Cardiovascular disease is the main cause of morbidity and

Vascular Calcification in Chronic Renal Failure What Have We Learned From Animal Studies? Ellen Neven, Patrick C. D Haese Abstract: Accelerated atherosclerotic plaque calcification and extensive medial calcifications are common and highly detrimental complications of chronic kidney disease. Valid murine models have been developed to investigate both pathologically distinguishable complications, which allow for better insight into the cellular mechanisms underlying these vascular pathologies and evaluation of compounds that might prevent or retard the onset or progression of vascular calcification. This review describes various experimental models that have been used for the study of arterial intimal and/or medial calcification and discusses the extent to which this experimental research has contributed to our current understanding of vascular calcification, particularly in the setting of chronic renal failure. (Circ Res. 2011;108:249-264.) Key Words: animal models vascular calcification chronic renal failure Cardiovascular disease is the main cause of morbidity and mortality in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD), accounting for approximately 50% of all deaths in patients on dialysis and in recipients of renal transplants. 1 A large-scale prospective population-based study showed that renal function was inversely associated with cardiovascular and allcause mortality. 2 Vascular calcification is the major cause of cardiovascular disease in patients with CKD as it contributes to myocardial ischemia, impaired myocardial function, valvular insufficiency, arrhythmias and stroke and is shown to be a strong independent predictor of mortality in the general 3,4 as well as in the dialysis population. 5 7 In patients with endstage renal disease, the risk of death increases with the number of vascular sites affected by calcification in the aorta and the carotid and femoral arteries. 5 The high prevalence of vascular calcification is already reported in early stages of CKD 8,9 and in young dialysis patients. 10,11 Atherosclerotic plaque burden in the intimal layer is higher and these lesions are also more heavily calcified in CKD patients compared to the normal population. 12 14 Although intimal calcification is associated with cardiovascular mortality, 6 it remains controversial whether calcification of advanced atherosclerotic lesions stabilizes plaque vulnerability 15 17 or rather contributes to rupture of the fibrous cap, 18,19 leading to thrombotic events and myocardial infarction. Interestingly, Ehara et al 20 nicely showed that the pattern of calcification in the intimal plaque is of importance: small, frequent, spotty calcifications are more often found in patients with an acute myocardial infarction or with unstable angina pectoris, whereas the presence of extensive calcifications was highest in those with stable angina pectoris. Recent investigations add new insights to this observation and indicate that, in contrast to spacious calcified areas, sparse microcalcifications produce local stress, 21 activate macrophages to secrete inflammatory mediators 22 and induce apoptosis of vascular smooth muscle cells, 23 all factors that make the atherosclerotic plaque vulnerable and prone to rupture. Aside from intimal calcifications, patients experiencing CKD also develop typical calcifications in the medial layer of the vessel wall, independently of local inflammatory processes as seen in atherosclerotic calcification. Medial calcification also contributes to cardiovascular mortality in CKD patients 6 because it causes loss of vessel elasticity, resulting in increased systolic blood pressure and left ventricle hypertrophy which may ultimately lead to arrhythmia and heart failure. 24 Traditional risk factors alone, such as hypertension and dyslipidemia, do not fully account for the high calcification burden in the vasculature of the dialysis population. 25,26 Hyperphosphatemia, caused by a reduced renal phosphate excretion, and an increased calcium phosphate product level are identified as important culprits of accelerated arterial calcification in these patients. 6,10,27 29 The disturbed mineral balance in CKD and the central role of phosphate herein is presented and explained in Figure 1. Moreover, particular therapies used to control phosphate homeostasis have been reported to negatively affect the extent of vessel calcification. Administration of calcium-containing phosphate binders, the most commonly used compounds to treat hyperphosphatemia and secondary hyperparathyroidism, often goes along with an excess calcium load and is found to be Original received August 19, 2010; revision received October 18, 2010; accepted October 19, 2010. In September 2010, the average time from submission to first decision for all original research papers submitted to Circulation Research was 13.1 days. From the Department of Pathophysiology, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium. Correspondence to Patrick C. D Haese, PhD, University of Antwerp, Department of Pathophysiology, building T3, Universiteitsplein 1, 2610 Wilrijk, Belgium. E-mail patrick.dhaese@ua.ac.be 2011 American Heart Association, Inc. Circulation Research is available at http://circres.ahajournals.org DOI: 10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.110.225904 249

250 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 Non-standard Abbreviations and Acronyms apoe APRT CKD CRF DDR FGF Gla HDL LDL LDLR M-CSF OPG PTH RANK VLDL apolipoprotein E adenine phosphoribosyltransferase chronic kidney disease chronic renal failure discoidin domain receptor fibroblast growth factor -carboxyglutamic acid high-density lipoprotein low-density lipoprotein low-density lipoprotein receptor macrophage colony stimulating factor osteoprotegerin parathyroid hormone receptor activator for nuclear factor B very-low-density lipoprotein associated with the progression of vascular calcification, particularly when used in combination with vitamin D. 10,27,30 In addition, several inhibitors of the calcification process are dysregulated in patients with CKD. Matrix Gla protein, fetuin-a, and pyrophosphate, either locally or systemically, prevent the formation of calcium phosphate crystals in the artery. However, plasma concentrations of the inactive uncarboxylated form of matrix Gla protein were markedly increased from CKD stage 4 onward and associated with aortic calcification. 31 In dialysis patients, circulating fetuin- A 32 and pyrophosphate 33 are reduced compared to healthy subjects and are found to be negatively associated with vascular calcification. 34,35 Another important factor one must take into account with regard to the onset and progression of arterial calcification, is the condition of the bone. The disturbed mineral metabolism in patients with CKD leads to renal osteodystrophy. Both high- and low-turnover bone diseases may contribute to the development of vascular calcification. 36 An increased bone turnover provides a continuous supply of calcium and phosphate to the serum, whereas a reduced bone turnover results in an impaired capacity to incorporate these minerals into the bone. The link between the bone status and vascular calcification is also found in patients with osteoporosis: demineralization of the bone is associated with mineralization in the vessel wall. Several decades ago, the prevalence of vascular calcification in dialysis patients was described in autopsy studies. 37,38 The development of new noninvasive imaging techniques such as electron beam computed tomography and ultrasound allowed screening, quantification and follow-up of large study groups for the presence of arterial calcification. However, these techniques are not able to distinguish between intimal and medial calcification. As such, the availability of Figure 1. Disturbed mineral metabolism in CKD patients and the central role of hyperphosphatemia. Renal failure leads to both impaired phosphate excretion and active vitamin D production. Increased serum phosphate levels may induce secretion of phosphaturic hormone FGF23 in osteocytes, which in turn further inhibits active vitamin D production, resulting in decreased intestinal calcium absorption. Low calcium and vitamin D concentrations, together with high phosphate levels, stimulate PTH production in an attempt to normalize calcium and phosphate by increasing renal phosphate excretion and calcium reabsorption. However, as in renal failure, the kidneys are not able to react appropriately, and PTH will recruit calcium from the bone, thereby also releasing phosphate. Hyperphosphatemia persists, creating a vicious cycle. Phosphate binders, vitamin D receptor activators, calcimimetics and bisphosphonates act on different targets within the disturbed mineral metabolism.

