Firming Up Inequality
|
|
- Dinah Allison
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1
2 Firming Up Inequality Jae Song Social Security Administration Fatih Guvenen Minnesota, FRB Mpls, NBER David Price Stanford Nicholas Bloom Stanford and NBER Till von Wachter UCLA and NBER February 5, 2016
3 Motivation I US income inequality has been rising for almost four decades Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 1 / 208
4 Motivation I US income inequality has been rising for almost four decades I Much research on inequality between groups defined by observable characteristics: education/skill, occupation, age, gender, race, and so on. Main conclusion: substantial rise in within-group inequality. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 1 / 208
5 Motivation I US income inequality has been rising for almost four decades I Much research on inequality between groups defined by observable characteristics: education/skill, occupation, age, gender, race, and so on. Main conclusion: substantial rise in within-group inequality. I This paper: study the employer/firm as an observable worker characteristic: Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 1 / 208
6 Motivation I US income inequality has been rising for almost four decades I Much research on inequality between groups defined by observable characteristics: education/skill, occupation, age, gender, race, and so on. Main conclusion: substantial rise in within-group inequality. I This paper: study the employer/firm as an observable worker characteristic: Between firms (e.g., top firms are paying better) Within firms (e.g., higher executive pay relative to average pay) Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 1 / 208
7 This Paper Two questions: Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 2 / 208
8 This Paper Two questions: 1. How much of the rise in income inequality is between firms and how much is within firms? For bottom 99% : Almost all of it between firms For the top 1% : Almost all of it between firms up to 99.8th percentile Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 2 / 208
9 This Paper Two questions: 1. How much of the rise in income inequality is between firms and how much is within firms? For bottom 99% : Almost all of it between firms For the top 1% : Almost all of it between firms up to 99.8th percentile Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 2 / 208
10 This Paper Two questions: 1. How much of the rise in income inequality is between firms and how much is within firms? For bottom 99% : Almost all of it between firms For the top 1% : Almost all of it between firms up to 99.8th percentile 2. Why has inequality risen so much between firms? Large rise in sorting between firms and workers Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 2 / 208
11 This Paper Two questions: 1. How much of the rise in income inequality is between firms and how much is within firms? For bottom 99% : Almost all of it between firms For the top 1% : Almost all of it between firms up to 99.8th percentile 2. Why has inequality risen so much between firms? Large rise in sorting between firms and workers Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 2 / 208
12 Outline I The Social Security Administration (SSA) database I Non-parametric results on inequality The bottom 99% Robustness (region, industry, gender, age, measures) The top 1% I More formal econometric approach I Why is this happening? The changing structure of firms Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 3 / 208
13 The Data
14 Data: SSA Master Earnings File I Universe of all W-2s from 1978 to Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 4 / 208
15 Data: SSA Master Earnings File I Universe of all W-2s from 1978 to I For each job: SSN, EIN, and total compensation Total compensation includes: wages, salaries, tips, restricted stock grants, exercised stock options, severance payments, and many other types of income considered remuneration for labor services by the IRS. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 4 / 208
16 Data: SSA Master Earnings File I Universe of all W-2s from 1978 to I For each job: SSN, EIN, and total compensation Total compensation includes: wages, salaries, tips, restricted stock grants, exercised stock options, severance payments, and many other types of income considered remuneration for labor services by the IRS. I For each worker: age, sex, place of birth, date of death Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 4 / 208
17 Data: SSA Master Earnings File I Universe of all W-2s from 1978 to I For each job: SSN, EIN, and total compensation Total compensation includes: wages, salaries, tips, restricted stock grants, exercised stock options, severance payments, and many other types of income considered remuneration for labor services by the IRS. I For each worker: age, sex, place of birth, date of death I For each EIN: 4-digit SIC (industry) code, location We define Firm = EIN (same as used by Bureau of Labor Statistics) Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 4 / 208
18 Data: SSA Master Earnings File I Universe of all W-2s from 1978 to I For each job: SSN, EIN, and total compensation Total compensation includes: wages, salaries, tips, restricted stock grants, exercised stock options, severance payments, and many other types of income considered remuneration for labor services by the IRS. I For each worker: age, sex, place of birth, date of death I For each EIN: 4-digit SIC (industry) code, location We define Firm = EIN (same as used by Bureau of Labor Statistics) I No top-coding; no survey response error Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 4 / 208
19 Building a US Matched Employer-Employee Dataset I MEF: Universe of US workers =) Universe of U.S. firms I Individuals assigned to firm where they earn most of their annual income. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 5 / 208
20 Building a US Matched Employer-Employee Dataset I MEF: Universe of US workers =) Universe of U.S. firms I Individuals assigned to firm where they earn most of their annual income. I Baseline: Firms with 20+ employees. Workers at those firms. Exclude government and education. Covers 1.1 million firms (about 18% of total) and 103 million workers (73% of total) and $5.4tn in wages (80% of total) Results robust to sample selection (All firms & all sectors) & worker assignment to firms. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 5 / 208
21 Firm Size Distribution: EIN vs. Census Firm (Log) Number of Firms SSA Firms Census Firms Employees Notes: Natural log of the number of firms in each size category are shown. Census figures count the number of employees at a point in time, while the SSA numbers count the number of FTEs over the course of a year. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 6 / 208
22 Total Payroll Total Income Over Time Total Income (Trillions of 2012 Dollars) SSA total NIPA Year Notes: SSA data includes all entries in the MEF. All data are adjusted for inflation using the PCE price index. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 7 / 208
23 Total Employment Total Employment (Millions) SSA individuals Total Employment Over Time CPS Total Employment Year Notes: SSA data includes all entries in the MEF. Current Population Survey (CPS) total employment shows the yearly average of the monthly employment numbers in the CPS. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 8 / 208
24 Number of Firms Total Firms Over Time Number of Firms (Millions) SSA firms Census Firms Year Notes: SSA data includes all entries in the MEF. Census firms shows the total number of firms reported by the Census Bureau s Statistics of U.S. Businesses data set. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 9 / 208
25 EMPIRICAL RESULTS
26 Basic Variance Decomposition I w ij t : log income of worker i at firm j Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 10 / 208
27 Basic Variance Decomposition I w ij t : log income of worker i at firm j I Simple decomposition: w ij t w j t {z} Firm avg. wage + h w ij t w j t i {z } Worker wage rel. to firm avg. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 10 / 208
28 Basic Variance Decomposition I w ij t : log income of worker i at firm j I Simple decomposition: w ij t w j t {z} Firm avg. wage + h w ij t w j t i {z } Worker wage rel. to firm avg. ) var i (w ij t {z } ) var j (w j t {z } ) + Total dispersion Between-firm dispersion JX P j var i (w ij t i 2 j). {z } Within-firm j dispersion j=1 P j : employment share of firm j Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 10 / 208
29 Total Wage Inequality Variance of Log(Wage) Total Variance Year Note: Firms with less than 10,000 FTE employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 11 / 208
30 Total vs. Between-Firm Wage Inequality Variance of Log(Wage) Total Variance Between Firm Year Note: Firms with less than 10,000 FTE employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 12 / 208
31 Total vs. Between-Firm Wage Inequality Variance of Log(Wage) Total Variance Between Firm Year Note: Firms with less than 10,000 FTE employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 13 / 208
32 Total, Between- and Within-Firm Inequality Variance of Log(Wage) Total Variance Within Firm Between Firm Year Note: Firms with less than 10,000 FTE employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 14 / 208
33 Large Firms Only (10,000+ FTE) Variance of Log(Wage) Total Variance Within Firm Between Firm Year Note: Firms with more than 10,000 FTE employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 15 / 208
34 A GRAPHICAL FRAMEWORK
35 Empirical Framework 0.4 Year = Density Income Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 17 / 208
36 Empirical Framework 0.4 Year = Density P10 P50 P90 Income Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 18 / 208
37 Empirical Framework 0.4 Year = Density P10 P50 P90 Income 0.4 Year = Density P10 P50 P90 Income Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 19 / 208
38 Example: No Rise in Inequality Earnings Change: 1982 to Individuals Percentiles of Earnings Distribution Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 20 / 208
39 Example: Rise in Inequality Between Top and Rest Earnings Change: 1982 to Individuals Percentiles of Earnings Distribution Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 21 / 208
40 Example: Rise in Inequality Everywhere Earnings Change: 1982 to Individuals Percentiles of Earnings Distribution Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 22 / 208
41 RESULTS: BOTTOM 99%
42 Wage Inequality: By Percentile Log Change, Indv Total Wage 50%ile 1981: $32k 2013: $36k top %ile 1981: $280k 2013: $540k Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 24 / 208
