Common Variable ImmunoDeficiency (CVID) Nima Rezaei, MD, PhD Deputy President of Research Center for Immunodeficiencies, Children s Medical Center, Pediatrics Center of Excellence, Associate Dean of International Affairs, School of Medicine Director of Global Academic Program Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Case 1 A 14-year-old patient, who had liver granuloma, extranodal marginal zone B-cell lymphoma, and autoimmune neutropenia. The patient was born to first-degree consanguineous parents. He developed pneumonia as well as lymphoproliferative manifestations, including retroperitoneal para-aortic lymph node hyperplasia and hepatosplenomegaly, leading to pancytopenia. The immunologic profile of this patient showed hypogammaglobulinemia: IgG, 320 mg/dl IgM, 30 mg/dl IgA, 15 mg/dl blood type O yet with an absence of anti-a and anti-b isohemagglutinins CD3, 78.2% CD4, 55.2% CD8, 20.0% CD19, 5.7% CD16, 11.9%
What is the diagnosis of the patient?
Mutations in all known gene defects associated with CVID (including CD19; CD20; CD21; CD81; ICOS; TACI; BAFFR; and LRBA) were ruled out by the exome sequencing data. Homozygosity mapping suggested one linkage to a 71.68-Mb region on chromosome 11. We subsequently found a novel homozygous mutation (c. G1073A, p. C358Y) in the RAG1 gene, which is predicted to be probably damaging by using Polyphen 2. This mutation was confirmed by Sanger sequencing in the patient (homozygous form) and his parents (heterozygous form), who were asymptomatic. Furthermore, we performed a functional test for RAG1, and the results were consistent with a mild phenotype, atypical SCID with granuloma with a residual recombination activity of 48.8% 6 0.6% of wild-type protein, as measured by using an artificial green fluorescent protein substrate.
Case 2 A 14-month-old boy was admitted due to chronic diarrhea. He was the second child of consanguineous parents. He had a medical history of 4 previous hospitalizations because of pneumonia (at 7 months), febrile seizure (at 9 months), viral meningitis (at 11 months), and bronchiolitis and failure to thrive (at 12 months). The immunologic profile of this patient showed hypogammaglobulinemia: IgG, 100 mg/ dl IgA, 0 mg/dl IgM, 23 mg/dl isohemagglutinin titer, 0 White blood cells, 7700 cells/μl, lymphocytes, 2464 cells/μl CD3+, 1374 cells/ μl CD3+CD4+, 616 cells/ μl CD3+CD8+, 665 cells/μl CD19+, 714 cells/ μl CD16/56+, 167 cells/μl What is the diagnosis of the patient?
We found a known, homozygous mutation in p.v722i (c.2164g>a) in the JAK3 gene
Case 3 A 10-year-old boy is presented with recurrent infections and autoimmunity. His parents are cousins. He came with a history of an episode of severe upper respiratory infection and gastroenteritis leading to hospitalization at 2 years of age. Severe disseminated varicella infection occurred 8 months later and soon afterward he developed thrombocytopenia and splenomegaly The immunologic profile of this patient showed hypogammaglobulinemia: IgG, 47 mg/ dl IgA, 45 mg/dl IgM, 193 mg/dl White blood cells, 5800 cells/μl, lymphocytes, 1682 cells/μl CD3+, 1429 cells/ μl CD3+CD4+, 555 cells/ μl CD3+CD8+, 841 cells/μl CD19+, 134 cells/ μl CD16/56+, 176 cells/μl What is the diagnosis of the patient?
