The Primary Hyperoxalurias

Transcription

1 DISEASE OF THE MONTH Eberhard Ritz, Feature Editor J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 The Primary Hyperoxalurias ERNST LEUMANN* and BERND HOPPE *Division of Pediatric Nephrology, University Children s Hospital, Zurich, Switzerland, and Division of Pediatric Nephrology, University Children s Hospital, Cologne, Germany. Primary hyperoxaluria (PH) results from endogenous (primary) overproduction of oxalic acid, as opposed to secondary hyperoxaluria, which is attributable to increased intestinal absorption (enteric) or excessive intake (dietary) of oxalate. Why are nephrologists interested in PH type 1 (PH1), the prevailing type, although it is far from being a primary renal disorder? First, the clinical treatment of patients with this nephrologic liver disease is quite challenging, particularly in end-stage renal failure (ESRF). Second, the study of PH1 has yielded better understanding of the pathogenesis of calcium oxalate (CaOx) crystal deposition and stone formation in general, with this disease serving as a model of nephrocalcinosis and urolithiasis. Finally, fascinating insights into the mechanisms of cellular trafficking have been obtained from the study of PH1; however, many questions remain unresolved. It has also become apparent that PH encompasses more than PH1 and PH2, and some patients who were previously classified as having secondary hyperoxaluria might actually have a type of PH. Received September 25, Accepted March 5, Correspondence to Dr. Ernst Leumann, Division of Pediatric Nephrology, University Children s Hospital, Steinwiesstrasse 75, CH-8032 Zürich, Switzerland. Phone: ; Fax: ; E.Leumann@swissonline.ch / Journal of the American Society of Nephrology Copyright 2001 by the American Society of Nephrology PH1 Metabolic and Genetic Basis PH1, which is an autosomal recessive disease, is caused by a defect in glyoxylate metabolism attributable to low or absent activity of the liver-specific peroxisomal enzyme alanine/ glyoxylate aminotransferase (AGT) (392 amino acids, 43 kd) (Figure 1) (1,2). As a result, urinary excretion of oxalate and (in most cases) glycolate is greatly increased (2). Although massive intrarenal CaOx deposits were noted by Lepoutre in 1925 for a pediatric patient who was surgically treated for urolithiasis (abstract cited in reference 2), the disease was not named PH until 1957 (3) and the metabolic defect was localized in liver peroxisomes (therefore not within the cytosol, as previously thought) in 1986 (1). In contrast to PH1, patients with a primary peroxisomal disorder such as the Zellweger syndrome do not exhibit hyperoxaluria (2). Except for the AGT defect, peroxisomes in PH1 are normal in almost every respect; they appear only slightly smaller in electron microscopic evaluations (4). The functional deficiency of AGT in PH1 results in a failure to detoxify glyoxylate within the peroxisomes. Instead of being transaminated to glycine, glyoxylate is oxidized to oxalate and/or reduced to glycolate, resulting in greatly increased urinary excretion of oxalate and glycolate (Figure 1) (1,2,4). Glyoxylate itself is synthesized within the peroxisomes from glycine and glycolate (2). The gene coding for AGT, i.e., AGXT, is located on chromosome 2q37.3 and consists of 11 exons spanning approximately 10 kb (2,5). More than 30 mutations have been identified to date. There is considerable molecular heterogeneity; many patients are compound heterozygotes (frequently with only one allele identified), whereas populations with high rates of consanguinity, e.g., Israeli Arabs (6) or Northwest Africans (7), exhibit mutations in a homozygous pattern. One-half of the patients exhibit no detectable AGT catalytic activity, whereas the other half exhibit residual (2 to 48%) AGT activity (2,4). Why do individuals with residual AGT activity become ill, not differing clinically from patients with absent AGT activity? AGT is mistargeted from the peroxisomes to the mitochondria, as elegantly demonstrated by Danpure and co-workers (2,4,5). Although such patients often exhibit considerable residual enzymatic activity, only 10% of the immunoreactive AGT (crossreacting material positive) is localized within the peroxisomes; 90% is found within the mitochondria, where it is metabolically inactive. In his laureate speech, Günter Blobel, the 1999 recipient of the Nobel Prize in Medicine, referred specifically to PH1, in which the altered sorting signal leads to erroneous intracellular localization of the enzyme ( This protein-trafficking defect is unparalleled in human subjects (2). It is observed in approximately 30% of all patients with PH1, usually as the result of a 630G3A mutation (associated with a Pro11Leu polymorphism), which leads to a Gly170Arg amino acid substitution, or, less often, as the result of a 576T3A mutation (2,8). Pathophysiology Urine is a saturated solution, and its concentration can change very drastically within a short time (9). Stone formation or the development of nephrocalcinosis thus occurs when the delicate interplay between promotors (in PH1, especially oxalate) and inhibitors (e.g., citrate, magnesium, and glycosaminoglycans) of crystal formation is disturbed (9,10). In PH1, the urine is supersaturated with respect to CaOx (urinary CaOx