43 Calculating Average Log Employer Pay Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 25 / 208
44 Calculating Average Log Employer Pay I Take the employers of workers who are in the same percentile bin of income distribution. I Then compute the average of log pay of each employer in this group. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 25 / 208
45 Calculating Average Log Employer Pay I Take the employers of workers who are in the same percentile bin of income distribution. I Then compute the average of log pay of each employer in this group. I Then compute the average of average log pay across all employers in the group Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 25 / 208
46 Wage Inequality: Between Firms Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm 50%ile 1981: $30k 2013: $35k top %ile 1981: $49k 2013: $83k Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 26 / 208
47 Wage Inequality: Within Firms Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average 50%ile 1981: : 1.03 top %ile 1981: : Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 27 / 208
48 ROBUSTNESS
49 Wage Inequality: Within Firms Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 29 / 208
50 Many Measures of Firm Pay Log Change, Avg of Log Wages at Firm (Difference) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 30 / 208
51 Many Measures of Firm Pay Log Change, Avg of Log Wages at Firm (Difference) Firm Log Average (Leaving Out Indv) (Difference) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 31 / 208
52 Many Measures of Firm Pay Log Change, Avg of Log Wages at Firm (Difference) Firm Log Average (Leaving Out Indv) (Difference) Firm Average Wage (Difference) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 32 / 208
53 Many Measures of Firm Pay Log Change, Avg of Log Wages at Firm (Difference) Firm Log Average (Leaving Out Indv) (Difference) Firm Average Wage (Difference) 50th %ile at Firm (Difference) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 33 / 208
54 Robustness: Std Dev. Log Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 34 / 208
55 Robustness: Std Dev. Log Wage Log Change, Std Dev of Log Wage at Firm Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 34 / 208
56 Robustness: Frac. Going to Bottom 95% Log Change, Frac of Wages to Bottom 95% Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 35 / 208
57 Individual Industries
58 Wage Inequality: Controlling for (4-Digit SIC) Industry Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 37 / 208
59 Wage Inequality: Controlling for (4-Digit SIC) Industry Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Within Industry Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 37 / 208
60 Fama-French Industries: Beer and Liquor Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Beer & Liquor Note: Sample contains an average of 65,660 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 38 / 208
61 Fama-French Industries: Candy and Soda Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains an average of 193,000 workers in 1981 and Candy & Soda Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 39 / 208
62 Fama-French Industries: Pharmaceuticals Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Pharmaceutical Products Note: Sample contains an average of 140,650 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 40 / 208
63 Fama-French Industries: Chemicals Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains an average of 644,660 workers in 1981 and Chemicals Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 41 / 208
64 Fama-French Industries: Defense Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains an average of 74,350 workers in 1981 and Defense Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 42 / 208
65 Fama-French Industries: Recreation Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Recreation Note: Sample contains an average of 142,200 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 43 / 208
66 Fama-French Industries: Utilities Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Utilities Note: Sample contains an average of 703,320 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 44 / 208
67 Fama-French Industries: Consumer Goods Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains an average of 1,699,270 workers in 1981 and Consumer Goods Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 45 / 208
68 Fama-French Industries: Communication Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Communication Note: Sample contains an average of 951,920 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 46 / 208
69 Fama-French Industries: Computers Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Computers Note: Sample contains an average of 197,520 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 47 / 208
70 Fama-French Industries: Electronic Equipment Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Electronic Equipment Note: Sample contains an average of 407,150 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 48 / 208
71 Fama-French Industries: Agriculture Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains an average of 931,380 workers in 1981 and Agriculture Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 49 / 208
72 Fama-French Industries: Insurance Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains an average of 1,452,050 workers in 1981 and Insurance Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 50 / 208
73 Fama-French Industries: Trading Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Trading Note: Sample contains an average of 1,240,390 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 51 / 208
74 Exceptions
75 Fama-French Industries: Healthcare Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Healthcare Note: Sample contains an average of 7,667,800 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 53 / 208
76 Fama-French Industries: Banking Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Banking Note: Sample contains an average of 2,013,760 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 54 / 208
77 Fama-French Industries: Apparel Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Apparel Note: Sample contains an average of 606,320 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 55 / 208
78 Fama-French Industries: Hotels & Restaurants Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Log Wages at Firm Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Restaurants, Hotels, Motels Note: Sample contains an average of 2,610,400 workers in 1981 and Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 56 / 208
79 Subgroups: Bottom 99 pct I By Industry: HERE I By Region: HERE I By Firm Size: HERE I By Sex: HERE I By Age: HERE Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 57 / 208
80 RESULTS: TOP 1%
81 Rise in Top 1% Inequality Log Change, Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 59 / 208
82 Rise in Top 1% Inequality: Largely Between Firms Log Change, Firm Average Wage Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 60 / 208
83 Rise in Top 1% Inequality: Largely Between Firms Log Change, Firm Average Wage Indv Total Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 61 / 208
84 CAUTION
85 Firm Size: 20 10, 000 FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 63 / 208
86 Firm Size: 10, 000+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 64 / 208
87 Recap: Between- vs. Within Rise in Inequality: Fraction Within-Firm Firm Size Percentiles Income Percentiles Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 65 / 208
88 Bottom 99%: Almost All Between Firms Rise in Inequality: Fraction Within-Firm Firm Size Percentiles Income Percentiles Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 66 / 208
89 Rise in Within-Firm: Top 0.5% of Firms Rise in Inequality: Fraction Within-Firm Firm Size Percentiles Income Percentiles Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 67 / 208
90 Why Are Large Firms Different? 1. Top End Figure: Sensitivity to S&P Returns, By Employee Rank and Firm Size Regression Coefficient k Rank Within Firm log(wage) vs log(s&p 500) w/ controls, Aggregated by Geometric Mean, Winsorized at Max in Execucomp Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 68 / 208
91 Why Are Large Firms Different? 1. Top End Figure: Sensitivity to S&P Returns, By Employee Rank and Firm Size Regression Coefficient k 1k 5k Rank Within Firm log(wage) vs log(s&p 500) w/ controls, Aggregated by Geometric Mean, Winsorized at Max in Execucomp Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 69 / 208
92 Why Are Large Firms Different? 1. Top End Figure: Sensitivity to S&P Returns, By Employee Rank and Firm Size Regression Coefficient k 1k 5k 5k 10k Rank Within Firm log(wage) vs log(s&p 500) w/ controls, Aggregated by Geometric Mean, Winsorized at Max in Execucomp Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 70 / 208
93 Why Are Large Firms Different? 1. Top End Figure: Sensitivity to S&P Returns, By Employee Rank and Firm Size Regression Coefficient k 1k 5k 5k 10k 10k Rank Within Firm log(wage) vs log(s&p 500) w/ controls, Aggregated by Geometric Mean, Winsorized at Max in Execucomp Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 71 / 208
94 Why Are Large Firms Different? 2. Bottom End Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 72 / 208
95 Why Are Large Firms Different? 2. Bottom End Figure: Change in Wage Percentiles By Firm Size 10th %ile 10th %ile Log Change in Indv Pctls Since th %ile 50th %ile 75th %ile 90th %ile Year 1000 Firm Size < 2000 Log Change in Indv Pctls Since th %ile 50th %ile 75th %ile 90th %ile Year 10,000 Firm Size Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 72 / 208
96 ) Major Change in Firm Size Pay Relation Number of Employees (Thousands) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Median of Firm Size, 20 Firm Size Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 73 / 208
97 What is the Role of CEO Pay in Rising Inequality? Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 74 / 208
98 What is the Role of CEO Pay in Rising Inequality? As for wages and salaries... all the big gains are going to a tiny group of individuals holding strategic positions in corporate suites. Paul Krugman (NY Times, 02/23/2015) Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 74 / 208
99 What is the Role of CEO Pay in Rising Inequality? As for wages and salaries... all the big gains are going to a tiny group of individuals holding strategic positions in corporate suites. Paul Krugman (NY Times, 02/23/2015) The primary reason for increased income inequality in recent decades is the rise of the supermanager. Piketty (2013, p. 315) Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 74 / 208
