ARTICLE. Outcome of Children Identified as Anemic by Routine Screening in an Inner-city Clinic

Similar documents
Topic owner: Mollie Grow MD MPH, updated June 2018

Effectiveness of zinc protoporphyrin/heme ratio for screening iron deficiency in preschool-aged children

Screening for Iron Deficiency Ann Chen Wu, Leann Lesperance and Henry Bernstein. DOI: /pir

ARTICLE. Iron Depletion Is Associated With Daytime Bottle-feeding in the Second and Third Years of Life

IRON DEFICIENCY IS THE MOST COMmon

Assessing Iron Deficiency in Adults. Chris Theberge. Iron (Fe) deficiency remains as one of the major global public health problems for

Tools & Techniques for Using the Bright Futures Periodicity Schedule in Infancy & Early Childhood

PEDIATRIC PREVENTIVE HEALTH GUIDELINES

Archives of Clinical and Biomedical Research

Potential Use of a Causal Bayesian Network to Support Both Clinical and Pathophysiology Tutoring in an Intelligent Tutoring System for Anemias

Progress in the Control of Childhood Obesity

Guideline developed by Shelley Crary, MD, MS,* in collaboration with the ANGELS team. Last reviewed by Shelley Crary, MD, MS, January 19, 2017.

Key words: social marketing, iron-folic acid, socioeconomic INTRODUCTION

201 Low Hematocrit/Low Hemoglobin

Approach to the child with anemia. Nittaya Wisanuyothin,MD. Pediatrics Department, Maharat Nakhonratchasima Hospital

Via Electronic Submission to: February 19, 2010.

Research Article Schoolchildren with Learning Difficulties Have Low Iron Status and High Anemia Prevalence

A SherriV, A Emond, J C Bell, J Golding, and the ALSPAC Study Team

RACIAL DIFFERENCES IN THE OUTCOME OF LEFT VENTRICULAR DYSFUNCTION RACIAL DIFFERENCES IN THE OUTCOME OF LEFT VENTRICULAR DYSFUNCTION

The assessment of nutritional and growth

6.1 Extended family screening

Thalassemia and other hemoglobinopathies among anemic individuals in Metro Manila: Preliminary findings from the National Nutrition Survey

Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnosis and Treatment (EPSDT)

Diagnosis of anemia and iron deficiency: analytic and biological variations of laboratory tests13

BECAUSE OF THE HARM OF

SUPPLEMENT ARTICLE METHODS

Maternal and Infant Nutrition Briefs

Measures of Malnutrition

PEDIATRIC HEMATOLOGY/ONCOLOGY ROTATION

Changes in Automated Complete Blood Cell Count and Differential Leukocyte Count Results Induced by Storage of Blood at Room Temperature

Research Article Effects of Iron Deficiency on Cognitive Function in School Going Adolescent Females in Rural Area of Central India

Summary of Recommendation Statements Kidney International Supplements (2012) 2, ; doi: /kisup

BONE MARROW PERIPHERAL BLOOD Erythrocyte

PNEUMOCOCCAL DISEASE IS AN

Running head: EARLY IMPLEMENTATION OF CAPSULE ENDOSCOPY Chambers 1. A Cost-Benefit Analysis. Winde R. Chambers. Texas Woman's University

MARYLAND DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT

HEALTH CARE EXPENDITURES ASSOCIATED WITH PERSISTENT EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT USE: A MULTI-STATE ANALYSIS OF MEDICAID BENEFICIARIES

Update on Tuberculosis Skin Testing of Children

NEWBORN SCREENING FOR SICKLE CELL DISEASE Progress Towards Improved Outcomes for Children and Families

Changes to CBC Reference Ranges

IRON DEFICIENCY IN ADOLESCENTS

university Center for excellence in DeveLoPMentaL DisaBiLities, education, research, and services (se habla español)

Predictors of Severity of Alcohol Withdrawal in Hospitalized Patients

Diagnostic Approach to Patients with Anemia

1. Adequate diet and iron intake to prevent iron deficiency 2. Signs and symptoms of malignant disease

Centocor Ortho Biotech Services, LLC

Systematic review of the non- specific effects of BCG, DTP and measles containing vaccines

International Journal of Health Sciences and Research ISSN:

List of abbreviations Introduction Aims of the study Materials and Methods Results and Discussion Conclusions...

Haemoglobin and ferritin concentrations in children aged 12 and 18 months

Relationship between hemoglobin concentration and transferrin saturation in iron-sufficient 2

Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnosis and Treatment (EPSDT)

New York State Department of Health Center for Environmental Health

2007 ACIP Recommendations for Influenza Vaccine. Anthony Fiore, MD, MPH Influenza Division, NCIRD, CDC

The prevalence of obesity has increased markedly in

mean hemoglobin 11 g/dl (110 g/l) compared to patients with lower mean hemoglobin values (Table 20).

