Radiation Metrics and the Media Confusion Fuels Public Fears

Similar documents
Ionizing Radiation. Alpha Particles CHAPTER 1

Radiation in Everyday Life

TESTIMONY OF John D. Boice, Jr., Sc.D.

STANDARDIZED RADIOGENIC CANCER RISK COEFFICIENTS: A REVIEW OF THE METHODOLOGY PRESENTED IN FEDERAL GUIDANCE REPORT NO. 13

Nuclear Radiation Today

RADIATION RISK ASSESSMENT

Understanding Radiation and Its Effects

IONIZING RADIATION, HEALTH EFFECTS AND PROTECTIVE MEASURES

Radionuclide Concentrations in Food and the Environment

Cancer Risk Factors in Ontario. Other Radiation

Hazards + uses of emissions; Background radiation

Presentation. To the BAPE Panel on Uranium Mining In Quebec. by Gordon Edwards, Ph.D. November 17, 2014

The health risks of exposure to internal radiation. Korea National Assembly Seoul 22 nd August 2015

Lab & Rad Safety Newsletter

Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation & Commonly Used Radiation Units

Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation & Commonly Used Radiation Units

1. The Accident of Chernobyl Unit 4 of 1,000 MWe Graphite-Moderated Boiling Water Pressure Tube Reactor in 1986

Q&A: Health effects of radiation exposure

BIOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF

The Atomic War at Home

nuclear science and technology

Principles of Radiation

Sources of ionizing radiation Atomic structure and radioactivity Radiation interaction with matter Radiation units and dose Biological effects

Topic 6 Benefits and drawbacks of using radioactive materials

Radiobiology Hall 14: Radiologic Terrorism (Completed)

The detection limit for tritium is 300 pci/l

The activity. Suggested Answers

Effects of Radiation on Human In the Face of Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant Accident

DOWNLOAD OR READ : IONIZING RADIATION EFFECTS IN ELECTRONICS FROM MEMORIES TO IMAGERS DEVICES CIRCUITS AND SYSTEMS BOOK 50 PDF EBOOK EPUB MOBI

REVIEW Nuclear Disaster after the Earthquake and Tsunami of March 11

Chem 481 Lecture Material 3/11/09

RERF s Views on Residual Radiation 8 December 2012 Radiation Effects Research Foundation. Introduction

Environmental Health Physics

Radioactivity. Alpha particles (α) :

UNSCEAR Recent and Future Programme of Work. Emil Bédi

THE CROATIAN PARLIAMENT

REPORT NO. 5. background material. for the development of. radiation protection. standards. July Staff Report of the FEDERAL RADIATION COUNCIL

Ionizing Radiation. Michael J. Vala, CHP. Bristol-Myers Squibb

POTENTIAL HEALTH RISKS

Lecture 14 Exposure to Ionizing Radiation

Twelfth Annual Warren K. Sinclair Keynote Address

Hiroshima / Fukushima: Gender Matters in the Atomic Age

HEALTH PHYSICS SOCIETY

Radiation Carcinogenesis

Ionizing radiation. What is ionizing radiation?

Core Concepts in Radiation Exposure 4/10/2015. Ionizing Radiation, Cancer, and. James Seward, MD MPP

2015 IAEA Report on Fukushima - Remarks. Heinz Smital, nuclear physicist at Greenpeace

Radioactive Exposure. Abstract of Article:

International Food Safety Authorities Network (INFOSAN) INFORMATION on Nuclear accidents and radioactive contamination of foods 30.

Radiological Protection Countermeasures after TEPCO Fukushima NPP Accident -Who should play the role of risk communication-

ESTIMATES AND EVALUATION OF FALLOUT IN THE UNITED STATES FROM NUCLEAR WEAPONS TESTING CONDUCTED THROUGH 1962

Section 7 ALARA Program

Everyday Radiation. David D. Dixon HDT Rally Hutchinson, KS October 15, 2014

RADIOACTIVITY & RADIATION CHARACTERISTICS

Training Course on Medical Preparedness and Response for a Nuclear or Radiological Emergency Pre- Test - BASIC

Estimation of annual effective dose to the adult Egyptian population due to natural radioactive elements in ingestion of spices

ROUND TABLE 1: Health risk management Health examinations in different workplaces

Radiation Safety Guide. Analytical X-Ray Equipment

Radiation and harm to human health

INCOMING! Is your ED Ready for a Nuclear Bomb?