100 What is the Role of CEO Pay in Rising Inequality? As for wages and salaries... all the big gains are going to a tiny group of individuals holding strategic positions in corporate suites. Paul Krugman (NY Times, 02/23/2015) The primary reason for increased income inequality in recent decades is the rise of the supermanager. Piketty (2013, p. 315) I Policy: Dodd-Frank act (Section 953(b)): companies to report the ratio of top executives compensation to average wage in the firm. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 74 / 208
101 Rise in Inequality: Baseline Log Change, Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 75 / 208
102 Rise in Inequality Without Top Executives Log Change, Indv Total Wage Indv Total Wage (Non Top 1 Employees) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 76 / 208
103 Rise in Inequality Without Top Executives Log Change, Indv Total Wage Indv Total Wage (Non Top 1 Employees) Indv Total Wage (Non Top 5 Employees) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 77 / 208
104 Rise in Inequality Without Top Execs: FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Indv Total Wage (Non Top 1 Employees) Indv Total Wage (Non Top 5 Employees) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 78 / 208
105 Top 1% Inequality Without Top Executives: Baseline Log Change, Indv Total Wage Indv Total Wage (Non Top 1 Employees) Indv Total Wage (Non Top 5 Employees) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Excluding top 5 individuals reduces the sample size from 76,251 to 73,620 in 1982 ( 3.45%) and from 119,155 to 115,602 in 2012 ( 2.97%). Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 79 / 208
106 Top 1% Inequality Without Top Executives: FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Indv Total Wage (Non Top 1 Employees) Indv Total Wage (Non Top 5 Employees) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 80 / 208
107 Why Don t Executives Matter (Much)? I US Wages and Salaries: $6.9 Trillion I Wage income share of top 1 percent: 12% (Guvenen, Kaplan, and Song (2014)) 12% of $6.9 Tr = $828 Billion I Average annual compensation of S&P500 CEOs: $22 million Total income: $22 million 500 = $11 Billion I $11B Large firm CEOs account for: $828B of top 1 percent. = 1.3% of the total compensation I Bottom line: Top executives control too small a share of the top incomes to make a dent. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 81 / 208
108 Subgroups: Top 1 pct I By Industry: HERE I By Region: HERE I By Firm Size: HERE I By Sex: HERE I By Age: HERE Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 82 / 208
109 A More Formal Econometric Approach
110 What We Have Done So Far I A simple decomposition: w ij t = w j t + h w ij t w j t var i (w ij t )= var j(w j t {z } ) + Between-firm dispersion i JX P j var i (w ij t i 2 j). {z } Within-firm jdispersion j=1 Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 84 / 208
111 What We Have Done So Far I A simple decomposition: w ij t = w j t + h w ij t w j t var i (w ij t )= var j(w j t {z } ) + Between-firm dispersion I Our main conclusion: i JX P j var i (w ij t i 2 j). {z } Within-firm jdispersion j=1 large increase in between-firm dispersion little change in within-firm dispersion, except at the top end for very large firms Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 84 / 208
112 What We Have Done So Far I A simple decomposition: w ij t = w j t + h w ij t w j t var i (w ij t )= var j(w j t {z } ) + Between-firm dispersion I Our main conclusion: i JX P j var i (w ij t i 2 j). {z } Within-firm jdispersion j=1 large increase in between-firm dispersion little change in within-firm dispersion, except at the top end for very large firms I Q: Can we go deeper into between and within-firm components? Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 84 / 208
113 AKM+ Decomposition I Consider this model for wages: w ij t = {z} i + j {z} Worker FE Firm FE + Xt i {z} + " i t (1) Time var. char. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 85 / 208
114 AKM+ Decomposition I Consider this model for wages: w ij t = {z} i + j {z} Worker FE Firm FE + Xt i {z} + " i t (1) Time var. char. I Estimating (1) from US population: 150 million worker FEs and 6 million firm FEs. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 85 / 208
115 AKM+ Decomposition I Consider this model for wages: w ij t = {z} i + j {z} Worker FE Firm FE + Xt i {z} + " i t (1) Time var. char. I Estimating (1) from US population: 150 million worker FEs and 6 million firm FEs. I Set X i t 0 for a moment. Average firm wage: w j t = j + j Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 85 / 208
116 AKM+ Decomposition I Consider this model for wages: w ij t = {z} i + j {z} Worker FE Firm FE I Estimating (1) from US population: 150 million worker FEs and 6 million firm FEs. + Xt i {z} + " i t (1) Time var. char. I Set X i t 0 for a moment. Average firm wage: w j t = j + j I Key decomposition: var i (w ij t )= var j( j )+var j ( j )+cov( i, j ) {z } Between-firm dispersion + X P j (var i ( i i 2 j)+var i (" i t i 2 j)) j {z } Within-firm dispersion Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 85 / 208
117 AKM Decomposition, Cont d Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 86 / 208
118 AKM Decomposition, Cont d Change in: = i + j + Xt i + " i t Baseline Drop mega firms Drop large firms Between-Firm var j ( j ) Components + var j ( j ) of Variance + 2 cov( i, j ) w ij t + 2 cov( i + j, X i b) = Between-firm var Within-Firm var i ( i + X i b i 2 j) Components + var i (" i t i 2 j) of Variance = Within-firm var Total in var(w ij t ) Note: Mega firms: 10,000+ male employees. Large firms: 1,000+ employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 86 / 208
119 AKM Decomposition, Cont d Change in: = i + j + Xt i + " i t Baseline Drop mega firms Drop large firms Between-Firm var j ( j ) Components + var j ( j ) of Variance + 2 cov( i, j ) w ij t + 2 cov( i + j, X i b) = Between-firm var Within-Firm var i ( i + X i b i 2 j) Components + var i (" i t i 2 j) of Variance = Within-firm var Total in var(w ij t ) Note: Mega firms: 10,000+ male employees. Large firms: 1,000+ employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 86 / 208
120 AKM Decomposition, Cont d Change in: = i + j + Xt i + " i t Baseline Drop mega firms Drop large firms Between-Firm var j ( j ) Components + var j ( j ) of Variance + 2 cov( i, j ) w ij t + 2 cov( i + j, X i b) = Between-firm var Within-Firm var i ( i + X i b i 2 j) Components + var i (" i t i 2 j) of Variance = Within-firm var Total in var(w ij t ) Note: Mega firms: 10,000+ male employees. Large firms: 1,000+ employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 86 / 208
121 Increasing Sorting Joint Worker and Firm Fixed Effect Distribution Interval 1: Proportion of Observations Firm Fixed Effect Decile Worker Effect Decile 1 Worker Effect Decile 2 Worker Effect Decile 3 Worker Effect Decile 4 Worker Effect Decile 5 Worker Effect Decile 6 Worker Effect Decile 7 Worker Effect Decile 8 Worker Effect Decile 9 Worker Effect Decile 10 Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 87 / 208
122 Increasing Sorting Joint Worker and Firm Fixed Effect Distribution Interval 5: Proportion of Observations Firm Fixed Effect Decile Worker Effect Decile 1 Worker Effect Decile 2 Worker Effect Decile 3 Worker Effect Decile 4 Worker Effect Decile 5 Worker Effect Decile 6 Worker Effect Decile 7 Worker Effect Decile 8 Worker Effect Decile 9 Worker Effect Decile 10 Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 88 / 208
123 Increasing Sorting.01 Change in Joint Worker and Firm Fixed Effect Distribution from Interval 1 to 5 Proportion of Observations Firm Fixed Effect Decile Worker Effect Decile 1 Worker Effect Decile 2 Worker Effect Decile 3 Worker Effect Decile 4 Worker Effect Decile 5 Worker Effect Decile 6 Worker Effect Decile 7 Worker Effect Decile 8 Worker Effect Decile 9 Worker Effect Decile 10 Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 89 / 208
124 Related Evidence I (US, ) Rise in between-establishment dispersion of average wage in manufacturing tracks rise in wage dispersion across workers (Dunne et al (2004)). Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 90 / 208
125 Related Evidence I (US, ) Rise in between-establishment dispersion of average wage in manufacturing tracks rise in wage dispersion across workers (Dunne et al (2004)). I (US: ) Rise in between-establishment inequality is 2/3 of rise in overall wage inequality (Barth et al (2014)). Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 90 / 208
126 Related Evidence I (US, ) Rise in between-establishment dispersion of average wage in manufacturing tracks rise in wage dispersion across workers (Dunne et al (2004)). I (US: ) Rise in between-establishment inequality is 2/3 of rise in overall wage inequality (Barth et al (2014)). I Very similar results for UK ( ), Faggio, et al (2007) Germany ( ), Card et al (2013) Brazil ( ), Helpman et al (2015) Sweden ( ), Håkanson et al (2015)) I So, whatever the driving force(s) are, they seem global. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 90 / 208
127 Further Thoughts I Why are worker FEs getting (i) more dispersed across firms, and (ii) more systematically related to firm FEs (sorting)? Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 91 / 208
128 Further Thoughts I Why are worker FEs getting (i) more dispersed across firms, and (ii) more systematically related to firm FEs (sorting)? I In our estimation, correlation between j and j goes from 0.12 up to 0.52 (by 0.40) over the period. Hakanson et al (2015): increasing sorting by cognitive and noncognitive skills in Sweden due to stronger complementarities between worker skills and technology. Handwerker and Spletzer (2015): Increasing occupational segregation in the US. Increased domestic outsourcing: Dube and Kaplan (2010), Berlingieri (2014), and Goldschmidt and Schmieder (2015) Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 91 / 208
129 Conclusions I Rising in income inequality is almost entirely between firms. Within-firm inequality flat. True for very fine industry groups, across regions, and across firm size categories. Only exception: Very large firms. Within dispersion increased both at very top end and bottom end. I Rise in between inequality, not due to firm effects, but due to rising dispersion of worker FEs and increased sorting. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 92 / 208
130 Conclusions I Rising in income inequality is almost entirely between firms. Within-firm inequality flat. True for very fine industry groups, across regions, and across firm size categories. Only exception: Very large firms. Within dispersion increased both at very top end and bottom end. I Rise in between inequality, not due to firm effects, but due to rising dispersion of worker FEs and increased sorting. I Evidence points to major changes in firms organization. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 92 / 208