Neven and D Haese Uremic Animal Models for Vascular Calcification 251 animal models that develop either calcified atherosclerotic plaques or medial calcification offers the advantage to study both pathological distinct entities separately. Use of Animal Models to Study Vascular Calcification Generally, animal models serve to mimic (patho)physiological states known to occur in humans and are used in basic as well as in applied research. The use of animal models allows us to study in detail the successive stages of a pathological process in function of time and to get new insights in the cellular mechanism and molecular pathways underlying these processes. Laboratory animals are also used for the development and evaluation of new therapeutics. Likewise, the isolated effect of particular drugs on pathological entities can be investigated under standardized conditions without the interference of other therapies that are often prescribed in patients. The most useful, practical, and valid species for the study of cardiovascular disease are small rodents: rats and mice. These species are easy to manipulate and have a short lifespan of 1 to 2 years, which are time- and cost-saving advantages for experimental studies. Moreover, rats and mice resemble humans in metabolism and physiology. The rat and mouse genomes contain about the same number of genes as the human genome. Numerous human genes known to be involved in particular disorders have counterparts in the rat and mouse genome and appear highly conserved through mammalian evolution. To examine the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying the process of vascular calcification, a variety of rat and mouse models have been developed. Gene deletion in mice is a useful technique to unravel the specific role of a particular protein in the development of vascular calcification. This way, the importance of the phosphaturic hormone fibroblast growth factor (FGF) 23 and its necessary cofactor Klotho in the process of vascular calcification have been demonstrated: FGF23 deficient mice 39,40 and mice deficient in Klotho 41 exhibit extensive vascular and soft tissue calcification. Several murine knockout models of genes that regulate bone formation have led to new insights into the pathogenesis of arterial calcification. Matrix Gla protein, 42 osteoprotegerin (OPG), 43 and fetuin A 44 knockout mice display extensive aortic calcifications thereby demonstrating the preventive role of these proteins in the calcification process. Alternatively, to induce vascular calcification in rodents, various stimulants such as vitamin D, 45 nicotine, 46 warfarin 47 or uremic toxins such as indoxyl sulfate 48 have been administered. This review focuses on animal models used to study uremia-related vascular calcification and discusses to what extent the use of these models have contributed to our current knowledge on this vascular pathology. Animal Models of Chronic Renal Failure With Intimal/Medial Calcification A drawback of using rodents for the study of atherosclerotic plaque calcification consists of the high resistance of mice and rats to the development of atherosclerosis, with exception of mice on a C57/BL6 genetic background. 49,50 The lipid profile of rodents significantly differs from humans in that mice and rats carry most of their plasma cholesterol on high-density lipoprotein (HDL), 51 which is known to protect against atherosclerosis, whereas humans carry 75% of their cholesterol on low-density lipoprotein (LDL). The high levels of antiatherosclerotic plasma HDL and low levels of proatherogenic LDL contribute to the resistance to atherosclerosis in rodents. Therefore, the current mouse models are based on interventions in lipoprotein metabolism through genetic and dietary manipulations. Apolipoprotein E Knockout Mice Feeding C57/BL6 mice an atherogenic diet (15% fat, 1.25% cholesterol, and 0.5% cholic acid) results in very small atherosclerotic lesions that are mainly limited to the fatty streak stage. 49 A search for a mouse model that reflects the human pathology covering the entire spectrum of atherosclerotic plaque lesions led to the development of the apolipoprotein (apo)e knockout model. ApoE, a glycoprotein and constituent of all lipoproteins except LDL, serves as a ligand for receptors involved in the clearance of chylomicrons and very low-density lipoproteins (VLDL) remnants from the circulation. Deletion of the apoe gene in mice results in a pronounced increase in plasma VLDL and to a lesser extent in LDL concentrations as well as a 45% reduction of the normal HDL levels leading to the development of atherosclerotic lesions largely confined to the aortic root and the ascending aorta. 52 These lesions resemble their human counterparts and develop over time from early fatty streaks comprised of foam cells and migrating smooth muscle cells over more advanced lesions with a necrotic core and proliferating smooth muscle cells surrounded with a fibrous cap to calcified plaques. 53 The development of more widely distributed and more complex atherosclerotic plaques in the apoe knockout mouse requires a high-fat, high-cholesterol diet. When fed this diet, total plasma cholesterol levels are elevated 3-fold, lesion formation is significantly accelerated and lesion size is increased. 54 Superimposing chronic renal failure (CRF) on the apoe deletion increases the aortic plaque area and markedly accelerates atherosclerosis. 55,56 Sixteen-week-old apoe knockout mice with normal renal function show moderate intimal calcification and only mild medial calcification (6.1 0.03 and 1.0 0.01 area %, respectively). Subtotal nephrectomy (removal of one kidney and partial reduction of the other by electrocautery) enhances aortic calcification at both the intimal plaque sites and the atherosclerosis-free tunica media after 6 weeks (17.8 0.05 and 3.8 0.01 area percentage, respectively). 57 The apoe knockout model combined with induction of renal failure involves the development of atherosclerosis and in particular develops atherosclerotic plaque calcifications at the intima. This model is less suitable to study medial calcification, but provides a useful tool to study the molecular and cellular mechanisms responsible for intimal calcifications associated with CRF and to evaluate new therapeutic strategies for this harmful complication. Low-Density Lipoprotein Receptor Knockout Mice The LDL receptor (LDLR) knockout mouse represents another frequently used model for atherosclerosis. LDLR is a

252 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 cell-surface receptor responsible for the clearance of cholesterol-rich lipoproteins from the circulation through receptormediated endocytosis in hepatocytes. Loss-of-function mutations in the LDLR gene results in familial hypercholesterolemia characterized by dramatically elevated plasma LDL and is a serious risk for the development of atherosclerosis and coronary heart disease. LDLR knockout mice show a modest, doubling of plasma cholesterol, mainly attributable to elevated LDL levels. The extent of atherosclerosis in these animals is minimal, with only small fat deposits in the aorta. 58 However, when fed a 1.25% cholesterol-rich diet, LDLR knockout mice display an 8-fold increase in plasma cholesterol levels and show rapidly developing, large atherosclerotic lesions over the entire length of the aorta. 58 Administration of a high-cholesterol, high-fat diet to LDLR knockout mice leads to a 2-fold increase in aortic calcification and a decreased bone formation rate. 59,60 Vascular calcification in this model is largely associated with atherosclerotic lesions and only punctuate calcifications were observed in the tunica media. 61 Similar to the apoe knockout model, partial ablation of the right kidney followed by left nephrectomy in the high fat fed LDLR knockout model results in a 3-fold increase in aortic calcium content. 59 In addition, superimposing renal failure caused low bone turnover disease as shown by significantly reduced osteoblast number and perimeter, mineralizing surfaces and bone formation rates. 60 Overall, the LDLR knockout mouse represents a more moderate model for atherosclerosis and associated intimal plaque calcification as compared to the apoe knockout mouse, which is mainly attributed to a lower degree of hypercholesterolemia. However, the plasma lipid profile of LDLR knockout mice fed a cholesterol-rich diet resembles more that of humans as the largest proportion of the plasma cholesterol levels consists of LDL, whereas most plasma cholesterol in apoe knockout mice is carried by VLDL. Animal Models of Chronic Renal Failure With Medial Calcification Recently, the first uremic mouse model with isolated medial calcification has been described. 62 Electrocautery of one kidney followed by nephrectomy of the other in calcificationprone DBA/2 mice on a 0.9% high P diet led to widespread medial calcification in the vascular tree after 14 to 15 weeks at levels comparable to those observed in humans, without interference of atherosclerosis and in the absence of inflammation. In agreement with clinical observations, 63,64 the extent of arterial medial calcification shows uremia severity and phosphate dependence and correlation with serum FGF23. Furthermore, uremia increased serum PTH and alkaline phosphatase levels that were similar to changes in CKD patients. 