P eloquin(1990)notedthatmechanicalexpertiseandskillweretheprimaryfocus

Similar documents
Rehabilitation Protocol: Primary Flexor Tendon Repair LHMC Protocol for Zone 1 & 2

Extensor Tendon Repair Zones II, III, IV

American Burn Association Burn Rehabilitation Therapist Competency Tool Version 2

Dr Klika Proximal & Middle Phalanx Fracture with CRPP

Dr. Klika Metacarpal Fracture with CRPP

Dr. Brian Klika Sagittal Band Repair / EDC Recentralization Phase 1- Early Protective Phase (Day 1 2 weeks)

Metacarpophalangeal Joint Implant Arthroplasty REHABILITATION PROTOCOL

AROM of DIP flex/ext, 10 reps hourly.

SUMMARY OF MEDICAL TREATMENT GUIDELINE FOR CARPAL TUNNEL SYNDROME AS IT RELATES TO PHYSICAL THERAPY

Phase 1 Maximum Protection 0-4 Weeks

This presentation is the intellectual property of the author. Contact them for permission to reprint and/or distribute.

Basal Joint Arthritis of the Thumb

STATE COLLEGE OF FLORIDA OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY ASSISTANT PROGRAM

CRITICALLY APPRAISED PAPER (CAP)

WOUND MANAGEMENT WHITE PAPER

Treatment of the Child with Cerebral Palsy Post Surgical Rehabilitation

Corporate Medical Policy

A Patient s Guide to Elbow Dislocation

A Patient s Guide to Biceps Tendon Tears at the Elbow

Client centered approach to distal radius fracture management. Jared Rasmussen OTR

Ascension PIP Post-Operative therapy protocol

CRITICALLY APPRAISED PAPER (CAP)

Procedure code billed is not approved for the therapy/pathology assistant.

Course Descriptions for Courses in the Entry-Level Doctorate in Occupational Therapy Curriculum

FLEXOR TENDON REPAIR FINGERS Indiana ACTIVE Motion Program Initial 4 Weeks Postop

Trigger Finger and Trigger Thumb A Patient's Guide to Trigger Finger & Trigger Thumb

UTILIZING CPT AND HCPCS CODES FOR HEALTHCARE REIMBURSEMENT: A guide to billing and reimbursement of SpiderTech kinesiology tape products

CRITICALLY APPRAISED PAPER (CAP)

Test outline for the OTR examination

PIP Joint Injuries of the Finger A Patient's Guide to PIP Joint Injuries of the Finger

CRITICALLY APPRAISED PAPER (CAP)

MULTIMEDIA ARTICLES. Mary C. Burns & Brian Derby & Michael W. Neumeister

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Orthopaedic Department Patient Information Leaflet. Under review. Page 1

Occupational Therapy. Occupational Therapy Payment Policy Page 1

Finger Mobility Deficits Fracture of metacarpal Fracture of phalanx of phalanges

Integra. Thumb Joint Replacement PATIENT INFORMATION. with PyroCarbon implants

A Patient s Guide to Elbow Dislocation

Duputytren's Contracture

Payment Policy. Chiropractic Care. Policy Specific Section: September 10, 2012 November 10, 2012

Therapy Manual DO NOT PRINT

CARPAL TUNNEL SYNDROME

STATE COLLEGE OF FLORIDA OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY ASSISTANT PROGRAM

A Patient s Guide to Medial Epicondylitis (Golfer s Elbow) William T. Grant, MD

Rehabilitation after Total Elbow Arthroplasty

WAHT-OCT-002 It is the responsibility of every individual to ensure this is the latest version as published on the Trust Intranet

WAHT-OCT-002 It is the responsibility of every individual to ensure this is the latest version as published on the Trust Intranet

CRITICALLY APPRAISED PAPER (CAP)

Occupational therapy guidelines for conditions in which the metacarpophalangeal joints could be splinted in extension

Physical Therapy. Physical Therapy Payment Policy Page 1

Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation Volume 1 and 2

PRIMARY CARE SPORTS MEDICINE

Original Policy Date

LABETTE COMMUNITY COLLEGE BRIEF SYLLABUS. Please check with the LCC bookstore for the required texts for this class.

Travel Report. Rehab Dept of KATH Hospital, Kumasi, Ghana. Date:August 2016

Visualize, stabilize, mobilize. Wristore * Distal Radius Fracture Fixator Abbreviated Surgical Technique

FOOSH It sounded like a fun thing at the time!