131
132 APPENDIX
133 What is an EIN? I Our definition of a firm is an Employer Identification Number (EIN) I Any firm with an employee (issued a W-2) must have an EIN, issued by the IRS. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 95 / 208
134 What is an EIN? I Our definition of a firm is an Employer Identification Number (EIN) I Any firm with an employee (issued a W-2) must have an EIN, issued by the IRS. I Many firms use only 1 EIN (e.g. Facebook, Google, Walmart stores) Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 95 / 208
135 What is an EIN? I Our definition of a firm is an Employer Identification Number (EIN) I Any firm with an employee (issued a W-2) must have an EIN, issued by the IRS. I Many firms use only 1 EIN (e.g. Facebook, Google, Walmart stores) I Some firms use different EINs for different divisions For example: Stanford has 1 for the university, 1 for each hospital and 1 for the bookshop General Electric has about 80 EINs. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 95 / 208
136 What is an EIN? I Our definition of a firm is an Employer Identification Number (EIN) I Any firm with an employee (issued a W-2) must have an EIN, issued by the IRS. I Many firms use only 1 EIN (e.g. Facebook, Google, Walmart stores) I Some firms use different EINs for different divisions For example: Stanford has 1 for the university, 1 for each hospital and 1 for the bookshop General Electric has about 80 EINs. I Bureau of Labor Statistics uses the EIN as the definition of firm. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 95 / 208
137 Wage Inequality: Median Firm Wage Log Change, th %ile at Firm Indv Total Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Note: Sample contains workers in firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 96 / 208
138 Firm as the Unit of Analysis I Group firms by average pay I Group firms by size (employment) Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 97 / 208
139 Standard Deviation of Log Wages Log Change, Std Dev of Log Wage at Firm Firm Average Wage Percentile of Firm Average Wage Note: Sample contains firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 98 / 208
140 Frac. to Bottom 95% Log Change, Frac of Wages to Bottom 95% Firm Average Wage Percentile of Firm Average Wage Note: Sample contains firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 99 / 208
141 Avg. of Log Wages Log Change, Average of Log Wages at Firm Firm Average Wage Percentile of Firm Average Wage Note: Sample contains firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 100 / 208
142 Ranking Firms By Size
143 Firm Size Distribution Table: Percentiles for Firm Size Distribution Number of Employees P50 P90 P95 P99 P99.5 P99.9 P ,178 3,270 13,180 58,335 Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 102 / 208
144 Rise in Pay Inequality: Firms By Size Log Change, Firm Average Wage Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 103 / 208
145 Change in P10 by Firm Size Log Change, th %ile at Firm Firm Average Wage Difference Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 104 / 208
146 Change in P90 By Firm Size Log Change, th %ile at Firm Firm Average Wage Difference Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 105 / 208
147 Inequality by Firm Size: Standard Deviation Log Change, Std Dev of Log Wage at Firm Firm Average Wage Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 106 / 208
148 Inequality by Firm Size: Frac. Wages to Bottom 95% Log Change, Frac of Wages to Bottom 95% Firm Average Wage Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 107 / 208
149 P90-10 Log Change, Diff at Firm Firm Average Wage Percentile of Firm Average Wage Note: Sample contains firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 108 / 208
150 Avg of Bottom 95% Log Change, Avg of Bottom 95% at Firm Firm Average Wage Difference Percentile of Firm Average Wage Note: Sample contains firms with 20+ full-time equivalent employees. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 109 / 208
151 Change in Avg. Log Wages by Firm Size Log Change, Average of Log Wages at Firm Firm Average Wage Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 110 / 208
152 Inequality by Firm Size Log Change, Diff at Firm Firm Average Wage Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 111 / 208
153 Avg. of Bottom 95% by Firm Size Log Change, Avg of Bottom 95% at Firm Firm Average Wage Difference Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 112 / 208
154 Bottom 99%: Industries
155 Industry: Ag/Mining/Construction/Other Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 114 / 208
156 Industry: Manufacturing Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 115 / 208
157 Industry: Utilities Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 116 / 208
158 Industry: Finance/Insurance/Real Estate Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 117 / 208
159 Industry: Services Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 118 / 208
160 Bottom 99%: US Regions
161 Region: Northeast Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 120 / 208
162 Region: South Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 121 / 208
163 Region: Midwest Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 122 / 208
164 Region: West Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 123 / 208
165 Robustness: Average of Bottom 95pct Log Change, Indv Total Wage Avg of Bottom 95% at Firm Difference Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 124 / 208
166 ADDITIONAL FIGURES
167 Within 4-Digit Industry Code Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 126 / 208
168 Firm Size: 20 10, 000 FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 127 / 208
169 Firm Size: 10, 000+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 128 / 208
170 Fraction Top-Paid Employee Fraction Top Paid Employee at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 129 / 208
171 Fraction Top-Paid Employee (Top 1%) Fraction Top Paid Employee at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 130 / 208
172 Rising Inequality Among Non-CEOs Change, Indv Total Wage Indv Total Wage (Non Top 1 Employees) Indv Total Wage (Non Top 5 Employees) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 131 / 208
173 Rising Inequality Among Non-CEOs (Top 1%) Change, Indv Total Wage Indv Total Wage (Non Top 1 Employees) Indv Total Wage (Non Top 5 Employees) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 132 / 208
174 Many Measures of Firm Wage Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Firm Average (Leaving Out Indv) Average of Log Wages at Firm 50th %ile at Firm Avg of Bottom 95% at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 133 / 208
175 Many Measures of Firm Wage (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Firm Average (Leaving Out Indv) Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 134 / 208
176 Many Measures of Firm Wage (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Average of Log Wages at Firm 50th %ile at Firm Avg of Bottom 95% at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 135 / 208
177 Standard Deviation of Log Wage in Firm Log Change, Indv Total Wage Std Dev of Log Wage at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage FIRM DIFFERENTIAL Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 136 / 208
178 Standard Deviation of Log Wage in Firm (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Std Dev of Log Wage at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage FIRM DIFFERENTIAL Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 137 / 208
179 Frac. Wages to Bottom 95% Frac of Wages to Bottom 95% Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 138 / 208
180 Max Wage in Firm Log Change, Indv Total Wage Max wage at Firm Difference Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 139 / 208
181 By Percentile for Group Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 140 / 208
182 Top 1%: Industries
183 Industry: Ag/Mining/Construction/Other (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 142 / 208
184 Industry: Manufacturing (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 143 / 208
185 Industry: Utilities (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 144 / 208
186 Industry: Finance/Insurance/Real Estate (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 145 / 208
187 Industry: Services (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 146 / 208
188 Top 1%: US Regions
189 Region: Northeast (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 148 / 208
190 Region: South (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 149 / 208
191 Region: Midwest (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 150 / 208
192 Region: West (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 151 / 208
193 Bottom 99%: Size
194 Firm Size: 1+ FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 153 / 208
195 Firm Size: 5+ FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 154 / 208
196 Firm Size: 10+ FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 155 / 208
197 Firm Size: FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 156 / 208
198 Firm Size: 100+ FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 157 / 208
199 Firm Size: 20-1,000 FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 158 / 208
200 Firm Size: 1,000+ FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 159 / 208
201 Firm Size: 20-10,000 FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 160 / 208
202 Firm Size: 10,000+ FTE Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 161 / 208
203 Bottom 99%: Gender
204 Men Only Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 163 / 208
205 Women Only Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 164 / 208
206 Bottom 99%: Age
207 Age 34 and Below Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 166 / 208
208 Age Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 167 / 208
209 Age Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 168 / 208
210 Age 55 and Above Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 169 / 208
211 Top 1%: Firm Size
212 Firm Size: 1+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 171 / 208
213 Firm Size: 5+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 172 / 208
214 Firm Size: 10+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 173 / 208
215 Firm Size: FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 174 / 208
216 Firm Size: 100+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 175 / 208
217 Firm Size: 20-1,000 FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 176 / 208