65 When applied in knockout mice, this mouse model opens new opportunities for clarifying the role of molecules in uremia-related medial calcification. Because rats are highly resistant to atherosclerosis, these animals form an appropriate tool to induce and study the process of calcifications in the tunica media without interference of intimal calcifications associated with the inflammatory and lipid involved atherosclerotic process. To examine uremia-related medial calcifications in rats, two CRF models are most commonly used, ie, the remnant kidney model and the adenine model. The remnant kidney model comprises the surgical reduction of the renal mass, whereas in the adenine model, more severe renal impairment is achieved by feeding the rats an adenine-rich diet. Remnant Kidney Rat The remnant kidney or 5/6th nephrectomy rat model reproduces experimental CRF by mimicking the progressive nephron loss that occurs in human CRF. Reduction in renal mass is usually installed by a two-stage surgical procedure: partial nephrectomy of one kidney and total nephrectomy of the contralateral kidney. Partial nephrectomy can be performed with different methods, ie, resection or ligation of the upper and lower poles of the kidney, cauterization or electrocoagulation of the renal cortex and arterial ligation. Arterial ligation, ie, ligation of 2/3 of the extrarenal branches of the renal artery of the kidney, performed on one kidney combined with resection of the other kidney is the most common used 5/6th nephrectomy rat model. 66,67 A mild to moderate degree of CRF is induced with a2to3-fold increase in serum creatinine values. Administration of a high phosphorus diet to remnant kidney rats induces hyperphosphatemia and high parathyroid hormone (PTH) concentrations with the development of secondary hyperparathyroid bone disease, 68 typical hallmarks that occur in CKD patients. The 5/6th nephrectomy rat model is also used to evaluate uremia-related vascular calcifications. Follow-up of 10 weeks of nephrectomized rats fed a standard rodent diet (0.8% P and 1.1% Ca) reveals that no calcification develops in the aorta, 69 except for the aortic arch 70 which is the site most prone for the onset of calcification. Increasing the dietary phosphorus concentration to 0.9% P in 5/6th nephrectomized rats did not induce medial calcifications after a short-term follow-up of 6 to 8 weeks. 71,72 Even after a long-term follow-up of 6 months, only a small increase in aortic calcium content was noted (2.15 mg/g wet tissue in remnant kidney rats versus 0.39 mg/g wet tissue in control rats). 73 Only a high 1.2% phosphorus and a low 0.4% calcium content in the diet to induce severe secondary hyperparathyroidism resulted in severe medial calcification in the abdominal aorta in 5 of 8 nephrectomized rats after a 10-week observation period. 69 To obtain manifest medial calcifications in this uremic rat model, 1,25(OH) 2 vitamin D 3 was administered orally, subcutaneously, or intraperitoneally. 70,71,74 76 As such, an aortic calcium content up to an average 35 mg/g wet tissue was established. 76 Diffuse, massive calcifications of the entire aortic wall, involving both the thoracic and abdominal part, develop in 1,25(OH) 2 vitamin D 3 treated 5/6th nephrectomized rats with a mean calcified area of more than 50%. 74 This rat model for uremia-related arterial calcification shows a reproducible and comparable severe degree of medial calcifications in all rats. Recently, a new remnant kidney model for medial calcification has been generated in which 5/6th nephrectomized rats are fed a high-phosphorus, high-lactose diet (1.2% P, 1% Ca, and 20% lactose). 77 Lactose has been shown to increase calcium and phosphorus absorption in the intestine. 78,79 Se-

Neven and D Haese Uremic Animal Models for Vascular Calcification 253 vere medial calcifications were reported with aortic calcium concentrations of approximately 25 mg/g dry tissue. However, the biological variability and reproducibility of the development of arterial calcification in this animal model could not be deduced from the study report. Another method to induce vascular calcification in subtotally nephrectomized rats is introduced by Neves et al. 80 Parathyroid glands were removed and replaced by a subcutaneously implanted mini-pump that continuously infuses 1 34 rat PTH fragments at a supraphysiological rate. Regardless of the dietary phosphorus content (1.2% versus 0.2%), all remnant kidney rats on PTH replacement developed intense, comparable aortic medial calcifications. This experimental model is interesting to investigate the isolated effect of PTH on cardiovascular calcifications in the setting of CRF. The Cy / Rat With Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease The heterozygous Cy / rat develops polycystic kidney disease and progressive CRF 81,82 attributable to a spontaneous genetic mutation (Cy) encoding for a protein with an unknown function. 83 Persistent azotemia is seen from 10 weeks of age onwards and slowly progresses to uremia around 40 weeks, accompanied by anemia, hypertension, hyperlipidemia and secondary hyperparathyroidism. 81 Recently, Moe et al 84 reported that in this rat model of slowly progressive kidney disease all 3 components of Chronic Kidney Disease - Mineral and Bone Disorder are induced when fed a normal 0.7% phosphorus diet: (1) abnormal serum biochemistries, ie, a significant rise in serum phosphate and PTH between 20 and 38 weeks of age, (2) abnormal bone remodeling, ie, secondary hyperparathyroid bone disease with fibrosis, and increased osteoblasts and osteoclasts, and (3) calcification in the tunica media of the aorta. In this rat model, 60% of the animals developed mild to severe aortic calcifications after 38 weeks of age, although no histological evidence for calcification was found at 34 weeks. The advantage of this rat model for uremia-related vascular calcifications consists of the spontaneous development of hyperphosphatemia, secondary hyperparathyroidism and calcified lesions in the aorta without manipulation of the dietary phosphorus content. The main disadvantage however, particularly for the use of interventional studies, is the slow progression of CRF and as a consequence the late onset of the first calcified spots in the arteries (between 34 to 38 weeks of age) and the limited reproducibility. The Adenine-Induced Chronic Renal Failure Rat More severe chronic renal impairment in the rat is established by the administration of an adenine-rich diet. Normally, adenine is efficiently salvaged by adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) and is present at very low levels in blood and urine. APRT is an ubiquitously expressed enzyme present in all mammalian cells and is involved in the purine nucleotide salvage pathway used to recover bases and nucleosides from RNA and DNA degradation. This enzyme represents the rate-limiting step in the conversion of adenine and 5-phosphoribosyl-1-pyrophosphate to adenosine monophosphate. When adenine is administered in excess, APRT activity is saturated and adenine is oxidized by xanthine dehydrogenase to 2,8 dihydroxyadenine via an 8-hydroxyadenine intermediate. 85 Adenine and 2,8 dihydroxyadenine are excreted in the urine. However, the very low solubility of 2,8 dihydroxyadenine results in its precipitation in the kidney. 86 The autosomal recessive metabolic disorder APRT deficiency represents the human counterpart in which the accumulation of insoluble 2,8 dihydroxyadenine results in nephrolithiasis and renal failure with permanent kidney damage. 87 High-adenine feeding in rats results in the formation of crystals in the renal tubules, with subsequent tubular injury and inflammation, obstruction, and marked fibrosis. 88 This severe kidney damage goes along with biochemical changes characteristic for the presence of CRF, such as significant elevated serum creatinine, blood urea nitrogen, and phosphorus. Okada et al 89 have optimized the adenine-induced CRF model in the rat closely inducing the clinical condition of human CRF so that it has become a useful model for the study of complications of CKD patients. Induction of CRF in rats by dietary administration of 0.75% adenine for 4 weeks results in irreversible renal dysfunction and when maintained on a high phosphorus diet (1.03% P and 1.06% Ca) for the next 4 weeks severe calcifications of the aortic media develop. 90 An aortic calcium content of approximately 20 mg/g dry tissue on average (versus 1.7 mg/g in control animals) was noted, and 8 out of 10 adenine-treated rats showed moderate to severe medial calcifications in the aorta. Renal pathology of the adenine rat model mimics the clinical situation with development of hyperphosphatemia, hypocalcemia, severe secondary hyperparathyroidism characterized by high PTH levels, hypovitaminosis D, and renal osteodystrophy (mainly high bone turnover disease). Over the last 5 years, several research groups made use of the adenine model to evaluate therapeutic agents in the prevention of medial calcification. From these studies, it became clear that up to 50% of the adenine rats are not prone to aortic medial calcification despite the installation of a comparable, stable moderate-to-severe CRF. Although this model reflects the high biological variability with regard to the development of vascular calcifications in humans and is appropriate to study the mechanism of vascular calcifications and the factors involved in this process, it is less suitable to compare the effect of numerous treatment regimens on arterial calcification in the context of CRF. Because only approximately half of CRF animals develop medial calcifications, a group with an unacceptably high amount of animals would be required to investigate and compare with an acceptable statistical power the effect of different therapeutic compounds on the development of vascular calcification. Interestingly, the group of Price 91 introduced a variant on this experimental model by administration of an adenine-rich diet with a low 2.5% protein content to the animals for 4 weeks. This combination resulted in the development of severe, uniform medial calcification in the entire aorta of all rats 4 weeks after the induction of CRF. The consistent onset and progression of aortic medial calcification is most likely caused by the more severe hyperphosphatemia, 92 because in this synthetic diet, less protein-bound phosphate and more

