Collected systematic reviews on the topic: Psychosocial stress at work and cardiovascular diseases

Transcription

1 Collected systematic reviews on the topic: Psychosocial stress at work and cardiovascular diseases No. Reference 1. Eller NH, Netterstrøm B, Gyntelberg F, Kristensen TS, Nielsen F, Steptoe A, Theorell T. Work-related psychosocial factors and the development of ischemic heart disease: a systematic review. Cardiol Rev Mar-Apr;17(2): Kivimäki M, Virtanen M, Elovainio M, Kouvonen A, Väänänen A, Vahtera J. Work stress in the etiology of coronary heart disease-- a meta-analysis. Scand J Work Environ Health Dec;32(6): Mann SJ. Job stress and blood pressure: A critical appraisal of reported studies. Current Hypertension Reviews, Volume 2, Number 2, May 2006, pp (12). 4. Netterstrom B, Kristensen TS. Ugeskr Laeger. Psychosocial factors at work and ischemic heart disease. Ugeskr Laeger Nov 14;167(46): Belkic KL, Landsbergis PA, Schnall PL, Baker D. Is job strain a major source of cardiovascular disease risk? Scand J Work Environ Health Apr;30(2): Study Grading PubMed link (according to SIGN: ++/+/-) + PM: PM: PM: PM: Search Documentation Form Stress at work and CV diseases.doc - 1 -

2 PEROSH Clearinghouse Search Documentation Form Name: Fishta A., Isotalo L., Euler U. Institute/Organisation: Federal Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (BAuA) Address and Nöldnerstr , Berlin and 1 Objective: Collecting systematic reviews on the topic: Psychosocial stress at work and cardiovascular diseases. 2 Question Does psychosocial stress at work lead to cardiovascular morbidity and mortality? Population: workers between years of age Intervention/Exposure: psychosocial stress at work Comparison (control): no psychosocial stress at work Outcome: cardiovascular morbidity and mortality (coronary heart disease, myocardial infarction, angina pectoris, heart insufficiency, stroke and hypertension) 3 Searched Databases: Database Time span Date searched (yyyy-mm-dd) Citations in Database Citations after duplicate check Medline (PubMed) 2000 to EMBASE 2000 to Other sources (if yes, please list them) Total (including Medline, EMBASE and others) Search Documentation Form Stress at work and CV diseases.doc - 2 -

3 4 Search Strategy: Medline via PubMed, searched # Searches Results 1 (occupation* OR worker*) (occupational diseases [MH] OR occupational exposure [MH] OR occupational medicine [MH] OR occupational risk [TW] OR occupational hazard [TW] OR (industry [MeSH Terms] mortality [SH]) OR occupational group* [TW] OR work-related OR occupational air pollutants [MH] OR working environment [TW]) 3 #1 OR # (psychosocial[all Fields] AND ("Stress"[Journal] OR "stress"[all 9049 Fields])) 5 ("stress, psychological"[mesh Terms] OR ("stress"[all Fields] AND "psychological"[all Fields]) OR "psychological stress"[all Fields] OR ("psychological"[all Fields] AND "stress"[all Fields])) 6 #4 OR # ("cardiovascular diseases"[mesh Terms] OR ("cardiovascular"[all Fields] AND "diseases"[all Fields]) OR "cardiovascular diseases"[all Fields]) 8 #6 AND # #3 AND # (meta-analysis as topic[mh] OR meta-analysis[pt] OR metaanalysis[tiab] OR review[pt] OR review[tiab]) NOT (letter[pt] OR editorial[pt] OR comment[pt]) NOT ((animals[mesh:noexp]) NOT (humans[mesh])) 11 #9 AND # ("2000/01/01"[PDAT] : "2010/07/08"[PDAT]) #11 AND #12 59 Search string: (((((occupation* OR worker*) OR (occupational diseases [MH] OR occupational exposure [MH] OR occupational medicine [MH] OR occupational risk [TW] OR occupational hazard [TW] OR (industry [MeSH Terms] mortality [SH]) OR occupational group* [TW] OR work-related OR occupational air pollutants [MH] OR working environment [TW])) AND (((psychosocial[all Fields] AND ("Stress"[Journal] OR "stress"[all Fields])) OR ("stress, psychological"[mesh Terms] OR ("stress"[all Fields] AND "psychological"[all Fields]) OR "psychological stress"[all Fields] OR ("psychological"[all Fields] AND "stress"[all Fields]))) AND ("cardiovascular diseases"[mesh Terms] OR ("cardiovascular"[all Fields] AND "diseases"[all Fields]) OR "cardiovascular diseases"[all Fields]))) AND (meta-analysis as topic[mh] OR meta-analysis[pt] OR metaanalysis[tiab] OR review[pt] OR review[tiab]) NOT (letter[pt] OR editorial[pt] OR comment[pt]) NOT ((animals[mesh:noexp]) NOT (humans[mesh]))) AND ("2000/01/01"[PDAT] : "2010/07/08"[PDAT])) Search Documentation Form Stress at work and CV diseases.doc - 3 -

