSAG Implementation Highlights of Strategies Commenced: Whole of government approach (e.g. Min of Finance re contraband) engagement of first nations re contraband Tobacco growing: Raw leaf regulation commencing in January, 2014 Cessation: Coordinated tobacco cessation services hospital-based and workplace-based smoking cessation demonstration grants increased access to counseling and pharmacotherapy through primary care ODB coverage for cessation products

37 TSAG Implementation Strategies commenced: Research Provincial and local research, surveillance and monitoring re initiatives, programs, policies, disparities, youth and young adult prevention Reduce disparities Engage First Nations (Min of Finance) Social marketing Social smoking provincial commercial (movies and internet Cannes award for creativity)

38 TSAG Implementation Strategies awaiting commencement / uncertain status: Sufficient resources (at least $100 M would be within the CDC recommendations) Current strategy funding is $47.8 million (this includes the $5M enhancement in 2011) Dedicated funding from tobacco taxes to tobacco control Public health funding from tobacco settlements Divestment of investments Products: prohibit new products, plain packaging, restrict water pipes Price: Increase price / tax; Anti-contraband public education Promotion: Adult rates for movies and video games with tobacco imagery

39 TSAG Implementation Strategies awaiting commencement / uncertain status: Tobacco Growing: Work with partners to reduce tobacco production over time (licenses, acreage, ceilings) Protection Amend SFO to eliminate smoking in patios, hotels, doorways, playgrounds (local public health action re bylaws 75+ outdoor smoking amendments) Smoke-free Multiunit Dwellings: Amend Residential Tenancies Act to allow smoke-free MUDs a material term of leases (local municipal initiatives now 75 + smoke-free community housing buildings in Ontario) Tax credits for smoke-free affordable housing

40 International trends (from the industry) Although China will pay lip service to tobacco control, population growth is forecast to mitigate any fall in smoking prevalence, even in the long term. From: Passport The Future of Tobacco. Euromonitor. September 2011

41 Words from the industry Euromonitor International s view is that widely implemented plain packaging legislation would be the most damaging tobacco control measure ever introduced, because at least 50% of cigarettes pricing strength resides in the branding. Australia commenced plain packaging in 2012

42 Some observations from tobacco s history The power of industry: An industry capable of making great profits at the expense of 10 years of the life expectancy for most of the population for most of a century Once established, has enormous influence, delaying effective government action for decades Foresight is possible, but action has been delayed: The solutions can be logically deduced (but delayed in implementation). Some identified early (the 1960s) the range of tobacco-control strategies required Research is the beginning determination, the end Research is the essential starting point to turning things around but is not enough. The courage and determination of many people in and out of the public health community over many years has been critical for change

43 What next? What is our end-game? Provincially? Internationally? How should local public health be positioned in this? We have achieved much and much remains to be achieved TSAG recommendations are excellent but much remains to be implemented Expect many years of dedicated work to come Expect (and work to overcome) setbacks and delays Know that the industry still has enormous resources and influence but also that the peak and decline in tobacco internationally will come

44 What are the transferable lessons? There are parallels with other unhealthy commodities. Unhealthy foods Inadequate physical activity Unsafe alcohol consumption Vinyl chloride, asbestos, cars Underlying common strategies of unhealthy commodity industries: Seek to bias research findings Co-opt policy makers and health professionals Lobby politicians and public officials to oppose public regulation Encourage voters to oppose public health regulation To deflect criticism - promote actions outside their areas of expertise Conclusion - there is little objective evidence that public private partnerships deliver health benefits Sources: Profits and pandemics: prevention of harmful effects of tobacco, alcohol, and ultra-processed food and drink industries. Rob Moodie et al, on behalf of The Lancet NCD Action Group - Lancet 2013; 381: Why corporate power is a public health priority. Gerard Hastings. BMJ August 2012:345

45 What are the transferable lessons? There are transferable strategies. Healthy Kids Panel recommendations (re healthy weights in children) National Alcohol Strategy recommendations Commonly recommended strategies Whole of government approach Government outreach and funding to partners Safe / healthy consumption standards Restrictions on marketing / product placement / outlet density (eg. maintain the LCBO) Product content disclosure / signage Public awareness raising School programs Surveillance and public reporting Healthcare interventions Protection of vulnerable populations / poverty reduction / youth Legislation enforcement Ongoing research

46 Final Thoughts Tobacco is the industry-driven cause of the greatest loss of life in modern history We have made very difficult and slow progress but indeed we have progressed Much remains to be achieved in Ontario Things will get worse before they get better internationally There are transferable insights regarding other industry-driven challenges to public health