254 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 anorganic phosphate is present, with the latter being much more bioavailable. Another promising alternative was recently explored by Terai et al, 93 dosing rats orally through gavage with adenine for 10 days. Unfortunately, only about one third of the animals presented aortic calcification after 15 weeks. However, subsequent treatment with a low dose of vitamin D 3 (100 ng/kg PO, 3 to 4 times/wk) for 18 days caused vascular calcification in all rats. Both variants on the adenine model represent valuable, improved uremic models for future therapeutic follow-up studies evaluating the prevention and regression of medial calcification by particular compounds. In general, with regard to the comparability with human vascular pathology in the setting of renal disease, minimal requirements should be satisfied on rodent models for uremia-related vascular calcification. First, within each animal model a comparable and stable degree of CRF, established by increased serum creatinine or urea, needs to be induced as well as the concomitant biochemical changes inherent to CKD: (1) hyperphosphatemia, (2) secondary hyperparathyroidism, and (3) hypovitaminosis D. Regardless of the method to induce CRF in mice and rats, either through surgery or through the diet, these biochemical abnormalities are to be met. Taking into account the high incidence of renal osteodystrophy in CKD and being an important determinant for vascular calcification, animal models for CRF should display bone abnormalities similar to those seen in CKD patients. In this context, it is worth mentioning that highturnover bone disease, as observed in most uremic patients, develops in subtotal nephrectomized apoe knockout mice, 94 remnant kidney rats on a high phosphorus diet, 68 and adenineinduced CRF rats. 95 Until now, the uremic LDLR knockout mouse is the only experimental model available for studies on the development of vascular calcification in the setting of low-turnover bone disease, 60 which is recognized with increasing frequency in CKD patients because of changed strategies to control secondary hyperparathyroidism. Criteria for vascular calcification (localization, extent, and consistency) in CRF animals depend largely on the aim of the study. Both apoe and LDLR knockout mice have shown to develop the successive stages of atherosclerotic plaque progression finally leading to calcified lesions which are accelerated by uremia and show striking similarities to human plaque progression. 54,58 In uremic and nonuremic apoe and LDLR knockout mice, intimal plaque calcifications are characterized by loss of the vascular smooth muscle type structure and changes of vascular cells toward osteochondrogenic phenotypes with expression of bone associated proteins such as OPN, cbfa1, osterix, osteocalcin, BMP-2, collagen II and X, or sox9, 61,96 98 which is in line with observations in human arteries affected by intimal plaque calcification. 99,100 These experimental models are thus particularly useful for studies in the context of (uremic) intimal calcification. Despite the development of discrete medial calcifications in these uremic mouse models, the remnant kidney and adenine induced-crf rat models or the calcification-prone mouse model described by El-Abbadi et al 62 are preferentially used to study isolated uremic medial calcification. In accordance with medial calcification in human vessels, 101,102 no local vascular inflammation is detected, the media thickness is increased and osteochondrogenic cells around calcified foci are observed in uremic rat models. 70,77,102 Experiments aiming to investigate the efficiency of therapies on medial calcification should optimally use rodent models that develop consistent, robust medial calcification in all animals within a relative short time period as seen in the adenine-induced CRF rat model either on a low protein diet or treated with low dose vitamin D 3,or 5/6th nephrectomized rats administered high doses of vitamin D 3. Alternatively, experimental models showing a high biological variability with respect to the severity of arterial calcification might be applied to define and analyze determinants of vascular calcification and to get a better insight into the molecular evolution of the calcification process. Experimental Evaluation of Therapies for the Prevention of Vascular Calcification Phosphate Binding Agents In end-stage renal disease, therapies mainly focus on controlling mineral homeostasis by targeting hyperphosphatemia and ensuing secondary hyperparathyroidism with phosphate binding agents and/or vitamin D receptor activators or calcimimetics (Figure 1). By doing so, one of the best known inducers of vascular calcification can be controlled: phosphate. A handful of clinical trials have studied the effect of phosphate binding agents on the progression of vascular calcification in predialysis, 103 prevalent, 29,104 and incident hemodialysis patients 105 whereby the interest is mainly focused on comparing calcium phosphate binders (calcium carbonate and calcium acetate) with one of the noncalcium phosphate binding agents, sevelamer. However, these studies report conflicting results as some studies show that sevelamer attenuates the progression of arterial calcification in comparison with calcium-containing phosphate binders, 29,104,105 whereas others did not find a difference between both treatments on the outcome of this disease process. 106,107 Confounding factors in comparative clinical studies investigating the effect of different phosphate binders on vascular calcification may be (1) the concomitant use of other medications, such as 1,25(OH) 2 vitamin D 3 ; (2) the presence of comorbidity factors such as diabetes or smoking; and (3) variations in the dialysate calcium concentrations, thereby abrogating differences between phosphate binder use. Moreover, within a patient population, the degree of vascular calcification also differs over a wide range, and it has been shown that the presence or absence of arterial calcification at the start of phosphate binder treatment is an important determinant for the effect of calcium- versus non calciumcontaining phosphate binders on the progression of the calcification process. Indeed, when calcifications were not present at the moment of initiation of phosphate binder treatment, no difference in the development and progression of arterial calcification between calcium carbonate and sevelamer-treated patients was found, whereas a higher calcification score was noted after treatment with calcium-containing phosphate binders versus sevelamer when calcifications were already present before the start of treatment. 103,105 Finally, ethical and practical considerations preclude histomorphometric

Neven and D Haese Uremic Animal Models for Vascular Calcification 255 analysis of bone parameters in large comparative clinical studies which is recommended as it has been shown that bone metabolism plays an important role in the development of vascular calcification. Administration of exogenous calcium in end-stage renal failure patients with low turnover bone disease indeed holds a risk for vascular calcification as the excess calcium cannot be excreted through the urine nor be built into the bone. This hypothesis is supported by the work of London reporting a clear association between daily calcium carbonate dosage and aortic calcification and pulse wave velocity in hemodialysis patients with adynamic bone disease, whereas no such association was found in patients with intact bone turnover. 108 To overcome these possible confounders in patient populations and to pursue a veracious comparison between phosphate binders under more standardized conditions, validated animal models with uremia-induced vascular calcifications are indispensible to add new perspectives on this debate. As shown in the Table, the effect of phosphate binding agents most commonly used in the clinic to date, ie, calcium carbonate or acetate, sevelamer and lanthanum carbonate, is investigated in different uremic murine models. Taken together, calcium carbonate as well as noncalcium phosphate binders seem to reduce the development of aortic calcification, either vascular medial calcification in adenine or 5/6th nephrectomized rats or atherosclerotic plaque-related calcification in LDLR or apoe knockout mice. Yet, both studies of Phan et al 109,110 demonstrated that sevelamer but not calcium carbonate reduced the severity of atherosclerotic lesions. Rather unexpected in light of the clinical trials pointing toward a detrimental effect of calcium phosphate binders on ectopic mineralization, dietary treatment with calcium carbonate decreased both plaque and non plaque-associated calcifications in the aorta versus nontreated animals. 