Bronchiolitis obliterans with organizing pneumonia (BOOP)
Primary antibody deficiencies (PAD) - The most common types of primary immunodeficiency diseases - Ranging from a severe reduction of all serum immunoglobulin classes and absent number of B cells to a selective antibody deficiency with normal serum immunoglobulin - Clinical manifestations: -Recurrent infections -Chronic inflammation -Autoimmunity -Cancers
Predominantly antibody deficiencies 2016 Recurrent bacterial infections e.g., Otitis media, pneumonia, sinusitis, diarrhea, sepsis
* X-linked Agammaglobulinemia Btk deficiency * AR-Agammaglobulinemia heavy chain deficiency 5 deficiency Ig deficiency Ig deficiency BLNK deficiency PI3KR1 deficiency * Other Forms of Agammaglobulinemia with Absent B-Cells TCF3 (E47) deficiency LRRC8 deficiency Thymoma with immunodeficiency and myelodysplasia with hypogammaglobulinemia
Immunoglobulin Class Switch Recombination Deficiencies CD40LG deficiency CD40 deficiency AICDA deficiency UNG deficiency INO80 deficiency MSH6 deficiency Other forms of CSR selective deficiency
* Selective IgA Deficiency * Other Immunoglobulin Isotypes or Light Chain Deficiencies Activated PI3K-delta PI3KR1 loss of function Isolated IgG subclass deficiency IgA with IgG subclass deficiency Ig heavy chain mutations/deletions IGKC deficiency light chain deficiency * Specific Antibody Deficiency with Normal Immunoglobulin Concentrations * Transient Hypogammaglobulinemia of Infancy * CARD11 gain of function
* Common Variable Immunodeficiency (CVID) * LRBA Deficiency * PI3KD Syndrome * CD19 Complex Deficiencies CD19 deficiency CD21 deficiency CD81 deficiency * CD20 Deficiency * Other Monogenic Defects Associated with Hypogammaglobulinemia ICOS deficiency TACI deficiency BAFF receptor deficiency TWEAK deficiency NFKB2 deficiency MOGS deficiency TRNT1 deficiency TTC37 deficiency
Definition CVID is a heterogeneous group of disorders characterized by Hypogammaglobulinemia Defective specific antibody production Recurrent and chronic infections Increased susceptibility to autoimmune disorders and cancers
- The most prevalent human PIDs requiring medical attention - Prevalence ranging from 1:10,000 to 1:50,000 - Affects males and females equally. - Broad clinical spectrum - Present at any age, but peaks of presentation is in childhood and early adult life - Average delay of 5 6 years between the onset of symptoms and diagnosis!
The total estimated cost of diagnosed CVID is US$274,200/patient annually and early diagnosis of the disease can save US$6500. Hospital admission cost (US$25,000/patient) accounts for the most important expenditure parameter before diagnosis, but medication cost (US$40,600/patients) was the main factor after diagnosis primarily due to monthly administration of immunoglobulin. The greatest cost-determining factor is the cost of treatment, spent mostly on immunoglobulin replacement therapy of the patients. CVID patients costs are reduced after diagnosis due to appropriate management.
Etiology - CVID was first described in 1953, but the basic molecular defect(s) is still unknown. - There is no single diagnostic immunological or genetic test for CVID - Its diagnosis relies on a decrease of immunoglobulins of at least two isotypes (serum IgG, IgA, and/or IgM), and genetic exclusion of other antibody deficiencies associated with well-defined single gene defects
Etiology Although the most CVID cases are sporadic, it has been estimated that 10 20% of the cases are familial. In multiple-case families, CVID is often present in one parent, accompanied by IgA deficiency (IgAD) in the descendants, and it has been estimated that about 15% of the patients with CVID have a first degree relative with either IgAD or CVID Some cases of IgAD, who progress to CVID, have been reported
Genetic Defects