POLONIUM IN CIGARETTES: A MAJOR SOURCE OF RADIATION EXPOSURE. NC-VA CHAPTER MEETING New Bern, NC Dade W. Moeller March 12, 2009

Theremino System About Radon

RADIATION HAZARDS. A dabbler s perspective. Jess H. Brewer

Chapter 8. Ionizing and Non-Ionizing Radiation

What is the current risk of radiation-related health problems in Japan to those near the reactor at the time, and those in other parts of Japan?

JHM-IRB Guidelines for Radiation Statements

Special Topic: Radiological Dispersal Device or Dirty Bomb EXPLOSION AND BLAST INJURIES

Radiation physics and radiation protection. University of Szeged Department of Nuclear Medicine

Introduction To Nuclear Power Module 3: Understanding Radiation and Its Effects

RADIATION SAFETY REFRESHER TRAINING FOR AUGUSTA UNIVERSITY USERS OF RADIOACTIVE MATERIAL

ACUTE RADIATION SYNDROME: Diagnosis and Treatment

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES STATEMENT. ROBERT G. McSWAIN ACTING DIRECTOR INDIAN HEALTH SERVICE BEFORE THE

Ernest Rutherford:

Radioactivity. Lecture 8 Biological Effects of Radiation

Saint Louis University Institutional Review Board Ionizing Radiation Risk Informed Consent Template Language

Annex V of Technical Volume 4 UNSCEAR ASSESSMENT OF THE DOSE TO THE PUBLIC

A PROBLEM OF LOW DOSE EFFECTS:

An update: Dealing with radiation as a hazard. WAJ Meintjes MBChB; DOM; FCPHM(SA) Occ Med; MMed (Occ Med)

Is there a risk of radioactive exposure from food contamination?

Radiological Preparedness & Emergency Response. Session V. Objectives. Clinical Evaluation and Management of Internal Contamination

Hazard 8: Radiation. Housing Health and Safety Rating System

Controlling Natural Occurring Radioactive Material (NORM) Exposure

So just how concerned about radiation poisoning should you be? Everyday Health took your top questions to experts for answers.

Radiation Protection Program Update: The Details. July 2010

Kazuo Sakai National Institute of Radiological Sciences Research Center for Radiation Protection

CRACKCast E146 Radiation Injuries

Summary of ICRP Recommendations on Radon

Radon and Cancer: Questions and Answers

Leukaemia Among Uranium Miners Late Effects of Exposure to Uranium Dust. L. Tomášek 1, A. Heribanová 2

Current and Planned Reports and Conferences of the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements

User's Guide for the Interactive RadioEpidemiological Program (NIOSH-IREP)

Protecting the Health of Uranium Mine Workers: The Situation from the 1930s to the Present Day

Hazard 8: Radiation. Healthy Home Rating System (HHRS)

RADON RISK IN URANIUM MINING AND ICRP

The health outcome of the Fukushima catastrophe Initial analysis from risk model of the European Committee on Radiation Risk ECRR.

Radiation Safety General Awareness and ALARA Training

Laboratory Safety 197/405. Types of Radiation 198/405

Fall Ohio University Lab & Rad Safety Newsletter. Table of Contents

Recent Progress in Radiation Dosimetry for Epidemiology and Radiological Protection. John Harrison ICRP Committee 2

RELIANT HOLDINGS LTD AND ITS AFFILIATES Safety Management System. Preparation: Safety Mgr Authority: CEO Issuing Dept: Safety Page: Page 1 of 5

Transcription:

Radiation Metrics and the Media Confusion Fuels Public Fears

Radiation Metrics and the Media Confusion Fuels Public Fears THREE MAIN POINTS Journalists neither know nor CARE about the units by which radiation is measured. They care about what their readers/viewers/listeners care about; the RISK to health. Any information about radiation metrics for media use MUST put the information in the context of what it means to health risk. Failure to do so feeds media/public confusion and fear.

4 th paragraph Risk Fear, fueled by the popular perception of radiation risks and the slow response to the fire by landfill operator Republic Services and the Environmental Protection Agency, has stoked conflict and distrust

7 th, 8 th paragraphs Risk The waste emits only tiny amounts of the gamma rays that can penetrate all but the most dense material, including the human body. Instead, almost all of the radiation released by the waste comes in the form of alpha particles, radiation that can t pierce the skin and needs to get inside the body to do damage. Asked to review measurements of radionuclides in the West Lake landfill and Coldwater Creek gathered by regulators, Sasa Mutic, the director of radiation oncology physics at Washington University School of medicine, indicated the risks from exposure are akin to driving a car.