109 Thus, by including a vehicle-treated group, which is ethically impossible in clinical trials, it could be demonstrated that, despite the risk for an excess calcium load, phosphate control using calcium-based agents has yet a more favorable effect on the prevention of vascular calcification compared to animals left untreated. Only few experimental studies made a direct comparison between calcium and noncalcium phosphate binders on the development of uremia-related arterial calcifications. Recently, Terai et al 93 nicely showed that when serum phosphate and PTH were equally controlled by sevelamer and calcium carbonate, both agents significantly reduced the development of medial calcifications, although a slightly better outcome was seen with sevelamer which was probably attributable to lower serum calcium levels. These experimental data suggest that the traditional calcium containing phosphate binders are not necessarily harmful in CKD patients, particularly not in those without vascular calcification at the start of treatment, provided the calcium balance is regularly monitored and no adynamic bone disease is diagnosed. Taking into account the high costs associated with the newer noncalcium phosphate binders, the poorer patient compliance seen with sevelamer because of the high pill burden, and the lack of conclusive clinical results whether or not calcium-containing phosphate binders aggravate arterial calcification, calcium carbonate and acetate remain useful compounds in the management of hyperphosphatemia. Calcimimetics Calcimimetics are among the newest alternatives used to treat secondary hyperparathyroidism. These small molecules bind to the calcium sensing receptor of the parathyroid gland and mimic the effect of an elevated extracellular ionized calcium concentration. In this way, low serum calcium concentrations which are typically present in CKD patients not yet in dialysis less likely trigger PTH secretion. Cinacalcet (Sensipar) is currently the only clinically available calcimimetic agent. In addition to effective control of secondary hyperparathyroidism, treatment with cinacalcet may improve the mineral balance as dialysis patients show reduced serum calcium and phosphate concentrations when administered a daily 25 to 100 mg dose. 111 The inhibition of continuous, excessive PTH production together with the reduction in serum calcium and phosphate concentrations offers hopeful perspectives for calcimimetics in the treatment of vascular calcification in CKD patients. Moreover, calcimimetics may directly affect the calcification process in vascular smooth muscle cells as the calcium sensing receptor is present in this cell type. 112,113 Also important to notice is that administration of daily doses of cinacalcet initially lowers serum PTH levels with an increase of these values toward predose concentrations after 12 to 24 hours thereby inducing oscillating serum PTH levels. 114 Daily intermittent decreases in serum PTH levels increase bone volume and density and thus have an anaboliclike effect on bone, 115 which may also reduce the risk for vascular calcification. The beneficial effect of calcimimetics on bone is also found in experimental studies which revealed that R-568, a calcimimetic used for experimental purposes only, reverses osteitis fibrosis and restores the loss of cortical bone strength in uremic rats with high bone turnover disease. 116 In rats exhibiting a low-turnover bone lesion and osteomalacia, daily gavage of R-568 exerted anabolic-like actions on the bone, manifested by an increased trabecular bone volume and bone mineral density. 115 Most experimental data regarding the effect of calcimimetics on the development of vascular calcification point toward a suppressive effect on aortic calcification (Table). It seems that calcimimetics retard both intimal and medial calcification and even halt the progression of atherosclerosis. 117 These experimental observations were the impetus for clinical trials on this subject. At present, an ongoing randomized, multicenter phase IV study (ADVANCE) evaluates the effect of cinacalcet combined with low dose vitamin D versus flexible vitamin D dosing on the progression of coronary artery calcification in hemodialysis patients. 118 One study investigating the effect of cinacalcet on cardiovascular morbidity and mortality showed a significant reduction in hospitalization and a trend toward reduced mortality among patients treated with cinacalcet versus placebo. 119 Bisphosphonates Bisphosphonates, worldwide prescribed for the treatment of osteoporosis because of their inhibitory effect on osteoclast differentiation, recruitment, and activity, have also been shown to reduce the development of experimentally induced medial calcification (Table). The first-generation bisphosphonate, etidronate, as well as the more potent ibandronate,

256 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 Table. Overview of Studies Investigating the Effect of Phosphate Binding Agents, Calcimimetics, and Bisphosphonates on Vascular Calcification in Uremic Murine Models Uremic Murine Model and Treatment Groups* Duration of Treatment Effect on VC Reference Phosphate binding agents 5/6 Nx 6 months Cozzolino et al 73 CaCO 3 3% 2 Sevelamer 3% 22 Adenine rat (0.75% dietary adenine 4 wk) 5 weeks Katsumata et al 90 Sevelamer 1% 22 Sevelamer 2% 22 ApoE / mouse 8 weeks Phan et al 110 Sevelamer 3% 22 LDLR / mouse 14 weeks Davies et al 60 CaCO 3 1% 2 LDLR / mouse 5 weeks Mathew et al 150 Sevelamer 1% 22 Sevelamer 3% 22 ApoE / mouse 8 weeks Phan et al 109 CaCO 3 3% 22 LDLR / mouse 6 weeks Mathew et al 61 CaCO 3 3% 22 LaCO 3 3% 2 Adenine rat (600 mg/kg adenine orally gavaged 10 days followed by 18 days Terai et al 93 100 ng/kg vitd PO, 3 4 /wk for 18 days) CaCO 3 3% 22 Sevelamer 3% 22 Adenine rat (0.75% dietary adenine 4 wk) 6 weeks Neven et al 95 LaCO 3 1% None LaCO 3 2% 22 Calcimimetics 5/6 Nx ( 0.1 g/kg per day vitd SC) 26 days Henley et al 151 Cinacalcet (10 mg/kg per day PO) None 5/6 Nx ( 80 ng/kg/48 hours vitd IP) Lopez et al 71 R-568 (1.5 mg/kg per day SC) 2 weeks 22 8 weeks 22 5/6 Nx ( 80 ng/kg/48 hours vitd IP) Lopez et al 75 AMG 641 (1.5 mg/kg per day SC) 2 weeks 22 4 weeks None 5/6 Nx ( 600 IE/kg vitd in diet) 12 weeks Koleganova et al 70 R-568 (20 mg/kg per day SC) 22 5/6 Nx ( 20% lactose in diet) 41 days Kawata et al 77 Cinacalcet 5 mg/kg per day PO 2 15 mg/kg per day PO 22 ApoE / mouse 2 months Joki et al 117 R-568 PO (dose not reported) 22 Adenine rat (0.75% dietary adenine 4 wk) 4 weeks Henley et al 152 AMG 641 (3 mg/kg per day PO) 2 (Continued)

Neven and D Haese Uremic Animal Models for Vascular Calcification 257 Table. Continued Uremic Murine Model and Treatment Groups* Duration of Treatment Effect on VC Reference Bisphosphonates 5/6 Nx ( 1 g/kg per day vitd PO) 3 weeks Tamura et al 153 Etidronate 2 mg/kg per day SC None 10 mg/kg per day SC 22 Adenine rat (0.75% dietary adenine 2.5% protein 4 wk) 16 days Price et al 91 Ibandronate (0.25 mg/kg per day SC) 22 5/6 Nx ( 1 g/kg per day vitd PO) 3 weeks Tamura et al 120 Etidronate 5 mg/kg per day SC 22 10 mg/kg per day SC 22 Alendronate (200 g/kg per day SC) None Adenine rat (0.75% dietary adenine 5 wk) 4 weeks Matsui et al 154 Alendronate (700 g/kg per wk SC) 22 Adenine rat (0.75% dietary adenine 7 days followed by 0.5% dietary 4 weeks Lomashvili et al 123 adenine 21 days 2.5% protein) Etidronate 0.17 mg/kg per day SC None 1.7 mg/kg per day SC 22 17 mg/kg per day SC 22 Pamidronate 0.03 mg/kg per day SC 22 0.3 mg/kg per day SC 22 3 mg/kg per day SC 22 5/6 Nx indicates 5/6th nephrectomized rats. *Few studies included other treatment groups, but only those concerning the discussed treatments in this review are listed in the table. 22, treatment causes a significant reduction of vascular calcification; 2, treatment causes a decreasing trend of vascular calcification. inhibits uremia-related vascular calcifications. 91,120 In hemodialysis patients, etidronate also halted the progression of coronary and aortic calcification, however the studied population was small. 121,122 Despite the fact that bisphosphonates nowadays are put forward in the treatment of vascular calcification, caution is warranted in dialysis patients, particularly with regard to the bone. Importantly, experimental studies suggested that the dose required for inhibition of arterial calcification also reduces bone mineralization 120,123 by physicochemical inhibition of hydroxyapatite formation. More recently developed bisphosphonates such as risedronate and zoledronate, with a 1000 to 10 000 times greater potency than etidronate, are used at lower doses and might less likely reduce bone mineralization. Therefore, it would be meaningful to investigate in experimental studies whether administration of more potent bisphosphonates can inhibit vascular calcification without reducing bone mineralization. Calcification Inhibitors Today, the focus for treatment is shifting toward intervening on the circulating concentration of calcification inhibitors, that is often found to be disturbed in CKD patients. Pyrophosphate is one of the candidates. This molecule binds to hydroxyapatite crystals and prevents further incorporation of inorganic phosphate into these crystals. 124 The protective role of pyrophosphate was demonstrated in cultured rat aortas exposed to high phosphate levels. 125 An article published several decades ago showed that pyrophosphate inhibits vitamin D induced aortic calcification in rats. 126 Last year, at the American Society of Nephrology Renal Week, O Neill et al 127 presented a 78% reduction of aortic calcification in pyrophosphate-treated, adenine-induced uremic rats. Interestingly, pyrophosphate did not adversely affect bone formation or mineralization because these molecules, which, unlike bisphosphonates, are nonhydrolyzable pyrophosphate analogs, are degraded by bone alkaline phosphatase. Another promising therapy in the prevention of vascular calcification might be vitamin K, a cofactor responsible for the -carboxylation of the Gla residues of matrix Gla protein and thus for biological activation of this potent calcification inhibitor. Vitamin K deficiency, 128 as well as increased circulating inactive matrix Gla protein levels, 31 has been reported in CKD patients and are associated with a higher degree of vascular calcification. 31,129 Prevention of warfarininduced medial calcification in rats could be obtained by vitamin K2, 130 and regression of this vascular pathology in this rat model was found under high intake of both vitamin K1 and K2. 131 The effect of modifying calcification inhibitors or their regulators on vascular calcification in the setting of

