Training Supplement. For Use with the TIPS for On Premise Program in conjunction with the. New York Alcohol Training Awareness Program (ATAP)

Transcription

1 New York Alcohol Training Awareness Program (ATAP) Training Supplement For Use with the TIPS for On Premise Program in conjunction with the New York Alcohol Training Awareness Program (ATAP)

2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Participant Information Section 1. Alcohol Training Awareness Program (Retail Sale and Delivery of Alcoholic Beverages to Persons under the Legal Age) 2. List of Written Materials 3. Table of Topics related to Written Materials Reference Materials 1. New York Alcoholic Beverage Control Law - Sections 17.3; 65.1; 65-4; 65-b; 112; 113; New York General Obligations Law - Sections ; New York Penal Law - Sections (b); ; 80.05; (b); ; Cases Matter of Beverly Lanes, Inc. vs. Rohan Matter of Al Ronick, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority Matter of Austin Lemontree, Inc., v. New York State Liquor Authority Matter of Jo Mar Jo Restaurant Corp. v. New York State Liquor Authority Matter of Culligan s Pub, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority Matter of Lakeside Inn Supper Club, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority Matter of Dark Horse Tavern, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority New York State Drivers Licenses HCI 1501 Wilson Boulevard Suite 500 Arlington, VA Ext. 390 Government Relations/Ext. 396 NY Account Manager govrel@gettips.com

3 PARTICIPANT INFORMATION SECTION

4 STATE OF NEW YORK EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT DIVISION OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL NEW YORK STATE LIQUOR AUTHORITY 80 SOUTH SWAN STREET SUITE 900 ALBANY, NEW YORK Chairman Dennis Rosen Commissioners Jeanique Green Kevin Kim Alcohol Training Awareness Program Retail Sale and Delivery of Alcoholic Beverages to Persons under the Legal Age Amendments to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Law enacted in 1998 and 1999 directed the New York State Liquor Authority to set minimum standards for an Alcohol Training Awareness Program addressing the retail sale and delivery of alcoholic beverages to persons under the legal age. The amendments to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Law additionally empowered the Authority to approve schools and other entities to teach such a program. The seriousness of the illegal delivery of alcohol to an underage person is reflected by the number and the severity of laws governing such an illegal sale: Provisions in the Alcoholic Beverage Control Law and the Penal Law provide for the imposition of criminal penalties upon a retailer and/or a retail employee found to have illegally delivered or permitted the delivery of alcohol to a person under the legal age. The General Obligations Law provides that a retailer and/or a retail employee may be held liable for injuries caused by the intoxication of a person under the age of twenty-one years. Significant administrative sanctions may be imposed against an alcoholic beverage retailer where the retailer or a retail employee makes or permits an illegal underage delivery of alcohol. The materials enumerated in the accompanying "List of Written Materials" are provided so that persons attending a session of an Alcohol Training Awareness Program will have the opportunity to fully familiarize themselves with statutory provisions and judicial cases which define the scope of their responsibility in the area of illegal underage alcohol deliveries. The six-page "Table of Topics related to Written Materials" is provided so that persons attending a session of an Alcohol Training Awareness Program will have: A table summarizing each Topic pertaining to a specific aspect of the retailer's and/or the retail employee's responsibility with regard illegal underage alcohol deliveries; and A reference tool which links each Topic to the related statutory provisions and/or judicial cases.