2 J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 Disease of the Month 1987 Figure 1. Metabolic defects in primary hyperoxaluria type 1 (PH1) [alanine/glyoxylate aminotransferase (AGT)] and PH2 [glyoxylate reductase (GR)/hydroxypyruvate reductase (HPR)]. Glyoxylate reductase also exhibits hydroxypyruvate reductase activity. GO, glycolate oxidase; DAO, D-amino oxidase; LDH, lactate dehydrogenase. saturation of 10 relative units) (2,8,11). This produces renal calculi, medullary nephrocalcinosis, or both. Oxalate is freely filtered in the glomerulus and is both secreted and reabsorbed in the proximal tubule (2). Oxalate transport across proximal tubular cells is complex, because this anion plays a role as a recycling substrate that functionally links the transcellular absorption of chloride to that of other anions (bicarbonate and sulfate) (12). At the basolateral membrane, oxalate enters the cell in exchange for sulfate or bicarbonate, via Sat-1 (12). At the luminal brush border membrane, oxalate is transported out of the cell in exchange for chloride and is transported back into the cell in exchange for sulfate. The overall result is a net secretion rate of 10 to 30%, corresponding to fractional oxalate excretion (C ox /C in ) of 1.09 to 1.28 (2). With physiologic concentrations of oxalate, occasional crystals either are passed as crystalluria particles or are endocytosed by renal epithelial cells (13). Endocytosed crystals are eliminated or are exocytosed to the basolateral side of the cells. From there, the crystals migrate to the interstitium, where they may eventually be destroyed by local inflammatory reactions involving macrophages (14). In PH1, far more oxalate is filtered in the glomeruli than under normal conditions, leading to extremely high oxalate concentrations within the proximal tubular cells. Until recently, these high oxalate concentrations were not considered to be harmful themselves, apart from the risk of CaOx deposit formation in the renal interstitium, followed by foreign-body reactions. However, it is now well established that high oxalate levels have direct toxic effects on renal tubular cells (15). Oxalate reduces both the growth rate and life span of LLC-PK1 cells (which resemble proximal tubular cells), in a concentration-dependent manner (15,16). Whereas oxalate acts as a mitogen at low concentrations, it is a toxic agent at high concentrations (16). These negative effects at the cellular level resemble those observed in other tissues after oxidative stress (15). Indeed, oxalate seems to promote the production of free radicals, which may explain its cellular toxicity (15,17). Because such effects are clearly concentration-dependent, this mechanism may directly contribute to rapid deterioration of renal function in PH1, which is much greater than that observed with nephrocalcinosis of other origins. In addition, the high plasma oxalate levels of patients with PH1 and renal insufficiency may exert toxic effects on other organs and tissues (18). Both plasma oxalate levels and plasma CaOx saturation values are significantly higher for patients with PH1 than for normal control subjects, even with normal renal function (19 21). The two parameters increase concomitantly (19 21) and are inversely correlated with the GFR (19). Plasma CaOx supersaturation (plasma CaOx saturation of 1), with plasma oxalate levels of 30 M, is observed with a GFR of 45 ml/min per 1.73 m 2, in contrast to non-ph1 patients, for whom supersaturation occurs only with a GFR of 8 ml/min per 1.73m 2 (18,19,21). CaOx crystal deposition therefore begins early in PH1, and patients are at risk of systemic CaOx deposition before the stage of chronic renal failure (19). Diagnosis Unfortunately, the diagnosis of PH1 is often overlooked or delayed; therefore, different diagnostic procedures are briefly discussed here.

3 1988 Journal of the American Society of Nephrology J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 Analysis of Urine. Hyperoxaluria is the hallmark of PH1. Urinary oxalate excretion is usually greatly elevated among patients with PH1 and recurrent urolithiasis and/or nephrocalcinosis, exceeding 2 mmol/24 h per 1.73 m 2 and sometimes even 4 mmol/24 h per 1.73 m 2 (normal, 0.5 mmol/24 h per 1.73 m 2 or 45 mg/24 h per 1.73 m 2 ) (2,8). However, family studies have demonstrated that some untreated patients with PH1 may exhibit only slightly elevated (0.5 to 1 mmol/24 h per 1.73 m 2 ) or even normal urinary oxalate excretion (22). Frequent sources of error are (1) incorrect urine collection (acidification to ph 2 is required to prevent deposition of insoluble CaOx), (2) failure to convert 24-h oxalate excretion values for pediatric patients to the adult surface area (1.73 m 2 )orto consult age-related tables for oxalate/creatinine ratios (8,10), and (3) renal insufficiency associated with oxalate retention and reduced urinary excretion. In such cases, plasma oxalate determinations may be helpful. Glycolate levels are elevated in only approximately two-thirds of patients with PH1; therefore, findings of normal values (which are in the same range as those for oxalate, in milligrams or millimoles) do not exclude this diagnosis (2,8). Plasma Oxalate Measurement. In patients with