UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD. INSTRADENT USA, INC. Petitioner

Transcription

1 Filed on behalf of Patent Owner Nobel Biocare Services AG By: Michelle E. Armond John B. Sganga, Jr. Rabinder N. Narula Sheila N. Swaroop KNOBBE, MARTENS, OLSON & BEAR, LLP 2040 Main Street, 14th Floor Irvine, CA Telephone: Facsimile: Filed: August 11, 2016 UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD INSTRADENT USA, INC. Petitioner V. NOBEL BIOCARE SERVICES AG Patent Owner. Case No. IPR U.S. Patent No. 8,714,977 PATENT OWNER S UPDATED EXHIBIT LIST

2 Pursuant to 37 C.F.R (e), Patent Owner Nobel Biocare Services AG ( Nobel ) hereby provides a current list of its exhibits Initial Determination in In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n Oct. 27, 2015) [redacted public version] 2002 [Nobel confidential] ITC Exhibit CX-1027C: Joe Day Direct Witness Statement [excerpted] 2003 [Nobel confidential] ITC Exhibit CX-1028: Dr. Ophir Fromovich Direct Witness Statement 2004 ITC Exhibit CX-1030C: Steven Hurson Direct Witness Statement 2005 [Nobel confidential] ITC Exhibit CX-1037C: Steve Hurson Rebuttal Witness Statement 2006 ITC Exhibit JX-0590: M. Kolinski et al., Evaluation of a Variable Thread Tapered Implant in Extraction Sites With Immediate Temporization: A 3 Year Multicenter Clinical Study, J. Periodontal 85(3): (March 2014) 2007 Statutory Disclaimer for 977 Patent 2008 Instradent Webpage ( ITC Exhibit CX-0546C: Domestic Industry Chart demonstrating that the NobelActive 4.3 x 13 mm implant is covered by the claims of 977 Patent 2010 ITC Exhibit CX-0597C: Nobel Biocare Brochure, NobelActive - the implant of the future 2011 ITC Exhibit CX-0598: Nobel Biocare Brochure, NobelActive - a new direction for implants -1-

3 2012 ITC Exhibit CX-0830: Nobel Active : The NobelActive Technical Story, technical brochure 2013 ITC Exhibit CX-0833: Nobel Biocare News (January 2013) 2014 ITC Exhibit CX-0837: Babbush, et al., A Single-Center Retrospective Analysis of 1001 Consecutively Placed NobelActive Implants, Implant Dentistry 21:1-8 (2012) 2015 ITC Exhibit CX-0839: NobelActive Receives Multiple Awards, Nobel Biocare media release 2016 ITC Exhibit CX-0840: Readers Choice Top 25 Implant Products, Nobel Biocare media release 2017 ITC Exhibit CX-0841: Top 100 Products, Nobel Biocare media release 2018 ITC Exhibit CX-0842: Hi-Tec Implants, ITC Exhibit CX-0843: Product Catalog for ADIN Dental Implant Systems LTD, ITC Exhibit CX-0854: Screenshot from video by Implant Direct regarding NobelActive backtapered design 2021 ITC Exhibit CX-1278: Niznick, Gerald A. DMD, Nobel Active Internal Hex Implant with Long Lead-in Bevel Nobel Marketing Claims this is the Implant of the Future 2022 ITC Exhibit JX-0303: Gultekin et al., Clinical Evaluation of Marginal Bone Loss and Stability in Two Types of Submerged Dental Implants, J. Int. J. Oral. Maxillofac. Implants 28: (2013) 2023 ITC Exhibit JX-0328: Implants with Conical Connection (abbreviated Nobel Product Catalog) -2-

4 2024 ITC Exhibit JX-0554: The CM Implant Line 2025 Nobel Biocare: Portrait of a Leader of Evidence-Based Restorative Dental Innovation 2026 Order No. 20 entered in In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n Apr. 2, 2015) exchange between Michelle E. Armond, counsel for Patent Owner, and Andrew R. Cheslock, Counsel for Petitioner 2028 Straumann 2014 Annual Report [excerpted] 2029 Declaration of Baraa Kahf in Support of Nobel s Opposition to Respondent s Motion to Compel Discovery from Complainants, In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n Jan. 9, 2015) from Andrew Cheslock, counsel for Petitioner, to counsel for Nobel, dated April 2, Order No. 23 entered in In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n Apr. 9, 2015) 2032 Transcript of July 9, 2015 proceedings In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n July 9, 2015) 2033 Respondent Neodent USA, Inc. s Objections and Responses to Nobel Biocare Services AG s and Nobel Biocare USA, LLC s First Set of Requests for Production of Documents and Things (Nos. 1-91), served in In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n Nov. 7, 2014) 2034 Commission Opinion in In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n May 11, 2016) [redacted public version] 2035 [Instradent Confidential] Declaration of Steven M. Hurson -3-