5 ABCL 65 Page 5 LIST OF WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Awareness Training Statutory Provisions Alcoholic Beverage Control Law Penal Law ABCL 17.3 ABCL 65.1 ABCL 65.4 ABCL 65-b ABCL 112 ABCL 113 ABCL } [3 pages] PL (b) PL PL PL (b) PL PL } General Obligations Law GOL GOL } Cases Matter of Beverly Lanes, Inc. v. Rohan, 12 A.D.2d 156, 160 (dissenting opinion), reversed for the reasons stated in the dissenting opinion, 11 N.Y.2d 909 Matter of Al Ronick, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 157 A.D.2d 656 Matter of Austin Lemontree, Inc., v. New York State Liquor Authority, 147 A.D.2d 476, affirmed, 74 N.Y.2d 869 Matter of Jo Mar Jo Restaurant Corp. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 197 A.D.2d 625 Matter of Culligan's Pub, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 170 A.D.2d 506 Matter of Lakeside Inn Supper Club, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 147 A.D.2d 901 Matter of Dark Horse Tavern, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 232 A.D.2d 947 [6 pages] [3 pages] [2 pages]

6 Page 1 of 7 New York State Liquor Authority Table of TOPICS related to WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Training Awareness Program For On Premises Licensees Topic Statutes Written Materials Court Cases DIRECT DELIVERY PROHIBITED : a delivery made by the licensee or server. The law forbids a licensee or server to deliver alcohol to an underage person. ("No person shall sell, deliver or give away *** any alcoholic beverage to any person actually, or apparently, under the age of twenty-one years.") Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.1 INDIRECT PERMISSIVE DELIVERY PROHIBITED : a delivery permitted by the licensee or server. The law forbids a licensee or server to permit another individual to deliver alcohol to an underage person. ("No person shall *** cause or permit or procure to be sold, delivered or given away any alcoholic beverage to any person actually, or apparently, under the age of twenty-one years.") Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.1 DUTY OF REASONABLE SUPERVISION. The statutory directive that the licensee not permit the delivery of alcohol to underage persons imposes a duty of reasonable supervision. The licensee or server must, through the exercise of reasonable diligence, keep aware of conditions within the licensed establishment. "[T]here is no safety in ignorance if proper inquiry would avail. *** Whatever reasonable supervision by oneself or one's agents would discover and prevent, that, if continued, will be taken as suffered" Beverly Lanes, 12 A.D.2d at 160 (dissent), quoting from People ex rel. Price v. Sheffield Farms Co., 225 N.Y. 25, Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.1 Matter of Beverly Lanes, Inc. v. Rohan, 12 A.D.2d 156, 160 (dissenting opinion), reversed for the reasons stated in the dissenting opinion 11 N.Y.2d 909 (1962). [6 pages]

7 Page 2 of 7 New York State Liquor Authority Table of TOPICS RELATED TO WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Training Awareness Program Topic Statutes Written Materials Court Cases INDIRECT PERMISSIVE DELIVERY MADE IN THE AREA WIT HIN THE LICENSEE'S OR SERVER'S REASONABLE APPREHENSION. The licensee and server are legally responsible for any subsequent redelivery o f an alcoholic beverage made by an individual to whom the server has made a single or multiple delivery, where such redelivery is made in the area within th e licensee's or server's reasonable apprehension. If the licensee or server knows -- or if the licens ee or server, in the exercise of reasonable diligence, should know -- that another individual (usually, but not necessarily, a patron) is delivering or has deliver ed alcohol to an underage person, and if the licensee or server does not act to stop or withdraw such delivery, then the licensee or server has, by his o r her inaction, permitted that other individual to deliver alcohol to an underage person, and the licensee and/or the server will be held responsible for the delivery. (Charges may also be brought against the patron for delivering alcoho l to an underage person.) In each of the following cases, the Court upheld a State Liquor Authority determination that the licensee and server had perm itted the delivery of alcohol to an underage person: Al Ronick, Inc. The server sold two alcoholic drinks to an adult ma le at the bar. The adult male then handed one of the drinks to a female seated ne xt to him at the bar. The female was under the legal age. Austin Lemontree, Inc. An alcoholic drink was sold to a male patron at the bar. The patron then gave the drink to a female located three feet from the b ar. Four or five bartenders were working at the bar at the time. The female wa s under the legal age. Jo Mar Jo Restaurant Corp. The server sold two alcoholic drinks to an adult ma le at the bar. The male returned to a table a where a female was seated, an d gave her one of the drinks. The bartender had an unobstructed view of the table. The female was under the legal age. [If the view of the bartender had been obstructed, the charge could have been sustained as a result of a "multiple deli very". Please consider the "multiple delivery" topic discussed at page 3 of this table.] Culligan's Pub, Inc. The server sold two pitchers of beer at the bar, an d provided five glasses. The beer was consumed by five males at a table situated seven or eight feet from the bar. The bartender had an unobstructed view of the table. One of the males was under the legal age. [If the view of the bartender had been obstructed, the charge could have been sustained as a result of a "multipl e delivery". Please consider the "multiple delivery" topic discussed at page 3 o f this table.] Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.1 Matter of Al Ronick, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 157 A.D.2d 656 Matter of Austin Lemontree, Inc., v. New York State Liquor Authority, 147 A.D.2d 476, affirmed, 74 N.Y.2d 869 [3 pages] Matter of Jo Mar Jo Restaurant Corp. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 197 A.D.2d 625 Matter of Culligan's Pub, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 170 A.D.2d 506 [2 pages]

