Moisture loss and oil uptake kinetics in French fries (var. Kufri Pukhraj) during frying in different oils and treatments

Similar documents
Optimization of Blanching Time-Temperature Combination and Pre-Drying Durations for Production of High Quality Potato Chips

Optimisation of Osmotic Dehydrated Microwave Frying of Potato Slices

Development and Quality Evaluation of Baked Potato Chips in Microwave

[Lien*, 5(4): April, 2016] ISSN: (I2OR), Publication Impact Factor: 3.785

Optimization of Vacuum Frying Condition for Shallot

Effect of Microwave Blanching on Acrylamide Content and Quality Attributes of French Fries Sezin Tuta a, Koray Palazoglu a, Vural Gökmen b

Study on the Effective Reduction of Oil Up-Take by the Application of Edible Hydrocolloid Coatings on French Fries

Vacuum frying: An alternative to obtain high quality potato chips and fried oil

Investigation of kinetics of mass transfer parameters during deep fat frying of native gum coated potato chips

Frying. PRO Ch. 17 of Fellows

Asian Journal of Food and Agro-Industry ISSN Available online at

5.0 Summary and conclusion

Standardization of Drying Conditions for Production of Osmotically Dehydrated Whole Aonla Fruits

Continuous Frying Improves the Longevity of Palm Olein for Processing of Extruded Product

Changes in Characteristics of Palm Oil During Vacuum and Atmospheric Frying Conditions of Sweet Potato

ACRYLAMIDE REDUCTION IN FRIED POTATO SLICES AND STRIPS BY USING ASPARAGINASE IN COMBINATION WITH CONVENTIONAL BLANCHING

SUPERHEATED STEAM AS PRETREATMENT TO REDUCE OIL UPTAKE DURING DEEP FRYING OF CHICKEN NUGGETS

Nutritional quality evaluation of Rice bean flour based Boondi

Effects of Initial Pore Diameter on the Oil Absorption Behavior of Potato Chips during Frying Process

Effect of Methyl Cellulose Coating and Pre-Treatment on Oil Uptake, Moisture Retention and Physical Properties of Deep-Fat Fried Starchy Dough System

Optimizationof some processing conditions for Kokoro production. Response Surface Methodology.

International Journal of Agricultural and Food Science

Technology Development of Salak (Salacca Zalacca) Chips With Vacuum Frying Machine Base On Expert System In Kramat-Bangkalan Regency

Preparation of value added products from dehydrated bathua leaves (Chenopodium album Linn.)

USE OF HYDROCOLLOIDS AS EDIBLE COVERS TO PRODUCE LOW FAT FRENCH FRIES

Effect of processing parameters on quality attributes of fried banana chips

Process Optimization and its Impacts on Physical Properties of Instant Rice

IMPACTS OF VARIETIES AND FREEZING STORAGE CONDITION ON THE QUALITY OF FRENCH FRIED POTATOES (SOLANUM TUBEROSUM L.)

Reduction of acrylamide formation in French fries by microwave pre-cooking of potato strips

POTATOES CRISPS QUALITY FROM FIELD TO FINISHED PRODUCT

Effect of Process Variable in Osmo-Convective Dehydration of Pomegranate Arils

OSMO-CONVECTIVE DEHYDRATION OF SWEET POTATO (IPOMOEA BATATAS L.)

Emerging innovations in food processing technologies

Optimization of moisture loss and fat uptake of goat meat during frying

Optimization of Deep-Fat Frying of Plantain Chips (Ipekere) using Response Surface Methodology

International Journal of Medical Sciences Volume 7 Issue 1&2 October,

Journal of Food Biosciences and Technology, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, 1, 33-40, 2011

Study on physico-chemical analysis for the development of multi grain flour biscuits

Studies on Effect of Sulphur Compounds on Osmotically Dehydrated Guava Slices

Preparation of Pineapple (Ananas comosus) Candy Using Osmotic Dehydration Combined With Solar Drying

OSMOTIC DEHYDRATION OF UNSKINNED ORANGE CARPEL

POTATO PROCESSING RESEARCH IN THE UNIVERSITY OF NAIROBI. Department of Food Science, Nutrition and Technology

Reducing Fat Content of Fried Potato Pellet Chips Using Carboxymethyl Cellulose and Soy Protein Isolate Solutions as Coating Films