258 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 CKD is still in its infancy, but initial experimental studies await confirmation in clinical trials. Strikingly, animal models are almost always used to evaluate the effect of different therapies on the onset of vascular calcification and thus investigate the preventive capacity of the particular agent. However, a significant proportion of the CKD population displays already manifested calcification in the arteries before the start of dialysis. Therefore, animal models with uremia-related vascular calcification should be further used to examine whether the therapy under study is able to halt or retard the progression of existing calcified areas or, even more important, to regress vascular calcification. The latter is a challenging target as adverse effects on the bone should be avoided. Search for Mechanisms of Vascular Calcification Over the last decade, it became clear that the onset and development of calcification in the arterial wall follows an active, tightly cell-mediated mechanism, triggered by an imbalance between inducers and inhibitors, which at least in part mimics bone formation. A large body of in vitro and ex vivo research on cultured vascular smooth muscle cells and rat aortas has converged to a better understanding of the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying vascular calcification, including some of the intracellular pathways involved. In addition, a growing number of studies use rodent models to further explore the cellular and molecular events regulating the calcification process in the arterial wall. As touched on before, several calcification inhibitors are discovered by their deletion in mice which resulted in distinct medial calcification. Knocking out specific genes in uremic apoe knockout mice has added new insights into the pathophysiology of atherosclerotic plaque calcification. In this murine model, fetuin A deficiency enhanced aortic intimal calcification without affecting the extent of atherosclerosis confirming the direct protective effect of this protein. 132 On the other hand, deletion of cathepsin S in uremic apoe knockout mice led to significant less aortic calcification, without reducing the plaque area, as compared to wild-type uremic apoe knockout mice. This novel finding demonstrates that this proinflammatory elastase accelerates vascular calcification and shows that fragmentation of elastin in the media is an important mechanism contributing to arterial calcification. 133 Similarly, genetic discoidin domain receptor (DDR)1 deficiency reduced intimal plaque calcification in LDLR knockout mice. 96 DDR1 is a receptor tyrosine kinase activated by type I collagen, that is known to be upregulated in calcified areas, and seems to regulate atherosclerotic calcification. In vitro studies confirmed these observations as DDR1 / vascular smooth muscle cells did not mineralize under high phosphate conditions, whereas DDR1 / vascular cells extensively calcify. Calcified areas in the vascular intima and media physicochemically resembling mineralized bone and cell types involved in normal bone turnover have been reported in calcified arteries. Using X-ray diffraction and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, the mineral formed in atherosclerotic intimal plaques of apoe knockout mice, 57 but also in patients with end-stage renal disease, 14 was identified predominantly as hydroxyapatite crystals. Synchrotron X-ray- fluorescence and diffraction analysis of the mineral of the calcified areas that developed in the tunica media of the adenine-induced CRF rat also showed that apatite is the main component of the mineral phase. 134 At the edges of the mineral phases, amorphous calcium phosphate deposits were found, which is supposed to represent an intermediate phase during biomineralization of hydroxyapatite. These findings indicate that this labile mineral compound in the vessel wall matures over time to form crystalline apatite as in bone. Moreover, in calcified atheromas of LDLR and ApoE knockout mice 97,99,135 cartilage metaplasia was detected and chondrocyte-like cells were observed as evidenced by the expression of specific markers such as sox9 and collagen II and X. The presence of cartilage and bone in close association with atherosclerotic plaque calcification suggests that intimal calcification resembles endochondral bone formation in long bones where a cartilage template serves as an intermediate before the actual bone is formed. Although medial calcification was previously considered to develop via a mechanism analogous to intramembranous bone formation, comprising direct conversion of vascular tissue into a bone structure, clear evidence has now emerged from animal studies supporting the concept that cartilage metaplasia is also involved in medial calcification. Chondrocyte-like cells were associated with aorta medial calcification in matrix Gla protein knockout mice. 42 Furthermore, studies performed in our laboratory revealed that cells morphologically resembling hypertrophic chondrocytes, characterized by their round shape and the presence of a lacuna, were present adjacent to calcified areas in the media of adenine-induced uremic rats. 102 Expression of the chondrocyte markers sox9, collagen II, and aggrecan confirmed the involvement of chondrocytes and cartilage tissue in the development of medial calcification. 92,102 Additionally, we found that molecules involved in the osteoblast differentiation pathway were suppressed in the calcified vascular media of uremic rats. 92 The expression of the osteoblast transcription factor, osterix as well as -catenin and LDLR-related protein 6, molecules regulating the wnt/ catenin pathway, were significantly downregulated just before and during the initial phase of the calcification process in the aorta. Both osterix and the wnt/ -catenin signaling pathway are responsible for the segregation of common osteochondroprogenitor cells toward osteoblasts, whereas suppression of the latter pathway and induction of the transcription factor sox9 guide these progenitor cells to chondrocytes. 136,137 The simultaneous upregulation of chondrocyte-specific markers and suppression of the osteoblast differentiation pathway led us to the hypothesis that medial smooth muscle cells more likely transdifferentiate into chondrocyte-like cells than having an osteoblast-like fate during uremia-related medial calcification. 92 Evidence for the expression of a chondrogenic phenotype in intimal and medial calcified lesions is also shown in arteries from diabetics 138,139 and transplant donors. 102 However, cartilage metaplasia might be just one of the pathological pathways causing vascular calcification. Indeed, in the LDLR knockout model, 140 medial calcification was associated with upregula-

Neven and D Haese Uremic Animal Models for Vascular Calcification 259 Figure 2. Current hypothesis of the origin of chondrocyte-like cells involved in arterial intimal versus medial calcification. HA indicates hydroxyapatite; VSMC, vascular smooth muscle cell. tion of bone morphogenetic protein-2, msx2, and the wnt signaling pathway, pointing toward the direct transdifferentiation of vascular cells to osteoblasts and suggesting that a cartilage intermediate is not required to form bone-like structures in arteries. Interestingly, treatment of LDLR knockout mice with antitumor necrosis factor- therapy in this study prevented the induction of these osteoblast markers and significantly reduced aortic calcium content thereby highlighting the crucial role of inflammation in phenotypic changes of medial smooth muscle cells. It is plausible to assume that the segregation between osteoblast or chondrocyte transdifferentiation in the vessel wall is determined by environmental factors, such as inflammatory mediators and/or uremic toxins. Recent well-performed studies regarding the origin of chondrocytes in calcified arteries are of particular interest (Figure 2). A cell lineage mapping study in a mouse model with distinctive arterial medial calcification demonstrated that medial smooth muscle cells underwent reprogramming toward an osteochondrogenic phenotype. 141 Conversely, using bone marrow transplantation in LDLR knockout mice, 90% of chondrocyte-like cells in atherosclerotic intimal calcification were shown to originate from hematopoietic, particularly myeloid, precursors in the bone marrow. 142 However, these findings need to be confirmed by a rigorous lineage tracing study and do not rule out the contribution of local chondrocyte transdifferentiation from vascular cells to chondrocartilagenous metaplasia during intimal calcification which is also a plausible mechanism as smooth muscle actin positive cells in atherosclerotic plaques show positivity for the chondrocyte marker sox9. 