PH1, plasma oxalate levels, which are already elevated ( 6.3 M) with normal renal function, are significantly higher ( 80 to 100 M) in ESRF, compared with those for patients without PH1 (40 to 60 M) (18,19,21). Liver Biopsy Assessment. A definitive diagnosis (which is essential if liver transplantation is being considered) requires assessments of AGT activity and immunoreactivity in hepatic tissue (minimum of 2 mg), unless the diagnosis has been established at the molecular level (2,8). Testing for both PH1 and PH2 can be performed with the same needle-biopsy specimen of the liver (23). DNA Analysis. Patients with PH1 are frequently compound heterozygotes, and the mutation on the second allele often remains unidentified, which renders DNA analysis impractical as a diagnostic procedure (2,8). However, selective screening among populations with high incidences of specific homozygous mutations (e.g., Ile244Thr in North African patients) would be feasible (7). Prenatal diagnosis can be performed by linkage analysis using chorionic villous biopsy samples, if the family has been demonstrated to be informative for the linkage marker (24). Genetic counseling must take into account, however, the fact that family members carrying identical mutations may exhibit grossly discordant clinical features (22). Stone Analysis. The calculi of patients with PH1 consist almost exclusively of pure CaOx monohydrate (whewellite); this finding may yield a diagnostic clue (25,26). Microscopic analysis reveals a characteristic subtype (subtype 1c) that is virtually pathognomonic for PH1 (25). Bone biopsies for patients with renal failure, to demonstrate birefringent CaOx crystals, were previously used for diagnosis. Eyeground examinations are diagnostically important (Figure 2). Clinical Manifestations Recurrent urolithiasis and nephrocalcinosis are the main symptoms, and the combination of the two conditions, leading to progressive loss of renal function, is characteristic for PH1 (Figure 2). One-half of the patients exhibit their first symptoms by the age of 5 yr (range, 1st month of life to 6th decade) (27,28). Diagnosis is usually delayed by 5 yr, except among infants (28). Although PH1 is a monogenic disease, the clinical severity is not correlated with the mutation or the degree of residual functional AGT activity (2,4,22). The clinical, biochemical, and genetic heterogeneity is very large, with some patients presenting in infancy with renal failure and others experiencing only occasional passage of stones in adult life, with maintained renal function (2,4,22,27,28). Family screening has demonstrated that some patients are completely without symptoms (with neither nephrocalcinosis nor stones) (22,28). Even members of the same family, with identical mutations, may exhibit completely different clinical phenotypes, e.g., severe infantile oxalosis, compared with absent clinical findings (22). In a malignant variant (infantile PH1), the first symptoms occur very early (median age, 4 mo), and affected infants present at a median age of 6 mo with the triad of a failure to thrive, severe metabolic acidosis, and anemia, all of which are secondary to renal failure (29). This infantile form is characterized by rapid progression to ESRF and severe systemic oxalosis (29). Why these infants rapidly develop diffuse nephrocalcinosis (Figure 2) but not urolithiasis is not clear. Systemic Oxalosis. Oxalate is systemically deposited when the critical saturation point for plasma oxalate (plasma oxalate levels of 30 M) is reached, i.e., early in renal insufficiency (19). Deposition occurs in every organ and tissue except the liver and leads to disastrous complications, which should be prevented by all possible means. The bones are the most crippling site of CaOx deposition. The bone oxalate content in ESRF is considerably higher (15 to 910 mol oxalate/g bony tissue) than that among patients without PH1 (2 to 9 mol/g) (30). The lesions are characteristic both in x-rays (radiodense metaphyseal bands, a bone-within-bone appearance, and diffuse demineralization with a coarse trabecular pattern) and in histologic assessments (intraosseous tophi of CaOx and granulomas replacing bone marrow) (31). Clinical manifestations of oxalate osteopathy are pain, spontaneous fractures, and erythropoietin-resistant anemia (31,32). Retinal CaOx deposits, which are easy to diagnose, may be one of the first obvious signs of systemic oxalosis (Figure 2) (33). Additional important sites of CaOx deposits are the media of the arteries (with subsequent ischemia and gangrene), the peripheral nervous system (neuropathy), the myocardium (atrioventricular block), the thyroid gland, and the skin (livedo reticularis). Epidemiologic Features and Prognoses Because the diagnosis is often delayed or overlooked (27,28,34), the incidence of PH1 is easily underestimated. Data from the United Kingdom, Switzerland, and France suggest that 1 in 60,000 to 120,000 children has PH1 (27,28,35). The

