Hepatocellular Carcinoma Surveillance

Transcription

1 Amit G. Singal, MD, MS Hepatocellular Carcinoma Surveillance Postgraduate Course: Challenges in Management of Common Liver Diseases 308 1

2 Patient Case 69 year-old otherwise healthy male with compensated HCV-related cirrhosis Treated with PEG-IFN and RBV in 2011 and achieved SVR Continues to feel well with no cirrhosis-related complications Normal ultrasound and AFP every 6 months for past 5 years Patient asks if he needs to continue HCC surveillance 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 309 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 2

3 Key Questions What is the risk of HCC in patients who achieve SVR? Is continued HCC surveillance indicated in this patient? If so, what is the optimal HCC surveillance strategy? 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 310 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 3

4 Key Questions What is the risk of HCC in patients who achieve SVR? Is continued HCC surveillance indicated in this patient? If so, what is the optimal HCC surveillance strategy? 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 311 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 4

5 Patients with HCV cirrhosis are at risk for HCC 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 312 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 5 Niedarau et al. Hepatology 1998 Degos et al. Gut 2000

6 SVR is associated with reduced risk of HCC 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 313 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 6 Morgan et al. Ann Intern Med 2013

7 However, HCC risk persists in patients post SVR 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 314 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 7 Kobayashi et al. Liver Int 2007

8 Risk factors for HCC Development among SVR Patients Study SVR Patients with Cirrhosis Median Follow-up # Incident HCC Risk Factors Van der Meer (84%) 6.7 years 50 (5%) Age Chang (38.9%) 3.5 years 37 (4.2%) Arase (7.8%) 8.1 years 44 (2.3%) Age, F3-F4, AFP, thrombocytopenia Male, age, alcohol, diabetes Huang (13.4%) 4.4 years 33 (5.1%) Age, F4 stage, GGT 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 315 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 8

9 Risk persists for > 10 years after SVR despite potential fibrosis regression Case No Years after HCV treatment Histology 1 18 F F F F3 5 > 10 years F AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 316 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 9 Nojiri et al. Oncol Lett 2010

10 SVR associated with with reduced risk of HCC but risk may plateau >7 years post SVR 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 317 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 10 Van der Meer et al JAMA 2012

11 Key Question What is the risk of HCC in patients who achieve SVR and is continued HCC surveillance indicated? SVR reduces HCC risk, but patients remain at elevated risk (annual incidence 0.5 2%) so surveillance indicated HCC risk prolonged (> 10 years) so surveillance may be be needed indefinitely HCC risk appears to plateau after first 6-7 years but unknown when falls below cost effectiveness threshold 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 318 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 11

12 Follow-up Question Does age matter? Is HCC surveillance indicated in this 69-year old patient? 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 319 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 12

13 Should surveillance be continued in the elderly? Systematic review of HCC outcomes in elderly patients Despite higher risk of non-liver related mortality, elderly patients had similar survival as non-elderly HCC patients Confounders: Higher comorbidity, worse performance status, provider reluctance to aggressively treat, smaller tumor burden, and less advanced fibrosis Conclusion: Prognosis driven more by tumor burden, liver function, and performance status than age 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 320 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 13 Borzio et al. World J Gastro 2015

14 Follow-up Question Is continued HCC surveillance indicated in this 69- year old patient? No absolute age cut-off at which HCC surveillance should be routinely discontinued Personalized decision based on comorbidities, performance status, degree of liver dysfunction, and patient/provider willingness to undergo HCC-directed treatment if needed 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 321 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 14

15 Follow-up Question Does this recommendation change with new DAA agents compared to IFN-based treatments? 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 322 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 15

16 HCC risk likely persists in patients post SVR with new DAA agents Proportion of patients without HCC DAA-treated patients IFN-treated historic controls Time (years) 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 323 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 16 Kozbial et al. J Hepatology 2016

17 HCC risk persists in patients post SVR 366 patients with cirrhosis and treated with DAAs 285 without HCC history 59 with history of HCC 9 (3.2%) with HCC within 6 months 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 324 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 17 Conti et al. J Hepatology 2016