135 These reports suggest that distinct mechanisms might be involved in intimal plaque mineralization and vascular medial calcification, the latter being much less associated with local inflammation. Osteoclast-like cells have also been reported in calcified vessels. In calcified lesions of OPG knockout mice, multinucleated cells were associated with the expression of receptor activator of nuclear factor B (RANK), an osteoclast cell surface receptor, and stained positive for the osteoclastspecific proteins cathepsin K and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase. 143 In human calcified atherosclerotic plaques, TRAP-positive cells were also found. 144 Osteoclasts are derived from the monocyte/macrophage hematopoietic lineage and require macrophage colony-stimulating factor (M-CSF) and RANK ligand mediated signaling for differentiation and maturation. As endothelial cells and vascular smooth muscle cells in the normal vessel wall produce M-CSF, and RANK ligand expression is induced in calcified vessels, these factors possibly may mediate the differentiation of osteoclast precursors such as monocytes/macrophages after being recruited to the vessel wall, eg, during atherosclerosis. However, despite little evidence for osteoclast-like cells to be present in calcified arteries, it is still unclear whether regression of vascular calcification takes place and whether these cells have the capacity to resorb pathological calcifications. One study mentioned a 75% regression of medial calcification 9 weeks after cessation of vitamin D treatment in rats. 45 Macrophages, identified as CD68 cells, were attached to the aortic endothelium and located around vascular calcium deposits suggesting an active resorption process. A recent study reported that bone marrow-derived osteoclasts reduced the mineral content of calcified elastin fibers in vitro by 80%, and in vivo, subdermal implantation of osteoclasts in the vicinity of calcified elastin, diminished elastin mineralization by 50%. 145 These observations suggest a potential mechanism by which osteoclast-like cells in the vessel wall could induce regression of arterial calcification. At the molecular level, the role of OPG and RANK ligand in vascular calcification has gained more interest through animal studies. Both molecules are important for the coupled regulation of bone formation and resorption. Binding of RANK ligand, expressed by osteoblasts, with its receptor RANK, located at the membrane surface of the osteoclast precursors, induces osteoclast activation, differentiation, and

260 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 maturation, thereby starting the process of bone resorption. The effects of RANK ligand are blocked by OPG, a soluble decoy receptor for RANK ligand, that in this way regulates bone resorption by inhibiting the final differentiation and activation of osteoclasts. OPG treatment reduced both intimal and medial calcification in LDLR knockout mice 146 and rats receiving vitamin D and warfarin treatment, 147 respectively. Whether the preventive effect of OPG is ascribed to direct actions on the vessel wall or occurred secondary through targeting the bone by inhibiting bone resorption and limiting release of calcium and phosphorus from the bone needs further investigation. The latter hypothesis is supported by Helas et al, 148 demonstrating that RANK ligand inhibition by denosumab inhibits glucocorticoid-induced bone resorption with a concomitant reduction in vascular calcium content by 50%. Clearly, the OPG/RANK/RANK ligand triad may serve as a promising new target for therapy in the prevention of vascular calcification, particularly in patients with a low bone mineral density. Conclusion Complementary to clinical and in vitro studies, various valuable animal models have added new insights into the cellular and molecular processes mediating intimal and medial calcification whether or not in the context of CRF. Using uremic experimental models has allowed evaluation of the preventive effect of therapeutics, intervening in the dysregulated mineral metabolism related to CKD, on the onset of vascular calcification. In view of new strategies for treatment of the high vascular calcification burden in CKD, animal models of vascular calcification are currently being used to evaluate therapies targeting the disturbed concentrations of calcification inhibitors present in CKD patients. In the future, uremic animal models could further improve their value in this research field as they serve as an excellent tool to study the regression of arterial calcification under treatment, which undoubtedly is of great clinical importance in the dialysis population. With regard to future studies aiming to investigate the reversal of vascular calcification, in vivo microtomography scanning has been shown to be a sensitive tool for the follow-up of aortic calcification in living rats. 149 Acknowledgments We thank Dirk De Weerdt for assistance with the figures. Sources of Funding E.N. has received a PhD grant from the Institute for the Promotion of Innovation through Science and Technology in Flanders (IWT). P.C.D. is supported by the Special Research Fund (BOF) of the Antwerp University and the Fund for Scientific Research Flandres (FWO). None. Disclosures References 1. US Renal Data System: USRDS 1998 Annual Data Report. Bethesda, Md: National Institutes of Health National Institute of Diabetes, Digestive, Kidney Diseases; 1998. 2. Henry RM, Kostense PJ, Bos G, Dekker JM, Nijpels G, Heine RJ, Bouter LM, Stehouwer CD. Mild renal insufficiency is associated with increased cardiovascular mortality: the Hoorn Study. Kidney Int. 2002; 62:1402 1407. 3. Witteman JC, Kok FJ, van Saase JL, Valkenburg HA. Aortic calcification as a predictor of cardiovascular mortality. Lancet. 1986;2: 1120 1122. 4. Wilson PW, Kauppila LI, O Donnell CJ, Kiel DP, Hannan M, Polak JM, Cupples LA. Abdominal aortic calcific deposits are an important predictor of vascular morbidity and mortality. Circulation. 2001;103: 1529 1534. 5. Blacher J, Guerin AP, Pannier B, Marchais SJ, London GM. Arterial calcifications, arterial stiffness, and cardiovascular risk in end-stage renal disease. Hypertension. 2001;38:938 942. 6. London GM, Guerin AP, Marchais SJ, Metivier F, Pannier B, Adda H. Arterial media calcification in end-stage renal disease: impact on all-cause and cardiovascular mortality. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2003; 18:1731 1740. 7. Okuno S, Ishimura E, Kitatani K, Fujino Y, Kohno K, Maeno Y, Maekawa K, Yamakawa T, Imanishi Y, Inaba M, Nishizawa Y. Presence of abdominal aortic calcification is significantly associated with all-cause and cardiovascular mortality in maintenance hemodialysis patients. Am J Kidney Dis. 2007;49:417 425. 8. Porter CJ, Stavroulopoulos A, Roe SD, Pointon K, Cassidy MJ. Detection of coronary and peripheral artery calcification in patients with chronic kidney disease stages 3 and 4, with and without diabetes. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2007;22:3208 3213. 9. Sigrist M, Bungay P, Taal MW, McIntyre CW. Vascular calcification and cardiovascular function in chronic kidney disease. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2006;21:707 714. 10. Goodman WG, Goldin J, Kuizon BD, Yoon C, Gales B, Sider D, Wang Y, Chung J, Emerick A, Greaser L, Elashoff RM, Salusky IB. Coronaryartery calcification in young adults with end-stage renal disease who are undergoing dialysis. N Engl J Med. 2000;342:1478 1483. 11. Oh J, Wunsch R, Turzer M, Bahner M, Raggi P, Querfeld U, Mehls O, Schaefer F. Advanced coronary and carotid arteriopathy in young adults with childhood-onset chronic renal failure. Circulation. 2002;106: 100 105. 12. Lindner A, Charra B, Sherrard DJ, Scribner BH. Accelerated atherosclerosis in prolonged maintenance hemodialysis. N Engl J Med. 1974; 290:697 701. 13. Savage T, Clarke AL, Giles M, Tomson CR, Raine AE. Calcified plaque is common in the carotid and femoral arteries of dialysis patients without clinical vascular disease. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 1998;13:2004 2012. 14. Schwarz U, Buzello M, Ritz E, Stein G, Raabe G, Wiest G, Mall G, Amann K. Morphology of coronary atherosclerotic lesions in patients with end-stage renal failure. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2000;15: 218 223. 15. Huang H, Virmani R, Younis H, Burke AP, Kamm RD, Lee RT. The impact of calcification on the biomechanical stability of atherosclerotic plaques. Circulation. 2001;103:1051 1056. 16. Beckman JA, Ganz J, Creager MA, Ganz P, Kinlay S. Relationship of clinical presentation and calcification of culprit coronary artery stenoses. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2001;21:1618 1622. 17. Wahlgren CM, Zheng W, Shaalan W, Tang J, Bassiouny HS. Human carotid plaque calcification and vulnerability. Relationship between degree of plaque calcification, fibrous cap inflammatory gene expression and symptomatology. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2009;27:193 200. 18. Virmani R, Burke AP, Farb A. Plaque morphology in sudden coronary death. Cardiologia. 1998;43:267 271. 19. Farb A, Burke AP, Tang AL, Liang TY, Mannan P, Smialek J, Virmani R. Coronary plaque erosion without rupture into a lipid core. A frequent cause of coronary thrombosis in sudden coronary death. Circulation. 1996;93:1354 1363. 20. Ehara S, Kobayashi Y, Yoshiyama M, Shimada K, Shimada Y, Fukuda D, Nakamura Y, Yamashita H, Yamagishi H, Takeuchi K, Naruko T, Haze K, Becker AE, Yoshikawa J, Ueda M. Spotty calcification typifies the culprit plaque in patients with acute myocardial infarction: an intravascular ultrasound study. Circulation. 2004;110:3424 3429. 21. Vengrenyuk Y, Carlier S, Xanthos S, Cardoso L, Ganatos P, Virmani R, Einav S, Gilchrist L, Weinbaum S. A hypothesis for vulnerable plaque rupture due to stress-induced debonding around cellular microcalcifications in thin fibrous caps. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2006;103: 14678 14683.