5 2036 Curriculum Vitae of Steve Hurson 2037 [Nobel Confidential] Declaration of Joe Day 2038 [Instradent Confidential] Initial Determination in In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (Int l Trade Comm n Oct. 27, 2015) [redacted confidential version, public version filed as Exhibit 2001] 2039 [Instradent Confidential] ITC Exhibit RX-0002C: Alexsander Golin Direct Witness Statement (with translation) 2040 [Instradent Confidential] Transcript from the Third Day of the ITC Hearing, Volume 3 in In the Matter of Certain Dental Implants, Inv. No. 337-TA-934 (July 09, 2015) [excerpted] 2041 Jaffin et al., The Excessive Loss of Branemark Fixtures in Type IV Bone: A 5-Year Analysis, J. Periodontol. 62:2-4 (1991) 2042 Johns et al., A Multicenter Study of Overdentures Supported by Brånemark Implants, Int. J. Oral Maxillofac. Implants 7: (1992) 2043 Salama et al., Immediate Loading of Bilaterally Splinted Titanium Root-Form Implants in Fixed Prosthodontics A Technique Reexamined: Two Case Reports, Int. J. Periodontics Restorative Dent. 15(4): (Aug. 1995) 2044 Ericsson et al., Different types of inflammatory reactions in periimplant soft tissues, J. Clin. Periodontol. 22: (1995) 2045 Tarnow et al., The Effect of Inter-Implant Distance on the Height of Inter-Implant Bone Crest, J. Periodontol. 71(4): (2000) 2046 Hurson, Laboratory Techniques to Prevent Screw Loosening on Dental Implants, J. Dent. Technol. (Apr. 1996) -4-

6 2047 Hermann et al., Crestal Bone Changes Around Titanium Implants: A Methodologic Study Comparing Linear Radiographic with Histometric Measurements, Int. J. Oral. Maxillofac. Implants 16(4): (2001) 2048 ITC Exhibit JX-0010 Biemmi, European Patent Application No ITC Exhibit JX-0014 U.S. Patent No. 5,000,686 (Lazzara) 2050 ITC Exhibit CX-0562 Jarvis et al., Biomechanical Advantages of Wide-Diameter Implants, Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry 18(7): (July 1997) 2051 ITC Exhibit CX-0838 Irinakis, et al., Initial Torque Stability of a New Bone Condensing Dental Implant. A Cohort Study of 140 Consecutively Placed Implants, J. Oral Implantol. 35(6): (2009) 2052 Picture of the JDEVOLUTION implant on the Advanced Dental Products website available at (accessed May 5, 2016) 2053 Picture of the Anthogyr Axiom PX implant on the Anthogyr library webpage at (accessed May 5, 2016) [excerpted] 2054 Picture of the Cortex Dynamix implant on the Cortex website available at (accessed May 5, 2016) 2055 Picture of the Megagen Reflect TM implant on the Integrated Dental Systems website available at Reflect Implant Systems, (accessed May 9, 2016) 2056 Nobel Biocare, Science First, Volume 1, Issue 1 (2013) -5-

7 2057 Nobel Biocare, Immediate Function in extraction sites proven concept with high patient satisfaction, Science First (2014) 2058 Nobel Biocare, NobelActive - stable bone levels and healthy soft tissue, Science First (2014) 2059 ITC Exhibit CX-0599: Nobel Biocare Brochure, implant solutions for every indication (2007) 2060 Nobel Biocare Brochure, Nobel Active : The NobelActive Clinical Story 2061 Nobel Biocare Presentation, NobelActive Features and Benefits [excerpted] 2062 Nobel Biocare Presentation, Guideline for the Speaker Active8 [excerpted] 2063 Nobel Biocare News (October 2007) 2064 Nobel Biocare, Media & News, Nobel Active named best implant system (Jan. 27, 2016) 2065 ITI International Team for Implantology Our Partner Webpage, (accessed May 10, 2016) 2066 Nobel Biocare Brochure, A new direction for implants. (2011) 2067 Nobel Biocare Media & News Release, NobelActive named top 25 implant product (June 18, 2014) 2068 The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language (4th ed. 2000) [excerpted] 2069 ITC Exhibit RX-0153: Misch, Contemporary Implant Dentistry (2d ed. 1999) [excerpted] 2070 Transcript of the August 11, 2016 Teleconference with the Patent Trial and Appeal Board -6-

8 Respectfully submitted, KNOBBE, MARTENS, OLSON & BEAR, LLP Dated: August 11, 2016 By: /Michelle E. Armond/ Michelle E. Armond (Reg. No. 53,954) John B. Sganga, Jr. (Reg. 31,302) Rabinder N. Narula (Reg. No. 53,371) Sheila N. Swaroop (Reg. No. 53,658) Attorneys for Patent Owner Nobel Biocare Services AG -7-

9 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that, pursuant to 37 C.F.R. 42.6(e) and with the agreement of counsel for the Petitioner, a true and correct copy of PATENT OWNER S UPDATED EXHIBIT LIST and EXHIBIT 2070 are being served electronically on August 11, 2016, to the addresses below: Paul S. Hunter phunter@foley.com Nicola A. Pisano npisano@foley.com Andrew R Cheslock acheslock@foley.com FOLEY & LARDNER LLP 3579 Valley Centre Drive San Diego, CA Dated: August 11, 2016 By: /Michelle E. Armond/ Michelle E. Armond (Reg. No. 53,954) John B. Sganga, Jr. (Reg. 31,302) Rabinder N. Narula (Reg. No. 53,371) Sheila N. Swaroop (Reg. No. 53,658) Attorneys for Patent Owner Nobel Biocare Services AG