18 Recurrence of HCC may increase post SVR 366 patients with cirrhosis and treated with DAAs 285 without HCC history 59 with history of HCC 17 (28.3%) with HCC recurrence within 6 months 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 325 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 18 Conti et al. J Hepatology 2016

19 Recurrence of HCC may increase post SVR o 58 HCC patients from 4 centers in Spain who had complete response after resection, ablation, or TACE All underwent DAA therapy after complete response o Recurrence occurred in 16 (27.6%) Median time from HCC treatment to DAA treatment was 11.2 ( ) months Median time from DAA treatment to HCC recurrence was 3.5 (1.1 8) months o Subgroup analysis: 41.2% recurrence if started DAA < 4 months of complete response vs. 21.9% if started > 4 months after complete response 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION FOR THE 326 STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 19

20 Follow-up Question Does this recommendation change with new DAA agents compared to IFN-based treatments? HCC risk likely remains high post SVR with new DAA agents so continued surveillance is indicated Further data are needed to enumerate HCC risk among DAA-treated patients May be higher given HCV therapy can be delivered to patients with more advanced liver dysfunction 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 327 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 20

21 Key Question What is the optimal HCC surveillance strategy in this patient? 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 328 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 21

22 HCC surveillance associated with improved survival in patients with cirrhosis Author Lead Time Survival Rates Significance El-Serag 2011 Tong 2010 Wong 2008 Tanaka 2006 Trevisani days 118 days 236 days 238 days days Median survival 298 vs. 130 days 3-year survival 62.5% vs. 36.6% 2-year survival 49.4% vs. 28.6% Median survival 6.3 vs. 5.3 years Median survival 30 vs. 20 months OR 0.81 (95%CI ) p=0.007 p=0.035 p=0.016 p< AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 329 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 22 Singal et al. PLOS Medicine 2014

23 Ultrasound is efficacious for HCC surveillance 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 330 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 23 Singal et al. Aliment Pharm Ther 2009

24 Efficacious may not equal effective Efficacy Access Recommend Adherence Effectivenes s Therapy A 50% 90% 90% 90% 37% Therapy B 90% 80% 60% 50% 22% 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 331 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 24 El Serag et al. Hepatology 2010

25 Ultrasound is not as effective in clinical practice Surveillance Test Sensitivity Sensitivity Early Stage Specificity AFP alone 27/41 (65.9%) 19/41 (46.3%) 363/401 (90.5%) Ultrasound alone 18/41* (43.9%) 13/41 (31.7%) 367/401 (91.5%) 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 332 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 25 Singal et al Cancer Epi Biomark Prev 2012

26 Potential limitations of Ultrasound Operator characteristics Variable experience and training of ultrasound technicians Patient characteristics Obesity Liver nodularity and echogenicity Presence of ascites 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 333 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 26

27 Limitations of Ultrasound Sensitivity Retrospective cohort of 1170 ITA.LI.CA database patients Ultrasound failure in 28.9% of patients Decreased from 33% in to 26% in Variable Multivariate analysis Annual vs. semiannual 2.20 ( ) Child Pugh B 1.60 ( ) Alpha fetoprotein (AFP)* 1.00 ( ) * Marker of aggressive tumor biology 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 334 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 27 Del Poggio et al. Clin Gastro Hep 2014

28 Limitations of Ultrasound Quality Retrospective cohort study of 941 patients with cirrhosis Ultrasound inadequate quality for surveillance in 134 (20.3%) patients Variable Multivariate analysis Male gender 1.68 ( ) Child B or C cirrhosis 1.93 ( ) BMI category (BMI < 25 reference) Overweight (BMI ) Obesity class I (BMI ) Obesity class II (BMI ) Obesity class III (BMI 40) Etiology (HCV reference) Hepatitis B Alcohol-related NASH 2.29 ( ) 2.95 ( ) 6.37 ( ) 8.22 ( ) 1.87 ( ) 2.11 ( ) 2.87 ( ) 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 335 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 28 Simmons et al. Aliment Pharmacol Ther (in press)