Emilia Parodi, 1 Maria Teresa Giraudo, 2 Fulvio Ricceri, 3 Maria Luigia Aurucci, 4 Raffaela Mazzone, 5 and Ugo Ramenghi 4. 1.

Increasing Rates of Influenza Vaccination During Pregnancy: A Multisite Interventional Study

HHS Public Access Author manuscript Eur J Pediatr. Author manuscript; available in PMC 2015 December 03.

Research Article Biological Sciences

Youth Entering Detention Incarcerated youth are more likely to be from low socioeconomic status families who have inadequate access to health care. De

Amy L Frith-Terhune, Mary E Cogswell, Laura Kettel Khan, Julie C Will, and Usha Ramakrishnan

Preventive Strategy to Control Iron Deficiency Anemia in Children and Adults

RESULTS OF A STUDY ON IMMUNIZATION PERFORMANCE

Parental Opinions of Anti-Tobacco Messages within a Pediatric Dental Office

Nutrition News for Africa October

Hematology/Oncology/BMT

Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnosis and Treatment (EPSDT)

Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnosis and Treatment (EPSDT)

Dr B Lal Clinical Laboratory Pvt Ltd. Jaipur, Rajasthan, India

Iron status in a group of Norwegian children aged 6 24 months

Original Article. Emergency Department Evaluation of Ventricular Shunt Malfunction. Is the Shunt Series Really Necessary? Raymond Pitetti, MD, MPH

Effective Health Care Program

Clinical Practice Guideline for Preventive Health Care - Pediatrics

Blue Cross of California Preventive Screening and Immunizations Recommendations for Healthy Children, Adolescents, Adults, Seniors and Pregnancy 2005

Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnosis and Treatment (EPSDT)

Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnostic and Treatment (EPSDT) Billing Guide

Approximately 20,000 influenza-associated deaths occurred

ARTICLE. Access of Over-the-counter Nicotine Replacement Therapy Products to Minors

EPI Case Study 2: Reliability, Validity, and Tests of Agreement in M. Tuberculosis Screening Time to Complete Exercise: 30 minutes

Osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) and other

Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnostic and Treatment (EPSDT) Billing Guide

COFM Immunization Policy 2016

ESM Table 2 Data extraction form and key data from included studies

GSK Medicine: Study Number: Title: Rationale: Study Period: Objectives: Indication: Study Investigators/Centers: Data Source:

The National Asthma Education and Prevention Program s

S Congenital Heart Futures Act (Introduced in Senate - IS) 111th CONGRESS 1st Session S. 621 IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES.

H Harahap 1, AB Jahari 1, MA Husaini 1, C Saco-Pollitt 2 and E Pollitt 3 *

The McMaster at night Pediatric Curriculum

The Effect of Transition Clinics on Knowledge of Diagnosis and Perception of Risk in Young Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer

DIETARY RISK ASSESSMENT IN THE WIC PROGRAM

Improving Influenza Vaccination Rates in Pregnant Women

April 18, Dear Mr. Blum and Dr. Conway:

1 Department of Family Medicine 2 Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health

RAPID REFERRAL ANEMIA CLINICS

Microcytic Hypochromic Anemia An Approach to Diagnosis

An Evaluation of Immunization Education Resources by Family Medicine Residency Directors

Diarrhea is well known to be a leading cause of. Oral Rehydration Therapy for Diarrhea: An Example of Reverse Transfer of Technology

Performance Analysis:

THE PREVALENCE OF OVERweight

Transcription:

ARTICLE Outcome of Children Identified as Anemic by Routine Screening in an Inner-city Clinic Debra L. Bogen, MD; Jennifer P. Krause, MD; Janet R. Serwint, MD Background: Children found to be anemic on routine screening by HemoCue, a rapid and relatively inexpensive method of screening for hemoglobin (Hb), are often prescribed iron as a diagnostic tool and potential treatment for presumed iron deficiency anemia (IDA). We questioned this approach given the declining prevalence of IDA and the concomitant relative increase in other causes of anemia. Objective: To evaluate the practice of Hb screening for IDA by determining the prevalence of anemia by HemoCue; the proportion of anemic patients treated with iron and followed up; the frequency of repeated Hb testing, additional iron studies, and iron prescriptions; and the 6-month outcomes of treated and untreated anemia. Design: Retrospective cohort study. Results: Of 1358 children aged 9 to 36 months who underwent screening, 343 (25%) had anemia, defined as a Hb level of less than 110 g/l. Outpatient medical records of 334 of the anemic children revealed that 239 (72%) were prescribed iron while 95 (28%) were not prescribed iron at the first visit for anemia. Anemia follow-up rates were low for the prescribed and not prescribed groups: 7% vs 5% returned within 1 month, while 37% vs 42% did not return within 6 months for followup. Of the children who were prescribed iron, 107 (71%) of 150 responded to treatment or anemia resolved within 6 months compared with 27 (68%) of 40 not prescribed iron. Children underwent repeated blood testing for measurement of Hb and complete blood cell count, but underwent few iron-specific studies. Conclusions: Routine screening for IDA by HemoCue followed by a therapeutic trial of iron was problematic because of a high rate of anemia in this predominantly African American population, low follow-up rates, and a high spontaneous resolution rate. Prospective studies are needed to evaluate other screening methods to differentiate IDA from other forms of anemia and to improve compliance and outcome in inner-city children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2001;155:366-371 From the Department of Pediatrics, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Md. Dr Bogen is now affiliated with the Department of Pediatrics, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pa, and Dr Krause is now with Children s Hospital of Denver, Denver, Colo. THE ADVERSE effects of iron deficiency anemia (IDA) on growth and development provide the rationale to screen all children for this nutritional deficiency. 1-5 The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that high-risk children be routinely screened for IDA by hemoglobin (Hb) level or hematocrit at the age of 9 to 12 months and again 6 months later. 6 However, the Hb level and the hematocrit are measures of anemia but do not provide information about the cause of anemia. In addition to IDA, anemia may be commonly present because of thalassemia traits, chronic diseases, or recent infections. 7,8 Many outpatient clinics and Women, Infants, and Children program facilities screen for anemia by HemoCue (HemoCue Inc, Mission Viejo, Calif). This rapid and relatively inexpensive method of screening for Hb is, under certain conditions, a reliable screening method when compared with the Coulter counter determination of Hb. 9-13 Response to iron therapy is a valid indication of IDA. A common practice is to assume all anemia detected on routine screening represents IDA, to treat it with 1 month of iron therapy, and to measure the response. An increase of 10 g/l of Hb is considered diagnostic of IDA. 6,14,15 For editorial comment see page 332 There are several limitations to screening for IDA followed by treatment with iron for all patients with a positive screening test result. It requires at least one timely follow-up visit to the health care provider and a second blood test. Furthermore, as the prevalence of IDA decreases, 16-19 the positive predictive value of Hb level for IDA decreases and other common causes of anemia become more likely. Prior experiences in our pediatric resident continuity clinic led us to ques- 366