8 Page 3 of 7 New York State Liquor Authority Table of TOPICS RELATED TO WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Training Awareness Program Topic Statutes Written Materials Court Cases INDIRECT PERMISSIVE DELIVERY MADE AS THE RESULT O F A MULTIPLE DELIVERY MADE TO A SINGLE INDIVIDUAL. A "multiple delivery" is, in premises licensed to sell alcoholic beverages for consumptio n on the premises, the delivery of more than one alcoholic beverage to an individua l patron in a single transaction. "Multiple delivery" includes the delivery of a quantity of alcohol which would reasonably be consumed by more than one person, suc h as, for example, one pitcher of an alcoholic beverage, or more than one glass, cup, mug, bottle, can, shot, or other individual serving of an alcoholic b everage. In premises licensed to sell alcoholic beverages for consumption off the pr emises, a "multiple delivery" is the delivery of more than one bottle, can, or indiv idual container of an alcoholic beverage. A licensee and the server for on-premises consumpti on are legally responsible for any subsequent redelivery of an alcoholic beverage made by an individual to whom the server has made a multiple delivery. When a licensee or server for on-premises consumpti on delivers, in a single delivery made to a single individual, a quantity of alcohol which would be reasonably be consumed by more than one person, the licensee or server is obligated to accompany such individual to the area of consumption and make sure that no alcohol is given to a person under the lega l age. If an on-premises licensee or server makes a multip le delivery to an individual patron, and fails to accompany the patron to the ar ea of consumption to make sure that none of the items is intended for an underage person, then the licensee or server, by his or her inaction, has permitted the patron to deliver alcohol to whomever the patron chooses. If the patron actually delivers the alcohol to an underage person, then the licensee and/or the serve r will be held responsible for the delivery. If an off-premises licensee or store clerk makes an alcohol delivery to an adult customer under circumstances which would indicate t o a reasonable person that the alcohol is likely to be shared with or redelivered to a person under the legal age; and if the adult customer actually does share the a lcohol with a person under the legal age, or actually does redeliver the alcohol t o a person under the legal age -- then the licensee or store clerk will be held to ha ve permitted the delivery of alcohol to a person under the legal age, in violati on of ABCL Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.1 Matter of Beverly Lanes, Inc. v. Rohan, 12 A.D.2d 156, 160 (dissenting opinion), reversed for the reasons stated in the dissenting opinion 11 N.Y.2d 909 (1962). [6 pages] A LICENSEE OR SERVER MAY LEGALLY REFUSE TO DELIVER AN ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IF THE LICENSEE OR SERVER IS NOT CERTAIN T HAT THE PERSON SEEKING THE ALCOHOL DELIVERY IS OF LEGAL AGE. The first sentence of subdivision 4 of section 65 of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Law provides: "Neither such person so refusing to sell or deliver under this section nor his employer shall be liable in any civil or criminal action or for any fine or penalty based upon such refusal, except that such sale or delivery shall not be refused, withheld from or denied to any person on account of race, creed, color or national origin." Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.4