4 J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 Disease of the Month 1989 Figure 2. Clinical findings of calcium oxalate (CaOx) deposits in PH1. (A) X-ray (plain film of the abdomen), demonstrating multiple kidney stones (some with a staghorn appearance) in a 7-yr-old patient with PH1 and renal failure. A double-j catheter was placed in the right ureter. Initial oxalate osteopathy, with cystic lesions in both femoral necks and pelvic bones, can also be observed. (B) Ultrasonogram (right kidney), demonstrating a white kidney, attributable to diffuse nephrocalcinosis, in a 3-mo-old patient with renal failure. (C) Eyeground examination image (6-yr-old patient), demonstrating numerous pitch-black foci (consisting of multiple layers of hyperplastic and hypertrophic retinal pigment epithelium) and multiple CaOx crystals in the inner retina. disease is far more common in certain countries such as Tunisia, where PH1 is the cause of ESRF for 13% of pediatric patients, compared with 0.7% (of those treated for ESRF) in North America and Europe (6,35). Clinical reports on PH1 are biased; of 330 patients reported, one-half were experiencing ESRF by the age of 15 yr (36). This finding contrasts with data from surveys performed in Switzerland and France, which demonstrated that ESRF occurred in 20% of patients by the age of 15 yr and in 50% of patients by the age of 25 yr (27,28). However, infantile oxalosis has a particularly poor prognosis, with one-half of the patients experiencing ESRF at the time of diagnosis and 80% developing ESRF by the age of 3 yr (29). The prediction of outcomes for individual patients is very difficult, if not impossible. Indeed, almost no renal disease is more problematic in this respect. Patients with PH1 with GFR of 50 ml/min may remain in stable condition for many years but may rapidly and irreversibly lose residual function during episodes of dehydration, urinary obstruction, or noncompliance. Nevertheless, the prognoses for patients with PH1 tend to be considerably better, if the disease is properly treated, than suggested in the literature. Treatment Conservative Therapy. The aims of therapy are to decrease oxalate production and to increase the urinary solubility of CaOx. The importance of close follow-up monitoring and of preventive measures to avoid episodes of dehydration cannot be overemphasized. Pyridoxine. Pyridoxal phosphate is an essential cofactor for aminotransferases such as AGT, and pharmacologic doses of pyridoxine (stepwise increases from 5 to 20 mg/kg per d, according to urinary oxalate excretion) are able to significantly reduce (by at least 30%) hyperoxaluria in one-third of patients (35). The patients most likely to respond are those with resid-

5 1990 Journal of the American Society of Nephrology J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 ual AGT activity (37). For assessment of pyridoxine responsiveness, reliable baseline values (a minimum of three) for urinary oxalate excretion are required. A trial of not less than 3 mo is warranted [determination of plasma oxalate levels is helpful in renal insufficiency (19,37)], although the effects are visible within 1 to 2 wk in most instances. Young infants may exhibit different behavior. Indeed, a 1-mo-old infant (with a 630G3A mutation) who failed to respond to high doses of pyridoxine in 2 mo exhibited a full response, within 1 wk, 14 yr later (E. Leumann, unpublished observations). Very high doses ( 30 mg/kg) are unnecessary and may lead to peripheral neuropathy. Occasionally, even low doses (20 mg/d) of pyridoxine may suffice (38). Pyridoxine responsiveness is still poorly understood at the molecular level (2). Direct pharmacologic interventions to reduce the glyoxylate or glycolate pools have not yet been successful (35). Enhancement of Solubility. Enhancement of the solubility of CaOx is essential. The most important and straightforward measure is to ensure a constant generous fluid intake ( 2.5 L/m 2 surface area per day), to avoid urinary oxalate concentrations exceeding 0.5 mm (or at most 0.8 mm); untreated patients with PH1 often exhibit values well above 1 mm. For infants, this may require continuous fluid administration via a nasogastric tube or gastrostomy. In addition, drugs that increase the urinary solubility product are of great importance. Orthophosphate (20 to 60 mg/kg body wt per d) has been demonstrated to reduce stone formation and delay CaOx deposition (39), and the same is true for alkali citrate (11). Citrate not only binds calcium but also is an inhibitor of CaOx crystal nucleation and growth (9). We use potassium citrate or a mixture of potassium citrate and sodium citrate (0.1 to 0.15 g/kg body wt per d), in three or four doses. Although there is experimental and clinical evidence for the beneficial effects of this treatment (11), it is difficult to conclusively prove its efficacy because of the sometimes unpredictable course of PH1. Magnesium is another potential inhibitor of CaOx aggregation, because it binds, instead of calcium, to oxalate. Therefore, a combination of alkali citrate and magnesium might enhance the inhibitory effects. Diet. Oxalate absorption studies using a stable isotope ( 13 C 2 ) suggested that intestinal absorption is 10% in healthy subjects (40). However, the contribution of dietary oxalate to the oxalate excreted in the urine is close to 50% in healthy individuals and exhibits great variation (10 to 72%) (41). People who lack the intestinal oxalate-degrading bacteria Oxalobacter formigenes exhibit greater dietary oxalate absorption (42). However, for patients with PH, oxalate of dietary origin contributes little to hyperoxaluria, because of their extremely high levels of endogenous oxalate production. It is therefore sufficient to avoid food with very high oxalate contents (beet root, spinach, rhubarb, and ice tea). Calcium restriction is not recommended, because less intestinal calcium would then be available to bind oxalate and to form insoluble CaOx complexes in the gut. Protein restriction has no place, because glycine, the precursor of glyoxylate (Figure 1), is not an essential amino acid. Vitamin C supplementation is not recommended, although ascorbic acid (a precursor of oxalate) contributes little to hyperoxaluria. Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy should be used with caution and only after generous hydration, because it may seriously harm the kidneys of patients with PH1 and nephrocalcinosis (43). Treatment in ESRF Dialysis. Neither hemodialysis nor peritoneal dialysis is able to keep pace with the endogenous production rate of oxalate, much less reduce the body oxalate burden (20,44). In fact, the weekly oxalate dialysance of renal replacement therapies (6 to 9 mmol/wk per 1.73 m 2 surface area) equals only the endogenous oxalate production of 2 to 3 d (44). Therefore, CaOx steadily accumulates, and CaOx crystals are deposited in other organs (systemic oxalosis), in addition to the kidney. Although the oxalate clearance is greater with hemodialysis (approximately 120 ml/min) than with peritoneal dialysis (approximately 7 ml/min), weekly oxalate elimination values are similar for the two renal replacement therapies (44). Not even the combination of the two therapies or the use of high-flux dialyzers, or hemofiltration, is able to prevent further oxalate retention (45); plasma oxalate levels and CaOx saturation values remain extremely elevated or increase even further (18). Therefore, intensified hemodialysis, with five or six 5-h sessions each week, may be necessary until transplantation is performed. Isolated Kidney Transplantation. Except among the few patients who respond well to pyridoxine (37), recurrent nephrocalcinosis and stone formation are expected to occur. Particular risk factors are long ischemia times (cold or warm) and any periods of graft dysfunction. The results of isolated, mostly cadaveric, kidney transplants performed in Europe in the 1980s were very poor, with 3-yr survival rates of only 20% for grafts and 74% for patients (46). This treatment modality has thus been largely abandoned there, in favor of combined liver/kidney transplantation. In contrast, isolated kidney transplantation (preferably with living related donors) is still favored in the United States (47). The medium-term results were acceptable, with actuarial 6-yr survival rates of 84% for patients and 51% for grafts; however, the 10-yr graft survival rate was only 35% (47). Combined Liver/Kidney Transplantation. The first liver transplant for a patient with PH1 was performed in 1984, before the basic enzymatic defect had been identified (48). Because the metabolic defect is in the liver, it is necessary to perform a total hepatectomy, although the liver is normal in every other respect (2). Auxiliary liver transplantation is not an option, because it would not affect oxalate overproduction by the patient s own liver (2,49). To date, 100 combined liver/ kidney transplants have been performed in Europe, according to the European Oxalosis Registry (Cambridge, UK) (50,51). Actuarial 5-yr survival rates (for 98 grafts in 93 patients) were 80% for patients and 71% for liver grafts (35,50,51). Notably, renal function has remained stable, with creatinine clearance rates of 40 to 60 ml/min per 1.73 m 2 after 5 yr. Specific risk factors are young age ( 5 yr) and long duration of dialysis ( 2 yr) (35,50,51). If the renal graft immediately

6 J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 Disease of the Month 1991 begins to function, there is no reason to perform additional hemodialysis or hemofiltration. Administration of generous amounts of fluids and treatment with alkali citrate during the first months are essential, because of the slow mobilization of the accumulated body stores of CaOx (18,37). In fact, both plasma oxalate levels and plasma CaOx saturation values, as well as urinary oxalate excretion, remain elevated for several months or even years after successful combined liver/kidney transplantation (2,18,37). In contrast, increased levels among patients without PH are normalized within 3 wk after transplantation (18,52). Preemptive (Isolated) Liver Transplantation. The rationale for preemptively performing liver transplantation, instead of waiting until ESRF occurs, initially seems straightforward (49). Indeed, if liver transplantation were a relatively harmless procedure and there were no shortage of organs, preemptive transplantation would probably be an accepted treatment method for many patients with PH1. However, the risks of graft loss or even the death of a patient who might have lived several years longer without any intervention raise serious ethical questions. Of additional concern is the need for immunosuppressive therapy with drugs that may severely compromise residual renal function and accelerate the onset of renal insufficiency. To