218 Firm Size: 1,000+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 177 / 208
219 Firm Size: 20-10,000 FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 178 / 208
220 Firm Size: 10,000+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 179 / 208
221 Top 1%: Gender
222 Men Only (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 181 / 208
223 Women Only (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 182 / 208
224 Top 1%: Age
225 Age 34 and Below (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 184 / 208
226 Age (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 185 / 208
227 Age (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 186 / 208
228 Age 55 and Above (Top 1%) Log Change, Indv Total Wage Firm Average Wage Indv Wage/Firm Average Percentile of Indv Total Wage BACK TO SUBGROUPS Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 187 / 208
229 Lorenz Curve of Firm Size Frac. People in Firms up to This Size Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 188 / 208
230 Lorenz Curve of Firm Size (Top 1%) Frac. People in Firms up to This Size Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 189 / 208
231 Values in Both Years Log Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 190 / 208
232 Values in Both Years, 10,000+ FTE Log Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 191 / 208
233 Values in Both Years Log Number of Employees Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 192 / 208
234 Values in Both Years Log Std Dev of Log Wage at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 193 / 208
235 Values in Both Years Log Diff at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 194 / 208
236 Values in Both Years Frac of Wages to Bottom 95% Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 195 / 208
237 Values in Both Years Log Firm Average Wage Percentile of Firm Average Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 196 / 208
238 Values in Both Years Log Number of Employees Percentile of Firm Average Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 197 / 208
239 Values in Both Years Log Number of Employees Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 198 / 208
240 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Log Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 199 / 208
241 Values in Both Years, 10,000+ FTE (Top 1%) Log Indv Total Wage Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 200 / 208
242 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Log Number of Employees Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 201 / 208
243 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Log Std Dev of Log Wage at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 202 / 208
244 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Log Diff at Firm Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 203 / 208
245 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Frac of Wages to Bottom 95% Percentile of Indv Total Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 204 / 208
246 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Log Firm Average Wage Percentile of Firm Average Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 205 / 208
247 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Log Number of Employees Percentile of Firm Average Wage Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 206 / 208
248 Values in Both Years (Top 1%) Log Number of Employees Percentile of Number of Employees Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 207 / 208
249 What Types of Executive Compensation Are Tax Deductible? Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, von Wachter Firming Up Inequality 208 / 208
Firming Up Inequality
Firming Up Inequality Jae Song Social Security Administration Fatih Guvenen Minnesota, FRB Mpls, NBER David Price Stanford Nicholas Bloom Stanford and NBER Till von Wachter UCLA and NBER February 22, 2016
More informationMAKING AN IMPACT ON GENDER EQUALITY LET S UNCOVER THE ISSUES. LET S CREATE SOLUTIONS.
MAKING AN IMPACT ON GENDER EQUALITY LET S UNCOVER THE ISSUES. LET S CREATE SOLUTIONS. BIG PICTURE A global focus COMMITMENT FOR CHANGE Coming together for good PINPOINT ON FOODSERVICE What s meaningful
More informationECON Introductory Econometrics. Seminar 1. Stock and Watson Chapter 2 & 3
ECON4150 - Introductory Econometrics Seminar 1 Stock and Watson Chapter 2 & 3 Empirical exercise E3.1: Data 2 In this exercise we use the data set CPS92_12.dta Each month the Bureau of Labor Statistics
More informationLecture II: Difference in Difference and Regression Discontinuity
Review Lecture II: Difference in Difference and Regression Discontinuity it From Lecture I Causality is difficult to Show from cross sectional observational studies What caused what? X caused Y, Y caused
More informationTable of contents. Part I. Gender equality: The economic case, social norms, and public policies
Table of contents Executive summary... 13 Part I Gender equality: The economic case, social norms, and public policies Chapter 1. The economic case for gender equality... 23 Chapter 2. Why social institutions
More informationEconomics of Cannabis and Demand for Farm Labor. California Agriculture and Farm Labor 2017 April 14, 2017
Economics of Cannabis and Demand for Farm Labor California Agriculture and Farm Labor 2017 April 14, 2017 Daniel A. Sumner and William A. Matthews Director University of California Agricultural Issues
More informationMultiple Linear Regression (Dummy Variable Treatment) CIVL 7012/8012
Multiple Linear Regression (Dummy Variable Treatment) CIVL 7012/8012 2 In Today s Class Recap Single dummy variable Multiple dummy variables Ordinal dummy variables Dummy-dummy interaction Dummy-continuous/discrete
More informationSupply and Demand Analysis - An Introduction. Nicholas W. Papageorge Johns Hopkins University September 7, 2018
- An Introduction Nicholas W. Papageorge Johns Hopkins University September 7, 2018 Introductions Who am I? Nicholas Papageorge. Asst. Prof. in the Economics Department. Undergrad at U. of Chicago, Ph.D.
More informationManufacturing Sector Profile for the Shreveport RLMA Parishes. Employment and Wage Trends 4 th Quarter 2015 for the Manufacturing Sector by Parish
Manufacturing Sector Profile for the Shreveport RLMA Parishes The Labor Market information (LMI) division of Research and Statistics helps provide information on various sectors in the regional economy.
More informationThe European Commission s science and knowledge service
The European Commission s science and knowledge service Joint Research Centre ICT use, innovation and employment growth in Gazelles 7 th IRIMA Workshop Innovation, Employment, Firm Growth and Job Creation
More informationEstimating the Economic Impact of Disease on a Local Economy The Case of Diabetes in the Lower Rio Grande Valley of Texas
Estimating the Economic Impact of Disease on a Local Economy The Case of Diabetes in the Lower Rio Grande Valley of Texas Joselito K. Estrada Department of Business Administration The University of Texas
More informationMULTIPLE REGRESSION OF CPS DATA
MULTIPLE REGRESSION OF CPS DATA A further inspection of the relationship between hourly wages and education level can show whether other factors, such as gender and work experience, influence wages. Linear
More informationDiagnostic Medical Sonography Program Report For Greater South Bay and Peninsula Region (Santa Clara and San Mateo Counties)
12345 El Monte Road Los Altos Hills, California 94022 650.949.7777 Diagnostic Medical Sonography Program Report For Greater South Bay and Peninsula Region (Santa Clara and San Mateo Counties) November
More informationLow Wage, Contingent and Temporary Workers How can TWH serve them? Laura Welch, MD CPWR: Center for Construction Research and Training AFL-CIO
Low Wage, Contingent and Temporary Workers How can TWH serve them? Laura Welch, MD CPWR: Center for Construction Research and Training AFL-CIO 39 million workers in the US are low wage workers (
More informationThose Who Tan and Those Who Don t: A Natural Experiment of Employment Discrimination
Those Who Tan and Those Who Don t: A Natural Experiment of Employment Discrimination Ronen Avraham, Tamar Kricheli Katz, Shay Lavie, Haggai Porat, Tali Regev Abstract: Are Black workers discriminated against
More informationNYS Paid Family Leave (PFL) Q & A 5/10/18
NYS Paid Family Leave (PFL) Q & A 5/10/18 Question 1: Question 2: What is NYS Paid Family Leave (PFL)? NYS Paid Family Leave will provide eligible workers with wage replacement during time away from work
More informationHealth and development during the 20th century
Health and development during the 20th century Daniel Gallardo Albarrán University of Groningen Groningen Growth and Development Center 25th Anniversary Conference 29-06-2017 Daniel Gallardo Albarrán Health
More informationwomen.nyc Fast Facts
women.nyc Fast Facts Make A #NYCPowerMove. WHY NYC IS THE BEST CITY IN THE WORLD FOR WOMEN: NYC has more women CEOs than any other city in the country. NYC has the smallest wage gap in the country. NYC
More informationThe Growing Importance of Social Skills in the Labor Market
The Growing Importance of Social Skills in the Labor Market David Deming Harvard University and NBER December 2015 SBTC and Job Polarization Source: Acemoglu and Autor (2011) Slowdown in demand for cognitive
More informationInfluenza vaccination coverage for staff of acute care facilities British Columbia, 2017/18
Influenza vaccination coverage for staff of acute care facilities British Columbia, 2017/18 Background Immunization coverage assessment is an important part of a quality immunization program and serves
More informationCancer survivorship and labor market attachments: Evidence from MEPS data
Cancer survivorship and labor market attachments: Evidence from 2008-2014 MEPS data University of Memphis, Department of Economics January 7, 2018 Presentation outline Motivation and previous literature
More informationThe Effects of Gender Inequality. identify as women and men. On August 26, 1920, American women were granted the right to
The Effects of Gender Inequality Gender inequality is defined as the gap in status, power, and prestige between people who identify as women and men. On August 26, 1920, American women were granted the
More informationIMPACT OF THE PRIMARY MARKET ON ECONOMIC GROWTH, PRODUCTIVITY AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP: A CROSS COUNTRY ANALYSIS
IMPACT OF THE PRIMARY MARKET ON ECONOMIC GROWTH, PRODUCTIVITY AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP: A CROSS COUNTRY ANALYSIS A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE FELLOW PROGRAMME IN MANAGEMENT
More informationAfter simple testing that only takes minutes people with elevated test results are then recommended to see their physicians for follow-up.