World Congress on Root and Tuber Crops Nanning, Guangxi, China, January 18-22, 2016

RBO CURRENT STATUS & FUTURE PROSPECTS in JAPAN

ORANGE-FLESHED SWEETPOTATO (OFSP) BREAD AND FRIED CRISPS: POTENTIAL VALUE- ADDED PRODUCTS FOR COMMERCIALIZATION

*EP A1* EP A1 (19) (11) EP A1 (12) EUROPEAN PATENT APPLICATION. (43) Date of publication: Bulletin 2004/21

FORMULATION AND PROXIMATE ANALYSIS OF SOYA FLOUR CARROT POMACE BISCUITS

The Effect of Temperature and Fat Type on the Physical and Sensory. Properties of Doughnut Holes. By: Amy Wright

RESEARCH PAPER S.K. PARMAR, A.H. RATHOD 1, A.A. KHULE 1, D.B. KAJALE 1 AND D.L. SUNDESHA 1

Assessment of application of pectin, whey protein concentrate, soy protein isolated and methyl cellulose films to improve quality of potato strips

Optimization of the Effect of Process Parameters and Study of Quality Characteristics of Osmotic Dehydrated Amla Slices

PREPARATION AND PACKAGING OF JACKFRUIT CHIPS

Acrylamide in food: understanding the law, minimising the risks

Acrylamide in Food - Mitigation Options

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Product Specification: Diced Potatoes 20/20/10 Sunflower pre fried & quick frozen

Assessment of application of pectin, whey protein concentrate, soy protein isolated and methyl cellulose films to improve quality of potato strips

Development and evaluation of fish ball from fish powder supplemented with potato flour

Influence of Initial Moisture Content on Some Proximate Quality Attributes of Packaged Gari in Storage. Adejumo, B. A.

A comparative study of the characteristics of French Fries produced by deep fat frying and air frying

Journal of Agriculture and Social Research (JASR) VOL. 10, No. 2, 2010

Experience the next level of lecithins!

Quality of khoa sold in Washim district

PROCESSING AND STORAGE OF INSTANT COOKED RICE

DIVERSITY AND CHARACTERISTICS OF POTATO FLAKES IN NAIROBI AND NAKURU, KENYA. Corresponding author: Phone:

Thickening Agents and Methods

Expert support to create delicious savory foods

Impact of Soaking in Salt Solutions after Blanching on Acrylamide Formation and Sensorial Quality of Potato Chips

Microstructure of Potato Products: Effect on Physico-Chemical Properties and Nutrient Bioavailability

The extrusion process in full action at Texas A&M University and a sample of fresh expeller.. (Photos: Riaz, Texas A&M)

DURATION: 3 HOURS TOTAL MARKS: 120. Internal Examiner: Dr. M Siwela. Internal Moderator: Dr. A. van Onselen

Kinetics of Mass Transfer in Microwave Precooked and Deep-Fat Fried Ostrich Meat Plates

Acrylamide mitigation in foods an update. A Leatherhead Food Research white paper. June Swanston

Microwave Drying of Enriched Mango Fruit Leather

MODIFIED CASSAVA STARCH IN MALAYSIAN FOOD PRODUCTS

Quality attributes of French fries as affected by different coatings, frozen storage and frying conditions.

Asian Journal of Food and Agro-Industry ISSN Available online at

QUALITY OF EXTRUDED TRIPE SNACK FOOD INCORPORATED WITH DIFFERENT EXTENDERS AND BUFFALO RUMEN MEAT

The effects of Frying on the thermal behaviour of some vegetable oils

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 11, November 2014

OF VACUUM FRIED BANANA CHIPS (NENDRAN)

Functional Properties of Foods. Database and Model Prediction

Studies on Banana Centre Core Flour Prepared by Different Drying Methods

Effect of drying methods on rehydration kinetics of potato slices

U.S.-Grown HIGH OLEIC SOYBEAN OIL

Effect of Hydrocolloid on Indian Traditional Food Puri Bended With Pearl Millet and Soyabean Flour

On the possibility of non-fat frying using molten glucose

AMINO ACID PROFILE IN LATVIAN POTATO VARIETIES PREPARED BY VARIOUS COOKING METHODS Irisa Murniece, Daina Karklina, Ruta Galoburda

Check list for follow up on acrylamide levels according to Commission Recommendation (Document C/2010/9681) Version:

Food & Process Innovations

Possibilities and Potentiality to increase blending ratio of Palm Olein with Soft oils in Egyptian market.