MATERIALS AND METHODS This retrospective cohort study using medical record review was conducted in a hospital-based inner-city pediatric resident continuity clinic in Baltimore, Md. The clinic staff included pediatric residents, attending physicians, general academic pediatric fellows, and 1.5 full-time equivalent pediatric nurse practitioners. Patients who attended the clinic were assigned to a single primary care provider who provided 85% to 90% of their health maintenance care. A yearly didactic session on anemia was attended by the residents, and suggested that screening be performed according to the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended guidelines; that anemia be defined as a Hb level of less than 110 g/l; and that anemia be treated with iron, as recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics and other sources. 6,14,15 The hospital laboratory billing system was used to identify all children aged 9 to 36 months who underwent HemoCue tests performed in the clinic from March 1, 1995, to February 28, 1997. This age group was targeted because the clinic followed the then current American Academy of Pediatrics recommended guidelines for screening children for anemia, at the age of 9 to 12 months and again at the age of 2 to 5 years. 20 All Hb values were obtained from the electronic patient record. Children with more than one Hb screening during the study period were counted only once. The sample population was divided into the anemic group, children with at least one Hb value of less than 110 g/l, and the nonanemic group, children with all Hb values of 110 g/l or greater. For children in the anemic group, the child s first visit with a Hb level of less than 110 g/l was considered the index visit, and subsequent additional HemoCue results were considered follow-up data. A standard data collection form designed for this project was used to review the outpatient medical records of all children identified as anemic for 6 months from the index visit. Abstracted information included demographic data, medical history, laboratory test results, visit dates, iron therapy, and recommended follow-up. Medical history information included newborn Hb electrophoresis results if available, a previous diagnosis of hemoglobinopathy, the number of medical record documented illnesses and hospitalizations for the 3 months before the index visit, and previous diagnosis and treatment of anemia. Because iron therapy before the index visit might represent variable degrees of treatment, the duration of and response to the iron therapy before the index visit were evaluated. The results of any anemia-related laboratory tests obtained at the discretion of the primary care provider were recorded, including HemoCue Hb level, Hb level from the complete blood count (CBC), mean corpuscular volume (MCV), red cell distribution width (RDW), reticulocyte count, lead level, serum iron level, serum ferritin level, transferrin level, total iron binding capacity, Hb electrophoresis, and sickle cell screen. Follow-up visits included all visits during which anemia was subsequently addressed, such as well-child care, acute care, follow-up, and Women, Infants, and Children program form completion; however, emergency department visits were not included. Physician-recommended time to follow-up and actual patient follow-up times were recorded. The status of anemia during the 6 months following the index visit was determined for each child using the following definitions: resolved if the highest follow-up Hb level was 110 g/l or greater, and responded if the highest follow-up Hb increased by 10 g/l from the index visit Hb level but remained less than 110 g/l. Outcomes for children treated with iron were classified into 3 categories: prescribed, resolved, prescribed, responded, and prescribed, did not respond or resolve. Outcomes for children not treated with iron were not prescribed, resolved and not prescribed, did not resolve. Other outcomes were no anemia follow-up after index visit and inadequate information to determine. Once anemia resolved, subsequent follow-up data were not considered for the 6-month outcome determination. Follow-up and outcome were analyzed by Hb level (106-109 and 106 g/l) to determine if more significant anemia is addressed more vigilantly. These Hb levels were selected because the sample was largely African American and the Institute of Medicine has advocated using 4-g/L lower Hb standards for this population. 14 Statistical analysis was performed using a computer program (SPSS 9.0 [Windows version]; SPSS Inc, Chicago, Ill). A t test was used to compare means, and 2 and Fisher exact tests were used to compare nominal data. Bonferroni correction was used to correct for multiple comparisons. Statistical significance was set at.05. The institutional review board approved this project. tion whether this screening method was effective in a mostly African American patient population, with its high rate of thalassemia trait, high burden of acute and chronic illness, high Women, Infants, and Children program participation, and declining rate of IDA. We are not aware of any studies looking at the outcomes of children identified as anemic by Hb screening in an inner-city pediatric population. The goal of this project was to evaluate the clinical practice of anemia screening followed by a therapeutic trial of iron by describing the following: (1) the prevalence of anemia using HemoCue; (2) the proportion of cases in which patients with positive Hb screening results were treated with a therapeutic trial of iron and appropriately followed up; (3) the frequency with which repeated Hb testing was performed, additional courses of iron were prescribed, and specific iron studies were obtained; and (4) the 6-month outcome of treated and untreated cases of known anemia. RESULTS During the 2-year study period, 1358 children aged 9 to 36 months were screened one or more times for anemia by HemoCue. One quarter of the children had at least one Hb value less than 110 g/l and were identified as being anemic. Nine anemic children were excluded, based on medical history, from further analysis, 6 with sickle cell anemia and 3 who were treated for lead poisoning with succimer under a study protocol in which iron therapy was contraindicated. The remaining 334 chil- 367