Clinical Manifestations The main clinical symptoms associated with CVID patients are recurrent infections, autoimmune manifestations, lymphoma and other selected cancers. - Acute sino-pulmonary infections: pneumonia, sinusitis, and otitis - Chronic pulmonary disease: bronchiectasis, lymphoid interstitial pneumonitis, non-caseating granulomatous infiltrations PULMONARY Asthma or non-smoker s COPD LIP GLILD COP Follicular bronchiolitis /respiratory bronchiolitis (DIP) LIVER, BILE DUCTS Nodular lymphoid hyperplasia (Sclerosing Cholangitis Primary Biliary Cirrhosis Autoimmune Hepatitis GASTROINTESTINAL Malabsorption -B12 (parietal cell ab neg, C+A atrophy) - Vitamin A, D, E (zinc, iron) Celiac disease /autoimmune enteropathy -biopsy: often no plasma cells Inflammatory bowel disease -Crohn -like, CU-like, GVHD-like and their combinations, lymphocytic colitis SICCA -common w/o Sjogren THYROID -TPOAb LYMPHOID TISSUE &BLOOD -enlarged spleen -clinically benign clonality -Malignancy: B-nHL, others ITP AIHA Evans AINP, other neutropenias Pancytopenia, BM aplasia SKIN Psoriasis (+arthritis) Vitiligo, alopecia JOINTS JIA Rheumatoid arthritis Sjögren SLE Reactive arthritis - Gastrointestinal disease: nodular lymphoid hyperplasia, inflammatory bowel disease, sprue-like illness with flat villi, giardiasis and nonspecific malabsorption -Autoimmune diseases: autoimmune hemolytic anemia, thrombocytopenia, rheumatoid arthritis, pernicious anemia -Lymphoma and cancers: gastrointestinal tract adenocarcinoma, non-hodgkin lymphoma
Clinical Characteristics of CVID * Recurrent pyogenic infections with extracellular encapsulated organisms, such as Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae type b, and group A Streptococcus * Otitis, sinusitis, recurrent pneumonia, bronchiectasis, and conjunctivitis * Few problems with fungal or viral infections (except enterovirus encephalitis and poliomyelitis) * Decreased levels of immunoglobulins in serum and secretions RHINOSINUSITIS Pneumococci, Haemophilus sp. Moraxella Tendency to need long ab courses and to recur LUNG INFECTIONS Pneumococci Haemophilus sp. S.aureus BRONCHIECTASIS recur GI INFECTIONS H.pylori: screen and treat!! Giardia: screen and treat Campylobacter Salmonella: MENINGITIS S.pneum, N.meningitidis purulent OTITIS CONJUCTIVITIS Purulent Often recur and together with sinusitis Sicca contributes SEPSIS ARTHRITIS -Mycoplasma (SKIN ABSCESSES) Sialadenitis * Diarrhea common, especially secondary to infection with Giardia lamblia * Growth retardation not striking * Compatible with survival to adulthood or for several years after onset unless complications occur
Immunological Defects - The core defect seems to be in late B cell differentiation, but the nature is unknown. - Other components of the immune system such as T cells or dendritic cells could also be involved. - Although most CVID patients have normal numbers of B cells, their B cells fail to differentiate into immunoglobulin-secreting plasma cells. - Consequently, CVID patients have reduced levels of serum immunoglobulin and respond abnormally to immunization with protein and polysaccharide antigens. - Reduced number of switched CD27+ memory B cells in CVID patients has been considered as a basis for sub-classification of CVID - 25 30% have increased numbers of CD8+ T cells and a reduced CD4/CD8 ratio (<1).
Diagnosis The most important laboratory criterion for establishing the diagnosis of CVID is a low serum IgG concentration, ranging from profoundly reduced (<100 mg/dl) to just 2 SDs below the normal values for age Flow cytometry is important in evaluating numbers of peripheral B cells in patients with profound hypogammaglobulinemia. Numbers of B cells in the peripheral blood may be normal or reduced and approximately 13% of patients will have a B cell count of less than 3% in peripheral blood. Approximately half of the patients with CVID may have reduced T cell numbers and diminished lymphocyte proliferative responses to mitogens and antigens. Documenting impaired production of specific antibodies (isohemagglutinins and/or poor responses to one or more vaccines) is valuable for the diagnosis of CVID.