The Forearm, Wrist, Hand and Fingers. Contusion Injuries to the Forearm. Forearm Fractures 12/11/2017. Oak Ridge High School Conroe, Texas

Kapi'olani Community College Courses , O-P, page 1

A Patient s Guide to Adult Finger Fractures

Early Elbow Motion Protocol Ligament Repair of the elbow

Timed Therapeutic Procedures

Physical Therapy MM /15/2003

CUBITAL TUNNEL SYNDROME

Certificate for Advanced Practice in Hand Therapy

CRITICALLY APPRAISED PAPER (CAP)

Flexor Tendon Case Conundrums

Andrew L Terrono, MD Chief Hand Surgery Service NEBH Clinical Professor Orthopaedics Tufts University. May 2 & 3, 2016

A A ~l~js AM f'ricj\n ACADBl\IY OF 0RTllOPAEDIC SURGEONS ~ J AMERICAN A SOCIATION OF ORTHOPAEDIC SURGEONS. Therapy billing for beginners

Date: December 4 th, 2012 CLINICAL SCENARIO:

Essential intervention No.1 Health education and self-care KEY OBJECTIVES

CRITICALLY APPRAISED PAPER (CAP)

FOOSH It sounded like a fun thing at the time!

A Patient s Guide to Nursemaid's Elbow in Children. PHYSIO.coza

Rehabilitation after ankle injuries

WEEKEND 2 Elbow. Elbow Range of Motion Assessment

8 Recovering From HAND FRACTURE SURGERY

Integra TenoGlide Tendon Protector Sheet

Small Rotator Cuff Repair

Cardinal Hill Occupational Participation Process Process: Adult INSERT Occupational Profile

Scope of Practice. Statement of Purpose. Introduction

SPORTS RELATED HAND INJURIES

A Patient s Guide to Adult Thumb Metacarpal Fractures

Flexor Tendons. Get a Grip on Flexor Tendons. 1) Click the arrows on the navigation panel at the bottom of the PDF page

Anatomy. Introduction

CONSTRAINT INDUCED MOVEMENT THERAPY. Healing is a matter of time, but sometimes it is also a matter of opportunity. Hippocrates.

Chapter 24. Arthroscopic Thumb Carpometacarpal Interposition Arthroplasty. Introduction. Operative Technique. Patient Preparation and Positioning

HAND INJURY REHAB CONCEPTS AND RETURN TO PLAY

Integra Use of TenoGlide Tendon Protector Sheet to Protect an Extensor Tendon Repair of the Thumb CASE STUDY

FLEXOR TENDON REPAIR FINGERS Indiana PASSIVE Motion Program Initial 3 Weeks Postop

Rehabilitating the Pediatric Gymnast s Wrist. Justine LaPierre, MS, OTR/L March 1, 2019

Physiotherapist's Guide to Elbow Fracture

The 3E Approach to Eliminating Musculoskeletal Injuries: Utility Spotlight

C.V. EDUCATION EXPERIENCE TURNING POINT REHABILITATION CONSULTING, INC.

GUIDELINES FOR SUPERVISION, ROLES, AND RESPONSIBILITIES DURING THE DELIVERY OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY SERVICES

Essential intervention No. 8 Adaptations in activities of daily living

Rehabilitation Protocol After Reverse Total Shoulder Replacement

Athletic Training Educational Competencies ATHP 3320 Therapeutic Modalities. Student Learning Outcomes

Total Shoulder Arthroplasty / Hemiarthroplasty Therapy Protocol

Transcription:

Documenting Progress: Hand Therapy Treatment Shift From Biomechanical to Occupational Adaptation Jada Jack, Rebecca I. Estes KEY WORDS arthritis exercise therapy hand human activities patient-centered care postoperative care The investment of time and self to develop therapeutic relationships with clients appears incongruent with today s time-constrained health care system, yet bridging the gap of these incongruencies is the challenge therapists face to provide high-quality, client-centered, occupation-based treatment. This case report illustrates a shift in approach from biomechanical to occupational adaptation (OA) in an orthopedic outpatient clinic. The progress of a client with lupus-related arthritis who was 6 days postsurgery is documented. The intervention initially used a biomechanical frame of reference, but when little progress had been made at 10 weeks after surgery, a shift was made to the more client-centered OA approach. The Canadian Occupational Performance Measure was administered, and an OA approach was initiated. On reassessment, clinically important improvements were documented in all functional tasks addressed. An OA approach provides the bridge between the application of clinical expertise, client-centered, occupation-based therapy and the time constraints placed by payer sources. Jack, J., & Estes, R. I. (2010). Documenting progress: Hand therapy treatment shift from biomechanical to occupational adaptation. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 64, 82 87. Jada Jack, OTR/L, is Private Contract Occupational Therapist, Sequim School District, 503 North Sequim Avenue, Sequim, WA 98382; jadajack@gmail.com Rebecca I. Estes, PhD, OTR/L, ATP, is Department Chair and Associate Professor, Department of Occupational Therapy, University of South Alabama, HAHN #2027, 307 North University Boulevard, Mobile, AL 36688. P eloquin(1990)notedthatmechanicalexpertiseandskillweretheprimaryfocus ofoccupationaltherapycurriculaandobservedthatthroughthesixthedition ofwillard and Spackman s Occupational Therapy,nochapterdiscussedthetherapeuticrelationshipormadereferencetothetermsrapport,relationship,empathy,or trust.overthepast20years,therehasbeenanawarenessoftheneedforashiftin focusbacktoour caring rootstoincludeamoreholistic,client-centeredapproach thatcouldsupplementthestrongmanualskillsofmorebiomechanicalapproaches (Chan&Spencer,2004;Daleetal.,2002;Peloquin,1993).Fortherapiststotruly demonstratecare,therapeuticrelationshipsmustbeformed.thisinvestmentof timeandselfappearsincongruentwithtoday shealthcaresystem,inwhichproductivityisparamountandtreatmenttimeiscurtailed,yetaccountabilitytoboth patientandpayersourcesisessential.inthiseraofmanagedcare,handtherapyis increasinglyperceivedasapracticeareainwhichmechanicalskillmustoftenovershadowclient-centeredapproachestomeethealthinsurerdemands.bridgingthese incongruenciestoprovideskilled,holistic,client-centeredcareisthechallengethat everypracticingtherapistfaces.individualized,occupation-basedtreatmentina hand therapy setting has been linked to enhanced patient outcomes(chan& Spencer,2004);however,concreteexamplesdocumentinghowtherapistscanshift fromamechanistictoaclient-centeredandoccupation-basedapproachhavenot beenpublished.thiscasereportprovidesanovelillustrationofhowtheshiftfrom astrictlybiomechanicaltoaclient-centered,occupation-basedapproachinhand therapypracticecanbemadetoenhancepatientoutcomes. The occupational adaptation(oa) framework(schkade& Schultz, 1992; Schultz&Schkade,1992)providesabasisforpatientcareregardlessofsettingand addresses the need for a more client-centered, holistic approach by fostering a 82 January/February 2010, Volume 64, Number 1

