Lead. Dr Mark Little. Clinical Toxicologist and Emergency Physician. NSW Qld WA Poisons Information Centre. March 2011

Transcription

1 Lead Dr Mark Little Clinical Toxicologist and Emergency Physician NSW Qld WA Poisons Information Centre March 2011

2 Aim Discuss Toxicology of lead Symptomatic childhood poisoning Asymptomatic childhood poisoning - why the concern Medical management My recommendations

3 Lead - history One of first metals smelted & used Lead based ochre paints Neanderthal era (40 000BC) Lead artifacts found in sites from Turkey 6200 BC Ancient Hebrews and Egyptians used lead Romans used lead for pipes, ceramic glazes, cooking utensils.

4 Lead today Most widely used non ferrous metal Global production 9 million tons pa Uses: Waterproofing, electrical & radiation shielding Batteries Telephone cables Solder Ammunition Paint Fuel additive

5 Human poisoning due to lead Greek physicians 2BC CNS effects mind gave way Pliny warned of the danger of inhaled lead fumes from smelting Benjamin Franklin (1763) described dry gripes = abdominal colic dangles = wrist drop In tinkers, painters and typesetters

6 Toxicology Absorption: Inhalation: <1mcm in alveoli Ingestion: adults 10-15% children 50% deficiency Fe, Zn increases absorption calcium reduces absorption Transplacental: readily crosses

7 Toxicology Distribution: 99% bound to RBC Deposited Bone Teeth Soft tissue CNS prefers grey matter

8 Toxicology Excretion: Mainly urine (65%) and bile (35%) Miniscule amount in hair Vit C may enhance excretion

9 How does lead cause toxicity? Lead binds to sulfhydryl groups effecting numerous enzymatic, receptors and structural proteins Similar to calcium so interfers with multiple metabolic pathways

10 Lead No known physiological role for lead Any lead found in the body fluids represents environmental contamination

11 BLL (mcg/dl) Effect in adults 100 Life threatening encephalopathy 80 Anaemia Impaired kidney function 60 Reduced fertility females 40 Impaired conduction peripheral nerves 30 Hypertension Reduced testicular function

12 Who is at risk from lead Children - especially under 4 Pregnant women - unborn baby Breast feeding mothers Those working with lead

13 Investigations Measure of body lead load Blood lead level used as primary biomarker Urine is insensitive Hair in unreliable Shed teeth is used in research

14 Level of concern BLL > 10 mcg/dl Recommended by NHMRC, CDC, WHO, AAP However we should aim for a BLL as low as possible

15 Variation in BLL with age Age Mean BLL mcg/dl 6 months months months 5.8 Canfield et al NEJM 03

16 Mt Isa Blood Lead Survey July 2007: children 1-4 years Mean 5.8 mcg/dl Median 5 mcg/dl 40 Number (n = 328) Rounded Blood Lead mcg/dl

17 WHO SHOULD GET TESTED IN MT ISA Everyone

18 CHILDHOOD LEAD POISONING

19 Childhood poisoning Lead paint poisoning recognised in Brisbane (Aust Med Gaz 1897) Law passed banning lead paint for houses 1914 USA only passed similar law 1961! Children recovering from symptomatic lead poisoning frequently left with neurological sequelae and intellectual impairment (Am J Dis Child 1943)

20 Childhood poisoning Symptomatic paediatric lead poisoning commonly seen in 1950/60 s in USA and effective chelation protocols developed (Paeds 1957, J Paed 1966) Recognition & quantification of more subtle neurocognitive impairment due to subclinical poisoning in 1970/80 s (NEJM 1972)

21 Clinical effects in children Symptomatic 1. Acute lead encephalopathy [SEVERE] (BLL>70mcg/dL) Presentation: altered LOC, seizures, vomiting, change behaviour, ataxia, change in developmental skills, CN palsies Anaemia

22 Clinical effects in children 2. Subencephalopathic [MODERATE] (BLL>50mcg/dL) Often difficult to diagnose 1-5 yo terrible two s Irritable, intermittent lethargy, constipation, intermittent vomiting, abdominal pain & anorexia Often not recognised until after chelation

