Therapeutic Uses of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation Current & Developing

Transcription

1 Therapeutic Uses of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation Current & Developing Alvaro Pascual-Leone, MD, PhD Berenson-Allen Center for Noninvasive Brain Stimulation Harvard Catalyst Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center Harvard Medical School

2 Disclosure Scientific Advisory Board Member for Neuronix, Nexstim, Neosync, Magstim, Neuroelectrics, Starlab, Axilium Robotics Serve on Device Expert Panel at FDA Funding from National Institutes of Health, National Science Foundation, Michael J Fox Foundation, Sidney-Baer Foundation I will talk about off-label applications Listed inventor on various patents on combination of TMS with EEG and fmri

3 Noninvasive Brain Stimulation Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) Transcranial Current Stimulation (tcs) tdcs, tacs, trns TMS tdcs tacs trns

4 FDA approved Treatment for Medication-Resistant Depression Medicare & Insurance Covered

5 TMS for Medication-Resistant Depression Changing Lives! >600 systems in clinical use in the US 250 days/year & 5 patients/day = 750,000 treatments per year avg. 25 treatment sessions/patient = 30,000 patients per year 30% remission rate = 9,000 remitters per year 25 remitters per day

6 Why do 40% of MDD Patients not respond to TMS? Patient characteristics Genetic factors Head-tissue morphology State (fatigue, attention, alertness, ) Disease characteristics Symptom complex Co-morbidities Stimulation characteristics

7 tdcs for Medication-Resistant Depression Study N Conditions Conclusions Palm et al Brain Stim 2012 Loo et al Biol Psych 2012 Brunoni et al JAMA Psych 2013 Martin et al J Affect Dis Cross-over Left DLPFC vs sham 1-2 ma, 2 wks 64 Left DLPFC anode vs sham 2 ma, 15 sessions over 3 wks 120 Left DLPFC anode / R cathode (real or sham) + sertraline (50 mg/d) or placebo 2 ma, 6 wks 26 6 Month continuation Rx Left DLPFC anode Weekly x 3 months then monthly 2 ma, 6 wks Real = sham Mood improved real>sham 13% responders in both groups Cognitive improvements real>sham tdcs+sertraline superior Efficacy and safety of tdcs = sertraline Prevent relapse? 84% at 3 mo 51% at 6 mo

8 FDA approved for Abortive Treatment of Migraine Paving the path for home use

9 randomized, sham-controlled, parallel-group multi-session studies Khedr et al Fregni et al

10

11

12 Beyond MDD: Therapeutic Indications of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation Indication Year Studies / Participants Conclusions Chronic Pain Chronic Pain in Spinal Cord Injury RCTs / N=1,710 (30 rtms, 14 tdcs, 11 CES) / N=616 (3 rtms; 8 tdcs; 5 CES) + high-freq rtms to M1 +/- tdcs; - CES +/- tdcs - rtms or CES ALS RCTs / N=50? rtms Stroke: UE Motor studies / N=18,078 Need large, robust RTCs Stroke: ADL s studies / N=455 +/- tdcs (L/R/bilat DLPFC) Stroke: Function trials / N=588? rtms Stroke: Aphasia studies / N=54 (+) cathodal non-lesioned Stroke: Dysphagia studies / N=6,779 Behavioral interventions; acupuncture; pharyngeal stim MS: Spasticity RCTs / N=301 low evidence rtms Tinnitus trials / N=233 (+) low freq rtms

13 Clinical Program Approved Indications Medication-resistant depression Stroke recovery (motor, non-fluent aphasia) Neuropathic pain Focal epilepsy Parkinson s disease (motor, mood, cognition) Hallucinations Tinnitus Cognitive control / impulsivity Dementia (cognitive function)

14 Cognitive Enhancement with tdcs (Coffman et al., 2014; Horvath et al., 2015) Executive functions Set-shifting Stop signal tasks Stroop tasks Language Grammatical learning Lexical learning Verbal fluency Naming Attention Selective attention Spatial attention Learning Motor learning Procedural learning Explicit learning Numerical learning Memory Digit-span recall Verbal episodic memory Visual working memory N-back working memory Mental arithmetic Automaticity Picture viewing/rating Visual perception Multimodal perception Social cognition Problem-solving Mood Gambling based risktaking Rumination Santarnecchi et al., in prep

15 Cognitive Enhancement with tdcs: Stimulation Sites Motor Learning Probabalistic Learning Explicit Learning Attention Social Cognition Language Working Memory Complex Cognition

16 Therapeutic Uses of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation 1. Focus on Symptoms 2. Guide Intervention with Neuroimaging / Neurophysiology MRI-guided for optimal spatial precision EEG-guided for optimal frequency for given cortical location / condition

17 Defining TMS target for depression Mike Fox Group Map Subgenual Seed R² = Predicted CLinical Efficacy Clinical Efficacy versus SG AntiCorrelation Correlation with Subgenual 0.8 Fox et al. Biol Psych 2012; Neuroimage 2013

18 Defining TMS target for depression Mike Fox Group Map Subgenual Seed Subject 1 Subject 2 Fox et al. Biol Psych 2012; Neuroimage 2013

19 Multifocal, MRI-guided tcs Fox et al PNAS 2014; Ruffini et al Neuroimage 2013 fmri activation map tcs solution with 2 electrodes Multifocal tcs solution with 8 electrodes

20 Alpha: automatic movements Dominant Oscillations for Different brain regions Beta: movement Gamma: selective attention Ѳ: working /long-term memory Alpha: visual perception Θ: spatial orienting

21 EEG Bands and Pathology Reduced synchrony in Schizophrenia Reduced amplitude in Alzheimer Increased Amplitude in Bipolar dis. Reduced synchrony in Schizophrenia Reduced synchrony in Alzheimer Reduced coherence in Alzheimer Increased phase-locking at Frontal and Central electrodes in Schizophrenia Reduced Coherence in Alzheimer and Schizophrenia Increased amplitude in Parkinson Increased Coherence in Bipolar dis. Decreased/increased amplitude in Schizophrenia (?) Increased Phase-locked response in ADHD

22 Therapeutic Uses of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation 1. Focus on Symptoms 2. Guide Intervention with Neuroimaging / Neurophysiology MRI-guided for optimal spatial precision EEG-guided for optimal frequency for given cortical location / condition 3. Consider Needs of Special Populations (e.g. pediatrics) 4. Combine with Behavioral / Pharmacologic / Other Interventions

23 Alzheimer s Disease Concurrent TMS stimulation with Cognitive Training TMS coil Patient Touch screen Technician stand Computer TMS Treatment chair

24 Therapeutic Uses of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation On-Label Off-Label Clinical Trial Major Depressive Disorder rtms - Neuronetics - Brainsway Home Use Patient Initiated - Do-it-yourself devices - Purchased devices Malpractice coverage Informed consent FDA Cleared Device - TMS - tdcs: iontophoresis [not tacs or trns] Regulation - Advertise - Billing Consumer (non-medical) devices Stroke: UE Motor IRB Informed consent IDE? Trial registration Funding

25 Tremor suppression? Rationale Tremor Suppression? Brittain et al., Curr. Bio 2013 Can tacs reduce tremor in PD patients? Design Closed-loop tacs tremor phase (accelerometer) Tremor amplitude (accelerometer) accelerometer Tremor

26 Tremor Suppression? Polar Map Brittain et al., Curr. Bio 2013 Tremor Excitation Tremor Suppression Identification of the optimal Phase-Delay for tremor suppression Phased-locked tacs reduced tremor by up to 50%