29 Potential solutions to improve effectiveness Better imaging quality Improved ultrasound quality Contrast enhanced CT or MRI Combining with biomarkers Alpha fetoprotein (AFP) AFP-L3% and DCP Others: GP73, osteopontin, etc AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 336 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 29

30 CT not recommended for HCC surveillance Variable Ultrasound (n=83) CT (n=80) p-value Number of HCC 8 (10.8%) 8 (10.0%) 0.86 Proportion BCLC A 5 (55.5%) 5 (62.5%) 0.93 HCC-related mortality 5 (6.0%) 7 (8.8%) 0.46 False positive imaging 3 (3.6%) 9 (5.6%) 0.06 Cost per HCC $17,041 $57, AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 337 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 30 Pocha et al. Aliment Pharm Ther 2013

31 MRI not recommended for HCC surveillance Prospective cohort study with 407 Child A-B patients 1112 surveillance rounds over 1.5 years Ultrasound and MRI done in all patients 35 patients with total of 40 HCC nodules 26 patients had BCLC stage 0 and 8 BCLC stage A Cohort MRI US P-value Sensitivity 97% 40% P<0.001 Sensitivity for BCLC O 96% 42% P<0.001 Specificity 94% 90% P= AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 338 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 31 Lim et al AASLD abstract 2014

32 Using AFP with ultrasound improves sensitivity for tumor detection in clinical practice Surveillance Test Sensitivity Specificity Ultrasound 92.0 ( ) 74.2 ( ) AFP > ( ) 93.3 ( ) Ultrasound and AFP > ( ) 68.3 ( ) Ultrasound and AFP >20 and >2* from nadir 99.2 ( ) 71.6 ( ) 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 339 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 32 Chang et al Am J Gastro 2015

33 Using AFP with ultrasound improves sensitivity for early tumor detection in clinical practice Test Sensitivity Efficacy Sensitivity Early Stage Sensitivity Effectiveness Sensitivity Early Stage AFP alone 35/51 (69%) 25/51 (49%) 27/41 (65.9%) 19/41 (46.3%) Ultrasound alone Ultrasound and AFP 43/51 (84%) 32/51 (63%) 18/41 (43.9%) 13/41 (31.7%) 47/51 (92%) 35/51 (69%) 37/41 (90.2%) 26/41 (63.4%) 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 340 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 33 Singal et al Cancer Epi Biomark Prev 2012

34 AFP performance varies by cirrhosis etiology Viral cirrhosis Non-viral cirrhosis N=1128; 452 HCC and 676 non-hcc Sensitivity 70.4% 69.6% Specificity 82.6% 98.0% Percent Correctly Classified 76.9% 89.4% 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 341 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 34 Gopal et al Clin Gastro Hep 2014

35 AFP performance improved by adjusting for ALT 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 342 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 35 El Serag et al Gastro 2014

36 Biomarkers being evaluated in phase II/III studies AFP-L3% DCP Osteopontin GP73 Squamous cell carcinoma antigen (SCCA) Circulating MiRNA Circulating tumor cells 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 343 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 36

37 Key Questions What is the optimal HCC surveillance strategy? Although ultrasound can be efficacious, it may have lower effectiveness given its operator dependent nature and differences in patient characteristics There are no data supporting routine use of CT or MRI for surveillance purposes AFP can improve sensitivity for early tumor detection and a combination of ultrasound/afp may be the optimal surveillance strategy 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 344 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 37

38 Summary: Patient Case 69 year-old otherwise healthy male with compensated HCV-related cirrhosis Treated with PEG-IFN and RBV in 2011 and achieved SVR Continues to feel well with no cirrhosis-related complications Normal ultrasound and AFP every 6 months for past 5 years Patient asks if he needs to continue HCC surveillance 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 345 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 38

39 Summary Patients with SVR remain at elevated risk for HCC and should continue to undergo HCC surveillance indefinitely Ultrasound with AFP every 6 months appears to be the optimal surveillance strategy to maximize early HCC detection in clinical practice 2016 AMERICAN ASSOCIATION 346 FOR THE STUDY OF LIVER DISEASES 39