9 Page 4 of 7 New York State Liquor Authority Table of TOPICS RELATED TO WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Training Awareness Program Topic Statutes Written Materials Court Cases THE AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE. THE LICENSEE'S OR SERVER'S REASONABLE RELIANCE UPON A PHOTOGRAPHIC IDENTIFICATION CARD AP PARENTLY ISSUED BY A GOVERNMENTAL ENTITY. If a licensee or server is charged with delivering alcohol to an underage person, the licen see or server is entitled to offer an affirmative defense to the charge. The defense is called an affirmative defense because the licensee or server has the affi rmative burden of presenting evidence which will satisfy all required elements o f the defense. In order to establish the affirmative defense, the licensee or server must present evidence which proves that, in connection with the specific underage alcohol delivery which is being charged, the licensee or server reas onably relied upon the underage youth's presentation of a photographic identification card apparently issued by a governmental agency. THE LICENSEE'S OR SERVER'S HOLDING OF A VALID CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION FROM AN AUTHORIZED ATAP PROGRAM. If a licensee or server is charged with delivering alcohol to an underage pers on or to a person that appears visibly intoxicated, and the licensee has had a cle an disciplinary record for at least five years, and the licensee or employee alleged to have committed the violation has a valid certificate of completion (or renewal) from an approved ATAP program, the civil penalty related to such offense will be limited to $1, In addition, if a licensee or server is charged with d elivering alcohol to an underage person or to a person that appears visibly intoxicated, and the licensee has had a clean disciplinary record for at least five years, but the licensee or employee alleged to have committed the violation does not ho ld a valid certificate of completion (or renewal) from an approved ATAP program at that time, the licensee will be given a period of 90 days from the imposition of any civil penalty arising from same to submit written proof that all of the licensee s employees involved in the direct sale or service of alcoholic beverages have obtained a valid certificate of completion (or renewal) from an approved ATAP program in return for which the civil penalty will be reduced by 25% by the liquor authority. Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.6 and 65.7 [2 pages]

10 Page 5 of 7 New York State Liquor Authority Table of TOPICS RELATED TO WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Training Awareness Program Topic Statutes Written Materials Court Cases REASONABLE RELIANCE: THE IDENTIFICATION PRESENTED BY THE PATRON MUST BE CURRENTLY VALID AND IN EFFECT. A driver's license, non-driver identification card, or passport presented as writ ten evidence of age must be currently valid. If the identification offered as written evidence of age has expired, the licensee or server cannot reasonably r ely upon the identification. Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65-b.2(b) [3 pages] REASONABLE RELIANCE: THE AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE CANNOT BE ESTABLISHED UNLESS THE IDENTIFICATION WAS EXAMINED ON THE SAME OCCASION AS THE UNDERAGE ALCOHOL DELIVERY BEING PRO SECUTED. The affirmative defense of reasonable reliance upon a photographic identification apparently issued by a governmental agency is not established unless the licensee and server prove that "the phot ographic identification was presented on the occasion of the specific sale or delivery un derlying the alleged violation" (Lakeside Inn Supper Club, 147 A.D.2d at ) [emphasis by italics has been added]. Matter of Lakeside Inn Supper Club, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 147 A.D.2d 901 REASONABLE RELIANCE: CAREFUL AND CRITICAL EXAMINATION. The defense of reasonable reliance is not establish ed unless a reviewing court would find that the licensee making the alcohol del ivery or the server making the alcohol delivery -- after having made a careful and critical examination of the identification -- reasonably concluded that the identification belonged to the person presenting the identification, and reasonabl y concluded that the identification had not been altered. Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.4 [1 pages] Matter of Dark Horse Tavern, Inc. v. New York State Liquor Authority, 232 A.D.2d 947 REASONABLE RELIANCE: IT IS THE PERSON DELIVERING THE ALCOHOL WHO MUST EXAMINE AND REASONABLY RELY UPON THE PHOTOGRAP HIC IDENTIFICATION CARD APPARENTLY ISSUED BY A GOVERNME NTAL AGENCY. ABCL 65.4 provides, in relevant part (word "under age" in brackets has been added; emphasis by underlining has been added): " *** It shall be an affirmative defense that such [underage] person had produced a photographic identification card app arently issued by a governmental entity and that the alcoholic beverage had been sold, delivered or given away to such person in reasonabl e reliance upon such identification." An employee who delivers an alcoholic beverage to a n underage patron cannot take advantage of the affirmative defense unless th e delivering employee has personally examined and reasonably relied upon the photographic identification produced by the underage patron. Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.4 [1 pages]