New Medical Device Company Addresses Two Very High Demand Markets with its Proprietary Products. Trader Tracks likes this company as they provide reasonably priced equipment and testing while medical costs
More informationVARIATIONS IN PRICES AND REIMBURSEMENT OF MEDICINES IN THE EUROPEAN UNION
VARIATIONS IN PRICES AND REIMBURSEMENT OF MEDICINES IN THE EUROPEAN UNION A snapshot of data on amoxicillin, budesonide, losartan and salbutamol in eight European Union Member States Report INTRODUCTION
More informationAlberta Motor Transport Association Industries
OCCUPATIONAL INJURIES AND DISEASES IN ALBERTA Lost-Time Claims, Disabling Injury Claims and Claim Rates Alberta Motor Transport Association Industries 2003 to 2007 Summer 2008 TABLE OF CONTENTS Highlights...2
More informationDiagnostic Medical Sonography
Diagnostic Medical Sonography Program Report For Greater South Bay and Peninsula Region (Santa Clara and San Mateo Counties) September 2016 12345 El Monte Road Los Altos Hills, California 94022 650.949.7777
More informationCommercial Redevelopment Study
Commercial Redevelopment Study Impact on Sanibel of Immediate Off-Island Development January 22, 2013 Commercial Redevelopment Study To date, Council has approved a vision statement and identified Sanibel
More information1in 5 Australians has some form of arthritis or osteoporosis. It can affect anybody
Workplace Giving. 1in 5 Australians has some form of arthritis or osteoporosis. It can affect anybody This represents approx. 1.5 Million NSW residents and about 870,000 people with arthritis of working
More information5,000. Number of cigarettes 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000
A HISTORY of TOBACCO CONTROL EFFORTS UNDERSTANDING the ROLE of TOBACCO in the NEW WORLD Tobacco use originated in the Americas and was exported worldwide. Once tobacco became a popular crop throughout
More informationThe impact of workplace smoking bans: results from a national survey
272 Center for Economics Research, Research Triangle Institute, 3040 Cornwallis Rd, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA M C Farrelly A E S Sfekas Department of Economics, University of Maryland,
More informationEmpirical Analysis of the Impact of Income on Dietary Calorie Intake in Nigeria. Babatunde, R. O
Empirical Analysis of the Impact of Income on Dietary Calorie Intake in Nigeria. Babatunde, R. O Department of Agricultural Economics and Social Sciences (490b), University of Hohenheim, D-70593 Stuttgart,
More information2017 American Academy of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation. All rights reserved.
I. Executive Summary A. Background The American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (AAPM&R) is the national medical specialty organization representing more than 9,000 physicians who are specialists
More informationA Research Study: The Measurable Economic Impact of Certain Smoke-Free Ordinances in Minnesota
A Research Study: The Measurable Economic Impact of Certain Smoke-Free Ordinances in Minnesota Prepared for the Minnesota Institute of Public Health by Dan Stoltz and Michael Bromelkamp February 23, 2007
More informationThe Dynamic Effects of Obesity on the Wages of Young Workers
The Dynamic Effects of Obesity on the Wages of Young Workers Joshua C. Pinkston University of Louisville June, 2015 Contributions 1. Focus on more recent cohort, NLSY97. Obesity
More informationStafff Paper Prepared by: Corey Freije. December 2018
UPPER MIDWEST MARKETING AREA ANALYSIS OF COMPONENT LEVELS AND SOMATIC CELLL COUNT IN INDIVIDUAL HERD MILK AT THE FARM LEVEL 2017 Stafff Paper 18-022 Prepared by: Corey Freije December 2018 Federal Milk
More informationTHE IMPACT of. icare BENEFITS HPV VACCINATION PILOT VIETNAM 2016
THE IMPACT of icare BENEFITS HPV VACCINATION PILOT VIETNAM 2016 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The formal workforce in Asian emerging countries more and more often can enjoy access to free basic healthcare services.
More informationBlack Women s Access to Health Insurance
FACT SHEET Black Women s Access to Health Insurance APRIL 2018 Data released by the U.S. Census Bureau show that, despite significant health insurance gains since the Affordable Care Act (ACA) was implemented,
More informationDENTAL BENEFITS: A BRIDGE TO ORAL HEALTH & WELLNESS
R GUARDIAN WORKPLACE BENEFITS STUDY SM 5TH ANNUAL DENTAL BENEFITS: A BRIDGE TO ORAL HEALTH & WELLNESS Dental benefits utilization, especially for preventive services, contributes to better oral health
More informationHow Will Tobacco Farmers Respond to the Quota Buyout? Findings from a Survey of North Carolina Tobacco Farmers
How Will Tobacco Farmers Respond to the Quota Buyout? Findings from a Survey of North Carolina Tobacco Farmers Presented by Robert H. Beach 1 ; David Richmond 2 ; W.D. Austin 1 ; and Alison Snow Jones
More informationUnderstanding Unsuccessful Work Attempts (UWA)
Understanding Unsuccessful Work Attempts (UWA) January 2016 Introduction Social Security recognizes that in some cases a beneficiary may try to return to work at a substantial level, but may only be successful
More informationPractice for Exam 1 Econ B2000, MA Econometrics Kevin R Foster, CCNY Fall 2011
Practice for Exam 1 Econ B2000, MA Econometrics Kevin R Foster, CCNY Fall 2011 Not all of these questions are strictly relevant; some might require a bit of knowledge that we haven't covered this year,
More informationState Summary Table 1 Child Care Workers/ Educators. Teachers 3 Assistant Teachers 4 Directors FCCH Providers
Appendix D: State Summary Table N Studies = a. Demographic Mean Age (Years) 11 (VI) 10, (VII) 1 42 (CA) 30 (WI) - 43.1 (MN) 31.3-42.4 (MN) 39.5-48.3 (MN) 37 (WI) - 45.7 (CA) Median Age (Years) 2 (VI) 2
More informationRECOMMENDED CITATION: Pew Research Center, December, 2014, Perceptions of Job News Trend Upward
NUMBERS, FACTS AND TRENDS SHAPING THE WORLD FOR RELEASE DECEMBER 16, 2014 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION ON THIS REPORT: Carroll Doherty, Director of Political Research Seth Motel, Research Analyst Rachel Weisel,
More informationUPPER MIDWEST MARKETING AREA ANALYSIS OF COMPONENT LEVELS AND SOMATIC CELL COUNT IN INDIVIDUAL HERD MILK AT THE FARM LEVEL 2015
UPPER MIDWEST MARKETING AREA ANALYSIS OF COMPONENT LEVELS AND SOMATIC CELL COUNT IN INDIVIDUAL HERD MILK AT THE FARM LEVEL 2015 Staff Paper 16-01 Prepared by: Corey Freije August 2016 Federal Milk Market
More informationSilicon Valley Housing and Economic Outlook
White Paper Silicon Valley Housing and Economic Outlook Santa Clara County, San Mateo County Prepared by John Burns Real Estate Consulting for Pacific Union 11.5.2014 Santa Clara County The booming tech
More informationGender inequality and growth in Europe. Stephan Klasen, Anna Minasyan Universität Göttingen Intereconomics, Brussels, November 3, 2016
Gender inequality and growth in Europe Stephan Klasen, Anna Minasyan Universität Göttingen Intereconomics, Brussels, November 3, 2016 Introduction Gender inequality generally declining in Europe (compared
More informationFP009: Energy Savings Insurance for private energy efficiencyinvestments by Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises. El Salvador IDB B.