239 (72%) Were at the Index Visit 150 (63%) Underwent Anemia Follow-up Within 6 mo Hb Level of < 110 g/l (n=343) Anemic (25%) 1358 Children Were Screened With 1 HemoCue Test During the Study Period 334 Included 9 Excluded 15 (27%) Were at a Later Visit 95 (28%) Were Not at the Index Visit 55 (58%) Underwent Anemia Follow-up Within 6 mo 40 (73%) Were Not at a Later Visit Hb Level of 110 g/l (n=1015) Not Anemic (75%) Study flow diagram. A detailed description of the 9 children who were excluded is given in the Results section of the text. Hb indicates hemoglobin. HemoCue (HemoCue Inc, Mission Viejo, Calif) is a rapid and relatively inexpensive Hb screening method. Table 1. Comparison of Anemic Groups: Prescribed vs Not at the Index Visit* Characteristic (n = 239) Not Prescribed Iron (n = 95) P Male sex 57 58.92 African American 95 94.64 Medicaid insurance 73 77.45 Age, mo Mean (SD) 19.4 (7.7) 19.8 (6.9).06 9-12 30 22 13-18 24 30 19-24 21 23.46 25-36 24 24 Hemoglobin level, g/l Mean (SD) 104 (5) 106 (3).001 106-109 46 66 100-105 38 30.001 100 16 3 Lead at index visit Yes 88 87.73 Mean (SD), µmol/l 0.33 (0.23) 0.35 (0.23).66 Illness in 3 mo before 21 15.20 the index visit: 1 Prescribed iron before the index visit 20 16.41 *Data are given as the percentage of each group unless otherwise indicated. All values obtained by 2 analysis unless otherwise indicated. ttest. 2 Linear trend analysis. To convert lead from micromoles per liter to micrograms per deciliter, divide micromoles per liter by 0.0483. dren constitute the anemic group for the remainder of the analysis (Figure). Children with a Hb value of less than 110 g/l at the index visit were categorized into 2 groups based on whether they were prescribed iron at the index visit. The groups were not significantly different for age, sex, race, and insurance status (Table 1). The rates of sickle cell trait, previous treatment with iron, serum lead levels, and number of illnesses and hospitalizations in the 3 months before the index visit were also not significantly different. Seventy-two percent of children with a Hb value of less than 110 g/l were prescribed iron at the index visit; 15 more children had iron prescribed at a follow-up visit. About half of the children had mild anemia, with Hb levels ranging from 106 to 109 g/l. Children who were prescribed iron had a lower mean Hb level, and thus more severe anemia, than were those not prescribed iron (104 vs 106 g/l; P.001); nevertheless, 33% of children who were not prescribed iron had a Hb level of less than 106 g/l at the index visit (Table 1). Health care provider documentation of the need to return for follow-up was significantly more likely if iron was prescribed, regardless of Hb level. However, only 44% of the patients who were prescribed iron and who had a medical record documented recommended time for a return visit were asked to return in 1 month. Patient follow-up rates for the prescribed and not prescribed groups were not significantly different. Within each group, follow-up rates did not vary significantly by level of anemia. Most notably, only 7% of patients who were prescribed iron, regardless of Hb level, and 3% with a Hb level between 106 and 109 g/l and 9% with a Hb level of less than 106 g/l who were not prescribed iron returned for follow-up within 1 month of diagnosis (Table 2). The following outcome results include only children who received anemia follow-up care within 6 months of the index visit: 150 (64%) of 234 children from the prescribed group and 55 (58%) of 95 from the not prescribed group. Outcomes are reported by Hb level (106-109 and 106 g/l, respectively). Of the prescribed group, 77% and 67% responded or resolved the anemia and 21% and 27% did not respond or resolve the anemia, respectively. Fifteen of 55 children in the not prescribed group were subsequently prescribed iron at a follow-up visit. Of these, 44% and 83% responded or resolved the anemia, respectively. However, 84% and 40%, respectively, of children not prescribed iron also resolved the anemia without treatment (Table 3). The 38 children in the prescribed group with a Hb level of less than 100 g/l warrant special attention because of the severity of the anemia. Only 3 (8%) returned for follow-up within 1 month, and 15 (39%) did not return for follow-up within 6 months, about the same rates as those with more mild anemia. Of the 23 who returned for follow-up within 6 months, 4 (17%) responded to iron therapy with a greater than 10-g/L increase in Hb, 10 (43%) resolved the anemia with iron therapy, 8 (35%) did not respond to iron therapy, and 1 (4%) had inadequate information to determine an outcome (percentages may not total 100 because of rounding). In the 6-month follow-up period, children who received follow-up care were subjected to repeated testing; 19% of children who were prescribed iron and 20% who were not prescribed iron underwent 3 or more HemoCue screens, while 14% vs 9% in each group underwent at least 2 more CBCs. Despite the repeated Hb testing, iron-specific studies were infrequently performed, including only 8 children undergoing serum fer- 368