Optimization of Vacuum Impregnation Conditions Using Response Surface Methodology for soaking of pantoa

FOOD STANDARDS AGENCY STUDY OF ACRYLAMIDE IN FOOD BACKGROUND INFORMATION & RESEARCH FINDINGS PRESS BRIEFING NH 2

Healthy Weight Guide A Guide for Parents of Children With Special Needs

Nutritional Assessment of Healthy Cakes Developed Using Partially Defatted Peanut Flour

High Oleic Soybean Oil Panel. National Institute of Oilseed Products March 17, 2015

Removal of Mycotoxins during Food Processing

REP18/CF-Appendix VI 1

Studies on Osmotic Dehydration of Sapota (Achras Sapota L.)

Transcription:

Research Article Moisture loss and oil uptake kinetics in French fries (var. Kufri Pukhraj) during frying in different oils and treatments Ankur M. Arya*, Suresh Chandra, Samsher, Jaivir Singh, Neelash Chauhan, Tarun Kumar, Kapil Kumar and Prince Department of Agricultural Engineering, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel University of Agriculture & Technology, Meerut (U.P.) 250110 India Abstract In this study relationship between moisture loss and oil uptake at different treatment of sample and time during deep-fat frying of french fries was investigated. The relationship between moisture loss and oil uptake is an important phenomenon in the context of characterizing the physical properties of French fries. French fries samples were diced and fried at different oil (Mustard oil, Soybean refined oil, Sunflower oil,) in a fryer for periods varying from 50 to 200 sec. The relationship between moisture loss and oil uptake during the frying was erratic and appeared to be independent of frying oil. The relationship Oil uptake was positively to moisture loss in the range of frying times 50 sec. to about 200 sec. After 100 sec, oil uptake tended to decrease while moisture loss continued. Keywords: Potato French fries, Blanching, Frying, Oil absorption, moisture loss, Sunflower oil *Correspondence Author: Ankur M. Arya Email: tt.king10@gmail.com Introduction Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) is grown in more than 100 countries in the world [1]. India ranks third, after China and Russia. It has become an integral part of breakfast, lunch and dinner among the larger population. Being a short duration crop, it produces more quantity of dry matter, edible energy and edible protein in lesser duration of time compared to cereals like rice and wheat. Hence, Potato is considered to be an important crop to achieve nutritional security of the nation. It can be processed into variety of products such as cubes, chips, flakes, granules, powder, French fries and dehydrated dice. In India, Potato processing industry mainly comprises four segments: Potato chips, French fries, Potato flakes/powder and other processed products such as dehydrated chips, Aloo bhujia, Samosa, and Tikkis. Krokida et al. [2] reported that blanching reduces oil absorption of fried potatoes by gelatinizing the surface starch, while air dehydration also leads to reduced oil absorption. Garayo and Moreira [3] found that the final shrinkage in volume of potato slices decreases as oil temperature increases; this behavior is believed to occur since the surface of the potato becomes rigid more rapidly at higher oil temperatures, thus producing increased resistance in volume change. Pedreschi [4] reported that the in the deep-fat frying process, water containing foodstuff is immersed into oil or fat at high temperatures, typically between 160 and 180 ºC. Santis et al. [5] showed that longer soaking time and higher NaCl concentrations improved the texture. Potato slices were darker after frying with increase of blanching temperature from 60ºC/5min to 80ºC/5min, for NaCl soaked slices against water-soaked slices. Blanching temperatures before frying enhanced the color of the potato chips. Ahmad et al. [6] reported that frying is extensively employed in the domestic and industrial sectors due to its ability to create unique sensory characteristics in food. Mir- Bel et al. [7] studied that during frying, heat transfer causes protein denaturization, starch gelatinization, water evaporation, crust formation and color development. Mass transfer is characterized by water and some soluble material escaping from the product during the process, combined with oil penetrating the food. Moreira et al. [8] determined the internal and structural oil absorption kinetics during vacuum frying of potato chips, and found that 14% of the total oil content was located in the core (internal oil) and the remaining 86% of the oil content was surface oil. Materials and Methods Present investigation was carried out to develop potato French fries and to evaluate relationship between moisture loss and oil uptake during frying in different oils; in the Laboratory of the Department of Agricultural Engineering, Sardar Chem Sci Rev Lett 2017, 6(24), 2144-2148 Article CS102048091 2144