client therapist relationship that facilitates the patient s adaptationandownershipoftreatmentgoalsandprogress. TheseconceptsareembeddedintheOccupational Adaptation Guides to Practice(Schultz&Schkade,1992)fromthedatagatheringstage,whenthepatient sevaluationisviewedholistically,andincludesobtaininginformationonthepatient s performance,abilitytoadapt,environments,roles,andoccupations.datagatheringisalsoclientcentered,seekingpatient and significant others input on concerns, goals, level of desiredoccupationalperformance(efficiency,effectiveness, andsatisfaction),andapproachtoadaptation. BycomparingtheOAmodeltothetypicalbiomechanical rehabilitationmodelappliedtopatientsrecoveringfrom hipfracture,jacksonandschkade(2001)demonstratedthat patientsbenefitwhentheoaframeworkisused.application oftheoaframeworkimprovedpatientoutcomeefficiency andgeneratedhigherpatientsatisfactionratingswhencomparedwithperformanceandratingsusingthebiomechanical model.providingoccupationaltherapyservicesunderthe OAframeworkcanbebothanartandaskillexecutedwith methodandprecision,whileprovidingthecollaborativecare demanded by this generation of consumers (Schultz & Schkade,1992). Thepurposeofthiscasereportwastoillustratethata shiftinframesofreferencefromabiomechanicaltoanoa approach in an orthopedic outpatient clinic can facilitate adaptation,improvepatientmotivation,andprovidedocumentationofclinicallysignificantfunctionalprogress.this casereportpresentsacomplicated,orthopedic,postsurgical patientwhopresentedwithseverelydeformedbilateraldistal extremitiesaftermultiplesurgicalinterventions.theconductofthiscasereportwasapprovedbythetexaswoman s UniversityInstitutionalReviewBoard;thepatientprovided informedconsenttobepartofthisstudy. Client History Toprotectconfidentiality,thepseudonymSusanwasused. Susan was diagnosed with lupus at age 16; lupus-related arthritis resulted in significant joint deformities to both hands(seefigures1and2)andfeet.althoughthephysical limitationsresultingfromthesedeformitiesdidnotprevent Susan from participating in daily activities, she reported havingagreatdealofdifficultygrowingupwiththediagnosis.sheidentifiedherpositiveattitudeandsheerdeterminationastwoofhergreatestassets.susanwasa51-year-old, divorced mother of two children. She and her children sharedasingle-level,three-bedroomhomeinaruralnorthwesterncommunity.sheprovidedfinanciallyforherfamily throughdisabilitybenefitsandstatefunds,andreceived143 hrpermonthofpersonalcaregiverassistance. Figure 1. Volar view of (B) hands. Figure 2. Dorsal view of (B) hands. Initial Evaluation Oninitialevaluation,Susanpresentedwithabulkydressing onherleftdistalforearmandhand.only6daysprior,she had undergone simultaneous left thumb interphalangeal jointhardwareremovalandarthrodesisrevision,leftopen carpaltunnelreleaseandsynovectomy,leftradiusscapholunatefusion,andaleftindexfingerflexordigitorumsuperficialistoflexordigitorumprofundus(fdp)tendontransfer. Susan also identified a history of emphysema but denied furthermedicalcomplicationsorotherdiagnoses. Afterthepatientinterview,herbulkydressingwascut away to reveal healing, blood-crusted suture lines with no abnormalerythemaordrainagenoted.typicalmeasurements were taken of the incisions; all sites presented moderately tendertopressure.susan slefthandrestedinadependent flexedposturewithherwristinneutral.goniometricmeasurements were taken on her left index finger metacarpal joint;inactiverangeofmotion(arom),shedemonstrated a20 extensionlagand50 offlexion.astraightfistmeasured 4cmfromfingertipstoproximalpalmarcrease.Noother The American Journal of Occupational Therapy 83