date, more than a dozen patients with PH1 who were not experiencing renal failure have been treated in this way, with reasonable results (49). However, some of the patients might have maintained their renal function without intervention. The major problem concerns the timing of transplantation, because the natural course of the disease is so difficult to predict. Obviously, isolated liver transplantation can be successful only if renal failure is not too far advanced; the minimal GFR is probably 40 ml/min, or even 50 to 70 ml/min, with plasma oxalate levels of 30 M (8,18). If the GFR is 40 ml/min per 1.73 m 2, there is a high risk of rapid further decline, necessitating secondary kidney transplantation (49). Obviously, the overall results of isolated liver transplantation should be better with better residual renal function. However, with better preservation of renal function, the risks and efforts involved become increasingly disproportionate, with respect to the potential benefits of such a procedure. Treatment in ESRF among Infants and in Developing Countries. Therapy for infants with the malignant variant of PH1 presents particular problems. Because of their small size, such patients require peritoneal dialysis for extended periods, which is invariably leading to progressive systemic oxalosis, until combined liver/kidney transplantation becomes technically feasible. Some developing countries exhibit a high incidence of PH1 but lack the necessary infrastructure and resources for organ transplantation (29). Because dialysis is not a suitable alternative treatment for PH1, except for very limited periods, therapeutic withdrawal in both situations is an option that raises serious ethical questions (29). Prospects for Gene Therapy. Enzyme replacement therapy via liver transplantation might be considered an extreme form of gene therapy. Considerable problems must be solved before gene therapy in the strictly defined sense becomes applicable. By analogy to auxiliary liver transplantation (which does not work because oxalate is still produced in excess), gene therapy would require transfection of far more than 20 or 30% of liver cells, which is impossible to perform with current vector technology (53). Another potentially beneficial approach involves increasing the level of ATG expression (i.e., AGT activity) per cell by using superactive AGT constructs (C. J. Danpure, personal communication, July 2000); this approach would not yield higher overall transfection efficiency (i.e., the percentage of cells expressing AGT). Whether gene therapy alone, even with such constructs, would be able to compensate for the ongoing abnormal endogenous oxalate production by nontransfected cells is a matter of debate. The question of how often such gene therapy would need to be repeated is also unresolved. PH2 PH2 is a rare disorder, with 30 reported cases (54,55), and is likely to be underdiagnosed (35). Clinical manifestations are not as severe as in PH1 and consist primarily of urolithiasis. Nephrocalcinosis is rather unusual (occurring in 12% of patients), and systemic involvement is rare (54). The median age at onset is 15 yr; ESRF does occur but has not been observed in the pediatric age group. The hallmarks of PH2 are high levels of urinary excretion of oxalate and L-glyceric acid [normal, 28 mmol/mol creatinine (54)]; however, normal L- glyceric acid excretion was observed in one case (G. Rumsby, personal communication, November 2000). PH2 results from the deficiency of a cytosolic enzyme with glyoxylate reductase, hydroxypyruvate reductase, and D-glycerate dehydrogenase activities (Figure 1) (23,55,56). The tissue concentration of glyoxylate reductase/hydroxypyruvate reductase is high in the liver but low in the kidneys, lymphocytes, and fibroblasts (23). Diagnoses of PH2 can be confirmed by measurements of the glyoxylate reductase activity in liver biopsy samples (23). The responsible gene, GRHPR, was recently mapped to the centromeric region of chromosome 9 and contains nine exons, spanning 9 kb (55,56). Several mutations (mostly homogeneous) have been reported (57). As for PH1, supportive treatment includes confirmation of high fluid intake, administration of crystallization inhibitors, and prevention of complications; there is no rationale for the use of pyridoxine. Kidney transplantation does lead to recurrence, because hyperoxaluria and elevated L-glycerate excretion persist (54). More biochemical data are required before liver transplantation can be recommended (54). Atypical PH As has been the case for other metabolic diseases, the advent of enzyme measurements has clearly demonstrated that PH comprises more than PH1 and PH2. There have been reports of several pediatric patients, for whom both PH1 and PH2 were definitely excluded and who did not present evidence of secondary hyperoxaluria, who exhibited early (average age, 2 yr) manifestations of urolithiasis attributable to hyperoxaluria, sometimes combined with hypercalciuria (26,35,58). Should this condition be termed PH3? There is considerable evidence