Table 2. Anemia Follow-up by Status and Hemoglobin (Hb) Level at the Index Visit* Not Follow-up Hb Level of 106-109 g/l (n = 110) Hb Level of 106 g/l (n = 129) Hb Level of 106-109 g/l (n = 63) Hb Level of 106 g/l (n = 32) Provider-documented recommended follow-up Yes, mo 1 27 (25) 45 (35) 6 (10) 1 (3) 2-3 41 (37) 45 (35) 9 (14) 6 (19) 3 1 (1) 3 (2) 2 (3) 3 (9) No 41 (37) 36 (28) 46 (73) 22 (69) Patient returned for follow-up Yes, mo 1 8 (7) 9 (7) 2 (3) 3 (9) 2-3 34 (31) 41 (32) 15 (24) 9 (28) 4-6 24 (22) 34 (26) 17 (27) 9 (28) No 44 (40) 45 (35) 29 (46) 11 (34) *Data are given as the number (percentage) of children in each group. Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Compared by Hb level within prescribing groups ( 1to 2 months): prescribed, P =.26; not prescribed, P =.20 (Fisher exact test). Compared prescribed with not prescribed: P.001 ( 2 test). Compared by Hb level within prescribing groups: prescribed, P =.90 ( 2 test); not prescribed, P =.78 (Fisher exact test). Compared prescribed with not prescribed: P.52 ( 2 test). Table 3. Anemia Outcome During 6 Months Following the Index Visit* At Index Visit At Subsequent Visit Not During 6-mo Follow-up Hb Level 106 g/l Hb Level 106 g/l Hb Level 106 g/l Hb Level 106 g/l Hb Level 106 g/l Outcomes (n = 66) (n = 84) (n=9) (n=6) (n = 25) Prescribed, responded, 51 (77) 56 (67) 4 (44) 5 (83) 0 0 or resolved Prescribed, did not 14 (21) 23 (27) 4 (44) 1 (17) 0 0 respond or resolve Not prescribed, resolved 0 0 0 0 21 (84) 6 (40) Not prescribed, did not 0 0 0 0 2(8) 8 (53) respond or resolve 1 (2) 5 (6) 1 (11) 0 2 (8) 1 (7) Inadequate information to determine Hb Level 106 g/l (n = 15) *Data are given as the number (percentage) of children in each group. Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Hb indicates hemoglobin. Responded denotes that the follow-up Hb level was 10 g/l or more higher than the index level, but the resulting Hb level was less than 110 g/l; resolved, the follow-up Hb level was 110 g/l or greater. ritin studies, 16 undergoing Hb electrophoresis, and 0 undergoing transferrin or total iron binding capacity studies. Similarly, 28% of children who were prescribed iron at the index visit were prescribed iron at least 3 more times (Table 4). Because of concern that including the 63 children (48 in the prescribed and 15 in the not prescribed group) who had been treated with iron before the index visit in the analysis might skew the results, the analyses were repeated without these children. The mean age of the sample decreased by about 1 month in each group because older children are more likely to have been previously screened and treated for anemia. Otherwise, the demographics of the sample were not significantly different from those presented in Table 1. Follow-up and outcome analyses, compared by prescribed and not prescribed groups but not by Hb level, were not significantly different for this sample compared with the entire study population using 2 analysis. COMMENT In summary, the prevalence of anemia, defined as a Hb level of less than 110 g/l was 25% among these innercity, mostly African American, children screened by HemoCue in our clinic. This figure is remarkably consistent with 1997 Pediatric Nutrition Surveillance System data for African American children (24.6%), 17 which come mostly from Women, Infants, and Children program data. The high rate of anemia could be explained by several factors. HemoCue measurement of Hb often results in slightly lower results when compared with the Coulter counter, particularly if a single drop of capillary blood is used rather than a pooled sample. 13 We were not able 369

Table 4. Proportion of Children Who Underwent Repeated Anemia Testing and Iron Treatment After the Index Visit* Testing and Treatment at the Index Visit (n = 150) Not at the Index Visit (n = 55) HemoCue screens 2 71 (47) 23 (42) 3 29 (19) 11 (20) 2 CBCs 21 (14) 8 (15) 3 HemoCue screens 60 (40) 22 (40) plus CBCs 3 Iron prescriptions 42 (28) 6 (11) Any iron-specific study performed 41 (27) 12 (22) *Data are given as the number (percentage) of each group. P.05 for all comparisons unless otherwise indicated. CBC indicates complete blood cell count. HemoCue (HemoCue Inc, Mission Viejo, Calif) is a rapid and relatively inexpensive hemoglobin screening method. Fifteen children were prescribed iron after the index visit ( P =.05, Bonferroni correction). to identify the method of blood collection for each sample, but children who underwent concomitant lead screening should have had venous sampling performed, which is the clinic policy. Of the 40 children who underwent HemoCue and Coulter counter Hb measurements at the index visit, 75% had a HemoCue Hb result lower than the Coulter counter Hb result. Given that 52% of the sample had a Hb level of 106 to 109 g/l, even a small discrepancy between the HemoCue and Coulter counter Hb values may result in misclassification. Furthermore, African American race is associated with lower Hb values when compared with other races, and at least one study found that children with sickle cell trait have slightly lower Hb levels, controlling for race. 14,21,22 If a Hb cutoff of less than 106 g/l is used for this group, as suggested by the 1993 Institute of Medicine recommendations, only 12% of children would be classified as anemic, which is more consistent with national data across races. 