11 Page 6 of 7 New York State Liquor Authority Table of TOPICS RELATED TO WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Training Awareness Program Topic Statutes Written Materials Court Cases CRIMINAL PENALTIES. Delivering or permitting the delivery of alcohol t o a person under the legal age in violation of ABCL 65.1 is an unclassified misdemeanor. The Penal Law directs that an unclassified misdemea nor be treated as a class A misdemeanor. Unlawfully Dealing with a Child in the First Degree, in violation of Penal Law , is a class A misdemeanor. A person convicted of a class A misdemeanor may be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of up to one year, and fined up to $1,000. In addition, the corporation for which the person works may be fined up to $5,000. THE LICENSEE'S OR SERVER'S HOLDING OF A VALID CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION FROM AN AUTHORIZED ATAP PROGRAM. If a licensee or server is charged with Unlawfully Dealing with a Child in the First Degree, and the licensee or server has not been convicted of same w ithin the preceding five years, the licensee or server is entitled to offer an affirmative defense to the charge that he or she is in possession of a valid c ertificate of completion (or renewal) from an approved ATAP program. In additio n, the licensee or server involved is supposed to have the ability to obtain a reasonable adjournment to obtain a valid certificate of completion (or renewal) from an approved ATAP program. Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65.1 and Penal Law (b) (b) [1 page each] CIVIL LIABILITY FOR INJURIES CAUSED BY THE INTOXICA TION OF A PERSON UNDER THE AGE OF TWENTY-ONE YEARS. A licensee or server who delivers alcohol to a person under the legal ag e may subsequently be found to have caused the intoxication of a person u nder the age of twentyone. Where such liability is established, the lice nsee and/or server may be obligated to pay money damages to innocent third pa rties to compensate them for injuries, including personal injury, injur y to property, and injury to means of support. General Obligations Law and

12 Page 7 of 7 New York State Liquor Authority Table of TOPICS RELATED TO WRITTEN MATERIALS Alcohol Training Awareness Program CIVIL ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES WHICH THE STATE LIQU OR AUTHORITY MAY IMPOSE AGAINST THE ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE LICENSE HOLDER. In connection with a violation of law, the State Li quor Authority may impose civil administrative penalties against a lic ensee. Penalties which may be imposed against the holder of a retail alcoh olic beverage license include revocation, cancellation, or suspension of the alcoholic beverage license; a civil money penalty of up to ten thousan d dollars; a bond claim of up to one thousand dollars; and a two-year ban agai nst the future licensure of the building containing the licensed premises. Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 17.3, 112 and 113 [1 page each] FIRST HAND ACCOUNTS OF PERSONS WHO HAVE SUFFERED A LOSS ATTRIBUTABLE TO PERSONS DRIVING A MOTOR VEHICLE WHI LE INTOXICATED. Pamphlet issued by STOP DWI New York "Shattered Lives