Vallabhbhai Patel university of Agriculture and Technology, Meerut (UP) India, during year 2012-14. Chemicals like NaCl, KMS, CaCl 2 and frying oil viz. mustard oil, refined soybean oil and sunflower oil and other raw materials were procured from the local market. Potatoes (var. Kufri Pukhraj) were collected from the farmer, washed with clean water to remove dust and dirt followed by peeling, cutting with the help of french fries cutter then blanching. The samples were fried in different oils (mustard oil, refined oil, sunflower oil) followed by packing. The French fries sample were blanched in control and four different treatments namely, (i) 3% NaCl at 90 C for 3 min, (ii) 0.5% KMS solution at 90 C for 3 min, (iii) 3% NaCl + 0.5% KMS solution at 90 C for 3 min, and (iv) 0.5% CaCl 2 solution at 90 C for 3 min. After blanching, the samples were cooled for 30 min in ceiling fan. Deep frying process is followed in which heat is transferred from the oil to the food, water is evaporated from the food and oil is absorbed in it. Frying conditions The potatoes cut into rectangular pieces and samples of the same mass were selected. The samples were washed in distillated water and excess surface water was removed using tissue paper. The potato to oil ratio was kept at 1:5. The samples were blanched with different treatments and frying was performed for four different times of 50, 100, 150, 200 sec. After each frying experiment, the level of oil was measured. Moisture content Moisture content of samples was determined by method as recommended by AOAC [9]. Oil uptake Oil uptake is measured as difference in mass of oil in pan during frying. Results and Discussions Moisture loss during frying The moisture content of the samples decreased during frying time increase. As expected, water evaporation took place quicker when the higher temperatures are applied. There are important differences between 50 to 200 sec., while increase has additional effect on moisture reduction when it is compared with 50 sec. Effect of mustard oil The experimental result for moisture content or moisture loss during frying in mustard oil represents that moisture loss was increased with increasing the frying period among the entire samples (Table 1). The pretreatment also affect the moisture loss during frying. Initial moisture content of sample was found 355 % db. The highest moisture loss was observed at first 50 sec. in KPM T 5 (355-122.58% db) and lowest in sample KPMT 2 (355 276.19% db). Frying for 100 sec. highest moisture loss was observed in sample KPMT 3 (355 62.71% db) and lowest in control sample KPM T 1 (355 197.72% db). Frying at 150 sec. highest moisture loss was observed in sample KPM T 3 (355 23.72% db) and lowest in sample KPMT 1 (355 109.09% db). Frying at 200 sec. highest moisture loss was observed in sample KPMT 5 (355 4.83% db) and lowest in sample KPM T 2 (355 44.73% db). The study was noticed that moisture loss was lost rapidly in first 50 sec of frying. The moisture was lost from 355 % (db) to 4.83% (db) during frying. Effect of refined oil Table 1 Effect of mustard oil on moisture content (%, db) of potato French fries. Time (sec.) KPM T 1 KPM T 2 KPM T 3 KPM T 4 KPM T 5 50 254.45 276.19 138.98 216.66 122.58 100 197.72 192.85 62.71 152.68 66.12 150 109.09 123.80 23.72 93.75 25.80 200 40.54 44.73 10.16 41.66 4.83 The experimental result for moisture content loss during frying in refined oil is given in (Table 2) represents the highest moisture loss was observed in first 50 sec. in KPR T 3 (355 98.50% db) and lowest in KPRT 4 (355 184.61% db). Frying at 100 sec highest moisture loss was observed in KPRT 3 (355 52.23% db) and lowest in KPR Chem Sci Rev Lett 2017, 6(24), 2144-2148 Article CS102048091 2145