FP009: Energy Savings Insurance for private energy efficiencyinvestments by Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises El Salvador IDB B.13/23 Annex 13 Gender Context Energy Savings Insurance (ESI) for private
More informationPrice-based measures to reduce alcohol consumption
Price-based measures to reduce alcohol consumption Andrew Leicester (with Rachel Griffith and Martin O Connell) Health Economics Research Unit, University of Aberdeen 12 th March 2013 Introduction Governments
More informationBRINGING OUTSIDERS IN. Foreign Workers and Women in Elite Jobs in Corporate Japan
BRINGING OUTSIDERS IN Foreign Workers and Women in Elite Jobs in Corporate Japan Hilary J. Holbrow, PhD June 18, 2018 OUTSIDERS IN CORPORATE JAPAN: PAST AND PRESENT c. 1985 Women were: 29% of Regular Employees
More informationMANAGED DENTAL CARE: PRACTICE OF DENTISTRY. Overview of Benefit Issues. Changes in the Delivery of Dental Benefits FEE-FOR-SERVICE
Managed Care: Dentistry June 25, 23 PRACTICE OF DENTISTRY (BUSINESS ASPECT) VS. Overview of Benefit Issues PRACTICING DENTISTRY (PROFESSIONAL ASPECT) Changes in the Delivery of Dental Benefits Indemnity
More informationFlorida s New Economic Reality: The State of the State
Florida s New Economic Reality: The State of the State FLORIDA PHILANTHROPIC NETWORK Dr. Gary Jackson Director, Regional Economic Research Institute Florida Gulf Coast University February 11, 2010 www.fgcu.edu/cob0/reri
More informationEaze Insights: The Modern Marijuana Consumer. Study: The modern marijuana consumer
Eaze Insights: The Modern Marijuana Consumer A study of over 10,000 California cannabis consumers exploring product preference and emerging wellness trends. Study: The modern marijuana consumer Modern
More informationInternet Appendix for. Do Stock Markets Catch the Flu? TABLE A.1. Aggregated and Regional Summary Data
Internet Appendix for Do Stock Markets Catch the Flu? Brian C. McTier, Yiuman Tse, and John K. Wald JOURNAL OF FINANCIAL AND QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS, Vol. 48, No. 3, June 2013 TABLE A.1 Aggregated and Regional
More informationDainippon Pharmaceutical and Sumitomo Pharmaceuticals Finalize Merger Agreement
For immediate release April 28, 2005 Dainippon Pharmaceutical and Sumitomo Pharmaceuticals Finalize Merger Agreement Dainippon Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. Sumitomo Pharmaceuticals Co., Ltd. Dainippon Pharmaceutical
More informationLecture II: Difference in Difference. Causality is difficult to Show from cross
Review Lecture II: Regression Discontinuity and Difference in Difference From Lecture I Causality is difficult to Show from cross sectional observational studies What caused what? X caused Y, Y caused
More informationTHE ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH AND SAFETY
1 THE ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH AND SAFETY OUTSOURCING GUIDE HOW EHS OUTSOURCING CAN SAVE YOUR COMPANY TIME AND MONEY TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. WHAT IS SAFETY OUTSOURCING? 2. WHY OUTSOURCE SAFETY? 3. BENEFITS OF
More informationECON Microeconomics III
ECON 7130 - Microeconomics III Spring 2016 Notes for Lecture #5 Today: Difference-in-Differences (DD) Estimators Difference-in-Difference-in-Differences (DDD) Estimators (Triple Difference) Difference-in-Difference
More informationMIDWEST FOOD PROCESSING INDUSTRY STATISTICS BY STATE WISCONSIN
MIDWEST FOOD PROCESSING INDUSTRY STATISTICS BY STATE WISCONSIN Wisconsin Food Processing Share in Wisconsin Manufacturing, 2016 74.0% 26.0% Manufacturing Food Processing The 2016 Annual Survey of Manufacturers
More informationTechnical Information
CAPT WEBINAR January 11, 2017 Providing Effective Technical Assistance Working with New Hampshire Businesses and Other Workplaces, Part 1 Dodi Swope, T/TA Specialist, Northeast Resource Team, CAPT Maria
More informationA Multilevel Approach to Model Weight Gain: Evidence from NLSY79 Panel
A Multilevel Approach to Model Weight Gain: Evidence from NLSY79 Panel Bidisha Mandal Washington State University bmandal@wsu.edu Obesity Trends* Among U.S. Adults BRFSS, 1985 (*BMI 30, or ~ 30 lbs. overweight
More informationEMERGING TRENDS ANNE #LifeExpectancy IN AMERICAN LIFE EXPECTANCY
EMERGING TRENDS IN AMERICAN LIFE EXPECTANCY ANNE CASE @hamiltonproj #LifeExpectancy Is 50 the New 80? Anne Case Death in the Afternoon Angus Deaton There has been a remarkable long-term decline in mortality
More informationThe Effect of the Smoke- Free Illinois Act on Casino Admissions and Revenue
The Effect of the Smoke- Free Illinois Act on Casino Admissions and Revenue Frank J. Chaloupka, University of Illinois at Chicago Society for Research on Nicotine & Tobacco Paper Session 10, Florence,
More informationNIGHT CRIMES: An Applied Project Presented to The Faculty of the Department of Economics Western Kentucky University Bowling Green, Kentucky
NIGHT CRIMES: THE EFFECTS OF EVENING DAYLIGHT ON CRIMINAL ACTIVITY An Applied Project Presented to The Faculty of the Department of Economics Western Kentucky University Bowling Green, Kentucky By Lucas
More informationWhy the Increase In Obesity
Obesity From an Economist s Perspective Eric Finkelstein, PhD, MHA RTI INTERNATIONAL The Economics of Obesity (outline) Why the Increase in Obesity Rates Adverse Health Consequences Why do (or should)
More informationApplication of OCR "margin of error" to API Award Programs
Application of OCR "margin of error" to API Award Programs The blood pressure parable reveals 'margin of error' folly CA schools falling within their margin of error have probability.97 and larger of positive
More informationChapter Three in-class Exercises. MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question.
Name Chapter Three in-class Exercises MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) The table below lists the populations, in thousands, of several
More informationAmerican Sign Language (ASL) Interpreters
American Sign Language (ASL) Interpreters October 2017 Prepared by the Los Angeles/Orange County Center of Excellence for Labor Market Research Program Recommendation This report was compiled by the Los
More informationThe Dental Corporation Opportunity
The Dental Corporation Opportunity for Practice Principals. It s the perfect professional collaboration. You focus on dentistry, we look after the paperwork. In recognition of what you, the Practice Principal,
More informationTRACER STUDIES ASSESSMENTS AND EVALUATIONS
TRACER STUDIES ASSESSMENTS AND EVALUATIONS 1 INTRODUCTION This note introduces the reader to tracer studies. For the Let s Work initiative, tracer studies are proposed to track and record or evaluate the
More informationUPPER MIDWEST MARKETING AREA ANALYSIS OF COMPONENT LEVELS AND SOMATIC CELL COUNT IN INDIVIDUAL HERD MILK AT THE FARM LEVEL 2010
UPPER MIDWEST MARKETING AREA ANALYSIS OF COMPONENT LEVELS AND SOMATIC CELL COUNT IN INDIVIDUAL HERD MILK AT THE FARM LEVEL Staff Paper 12-02 Prepared by: Corey Freije March 2012 Federal Milk Market Administrator
More informationI N C R E A S I N G C I G A R E T T E E X C I S E T A X I S BAD POLICY FOR OREGON
7 I N C R E A S I N G C I G A R E T T E E X C I S E T A X I S BAD POLICY FOR OREGON THE TOP REASONS WHY A HIGHER CIGARETTE TAX IS BAD FOR OREGON ONE TWO THREE FOUR INCREASING THE STATE CIGARETTE TAX WILL
More informationIn Health Matters, Place Matters - The Health Opportunity Index (HOI) Virginia Department of Health Office of Health Equity
In Health Matters, Place Matters - The Health Opportunity Index (HOI) Virginia Department of Health Office of Health Equity 1 Identifying the Problem America s Health Rankings United Health Foundation
More informationSumitomo Pharmaceuticals reaches a basic agreement to merge with Dainippon Pharmaceutical
For immediate release November 25, 2004 Sumitomo Pharmaceuticals reaches a basic agreement to merge with Dainippon Pharmaceutical Sumitomo Chemical Co., Ltd. announced today that its subsidiary, Sumitomo
More informationNevada s Marijuana Roots
RIANA DURRETT INTRODUCTION Practiced law for 5 years Nevada Dispensary Association Non-profit 501(c)(6) Corporation, formed in 2014 to develop and promote best practices in marijuana industry. Represents
More informationfull file at
Chapter 01 What Is Statistics? True / False Questions 1. A population is a collection of all individuals, objects, or measurements of interest. True False 2. Statistics are used as a basis for making decisions.