ROMmeasurementsweretakenatthistimebecauseshewas lessthan1weekpostoperative.thefigure-8edemameasurementwastakenofthelefthandandnotedas36cm;32cm wasnotedontherightforcomparison.susanwasinitially placedinaforearm-basedvolarrestingsplintwithherleft thumbanddigitspositionedforcomforttosupport,protect, andimmobilizethejointsduringthehealingprocess. Problemsidentifiedontheinitialoccupationaltherapy evaluationincludedpittinghandedema,decreasedromin alldigits,increasedpain,anddecreasedfunction.susanwas scheduledforoccupationaltherapyservicestwiceperweek for6weeks,formodalities,manualtherapies,andtherapeutic exercise to address treatment plan goals. The patient s verbalizedgoalsnotedatthetimeoftheinitialevaluation includedthedesiretobeabletoresumeplayingfrisbeewith improvedgripandtheabilitytoresumenormalactivitiesof dailyliving(adls)thatshehadbeenabletocompletebefore surgery. The following short-term goals were established: Patientwill(1)beindependentinhomeexerciseprogram within4weeks,(2)demonstrate2-cmdecreaseinedema usingfigure-8measurementwithin4weeks,(3)demonstrate well-healedincisionswithmaturingflatscartissuefreeof tetheringwithin4weeks,and(5)demonstratestraightfist 1.5cmfromproximalpalmarcreasewithin4weeks.Longtermgoalswereestablishedasfollows:Patient(1)willhave theabilitytogrippantstopullthemupindependentlyin8 weeks,(2)willhavetheabilitytomanipulateandopenpill jarsin8weeks,(3)wouldliketohavetheabilitytoresume playingfrisbeewithimprovedgrip,and(4)wouldlikethe abilitytoresumenormaladlsthatshewasabletocomplete beforesurgery. Treatment Occupationaltherapyserviceswereinitiallyprovidedunder thebiomechanicalframeofreferencewithaheavyemphasis onprotectingthesurgicalinterventions;gainingandmaintainingbotharomandpassiverom(prom);andreducingpresentedema,promotingwoundhealing,andproviding scar management (see Table 1). Treatments consistently included modalities, retrograde massage, and manual scar mobilizations as well as therapeutic exercises. Dressing changesanddebridementofwoundswereperformedasnecessary.splintmodificationswereperformedasedemasubsided,andpressureareaswerenoted.susanwasseeninthe clinicsevenofeightscheduledvisits;onlyoneappointment absenceoccurredwithinthefirst5weeksofcare. Fiveweeksaftersurgery,afollow-upoccupationaltherapyassessmentwasperformedbecauseofpoorglideofthe transferredindexfingerfdptendon.susanreportedintermittentpainwithincreasedfrequencyandlengthofduration associatedwithswellingoftheleftindexfingerafterherhome Table 1. Schedule of Intervention Activities and Treatment Focus Biomechanical Focus Shift of Focus Occupational Adaptation Focus Postoperative Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Evaluation/reevaluation Canadian Occupational Performance Measure Modalities Hot pack Ultrasound in water Functional electrical stimulation Manual therapies Retrograde massage Scar mobilization Range of motion of digits Passive Active assisted Active Range of motion of wrist Active assisted Dressing changes Debridement Splint fabrication modification Buddy tape Occupation-based tasks Functional activity performance Compensatory techniques Adaptive equipment training 84 January/February 2010, Volume 64, Number 1