T 4 (355 148.07% db). Frying at 150 sec highest moisture loss was observed in KPRT 3 (355 13.43% db) and lowest moisture loss in sample KPRT 4 (355 73.07% db). Frying at 200 sec highest moisture loss was observed in sample KPRT 3 (355 1.49% db) and lowest moisture loss in sample KPR T 4 (355 26.92% db). The moisture was lost during frying from 355 % (db) to 1.49% (db). Effect of sunflower oil Table 2 Effect of refined oil on moisture content (%, db) of potato French fries. Time (sec.) KPR T 1 KPR T 2 KPR T 3 KPR T 4 KPR T 5 50 127.86 138.90 98.50 184.61 150.87 100 90.16 74.57 52.23 148.07 110.52 150 36.06 35.59 13.43 73.07 66.66 200 6.55 6.77 1.49 26.92 16.17 The experimental result for moisture loss during frying in sunflower oil is given in (Table 3) represents the highest moisture loss was observed in first 50 sec. in KPST 2 (355 122.58% db) and lowest in control sample KPST 1 (355 234.70% db). Frying at 100 s highest moisture loss was observed in KPST 2 (355 66.12% db) and lowest in control sample KPST 1 (355 178.26% db).frying at 150 sec highest moisture loss was observed in KPST 2 (355 25.80% db) and lowest moisture loss by control sample KPST 1 (355 95.65% db). Frying at 200 sec highest moisture loss was observed in sample KPST 3 (355 5.08% db) and lowest moisture loss in control sample KPST 1 (355 60.86% db). It was noticed that the moisture was lost during frying from 355 %(db) to 5.08%(db). Oil absorption during frying Effect of mustard oil Table 3 Effect of sunflower oil on moisture content of potato French fries. Time (sec.) KPS T1 KPS T 2 KPS T 3 KPS T 4 KPS T 5 50 234.70 122.58 133.33 192.15 157.14 100 178.26 66.12 96.66 113.72 82.14 150 95.65 25.80 43.33 45.09 28.57 200 60.86 8.06 5.08 19.60 23.21 The experimental data for change in oil uptake of potato french fries fried in mustard oil are shown in (Table 4). It is clear that french fries oil uptake first increase then decrease with increase in time. Frying at 50 sec highest oil uptake by control sample KPMT 1 (40.90 g) and lowest in KPMT 5 (24.19 g). Frying at 100 sec highest oil uptake by KPMT 4 (18.75 g), and lowest oil uptake by sample KPMT 5 (9.67 g). Frying at 150 sec highest oil uptake by KPMT 2 (16.66 g) and lowest oil uptake by sample KPMT 5 (6.45 g). Frying at 200 sec highest oil uptake by sample KPMT 2 (9.52 g) and lowest oil uptake by sample KPMT 5 (4.83 g). Frying for 50-200 sec highest oil uptake was by control sample KPMT 1 (40.90 g) and lowest oil uptake by sample KPMT 5 (4.83 g). Effect of refined oil Table 4 Effect of mustard oil on oil uptake of potato French fries. Time (sec.) KPM T 1 KPM T 2 KPM T 3 KPM T 4 KPM T 5 50 40.90 34.00 30.50 33.33 24.19 100 13.63 14.28 13.55 18.75 9.67 150 11.36 16.66 10.16 12.50 6.45 200 9.09 9.52 6.77 8.33 4.83 The experimental data for change in oil uptake of potato french fries fried in refined oil are shown in (Table 5). Frying at 50 sec highest oil uptake by pretreated sample KPRT 2 (30.50 g) and lowest oil uptake by control sample KPRT 1 (22.95 g). Frying at 100 sec highest oil uptake by KPRT 3 (19.40 g) and lowest oil uptake by control sample KPRT 1 (8.19 g). Frying at 150 sec highest oil uptake by KPRT 3 (9.83 g) and lowest oil uptake by control sample KPRT 1 (6.55 g). Frying at 200 sec highest oil uptake by KPRT 4 (7.69 g) and lowest oil uptake by control sample Chem Sci Rev Lett 2017, 6(24), 2144-2148 Article CS102048091 2146