More informationInfluenza vaccination coverage for staff of residential care facilities British Columbia, 2017/18
Influenza vaccination coverage for staff of residential care facilities British Columbia, 2017/18 Background Immunization coverage assessment is an important part of a quality immunization program and
More informationLarge-Scale Farming and Gender Equality in Rural Areas: The Case of Ukraine Nataliia Kutsmus Taras Gagalyuk
Large-Scale Farming and Gender Equality in Rural Areas: The Case of Ukraine Nataliia Kutsmus Taras Gagalyuk IAMO Forum 2016 Rural Labor in Transition: Structural Change, Migration and Governance 22-24
More informationThis is copyrighted material. Women and Men in U.S. Corporate Leadership. Same Workplace, Different Realities?
Women and Men in U.S. Corporate Leadership Same Workplace, Different Realities? INTRODUCTION Although women occupy one-half (50.5 percent) of managerial and professional specialty positions in the United
More informationfull file at
CHAPTER 1 TEST ITEMS TRUE-FALSE 1. Work contributes to an employee s self-esteem and emotional security. (T, p. 3) 2. If the methods and findings of I-O psychology are used improperly by management or
More informationNovember 30, Dear Mr. Sprague: Re: Alberta Dental Fees
November 30, 2015 Mr. Bob Sprague, B.Sc., Pharmacy, MBA Director, Pharmaceuticals and Supplementary Health Benefits Branch Alberta Health Professional Services & Health Benefits Division PO Box 1360 Stn
More informationWhat Your Wellness Programs Aren't Telling You. Dan Witters Gallup March 18, 2014
What Your Wellness Programs Aren't Telling You Dan Witters Gallup March 18, 2014 Today s Topics 1. Public Opinion and Well-Being 2. U.S. Employers and Well-Being Programs 3. The New Well-Being 5 (Well-Being
More informationPrentice Hall. A Survey of Mathematics with Applications, 7th Edition Mississippi Mathematics Framework 2007 Revised,
Prentice Hall A Survey of Mathematics with Applications, 7th Edition 2005 C O R R E L A T E D T O Mississippi Mathematics Framework 2007 Revised, Survey of Mathematical Topics NUMBER AND OPERATIONS Competencies
More informationLEAD THE WAY TO ALZHEIMER S FIRST SURVIVOR.
LEAD THE WAY TO ALZHEIMER S FIRST SURVIVOR. 2018 TEAM CAPTAIN GUIDE Your guide to recruitment and fundraising success. 800.272.3900 alz.org/walk THANK YOU FOR STEPPING UP AS A TEAM CAPTAIN. The success
More informationCurrent Cigarette Smoking Among Workers in Accommodation and Food Services United States,
Current Cigarette Among Workers in Accommodation and Food Services United States, 2011 2013 Girija Syamlal, MPH 1 ; Ahmed Jamal, MBBS 2 ; Jacek M. Mazurek, MD 1 (Author affiliations at end of text) Tobacco
More informationEconomic Emergency Program Impact of Poultry and Egg Production Losses and Poultry Processing Losses Due to the Avian Influenza
Economic Emergency Program Impact of Poultry and Egg Production Losses and Poultry Processing Losses Due to the Avian Influenza Brigid Tuck May 2015-1- About The EDA Center The EDA Center at the University
More information2012 Assessment of St. Lucie County s Social, Health, and Public Safety Services
2012 Assessment of St. Lucie County s Social, Health, and Public Safety Services April 5, 2013 140 Intracoastal Pointe Drive, Suite 212 Jupiter, FL 33477-5064 561.744.5662 Fax: 561.575.7396 www.sra-researchgroup.com
More informationMANAGEMENT. MGMT 0021 THE MANAGEMENT PROCESS 3 cr. MGMT 0022 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 3 cr. MGMT 0023 MANAGERIAL ACCOUNTING 3 cr.
MANAGEMENT MGMT 0021 THE MANAGEMENT PROCESS 3 cr. An introduction designed to emphasize the basic principles, practices, and terminology essential to the understanding of contemporary business and its
More informationHighlights of The Economic Impact of the 2008 Fargo and West Fargo Smoking Bans report, June 2010
BRIEFING POINTS North Dakota State Data Center North Dakota State University P.O. Box 6050, Dept. 8000, Fargo, ND 58108 6050 Phone 701 231 7980; Fax 701 231 9730 Email Richard.Rathge@ndsu.edu Access the
More information14. EMPLOYMENT Occupational segregation Commonwealth Employment by industry for males and females who identify as
14. EMPLOYMENT Occupational segregation Commonwealth Employment by industry for males and females who identify as Annex 3 Issues 14 to 16 Indigenous, Other than Main English Speaking (OTMESC), or 55 years
More informationCommunity Dispatch. An InfoFax of Community Development Halton. August 2006 Vol. 10, No. 8
Community Dispatch An InfoFax of Community Development Halton August 2006 Vol. 10, No. 8 HALTON VOLUNTARY SECTOR HUMAN SERVICES LABOUR FORCE STUDY Preliminary Survey Findings (1) Human Resources: Employee
More informationWhere are moonlighters found?
Moonlighting: A growing way of life Deborah Sussman Moonlighting is becoming a way of life for an increasing number of Canadian workers. In the last 20 years, the number of multiple jobholders or moonlighters
More informationChildhood Obesity in North Carolina: Economic Cost and Implications
Childhood Obesity in North Carolina: Economic Cost and Implications Legislative Task Force on Childhood Obesity Raleigh, NC January 26, 2010 David Chenoweth, Ph.D.,FAWHP Obesity Trends Among U.S. Adults
More informationThe Economics of Obesity
The Economics of Obesity John Cawley Cornell University Usefulness of Economics in Studying Obesity Offers widely-accepted theoretical framework for human behavior (constrained maximization) We ask different
More informationForestry and Related Industries
OCCUPATIONAL INJURIES AND DISEASES IN ALBERTA Summer 2009 Lost-Time, Injury and Claim Rates Forestry and Related Industries 2004 to 2008 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Introduction... 2 2. Provincial Summary...
More informationMINNESOTA GERONTOLOGICAL SOCIETY ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2015 Phyllis A. Greenberg, PhD Sue Humphers-Ginther, PhD Jim Tift, M.A. Missy Reichl, B.S.
CAREERS IN AGING MINNESOTA GERONTOLOGICAL SOCIETY ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2015 Phyllis A. Greenberg, PhD Sue Humphers-Ginther, PhD Jim Tift, M.A. Missy Reichl, B.S. 1 WHAT IS GERONTOLOGY? GERIATRICS? Aging is
More informationASSIGNMENT 2. Question 4.1 In each of the following situations, describe a sample space S for the random phenomenon.
ASSIGNMENT 2 MGCR 271 SUMMER 2009 - DUE THURSDAY, MAY 21, 2009 AT 18:05 IN CLASS Question 4.1 In each of the following situations, describe a sample space S for the random phenomenon. (1) A new business
More informationWill There Be a Couch? What to Expect From Counseling
Will There Be a Couch? What to Expect From Counseling Presenter Dwight Bain Dwight Bain is a trusted professional with over 25 years of experience in solving problems. He is a nationally certified counselor
More informationEquipping Young People to make Drug-Free Choices. Fundraiser
Equipping Young People to make Drug-Free Choices Fundraiser About Hope UK Children and young people are at the heart of Hope UK s mission. Our vision is for children and young people in Britain to live
More informationLong-term trends in the cost of pharmaceutical goods
Feature Article Long-term trends in the cost of pharmaceutical goods purchased by community oncology practices seem to have dramatically changed in, potentially ending an era of practice growth built on
More information