exerciseprogram.shewasabletodemonstrateindependence withherhomeexerciseprogramandverbalizedprecautions independently.thetherapist sobjectivefindingsincluded healingscartissuewithlimitedmobilityatthedorsaland volarwristincisionsitesandslowhealingatthethumbinterphalangealjoint.oftheestablishedshort-termgoals,susan met two by independently performing her home exercise programandbypresentingwitha2-cmdecreaseinhand edema. However, tethering scar tissue and an inability to makeastraightfistpreventedherfrommeetingtheother two goals. The therapist s assessment identified minimal FDPfiringbutnotedthattheindexfinger sdistalinterphalangealjointwasfirmwithcontraction.thisconditionwas attributedtoheavyscarringattheincisionsites.itwasalso notedthatsusanwascompensatingwiththelumbricalsat themetacarpalphalangealjoint.hertreatmentwaschanged to include the use of continuous ultrasound followed by continued aggressive scar massage to reduce adhesions. Functional electronic stimulation, which simultaneously blockedthelumbricals function,wasaddedafterscarmassagetoaidintendonpullthrough.anarom,active-assisted ROM,andPROMhomeexerciseprogramandsplintingfor protectionwerecontinuedasappropriateuntilsusanwas dischargedfromoccupationaltherapy(seetable1). Susanattendedanadditionalsevenofeightscheduled appointmentswithoneabsenceoverthenext5weeks.she verbalizedcompliancewithallinstructedtasksbutreported discouragementinthepoorprogressshefeltshehadmade regardingherscarmobilityandrom.nineweeksafterthe operation,buddytapewasissuedtoaddressanulnardriftof Susan sleftindexfingeroverherlongfingerduringcompositeflexion.oneweeklater,atthe10thweekpostoperative progressreport,wefoundthatminimalimprovementscould be documented. Objective findings identified poor tissue mobilityatallincisionsites.weassessedthepatient sfunctionalgraspsthroughherabilitytopickupsmallobjects, suchasbuttons;however,shewasunabletoholdthemin thepalmofherhand.shewasunabletoholdaknifetocut foodandunabletogripamugwithherlefthand.thetherapistencouragedsusantocontinueherhomeexerciseprogram,aggressivescarmassage,andbuddytapeasastablepost forherindexfingertopushagainstduringtaskperformance. Thelong-termgoalinitiallyestablishedtoaddressimproved Frisbeethrowingskillwasdiscontinuedatthistime.Other establishedfunctionalgoalsremainedinplace. Afterthe10thweek,Susanagainexpresseddiscouragementwiththesmallobjectivegainsdocumented.Sheshared herthoughtsthatalthoughonlysmallgainswereseeninthe documentation,thesamesmallgainsoftenresultedinmajor shiftsinheroccupationalperformance.shewasdisappointed thatheroccupationalperformancegainswerenotreflected inthebiomechanicalgoalsorbiomechanicalmeasures.we decidedthatashiftinframesofreferencetoamoreclientcenteredapproachwasneeded.researchsupportsthatwhen theclientisengagedinmeaningfuloccupationandisinvested inhisorherrecoveryprocess,betteroutcomesareachieved (Dolecheck&Schkade,1999).WeselectedtheOAmodel becauseitwouldincorporatetheneededclientengagement andoccupation-basedapproachandfacilitategeneralization ofskillstonovelactivitiesandself-initiatedadaptations.the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (COPM; Lawetal.,1999)wasselectedto(1)identifySusan sprimary occupationalrolesandimportantoccupationalperformances and(2)obtainclient-ratedobjectivemeasurementsofher currentlevelsofperformance,specificallynotingperceived levelsofefficiency,effectiveness,andsatisfaction. Shifting to a Client-Centered Approach TheOAframeworkstatesthatOAisanormalprocessthat everypersonexperiences.whenapersonisfacedwithalife transition, such as a surgical intervention, compounding disabilitiesthatmayalreadybepresent,theoaprocessisat risk for dysfunction. It is through the use of the holistic approachofoathatclientsmaybefacilitatedtobecome theirownagentofchange.themodelhasbeensuccessfully usedinavarietyofsettingsandcomparedwithothermodels (Gibson & Schkade, 1997; Jackson & Schkade, 2001; Johnson&Schkade,2001). TheCOPMisasemistructuredinterviewinwhichthe patientreportsperformancesofconcernintheareasofself-care, productivity, and leisure. Once problems are specified, the patientisthenaskedtoratehisorherperceivedabilityofperformanceandsatisfactionwithperformance.thetoolmaybe usedtoaidintreatmentplanningandreassessmentandhas beenfoundtobeavalidandreliablemeasurementtoolina varietyofsettings(carswelletal.,2004;watterson,lowrie, Vockins,Ewer-Smith,&Cooper,2004). Implementing the OA Approach TheCOPMwasadministeredtoSusantoinitiatetheshift fromabiomechanicalapproachtothemoreholistic,clientcenteredoaapproach.becausesusanwasexceedinglylimitedinherabilitiestoperformanytasks,thecopmwas usedasabaselinetogainherinputonwhichoccupational taskswereofmostconcerntoher.susanidentifiedthedesire tobeabletosupinate,specifically toturndoorknobsorget changefrommypurse. Shealsoidentifiedthedesirefor functionalpinch, soicangetmyowntoothpasteoutor squeezeaketchuppacket. Shevoicedthedesiretoholda bookandcupaswellassafelymanipulatehercarwindow controls.onalikertscalerangingfrom1to10,shewas askedtoratehercurrentlevelofperformanceandherown The American Journal of Occupational Therapy 85