13 ABCL 65 Page 1 New York Alcoholic Beverage Control Law Section 65 Alcoholic Beverage Control Law 65. Prohibited sales No person shall sell, deliver or give away or cause or permit or procure to be sold, delivered or give n away any alcoholic beverages to 1. Any person, actually or apparently, under the ag e of twenty-one years; 2. Any visibly intoxicated person; 3. Any habitual drunkard known to be such to the pe rson authorized to dispense any alcoholic beverages. 4. Neither such person so refusing to sell or deliver under this section nor his or her employer shall be liable in any civil or criminal action or for any fine or penalty based upon such refusal, except that such sale or delivery shall not be refused, withheld from or denied to any person o n account of race, creed, color or national origin. [As amended by Laws 2010, Ch. 435] 5. The provisions of subdivision one of this sectio n shall not apply to a person who gives or causes t o be given any such alcoholic beverage to a person under the age o f twenty-one years, who is a student in a curriculu m licensed or registered by the state education department and is required to taste or imbibe alcoholic beverages in courses which are part of the required curriculum, provided such alcoholic beverages are used only for instructional purposes during classes conducted pursuant to such curriculum. 6. In any proceeding pursuant to section one hundre d eighteen of this chapter to revoke, cancel or sus pend a license to sell alcoholic beverages, in which proceeding it is alleged that a person violated subdivision one of this section; a) it shall be an affirmative defense that such person had produced a photographic identification c ard apparently issued by a governmental entity and that the alcoho lic beverage had been sold, delivered or given to s uch person in reasonable reliance upon such identification. In e valuating the applicability of such affirmative def ense, the authority shall take into consideration any written polic y adopted and implemented by the seller to carry ou t the provisions of paragraph (b) of subdivision two of section sixt y-five-b of this article; and b) it shall be an affirmative defense that at th e time of such violation such person who committed such alleged violation held a valid certificate of completion or renewal from an entity authorized to give and admi nister an alcohol training awareness program pursuant to subdivis ion twelve of section seventeen of this chapter. Su ch licensee shall have diligently implemented and complied with all of the provisions of the approved training pro gram. In such proceeding to revoke, cancel or suspend a license p ursuant to section one hundred eighteen of this cha pter, the licensee must prove each element of such affirmative def ense by a preponderance of the credible evidence. E vidence of three unlawful sales of alcoholic beverages by any employee of a licensee to persons under twenty-one years of age, within a two year period, shall be considered by th e authority in determining whether the licensee had diligently implemented such an approved program. [As amended by Laws 2010, Ch. 435] 7. In any proceeding pursuant to section one hundr ed eighteen of this chapter to revoke, cancel or su spend a license

14 ABCL 65 Page 2 to sell alcoholic beverages, in which proceeding a charge is sustained that a person violated subdi vision one or two of this section and the licensee has not had any a djudicated violation of this chapter at the license d premises where the violation occurred within the previous five yea r period; and (a) at the time of such violation the pe rson that committed such violation held a valid cer tificate of completion or renewal from an entity authorized to give and administer an alcohol training awareness p rogram pursuant to subdivision twelve of section seventeen of this chapter, the civil penalty related to such off ense shall be recovery of, as provided for in section one hundred twel ve of this chapter, the penal sum of the bond on file during the period in which the violation took place; or (b) at the time of such violation the licensee has not had any adjudicated violations of this cha pter at the licensed premises where the violation occurred within t he previous five year period, any civil penalty imposed shall be reduced by twenty-five percent if the licensee sub mits written proof, within ninety days of the imposition of such civil penalty, that all of the licensee's employe es involved in the direct sale or service of alcoholic beverages to the public at the licensed premises where the vi olation occurred have obtained a valid certific ate of completion or renewal from an entity authorized to give a nd administer an alcohol training awareness program pursuant to subdivision twelve of section seventeen of this cha pter. For the purposes of this subdivision, the f ive year period shall be measured from the dates th at the violations occurred. [As amended by Laws 2010, Ch. 435]

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

41

42

43

44