17 It is not possible to determine which children have iron deficiency as the cause of the anemia based on Hb level alone. Because treatment with iron is relatively inexpensive, safe, and effective, it has been widely accepted practice to treat all children with anemia with a trial of iron. 6,14,15 However, the effectiveness of a therapeutic trial of iron is uncertain for at least 3 reasons. First and most striking is that fewer than 10% of children returned for follow-up of their anemia within the recommended time of 1 month. The more time that lapses between treatment and follow-up, the more difficult it is to interpret the normalization of Hb level as a response to the iron or as spontaneous resolution due to resolved infections or dietary improvements. The anemia outcomes in this study must be interpreted with the low 1-month follow-up in mind. Second, the overall rates of anemia response or resolution within 6 months were similar for those who were prescribed iron (107 [71%] of 150) and those who were not prescribed iron (27 [68%] of 40). Children with more severe anemia were less likely to resolve the anemia whether they were prescribed iron or not, except for the children who were prescribed iron at a later visit. This may be due to the small sample of this group. Third, children were subjected to repeated blood testing and iron therapy using this approach to screening, resulting in morbidity from frequent blood testing, increased parental anxiety, possible contributions to vulnerable child syndrome, and increased medical costs. Patients who were prescribed iron and with a medical record documented recommended time to follow-up were not consistently asked to return in 1 month, the recommended practice. Actual anemia follow-up rates were poor. The longer the time between treatment and reevaluation of Hb level, the more difficult it is to evaluate the effect of iron therapy because of uncertainty in compliance with the medication, parental recall, and confounding factors, such as infections and dietary changes. More than a third of children did not receive follow-up for at least 6 months. Difficulty in follow-up has also been cited in the lead screening literature. 23 This issue must be taken into consideration when screening practices are implemented. These data have led us to question the practice of screening with HemoCue and prescribing iron to innercity children identified as anemic. This practice was developed when IDA was by far the most common cause of anemia. This is no longer the case. A prospective study 24 started in the same clinic a few months after this study and using the same definition of anemia found that, despite an anemia rate of 35%, the IDA rate was only 8%. The changing epidemiological features of IDA, poor follow-up rates, repeated testing and treatment, and the high rate of spontaneous resolution of those not treated have led us to consider other approaches. Several alternatives can be considered. One alternative is to screen by ferritin level. This test can detect early iron deficiency but costs about 3 to 4 times more than a Hb or CBC screen and, because it is an acute phase reactant, can be falsely normal because of even mild recent infection. A more practical alternative would be to screen children initially with a CBC because it provides the red blood cell indices, MCV and RDW, to aid in the diagnosis of IDA as the cause of anemia. A low MCV and high RDW can help to differentiate IDA from acute infection, where the MCV and RDW should be normal, and from thalassemia trait, where the MCV should be low and the RDW normal. 25-27 However, CBC results are not usually available before a child leaves the practice site and, therefore, the family must be contacted at a later time. Therefore, having the additional information must be balanced against the challenge of locating patients after discharge. Other possible screening options to consider are the zinc protoporphyrin level or the zinc protoporphyrin heme ratio. 28 Several limitations must be considered. The review of medical records carries the obvious limitations associated with documentation, such as varying levels of detail, legibility, and potential for missing (improperly filed or lost) paper encounter forms. To minimize the latter, visit dates and types and laboratory testing were verified in the electronic patient record. Patients may not have received all their health care at the clinic. Medical care is only provided to patients who choose this clinic for their medical home. Given the high penetration of managed care in the clinic, it is unlikely that anemia would 370