Tests for Antibody-Mediated Immunity * Quantitative immunoglobulin levels: IgG, IgA, IgM, IgE * Isohemagglutinin titers (anti-a, anti-b): measures IgM. function * Specific antibody levels: Protein antigens: diphtheria, tetanus Protein-conjugated antigens: Haemophilus influenzae, Streptococcus pneumoniae (conjugate vaccine) Polysaccharide antigens: S. pneumoniae (unconjugated vaccine) * B-cell numbers and subsets by flow cytometry
Approach to a patient with hypogammaglobulinemia
Management The mainstay of treatment for CVID is immunoglobulin replacement therapy. Intravenous (IVIG) or subcutaneous (SCIG) immunoglobulin prophylaxis can be used on a regular basis to maintain a trough level of at least 400 500 mg/dl. The prognosis for patients with CVID depends on the frequency of infections, structural lung damage and concomitant presence of autoimmune disease. Other major factors in determining the prognosis is the extent of end-organ damage and the success of prophylaxis against infections. Patients and their families should thus be educated about early signs of infection in order not to delay treatment. Other forms of supportive care, such use of prophylactic antibiotics and good pulmonary hygiene, are important as bacterial infections may continue, albeit at a reduced rate, even with appropriate immunoglobulin replacement
Case 4 - A 2-year-old boy - History of recurrent respiratory infections - Absent tonsils with no lymphadenopathy - Low serum immunoglobulin levels (IgG: 90 mg/dl, IgA: 5 mg/dl, IgM: 10 mg/dl) Q1. Which of the following test could make a diagnosis? A- Nitro blue tetrazolium (NBT) test B- Lymphocyte subpopulation (B- and T- cell) enumeration C- Specific antibody responses D- Delayed cutaneous hypersensitivity
Flow cytometry: CD3: 82%, CD4: 50%, CD8: 32%, CD19: 1% Q2. What is the most likely diagnosis? A- Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) B- Hyper IgM syndrome (HIGM) C- X-linked agammaglobulinemia (XLA) D- Severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID)
Q3. Which gene defect is responsible for the disease? A- CD40LG B- BTK C- AID D- TACI Q4. What is the treatment of choice for this patient? A- Bone marrow transplantation B- Gene therapy C- Immunoglobulin replacement therapy D- Interferon-γ therapy
Case 5 A 12-year-old male patient with splenomegaly and otitis media and sinusitis. Immunological work-up showed WBC: 4,240/mm 3 lymphocytes: 42.4% IgG: 487 mg/dl (normal values for age: 707-1919 mg/dl) IgA: 29 mg/dl (normal values for age: 60-270 mg/dl) IgM: 35 mg/dl (normal values for age: 61-276 mg/dl) Antibody response to tetanus toxoid and hepatitis B were absent CD3: 73.5%, CD4: 30.5%, CD8: 35.5%, CD19: 11.6%, CD16: 15.1%. Proliferative response to mitogens was normal. Q1. Which is the most likely diagnosis? A- CVID B- X-linked HIGM C- Agammaglobulinemia D- XLP
The patient returned to our attention for the presence of jaundice. Additional laboratory findings included Red blood cell: 2,540,000/mm 3 haemoglobin: 8.1 g/dl hematocrit: 23.5% MCV: 92.7 fl bilirubin total: 18.8 mg/dl (direct: 0.84 mg/dl, indirect: 17.96 mg/dl) Coombs test: positive Q2: What is the most likely diagnosis is? A- Autoimmune haemolytic anemia (AIHA) B- Leukemia C- Bone marrow failure D- Post-infectious anemia
The patient performed chest CT scan and abdominal sonography. Both imaging showed nodular lesions in the lung and spleen. Clinical examination was negative. Laboratory exams were negative. Q3. What could be the possible diagnosis? A- Lymphoma B- Neoplasia C- Metastatic lesions D- Granulomas Q4. Which of the following strategies could be used to evaluate the carrier status of the patient's mother or siblings for genetic counseling and family planning? A- Analysis of memory B cells B- TACI mutations analysis C- BAFF mutations analysis D- None
Q5. Which of the following is false about CVID? A- The patients usually, but not always, develop recurrent bacterial infections B- The minimum age used to diagnose a patient with CVID is 2 years C- Chest CT scan should be performed for older patients to exclude the presence of a thymoma D- Lymphoid malignancies should be excluded before the diagnosis of CVID is secured. Q6. What is the treatment of choice for CVID patients? A- Bone marrow transplantation B- GCSF therapy C- IVIG therapy D- IFN-g therapy.
Q7. All of the following can be the probable cause of adverse reactions following the administration of IVIG in this patient, except: A- Fast infusion rate B- Anti-IgA antibodies C- Intercurrent infection D- Autoimmunity Q8. If a patient with CVID receiving IVIG develops mild and minor adverse reactions, what would be the best step to take? A- Slowing the infusion rate of IVIG B- Discontinuing the infusion of IVIG C- Discontinuing the infusion of IVIG and administration of epinephrine E- Recommending longer interval between IVIG infusion
References * Picard C, et al. Primary Immunodeficiency Diseases: an Update on the Classification from the International Union of Immunological Societies Expert Committee for Primary Immunodeficiency 2015. J Clin Immunol. 2015 Oct 19. * Bpusfiha A, et al. The 2015 IUIS Phenotypic Classification for Primary Immunodeficiencies. J Clin Immunol. 2015 Oct 7.
Thank you for your attention