9 th paragraph first reference to dose metrics After years of testing, the highest concentration of contamination the EPA has detected near the surface of West lake would require ingesting over an ounce to deliver the same radiation dose as a whole-body CT scan, according to dose calculations from the international Commission on Radiological Protection and reviewed by experts. The dose from a whole-body CT scan, according to the National Research Council, a nonprofit institution that produces reports reflecting the scientific community s views, would be expected to cause a 1 in 1,000 risk of cancer

10 th paragraph, metric reference framed in terms of risk But the highest radionuclide concentrations in West Lake are not the norm, and many of the higher readings are dozens of feet underground. With most dirt at West Lake, it would take ingesting a least a quarter-pound, if not more, to deliver a CT scan s worth of radiation, according to EPA estimates of average concentrations.

26 th, 28 th paragraphs first reference to units, framed as RISK Radiation doses are usually expressed in millirems or milliseiverts. The average American typically receives about 320 millirem of natural radiation, or 3.2 milliseiverts, annually. The atomic bomb survivors, on average, received about 120 milliseiverts of radiation, or 12,000 millirem, Royal said. That s about 12 CT scans all at once.

30 th graph, risk per units The National Research Council s lifetime risk model estimates that one person in 1,000 would be expected to develop cancer if he or she were exposed to an additional 1,000 millirem, or 10 milliseiverts, of radiation, about as much as a whole-body CT scan

32 nd paragraph The confusion of a DIFFERENT unit The concentrations of those materials in the West Lake Landfill are measured in picocuries. When doctors use radioactive elements in tests or treatment, the unit we use is millicuries Royal said. Even the most contaminated portions near the surface of West lake contain only about 30,000 picocuries per gram of thorium, or 0.000003 millicuries. The concentrations of radium and uranium are lower still

5 th, 6 th paragraphs Units, to describe RISK But questions remain about whether radiation levels are low enough for all residents to return. On Friday morning, for example, the entrance to Minamisoma city s main hospital measured 0.51 microseiverts per hour in radiation, according to numbers released daily by the city. A simple calculation would bring annual exposure at the level to almost 4,500 microseiverts, or 4.5 milliseiverts a year, far above the annual limit of 1 milliseivert for civilians that is recommended by the International Commission on Radiological protection. (If, of course, you stood in that doorway for a year!)

7 th paragraph risk per unit (Uncertainty feeds fear.) While experts say these levels are still low the limit for radiation workers in the united States is 50 milliseiverts per year, for example little is known about the health effects of extended exposure to low level radiation. Moreover, children and pregnant women are known to be especially sensitive to radiation. A seivert measures the effect of radiation on the human body.

IAEA/INES scale Big numbers are scary, no clarity on risk/units this upgrade to level 3 ( Serious incident ) means the event involves the release of a few thousand terabecquerels of activity into an area not expected by design which requires corrective action, or one resulting in radiation rates of greater than one seivert per hour in an operating area, according to the INES user s manual. A terabecquerel is 1 trillion becquerels, defined as the radioactive decay of one nucleus per second; a seivert is a unit of biological radiation dose equivalent to about. 50,000 front view chest X rays

LiveScience article Immediately after the June 2011 meltdown, scientists measured that 5,000 to 15,000 terabecquerels of radioactive materials was reaching the ocean. The biggest threat at that time was from radioactive cesium. But for leaks that enter the ground, the radionuclides strontium and tritium pose more of a threat, because cesium is absorbed by the soil while the other two are not. The Tokyo Electric Power Plant (TEPCO) estimated that since the March 2011 disaster, between 20 trillion and 40 trillion becquerels of radioactive tritium have leaked into the ocean

New Yorker article The most radioactive place in New York City.

http://projects.newyorker.com/story/radioactive-nyc/

UNSCEAR document Radiation Effects and Sources (specific dose numbers)

UNSCEAR Radiation Effects and Sources (specific dose numbers)

UNSCEAR Radiation Effects and Sources (no specific dose numbers on X axis)

UNSCEAR Radiation Effects and Sources (Gy? Other slides were in Sv.)

Radiation Metrics and the Media Confusion Fuels Public Fears THREE MAIN POINTS Journalists neither know nor CARE about the units by which radiation is measured. They care about what their readers/viewers/listeners care about; the RISK to health. Any information about radiation metrics for media use MUST put the information in the context of what it means to health risk. Failure to do so feeds media/public confusion and fear.