23 Asymptomatic child with elevated blood lead levels Children with elevated lead burden but without overt symptoms the largest group of persons at risk from chronic lead toxicity Numerous studies demonstrate a correlation between elevated lead levels and:- Increased rate learning disabilities Lower IQ Lower class rank

24 Relationship between BLL and neurocognitive impairment Goldfrank s Clinical Toxicology 7th ED? Blood lead level (mcg/dl)

25 TREATMENT

26 Antidote Succimer = 2,3dimercaptosuccinic acid [DMSA] Oral agent SAS drug S/E: Transient LFT abnormalities Neutropenia (rare) GIT upset Hypersensitivity

27 Indication Adults Symptomatic BLL >60 mcg/dl Children Symptomatic BLL > 45 mcg/dl [Has been used to chelate mercury, arsenic, bismuth, antimony, copper - limited experience]

28

29 Summary 780 children with BLL mcg/dl Randomised double blind placebo controlled trial 3 x 25 days of succimer

30

31 Conclusion Those treated with succimer reduced BLL No improvement in cognition, behaviour or neuropsychiatric testing Succimer is NOT indicated in these children

32 Conclusion Suggests that as there is no effective treatment for children with moderate lead levels the collective evidence argues for shift toward primary prevention of lead exposure

33 Controversies

34 Many factors influence cognitive development in children Genetic Prenatal factors Socioeconomic factors Nutrition Smoking/drugs Parent and family nuturing

35 Effects on children with bll< 10 mcg/dl

36

37 Method 172 children BLL measured 6,12,18,24,36 mo Stanford Binet intelligence scale at 3 and 5 yrs Regression modelling

38 Results For 101 children with BLL < 10mcg/dL IQ dropped by 7.4 pts for lifetime average BLL <10 mcg/dl

39 Effects of early childhood lead exposure on academic performance and behaviour of school aged children Arch Dis Child children at 30 months had BLL Developmental behavioural and standardised educational outcomes at 7-8 yrs

40 Results 488 cases had all data on confounders Regression analysis

41 Distribution of BLL

42

43

44 Conclusion Exposure to lead early in childhood even at low levels is harmful on behaviour and school performance Reduce level of concern to 5 mcg/dl

45

46 Household interventions

47

48 To determine the effectiveness of household interventions in reducing lead exposure Only 12 studies All in the USA

49 Conclusion No evidence of effectiness of household interventions for education or dust controls Insufficient evidence for soil abatement Further trials required to establish the most effective intervention for the prevention of lead exposure

50

51 What do I recommend?

52 Toxicologist take home points Lead is here in Mt Isa Children absorb more lead that adults Children around 2 years seem to have the highest BLL Children probably absorb most of the lead through ingestion

53 Know the potential sources of lead Dust Lead paint and home renovations Contaminated people, clothes cars or items Rain water

54 Reduce the exposure Wash hands (especially children) before eating Wet wipe and mop Those working with lead shower and change before coming home Shoes/work gear outside Reduce exposure to potentially contaminated soil

55 Diet Regular meals Diet high in iron, zinc, calcium and vit C

56 Blood lead levels Aim for BLL < 10 mcg/dl The lower the better Everyone should be tested Opportunity to explain lead and its toxicity/reduction of exposure

57 If BLL > 10 mcg/dl Test entire family Involve Public Health Unit CDC

58 Summary of medical management BLL is best measure of lead body load BLL < 45 mcg/dl Not use chelating drug Seek enviromental source and limit Asymptomatic child BLL > 45mcg/dL Seek source Chelate with succimer dw toxicologist/pic Symptomatic or BLL > 70 mcg/dl Admit Immediate chelate - dw Toxicologist/PIC

59 Conclusion Lead poisoning humans for centuries Elevated BLL indicates environmental contamination Main concern is in children and the risk of cognitive development Major management [BLL < 45 mcg/dl] is removal from the lead source

60 Mt Isa Will have an ongoing lead exposure Need to have an ongoing process of education of community to reduce exposure to children Need to test the entire population

61

62 Need more help with medical management of patients Clinical Toxicologists available through the Poisons Information Centre system Ph any time and ask for a toxicologist

63 Questions?