satisfaction with that performance(see Table 2). Susan s averaged scores were calculated by adding the number of performanceorsatisfactionscoresanddividingby5,which representedthenumberofproblemsidentified.forexample, Susan saverageperformancescorewas16(16/5=3.2).as seenbytheseratings,all<5(midrange),susan sperceptions ofherlevelofperformance(3.2)andsatisfactionwithher performance(2.2)wereverylow. Susanattendedsixofeightadditionalscheduledtreatmentsessions;eachsessionaddressedtheactivitiesthatshe hadidentifiedasimportanttoheronthecopm.thetreatmentapproachfocusedonperformanceoffunctionalactivities and included compensatory techniques and adaptive equipmentforalternativesolutions(seetable1).through collaborationandproblemsolving,eachissuewasaddressed functionallyandinthecontextofperformance.forexample, twoactivitiesthatsusanverbalizedthedesiretoaccomplish weretoopendoorsindependentlyandtoreceiveherloose changefromstoreclerksinherhand.shewasunhappyhavingtoaskstoreclerksto tossthechangeinmypursebecause Ican tholditinmyhand. Fromabiomechanicalperspective,thiswasalackofsupinationandhandclosure.Usingthe OAapproachanddeeperinvestigationintotheclient soccupationalperformanceandmasteryofheractivities,thisdesire wasfoundtostemfromtheneedtomasterherenvironment, toexperienceefficiencyandeffectivenessinherperformances, andtoperformsatisfactorilyforherselfandintheeyesof others.useofdycemandexternalrotationattheshoulder provided successful adaptation to manipulate door knobs. Theuseofherdebitcardeliminatedthemajorityofsituations whereshereceivedloosechange.shewasabletomaintain grasponstandardpensandprovideasignaturewithoutdifficulty.hercarwindowcontrolswereadaptedwiththermoplasticmaterialtoprovidealevershecouldmanipulatewith increasedeaseandsafetyperdemonstration. Althoughthesamebiomechanicalconceptswerefollowed toaddresstheunderlyingromdeficits,theemphasisshifted tofacilitatingsusan sexperienceofimprovementinherown occupationalperformance.sheverbalizedinthesetreatments herexcitementoverthefunctionalsolutionscatalogfilledwith theoptionsforadaptivetechniques.althoughshestillverbalizeddisappointmentoverthemobilitylostatherwristand poor recovery of her index finger, she stated that she was attemptingmoreoccupationaltasksthanshehadbefore. On reassessment, the COPM demonstrated that the OA-facilitatedinterventionmadeperformance-basedchanges thatresultedinimprovementsonthecopm(seetable2). Susanratedhersatisfactionwithherperformanceandher abilitytoperformfunctionalactivitiessuchasmanipulating doorknobs,holdingabook,manipulatingcarwindowcontrols,andgraspingacup.heroverallperceptionofthesefive functionaltasksincreasedfroma3.2toa5of10,andher satisfactionlevelofherownperformanceincreasedfroma 2.2toa4.8of10.Althoughthesenumbersstillappearrelatively low, Carswell et al.(2004) identified that, on the COPM, a changed score of 2 points, when comparing baselineandreassessment,isclinicallysignificant. IncomplicatedsurgicalcasessuchasSusan s,thebiomechanical model and intervention tools are valuable. However, combining the biomechanical approach with client-centered,holistictreatmentisdifficult,especiallyfor hand therapists working within the current conditions of managedcareandcostcontainment(daleetal.,2002).this sentimentcouldbeexpressedbypractitionersinmanypracticesettings.however,itiseasiertoidentifythepresenceof this ever-pressing challenge than it is to address it. Documentingprogressthroughbiomechanicalgoals,inthis casereport,notedminimalgains,discouragedtheclient,and failedtodemonstratefunctionalgainsimportanttotheclient.ashifttoaclient-centered,occupation-basedapproach facilitatedtheclient sadaptation,improvedhermotivation andoutlook,andprovideddocumentationoftheclinically significantfunctionalprogressattained. Discussion Thiscasereportofapatientwhoreceivedhandtherapyinan orthopedicoutpatientclinicaftersurgerytocorrectjointdeformitiessecondarytolupus-relatedarthritisillustratesthatashift inframesofreferencefromabiomechanicalapproachtoan Table 2. Susan s Initial and Reassessment Scores on the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure Identified Task Initial Performance Initial Satisfaction Reassessed Performance Reassessed Satisfaction Supination 3 3 4 4 Functional pinch 1 1 1 1 Holding a book 4 4 6 6 Manipulating window controls 7 2 9 10 Static grasp of cup 1 1 5 3 Total score 3.2/10 2.2/10 5/10 4.8/10 86 January/February 2010, Volume 64, Number 1