KPRT 1 (4.91 g). Frying at 50-200 sec highest oil uptake by sample KPRT 2 (30.50 g) and lowest oil uptake by sample KPRT 3 (4.47 g). Effect of sunflower oil Table 5 Effect of refined oil on oil uptake of potato French fries. Time (sec.) KPR T 1 KPR T 2 KPR T 3 KPR T 4 KPR T 5 50 22.95 30.50 26.86 26.92 28.07 100 8.19 10.16 19.40 15.38 14.03 150 6.55 8.47 9.83 9.61 8.77 200 4.91 5.08 4.47 7.69 7.01 The experimental data for change in oil uptake of potato French fries fried in Sunflower oil are shown in (Table 6). Frying at 50 sec highest oil uptake was by control sample KPST 1 (39.13 g) and lowest oil uptake by KPST 3 (23.33 g). Frying at 100 sec highest oil uptake by sample control sample KPST 1 (15.12 g) and lowest oil uptake by sample KPST 2 (9.67 g). Frying at 150 sec highest oil uptake by control sample KPST 1 (13.04 g) and lowest by sample KPST 2 (8.06 g). Frying at 200 sec highest oil uptake by control sample KPST 1 (8.69 g) and lowest oil uptake by sample KPST 5 (5.35 g). Frying during 50-200 sec highest oil uptake was by controlled sample KPST 1 (39.13 g) and lowest was by sample KPST 5 (5.35 g). Conclusion Table 6 Effect of sunflower oil on oil uptake of potato French fries. Time (sec.) KPS T 1 KPS T 2 KPS T 3 KPS T 4 KPS T 5 50 39.13 25.80 23.33 29.41 26.78 100 15.12 9.67 11.66 11.76 10.71 150 13.04 8.06 10.00 7.84 8.92 200 8.69 6.45 6.66 5.88 5.35 This study shows relationship between oil uptake and moisture loss during deep-fat frying of French fries. The relationship between moisture loss and oil uptake is an important phenomenon in the context of characterizing the physical properties of fried product. Highest moisture loss in case of French fries fried in mustard oil was observed in samples pre-treated with 3% NaCl at 90 o C for 3 min and than the other pre-treated samples; oil uptake was found highest in controlled sample. Effect of refined oil on moisture content of French fries blanching with CaCl 2 at 90 o C for 3 min highest moisture loss and oil uptake was found in controlled sample. Effect of sunflower oil on moisture content of French fries was highest found in blanching with 3%NaCl + 0.5% KMS at 90 o C for 3 min and oil uptake was highest found in controlled sample References [1] FAO. Strengthening potato value chains, technical and policy options for developing countries. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 2010, http://www.fao.org/docrep/013/i1710e/i1710e00.pdf. [2] Krokida, M. K., Oreopoulou, V., Maroulis, Z. B., and Marinos- Kouris, D. Effects of osmotic dehydration pretreatment on quality of French fries. Journal of Food Engineering, 2001; 49, 339 345. [3] Garayo, J. and Moreira, R.G. Vacuum frying of potato chips. Journal of Food Engineering, 2002, 55:181-191. [4] Pedreschi, F., and Moyano, P. Oil uptake and texture development in fried potato slices. Journal of Food Engineering, 2005, 70:557 563. [5] Santis, N., Mendoza, F., Moyano, P., Pedreschi, F., Dejmek, P. Soaking in a NaCl solution produce paler potato chips. LWT-Food Science and Technology, 2007; 40(2): 307-312. [6] Ahmad Tarmizi, A. H., and Ismail, I. Comparison of the frying stability of standard palmolein and special quality palmolein. Journal of American of Oil Chemists Society, (2008); 85(3): 245 251. [7] Mir-Bel, J., Oria, R., Salvador, M.L. Influence of the vacuum break conditions on oil uptake during potato post-frying cooling. Journal of Food Engineering, 2009; 95 (3): 416 422. [8] Moreira, R.G. and Barrufet, M.A. A new approach to describe oil absorption in fried foods: a simulation study, Journal Food Eng, 1998, 31: 485 498. Chem Sci Rev Lett 2017, 6(24), 2144-2148 Article CS102048091 2147

[9] AOAC. Official methods of analysis (13th Ed). Association of Official Analytical Chemists. Washington, DC, 2000; 132 211. 2017, by the Authors. The articles published from this journal are distributed to the public under Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creative commons.org/licenses/by/3.0/). Therefore, upon proper citation of the original work, all the articles can be used without any restriction or can be distributed in any medium in any form. Publication History Received 10 th Sep 2017 Revised 28 th Sep 2017 Accepted 05 th Oct 2017 Online 30 th Oct 2017 Chem Sci Rev Lett 2017, 6(24), 2144-2148 Article CS102048091 2148