4 Embase via DIMDI or OVID or etc., searched # Searches Results 1 occupation* OR worker* 1,266,899 2 work*:de OR 35:cl 358,725 3 'working environment' OR 'work related' 11,295 5 'industry'/exp AND mortality 4,389 6 #1 OR #2 OR #3 OR #5 1,385,191 7 psychosocial AND stress 116,639 8 'mental stress' OR (psychological AND stress) 222,905 9 #7 OR #8 223, 'cardiovascular disease'/syn 2,301, cardiovascular:ab,ti AND disease*:ab,ti 120, #10 OR #11 2,310, review OR 'meta analysis' OR search 2,364, #6 AND #9 AND #12 3, #13 AND # #15 AND [ ]/py #15 AND [embase]/lim AND [ ]/py #15 AND [medline]/lim AND [ ]/py #17 NOT # Selection process: 5.1 Inclusion criteria: A. According to PICO- question B. According to inclusion criteria for systematic reviews (see PEROSH Clearinghouse Methods, Inclusion and classification criteria for Occupational Health Reviews) C. According to inclusion criteria for Occupational Health and Safety topics (see PEROSH Clearinghouse Methods, Inclusion and classification Criteria for Occupational Health Reviews) 5.2 Selection: First step: Based on titles and abstract, two reviewers (Ulrike Euler and Alba Fishta) selected the retrieved articles independently resolving discrepancies by discussions. Second step: Based on the pre-selected full texts, two reviewers (Ulrike Euler and Alba Fishta) applied the above mentioned inclusion criteria independently resolving discrepancies by discussions or by consensus conference. Search Documentation Form Stress at work and CV diseases.doc - 4 -

5 6 Results: (Adapted from PRISMA 2009 Flow Diagram) Included Eligibility Screening Identification Records identified through the PubMed and EMBASE databases (n = 263) Records after duplicates removed (n = 2) Records (titles/abstracts) screened (n = 261) Full-text articles screened for eligibility (n = 51) Studies included in qualitative synthesis (n = 5) Additional records identified through other sources (please list them) (n = 0) Records excluded (n = 210) Full-text articles excluded with the following reasons: Language 2 (Chinese, Japanese) Duplications 1 Full texts not available 3 Other reasons 40 (e.g. wrong PICO, did not fulfil the PEROSH criteria, narrative reviews that did not make a systematic search) Search Documentation Form Stress at work and CV diseases.doc - 5 -

6 7 Grading of the Systematic Reviews: (adopted from SIGN Methodology Checklist) No I st author / Publication year Overall study assessment Internal validity 1. Eller adequately addressed, 1.2 adequately addressed, 1.3 adequately 2. Kivimaki 2006 addressed, 1.4 adequately addressed, 1.5 adequately addressed 1.2 Description of the data synthesis is missing. 1.4 A sensitivity analysis is not done to exclude the studies at low quality adequately addressed, 1.2 adequately addressed, 1.3 adequately addressed, 1.4 poorly addressed, 1.5 well covered 1.2 Quality assessment is not described. 1.4 Quality assessment is not there. 3. Mann adequately addressed, 1.2 poorly addressed, 1.3 adequately 4. Netterstrom Belkic 2004 addressed, 1.4 not addressed, 1.5 poorly addressed Comments 1.2 A quality evaluation of the studies included in the systematic review is not done. A description of data extraction and data synthesis is missing adequately addressed, 1.2 adequately addressed, 1.3 adequately addressed, 1.4 well covered, 1.5 well covered 1.2 Data synthesis and study inclusion/exclusion criteria are not described well covered, 1.2 adequately addressed, 1.3 adequately addressed, 1.4 well covered, 1.5 well covered 1.2 Description of the data synthesis is missing. Search Documentation Form Stress at work and CV diseases.doc - 6 -