be addressed in the emergency department or at other clinics. It is likely that recent illnesses that were not evaluated by a physician were not recorded in the medical record. However, the rates of medical record documented recent infection were similar between the groups. Given the study design, compliance with iron treatment was not evaluated. The study was performed in a pediatric residency continuity clinic that has physicians at all levels of training, and training level was not identified during the medical record reviews. Although the mostly innercity African American sample may limit the generalizability of the study findings to other ethnic and cultural populations, there are many community health centers and hospital-based clinics that serve similar high-risk populations. In conclusion, HemoCue identified 25% of the children from this inner-city pediatric clinic as anemic, defined as a Hb level of less than 110 g/l. Anemia follow-up rates were low, especially at a month, the ideal time to interpret the effect of iron therapy on Hb level. Irrespective of treatment with iron, about two thirds of children resolved the anemia within 6 months. Children underwent repeated Hb screening and iron treatment, yet few ironspecific studies were obtained. Given the decline in IDA prevalence and the concomitant increase in other causes of anemia, the seriousness of missing cases of true IDA, and the limitations of the approach to screening, we suggest a CBC as a better screening test to delineate causes of anemia. Prospective studies are needed to evaluate the compliance with and outcomes from this and other methods of screening for IDA. Accepted for publication October 30, 2000. This study was supported by grants from the National Research Service Award, Health Resources and Services Administration, Department of Health and Human Services, Rockville, Md (Dr Bogen); and The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Md (Dr Krause). Presented at the 1998 Annual Meeting of the Ambulatory Pediatrics Association, New Orleans, La, May 3, 1998. We thank John Boitnott, MD, The Johns Hopkins University, for creating the laboratory billing system database; the medical records staff of the Harriet Lane Pediatric Clinic for assistance with medical records handling; and Heidi Feldman, PhD, MD, Deborah Moss, MD, MPH, Evelyn Reis, MD, and Kenneth Rogers, MD, for reviewing the manuscript. Deceased. Corresponding author and reprints: Debra L. Bogen, MD, General Academic Pediatrics, Children s Hospital of Pittsburgh, 3705 Fifth Ave, Room G205, Pittsburgh, PA 15213 (e-mail: bogend@chplink.chp.edu). REFERENCES 1. Oski FA, Honig AS, Helu B, Howanitz P. Effects of iron therapy on behavior performance on nonanemic, iron-deficient infants. Pediatrics. 1983;71:877-880. 2. Walter T, DeAndraca I, Chadud P, Perales CG. Iron deficiency anemia: adverse effects on infant psychomotor development. Pediatrics. 1989;84:7-17. 3. Lozoff B, Brittenham GM, Wolf AW. Iron deficiency anemia and iron therapy effects on infant developmental test performance. Pediatrics. 1987;79:981-995. 4. Chwang LC, Soemantri AG, Pollitt E. Iron supplementation and physical growth of rural Indonesian children. Am J Clin Nutr. 1988;47:496-501. 5. Bhatia D, Seshadri S. Growth performance in anemia and following iron supplementation. Indian Pediatr. 1993;30:195-200. 6. American Academy of Pediatrics. Iron deficiency. In: Kleinman R, ed. Pediatric Nutrition Handbook. 4th ed. Elk Grove Village, Ill: American Academy of Pediatrics; 1998:233-246. 7. Reeves JD, Yip R, Kiley VA, Dallman PR. Iron deficiency in infants: the influence of mild antecedent infection. J Pediatr. 1984;105:874-879. 8. Jansson LT, Kling S, Dallman PR. Anemia in children with acute infections seen in a primary care outpatient clinic. Pediatr Infect Dis. 1986;5:424-427. 9. Herzog B, Felton B. Hemoglobin screening for normal newborns. J Perinatol. 1994; 14:285-289. 10. Chen P, Short T, Leung D, Oh T. A clinical evaluation of the HemoCue haemoglobinometer using capillary, venous and arterial samples. Anaesth Intensive Care. 1992;20:497-503. 11. Mills A, Meadows N. Screening for anaemia: evaluation of a haemoglobinometer. Arch Dis Child. 1989;64:1468-1471. 12. Neville R. Evaluation of portable haemoglobinometer in general practice. BMJ. 1987;294:1263-1265. 13. Cohen A, Seidl-Friedman J. HemoCue system for hemoglobin measurement. Am J Clin Pathol. 1988;90:302-305. 14. Earl R, Woteki C. In: Food and Nutrition Board, Institute of Medicine, ed. Iron Deficiency Anemia: Recommended Guidelines for the Prevention, Detection, and Management Among US Children and Women of Childbearing Age. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1993:14, 15, 20. 15. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Recommendations to prevent and control iron deficiency in the United States. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 1998; 47(RR-3):1-29. 16. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Declining anemia prevalence among children enrolled in public nutrition and health programs: selected states, 1975-1985. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 1986;35:565-566. 17. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Pediatrics Nutrition Surveillance, 1997 Full Report. Atlanta, Ga: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, US Dept of Health and Human Services; 1998. 18. Looker AC, Dallman PR, Carroll MD, Gunter EW, Johnson CL. Prevalence of iron deficiency in the United States. JAMA. 1997;277:973-976. 19. Sherry B, Bister D, Yip R. Continuation of decline in prevalence of anemia in lowincome children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1997;151:928-930. 20. American Academy of Pediatrics. Iron deficiency. In: Barness LA, ed. Pediatric Nutrition Handbook. 3rd ed. Elk Grove Village, Ill: American Academy of Pediatrics; 1992:227-236. 21. Johnson-Spear MA, Yip R. Hemoglobin difference between black and white women with comparable iron status: justification for race-specific anemia criteria. Am J Clin Nutr. 1994;60:117-121. 22. Rana SR, Sekhsaria S, Castro OL. Hemoglobin S and C traits: contributing causes for decreased mean hematocrit in African-American children. Pediatrics. 1993; 91:800-802. 23. Block B, Szekely K, Escobar M. Difficulties in evaluating abnormal lead screening results in children. J Am Board Fam Pract. 1996;9:405-410. 24. Bogen DL, Duggan AK, Dover GJ, Wilson MH. Screening for iron deficiency anemia by dietary history in a high-risk population. Pediatrics. 2000;105:1254-1259. 25. Olivares M, Walter T, Osorio M, Chadud P, Schlesinger L. Anemia of a mild viral infection: the measles vaccine as a model. Pediatrics. 1989;84:851-855. 26. Oski FA. Iron deficiency in infancy and childhood. N Engl J Med. 1993;329:190-193. 27. Walters MC, Abelson HT. Interpretation of the complete blood count. Pediatr Clin North Am. 1996;43:599-622. 28. Rettmer RL, Carlson TH, Origenes ML, Jack RM, Labb RF. Zinc protoporphyrin/ heme ratio for diagnosis of preanemic iron deficiency. Pediatrics. 1999;104: e37. 371