7 1992 Journal of the American Society of Nephrology J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 that this condition is heterogeneous and involves further subtypes (e.g., PH3 and PH4). Conclusions Much progress has been made in recent years and the molecular genetic bases and enzyme diagnostic techniques have been firmly established for PH1 and PH2. However, considerable effort is required to explain the discrepancy between genotypes and phenotypes in PH1 and to define the underlying metabolic defects in atypical PH. Early diagnosis and aggressive conservative treatment are essential. Some controversy exists regarding the optimal therapy for patients with PH1 and renal insufficiency. The fact that no form of dialysis therapy is able to prevent progressive systemic oxalosis in ESRF is undisputed, however. The best medium- and long-term results have been achieved with combined liver/kidney transplantation, which corrects the metabolic defect. Intensified research in PH could also benefit the large numbers of patients with secondary hyperoxalurias, a goal also addressed by the Oxalosis and Hyperoxaluria Foundation ( References 1. Danpure CJ, Jennings PR, Watts RWE: Enzymological diagnosis of primary hyperoxaluria type I by measurement of hepatic alanine:glyoxylate aminotransferase. Lancet 1: , Danpure CJ: Primary hyperoxaluria. In: The Metabolic and Molecular Bases of Inherited Disease, edited by Scriver CR, Beaudet AL, Sly WS, Valle D, Childs B, Kinzler KW, Vogelstein B, New York, McGraw-Hill, 2001, pp Archer HE, Dormer AE, Scowen EF, Watts RWE: Primary hyperoxaluria. Lancet 2: , Danpure CJ, Jennings PR, Fryer P, Purdue PE, Allsop J: Primary hyperoxaluria type I: Genotypic and phenotypic heterogeneity. J Inherit Metab Dis 17: , Takada Y, Kaneko N, Esumi H, Purdue E, Danpure J: Human peroxisomal L-alanine:glyoxylate aminotransferase: Evolutionary loss of a mitochondrial targeting signal by point mutation of the initiating codon. Biochem J 268: , Rinat C, Wanders RJA, Drukker A, Halle D, Frishberg Y: Primary hyperoxaluria type 1: A model for multiple mutations in a monogenic disease within a distinct ethnic group. JAmSoc Nephrol 10: , Basmaison O, Bozon D, Rolland MO, Koch-Nogueira PC, Dumontel C, Divry P, Cochat P: Primary hyperoxaluria type 1: Clinical, enzymic and genetic study [Abstract]. Pediatr Nephrol 14: C36, Cochat P: Primary hyperoxaluria. Kidney Int 55: , Coe FL, Parks JH: New insights into the pathophysiology and treatment of nephrolithiasis: New research venues. J Bone Miner Res 12: , Leumann EP, Hoppe B: Urolithiasis in childhood. In: Therapeutic Strategies in Children with Renal Disease, edited by Proesmans W, London, Baillière s Clinical Paediatrics 5, 1997, pp Leumann E, Hoppe B, Neuhaus T, Blau N: Efficacy of oral citrate administration in primary hyperoxaluria. Nephrol Dial Transplant 10[Suppl 8]: 14 16, Karniski LP, Lötscher M, Fucentese M, Hilfiker H, Biber J, Murer H: Immunolocalization of Sat-1 sulfate/oxalate/bicarbonate anion exchanger in the rat kidney. Am J Physiol 275: F79 F87, Lieske JC, Deganello S: Nucleation, adhesion, and internalization of calcium-containing urinary crystals by renal cells. JAm Soc Nephrol 10[Suppl 14]: , Khan SR, Byer KJ, Thamilselvan S, Hackett RL, McCormack WT, Benson NA, Vaughn KL, Erdos G: Crystal-cell interaction and apoptosis in oxalate-associated injury of renal epithelial cells. J Am Soc Nephrol 10[Suppl 14]: , Scheid C, Koul H, Hill WA, Luber-Narod J, Kennington L, Honeyman T, Jonassen J, Menon M: Oxalate toxicity in LLC- PK1 cells: Role of free radicals. Kidney Int 49: , Koul H, Ebisuno S, Renzulli L, Yanagawa M, Menon M, Scheid C: Polarized distribution of the oxalate transport systems in LLC-PK1 cells, a line of renal epithelial cells. Am J Physiol 266: F266 F274, Lash LH, Tokarz JJ: Oxidative stress in isolated rat renal proximal and distal tubular cells. Am J Physiol 259: F338 F347, Hoppe B, Kemper MJ, Bökenkamp A, Portale AA, Cohn RA, Langman CB: Plasma calcium-oxalate supersaturation in children with primary hyperoxaluria and end-stage renal failure. Kidney Int 56: , Hoppe B, Kemper MJ, Bökenkamp A, Langman CB: Plasma calcium-oxalate saturation in children with renal insufficiency and in children with primary hyperoxaluria. Kidney Int 54: , Marangella M, Petrarulo M, Vitale C, Daniele PG, Sammartano S, Cosseddu D, Linari F: Serum calcium oxalate saturation in patients on maintenance hemodialysis for primary hyperoxaluria or oxalosis-unrelated renal diseases. Clin Sci 81: , Marangella M, Cosseddu D, Petrarulo M, Vitale C, Linari F: Thresholds of serum calcium oxalate supersaturation in relation to renal function in patients with or without primary hyperoxaluria. Nephrol Dial Transplant 8: , Hoppe B, Danpure CJ, Rumsby G, Fryer P, Jennings PR, Blau N, Schubiger G, Neuhaus T, Leumann E: A vertical (pseudodominant) pattern of inheritance in the autosomal recessive disease primary hyperoxaluria type I: Lack of relationship between genotype, enzymic phenotype and disease severity. Am J Kidney Dis 29: 36 44, Giafi CF, Rumsby G: Kinetic analysis and tissue distribution of human D-glycerate dehydrogenase/glyoxylate reductase and its relevance to the diagnosis of primary hyperoxaluria type 2. Ann Clin Biochem 35: , von Schnakenburg C, Weir T, Rumsby G: Linkage of microsatellites to the AGXT gene on chromosome 2q37.3 and their role in prenatal diagnosis of primary hyperoxaluria. Ann Hum Genet 61: , Daudon M, Estepa L, Lacour B, Jungers P: Unusual morphology of calcium oxalate calculi in primary hyperoxaluria. J Nephrol 11[Suppl 1]: 51 55, Neuhaus TJ, Belzer T, Blau N, Hoppe B, Sidhu H, Leumann E: Urinary oxalate excretion in urolithiasis and nephrocalcinosis. Arch Dis Child 82: , Cochat P, Deloraine A, Rotily M, Olive F, Liponski I, Deries N: Epidemiology of primary hyperoxaluria type 1. Nephrol Dial Transplant 10[Suppl 8]: 3 7, Kopp N, Leumann E: Changing pattern of primary hyperoxaluria in Switzerland. Nephrol Dial Transplant 10: , Cochat P, Koch Nogueira PC, Mahmoud MA, Jamieson NV, Scheinman JI, Rolland MO: Primary hyperoxaluria in infants:

8 J Am Soc Nephrol 12: , 2001 Disease of the Month 1993 Medical, ethical, and economic issues. J Pediatr 135: , Marangella M, Vitale C, Petrarulo M, Tricerri A, Carelli E, Cadario A, Barbos MP, Linari F: Bony content of oxalate in patients with primary hyperoxaluria or oxalosis-unrelated renal failure. Kidney Int 48: , Schnitzler CM, Kok JA, Jacobs DWC, Thomson PD, Milne FJ, Mesquita JM, King PC, Fabian VA: Skeletal manifestations of primary oxalosis. Pediatr Nephrol 5: , Toussaint C, De Pauw L, Vienne A, Gevenois PA, Quintin J, Gelin M, Pasteels JL: Radiological and histological improvement of oxalate osteopathy after combined liver-kidney transplantation in primary hyperoxaluria type I. Am J Kidney Dis 21: 54 63, Small KW, Scheinman J, Klintworth GK: A clinicopathological study of ocular involvement in primary hyperoxaluria type I. Br J Ophthalmol 76: 54 57, Hoppe B, Langman CB: Primary hyperoxaluria: From diagnosis to transplantation: A nationwide survey [Abstract]. JAmSoc Nephrol 9: 150A, Leumann E, Hoppe B: What is new in primary hyperoxaluria? Nephrol Dial Transplant 14: , Latta K, Brodehl J: Primary hyperoxaluria type I. Eur J Pediatr 149: , Marangella M: Transplantation strategies in type 1 primary hyperoxaluria: The issue of pyridoxine responsiveness. Nephrol Dial Transplant 14: , Yendt ER, Cohanim M: Response to a physiologic dose of pyridoxine in type I primary hyperoxaluria. N Engl J Med 312: , Milliner DS, Eickholt JT, Bergstralh EJ, Wilson DM, Smith LH: Results of long term treatment with orthophosphate and pyridoxine in patients with primary hyperoxaluria. N Engl J Med 331: , Hesse A, Schneeberger W, Engfeld S, von Unruh GE, Sauerbruch T: Intestinal hyperabsorption of oxalate in calcium oxalate stone formers: Application of a new test with [ 13 C 2 ]oxalate. JAm Soc Nephrol 10[Suppl 14]: , Holmes RP, Goodman HO, Assimos DG: Contribution of dietary oxalate to urinary oxalate excretion. Kidney Int 59: , Sidhu H, Hoppe B, Hesse A, Tenbrock K, Brömme S, Rietschel E, Peck AB: Absence of Oxalobacter formigenes in cystic fibrosis patients: A risk factor for hyperoxaluria. Lancet 352: , Boddy SA, Duffy PG, Barratt TM, Whitfield HN: Hyperoxaluria and renal calculi in children: The role of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy. Proc R Soc Med 81: , Hoppe B, Graf D, Offner G, Latta K, Byrd DJ, Michalk D, Brodehl J: Oxalate elimination via hemodialysis or peritoneal dialysis in children with chronic renal failure. Pediatr Nephrol 10: , Bunchman TE, Swartz RD: Oxalate removal in type I hyperoxaluria or acquired oxalosis using HD and equilibration PD. Perit Dial Int 14: 81 84, Broyer M, Brunner FP, Brynger H, Dykes SR, Ehrich JH, Fassbinder W, Geerlings W, Rizzoni G, Selwood NH, Tufveson G, et al.: Kidney transplantation in primary oxalosis: Data from the EDTA Registry. Nephrol Dial Transplant 5: , Saborio P, Scheinman JI: Transplantation for primary hyperoxaluria in the United States. Kidney Int 56: , Watts RWE, Calne RY, Rolles K, Danpure CJ, Morgan SH, Mansell MA, Williams R, Purkiss P: Successful treatment of primary hyperoxaluria type 1 by combined hepatic and renal transplantation. Lancet 2: , Nolkemper D, Kemper MJ, Burdelski M, Vaismann I, Rogiers X, Broelsch CE, Ganschow R, Müller-Wiefel DE: Long-term results of pre-emptive liver transplantation in primary hyperoxaluria type 1. Pediatr Transplant 4: , Jamieson NV, on behalf of the European PH 1 Transplantation Study Group: The European Primary Hyperoxaluria Type 1 Transplant Registry report on the results of combined liver/ kidney transplantation for primary hyperoxaluria Nephrol Dial Transplant 10[Suppl 8]: 33 37, Jamieson NV: Oxalosis registry [Abstract]. Nephrol Dial Transplant 14: 2788, Worcester EM, Fellner S, Nakagawa Y, Coe FL: Effect of renal transplantation on serum oxalate and urinary oxalate excretion. Nephron 67: , Danpure CJ: Molecular basis of PH 1: Implications for gene therapy [Abstract]. Nephrol Dial Transplant 14: 2784, Kemper MJ, Conrad S, Müller-Wiefel DE: Primary hyperoxaluria type 2. Eur J Pediatr 156: , Cramer SD, Ferree PM, Lin K, Milliner DS, Holmes RP: The gene encoding hydroxypyruvate reductase (GRHPR) is mutated in patients with primary hyperoxaluria type II. Hum Mol Genet 8: , Rumsby G, Cregeen DP: Identification and expression of a cdna for human hydroxypyruvate/glyoxylate reductase. Biochim Biophys Acta 1446: , Webster KE, Ferree PM, Holmes RP, Cramer SD: Identification of missense, nonsense, and deletion mutations in the GRHPR gene in patients with primary hyperoxaluria type II (PH2). Hum Genet 107: , Monico CG, Milliner DS: Hyperoxaluria and urolithiasis in young children: An atypical presentation. J Endourol 13: , 1999