OAapproachfacilitatedadaptation,improvedmotivation,and provided documentation of clinically significant functional progress.initialevaluationandtreatmentwerebasedonthe biomechanical approach. The patient became discouraged, andhermotivationdecreasedwithcontinueddocumentation ofonlyminimalgainsontraditionalbiomechanicalmeasures. Shestatedthatheroccupationalperformancegainsweremuch more significant than what the biomechanical measures showed.weshiftedtoamoreclient-centeredapproach the OAmodel andusedthecopmtodocumentthepatient s primaryoccupationalrolesandimportantoccupationalperformancesandobtainclient-ratedobjectivemeasurementsof hercurrentlevelsofperformance. Withtheshiftintreatmentapproach,thefocusturned towardperformanceoffunctionalactivitiesthatthepatient identifiedasimportanttoheronthecopmandincluded compensatorytechniquesandadaptiveequipmentforalternative solutions to increase independent performance of occupationalactivities.throughcollaborativeproblemsolving,eachissuewasaddressedfunctionallyandinthecontext ofperformance.onreassessment,thecopmdemonstrated that the OA-facilitated intervention made performancebasedchangesthatresultedinimprovementsonthecopm. IncomplicatedhandtherapysurgicalcasessuchasSusan s, thebiomechanicalmodelandinterventiontoolsarevaluable; however,combiningthebiomechanicalapproachwithoa allowedamoreclient-centered,holisticapproachthatfacilitatedtheclient sadaptation,improvedhermotivationand outlook,andprovideddocumentationoftheclinicallysignificantfunctionalprogressattained. Therapistsinotherhandtherapysettingsmayfindthat inclusionoftheoaframework(schkade&schultz,1992; Schultz&Schkade,1992)providesabasisforpatientcare thataddressestheneedforamoreclient-centered,holistic, occupation-basedapproach.patientownershipoftreatment goals and progress is increased through collaborative goal settinganddevelopmentofapositiveclient therapistrelationship that facilitates the patient s adaptation. The Occupational Adaptation Guides to Practice (Schultz & Schkade,1992)provideguidancetotherapistswhowantto incorporateoaintotheirtreatmentapproach.theguides describethetherapeuticapproachfromthedatagathering (initial assessment) stage through treatment and reassessment.providingoccupationaltherapyservicesundertheoa framework can be both an art and a skill executed with methodandprecisionwhileprovidingthecollaborativecare demanded by this generation of consumers (Schultz & Schkade,1992). Themechanicalexpertiseandskillofoccupationaltherapistspracticinginahandtherapysettingisvitalforskilled patientcare;however,improvedpatientoutcomesmaybe facilitatedbysupplementingbiomechanicalexpertisewitha moreholistic,client-centered,occupation-basedapproach. Althoughtheinvestmentoftimeandselfappearsincongruentwithtoday shealthcaresystem,bridgingthisincongruenceisachallengethattherapistsmayneedtoassumetobest meetpatientneeds.yetexamplesofhowtoaccomplishthis shiftintreatmentperspectiveshaveyettobepublished.this casereportprovidesanovelexampleofhowtoincorporate theoaframeworktoshiftfromamechanistic,strictlybiomechanical hand therapy approach to a client-centered, occupation-based,holisticapproach. s References Carswell,A.,McColl,M.,Baptiste,S.,Law,M.,Polatajko,H.,& Pollock,N.(2004).TheCanadianOccupationalPerformance Measure:Aresearchandclinicalliteraturereview.Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy,71,210 222. Chan,J.,&Spencer,J.(2004).Adaptationtohandinjury:An evolvingexperience.american Journal of Occupational Therapy, 58,128 139. Dale,L.,Fabrizio,A.,Adhlakha,P.,Mahon,M.,McGraw,E., Neyenhaus,R.,etal.(2002).Occupationaltherapistsworking inhandtherapy:thepracticeofholisminacostcontainment environment.work, 19,35 45. Dolecheck,J.,&Schkade,J.(1999).Theextentdynamicstanding enduranceiseffectedwhencvasubjectsperformedpersonallymeaningfulactivitiesratherthannonmeaningfultasks. OTJR: Occupation, Participation and Health, 19, 41 54. Gibson,J.,&Schkade,J.(1997).Occupationaladaptationinterventionwithpatientswithcerebrovascularaccident:Aclinicalstudy. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 51,523 529. Jackson,J.,&Schkade,J.(2001).Occupationaladaptationmodel versus biomechanical-rehabilitation model in treatment of patientswithhipfractures.american Journal of Occupational Therapy, 55,531 537. Johnson,J.,&Schkade,J.(2001).Effectsofanoccupation-based interventiononmobilityproblemsfollowingacerebralvascularaccident.journal of Applied Gerontology,20,91 109. Law,M.,Baptiste,S.,Carswell,A.,McColl,M.A.,Polatajko,H., &Pollock,N.(1999).Canadian Occupational Performance Measure.Ontario,Canada:CAOTPublications. Peloquin,S.(1990).Thepatient therapistrelationshipinoccupationaltherapy:understandingvisionsandimages. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 44,13 21. Peloquin, S.(1993). The patient therapist relationship: Beliefs thatshapecare.american Journal of Occupational Therapy, 47,935 942. Schkade, J., & Schultz, S. (1992). Occupational adaptation: Towardaholisticapproachforcontemporarypractice,part I.American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 46,829 837. Schultz, S., & Schkade, J. (1992). Occupational adaptation: Towardaholisticapproachforcontemporarypractice,part II.American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 46,917 925. Watterson,J.,Lowrie,D.,Vockins,H.,Ewer-Smith,C.,&Cooper,J.(2004).Rehabilitationgoalsidentifiedbyinpatients withcancerusingthecopm.international Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation,11,219 224. The American Journal of Occupational Therapy 87