Neven and D Haese Uremic Animal Models for Vascular Calcification 261 22. Nadra I, Boccaccini AR, Philippidis P, Whelan LC, McCarthy GM, Haskard DO, Landis RC. Effect of particle size on hydroxyapatite crystal-induced tumor necrosis factor alpha secretion by macrophages. Atherosclerosis. 2008;196:98 105. 23. Ewence AE, Bootman M, Roderick HL, Skepper JN, McCarthy G, Epple M, Neumann M, Shanahan CM, Proudfoot D. Calcium phosphate crystals induce cell death in human vascular smooth muscle cells: a potential mechanism in atherosclerotic plaque destabilization. Circ Res. 2008;103:e28 e34. 24. London GM. Cardiovascular calcifications in uremic patients: clinical impact on cardiovascular function. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2003;14: S305 S309. 25. Longenecker JC, Coresh J, Powe NR, Levey AS, Fink NE, Martin A, Klag MJ. Traditional cardiovascular disease risk factors in dialysis patients compared with the general population: the CHOICE Study. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2002;13:1918 1927. 26. Sarnak MJ, Coronado BE, Greene T, Wang SR, Kusek JW, Beck GJ, Levey AS. Cardiovascular disease risk factors in chronic renal insufficiency. Clin Nephrol. 2002;57:327 335. 27. Chertow GM, Raggi P, Chasan-Taber S, Bommer J, Holzer H, Burke SK. Determinants of progressive vascular calcification in haemodialysis patients. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2004;19:1489 1496. 28. Raggi P, Boulay A, Chasan-Taber S, Amin N, Dillon M, Burke SK, Chertow GM. Cardiac calcification in adult hemodialysis patients. A link between end-stage renal disease and cardiovascular disease? JAm Coll Cardiol. 2002;20:39:695 701. 29. Asmus HG, Braun J, Krause R, Brunkhorst R, Holzer H, Schulz W, Neumayer HH, Raggi P, Bommer J. Two year comparison of sevelamer and calcium carbonate effects on cardiovascular calcification and bone density. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2005;20:1653 1661. 30. Galassi A, Spiegel DM, Bellasi A, Block GA, Raggi P. Accelerated vascular calcification and relative hypoparathyroidism in incident haemodialysis diabetic patients receiving calcium binders. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2006;21:3215 3222. 31. Schurgers LJ, Barreto DV, Barreto FC, Liabeuf S, Renard C, Magdeleyns EJ, Vermeer C, Choukroun G, Massy ZA. The circulating inactive form of matrix gla protein is a surrogate marker for vascular calcification in chronic kidney disease: a preliminary report. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2010;5:568 575. 32. Ketteler M, Bongartz P, Westenfeld R, Wildberger JE, Mahnken AH, Bohm R, Metzger T, Wanner C, Jahnen-Dechent W, Floege J. Association of low fetuin-a (AHSG) concentrations in serum with cardiovascular mortality in patients on dialysis: a cross-sectional study. Lancet. 2003;361:827 833. 33. Lomashvili KA, Khawandi W, O Neill WC. Reduced plasma pyrophosphate levels in hemodialysis patients. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2005;16: 2495 2500. 34. Moe SM, Reslerova M, Ketteler M, O neill K, Duan D, Koczman J, Westenfeld R, Jahnen-Dechent W, Chen NX. Role of calcification inhibitors in the pathogenesis of vascular calcification in chronic kidney disease (CKD). Kidney Int. 2005;67:2295 2304. 35. O Neill WC, Sigrist MK, McIntyre CW. Plasma pyrophosphate and vascular calcification in chronic kidney disease. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2010;25:187 191. 36. Barreto DV, de Carvalho BF, de Carvalho AB, Cuppari L, Draibe SA, Dalboni MA, Moyses RM, Neves KR, Jorgetti V, Miname M, Santos RD, Canziani ME. Association of Changes in Bone Remodeling and Coronary Calcification in Hemodialysis Patients: A Prospective Study. Am J Kidney Dis. 2008;52:1139 1150. 37. Ibels LS, Alfrey AC, Huffer WE, Craswell PW, Anderson JT, Weil R III. Arterial calcification and pathology in uremic patients undergoing dialysis. Am J Med. 1979;66:790 796. 38. Kuzela DC, Huffer WE, Conger JD, Winter SD, Hammond WS. Soft tissue calcification in chronic dialysis patients. Am J Pathol. 1977;86: 403 424. 39. Razzaque MS, Sitara D, Taguchi T, St-Arnaud R, Lanske B. Premature aging-like phenotype in fibroblast growth factor 23 null mice is a vitamin D-mediated process. FASEB J. 2006;20:720 722. 40. Stubbs JR, Liu S, Tang W, Zhou J, Wang Y, Yao X, Quarles LD. Role of hyperphosphatemia and 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D in vascular calcification and mortality in fibroblastic growth factor 23 null mice. JAm Soc Nephrol. 2007;18:2116 2124. 41. Kuro-o M, Matsumura Y, Aizawa H, Kawaguchi H, Suga T, Utsugi T, Ohyama Y, Kurabayashi M, Kaname T, Kume E, Iwasaki H, Iida A, Shiraki-Iida T, Nishikawa S, Nagai R, Nabeshima YI. Mutation of the mouse klotho gene leads to a syndrome resembling ageing. Nature. 1997;390:45 51. 42. Luo G, Ducy P, McKee MD, Pinero GJ, Loyer E, Behringer RR, Karsenty G. Spontaneous calcification of arteries and cartilage in mice lacking matrix GLA protein. Nature. 1997;386:78 81. 43. Bucay N, Sarosi I, Dunstan CR, Morony S, Tarpley J, Capparelli C, Scully S, Tan HL, Xu W, Lacey DL, Boyle WJ, Simonet WS. Osteoprotegerin-deficient mice develop early onset osteoporosis and arterial calcification. Genes Dev. 1998;12:1260 1268. 44. Schafer C, Heiss A, Schwarz A, Westenfeld R, Ketteler M, Floege J, Muller-Esterl W, Schinke T, Jahnen-Dechent W. The serum protein alpha 2-Heremans-Schmid glycoprotein/fetuin-a is a systemically acting inhibitor of ectopic calcification. J Clin Invest. 2003;112: 357 366. 45. Bas A, Lopez I, Perez J, Rodriguez M, guilera-tejero E. Reversibility of calcitriol-induced medial artery calcification in rats with intact renal function. J Bone Miner Res. 2006;21:484 490. 46. Niederhoffer N, Bobryshev YV, Lartaud-Idjouadiene I, Giummelly P, Atkinson J. Aortic calcification produced by vitamin D3 plus nicotine. J Vasc Res. 1997;34:386 398. 47. Price PA, Faus SA, Williamson MK. Warfarin causes rapid calcification of the elastic lamellae in rat arteries and heart valves. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 1998;18:1400 1407. 48. Adijiang A, Goto S, Uramoto S, Nishijima F, Niwa T. Indoxyl sulphate promotes aortic calcification with expression of osteoblast-specific proteins in hypertensive rats. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2008;23: 1892 1901. 49. Paigen B, Morrow A, Brandon C, Mitchell D, Holmes P. Variation in susceptibility to atherosclerosis among inbred strains of mice. Atherosclerosis. 1985;57:65 73. 50. Thompson JS. Atheromata in an inbred strain of mice. J Atheroscler Res. 1969;10:113 122. 51. Dolphin PJ. Serum and hepatic nascent lipoproteins in normal and hypercholesterolemic rats. J Lipid Res. 1981;22:971 989. 52. Jawien J, Nastalek P, Korbut R. Mouse models of experimental atherosclerosis. J Physiol Pharmacol. 2004;55:503 517. 53. Reddick RL, Zhang SH, Maeda N. Atherosclerosis in mice lacking apo E. Evaluation of lesional development and progression. Arterioscler Thromb. 1994;14:141 147. 54. Nakashima Y, Plump AS, Raines EW, Breslow JL, Ross R. ApoEdeficient mice develop lesions of all phases of atherosclerosis throughout the arterial tree. Arterioscler Thromb. 1994;14:133 140. 55. Bro S, Bentzon JF, Falk E, Andersen CB, Olgaard K, Nielsen LB. Chronic renal failure accelerates atherogenesis in apolipoprotein e-deficient mice. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2003;14:2466 2474. 56. Buzello M, Tornig J, Faulhaber J, Ehmke H, Ritz E, Amann K. The apolipoprotein e knockout mouse: a model documenting accelerated atherogenesis in uremia. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2003;14:311 316. 57. Massy ZA, Ivanovski O, Nguyen-Khoa T, Angulo J, Szumilak D, Mothu N, Phan O, Daudon M, Lacour B, Drueke TB, Muntzel MS. Uremia accelerates both atherosclerosis and arterial calcification in apolipoprotein E knockout mice. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2005;16:109 116. 58. Ishibashi S, Goldstein JL, Brown MS, Herz J, Burns DK. Massive xanthomatosis and atherosclerosis in cholesterol-fed low density lipoprotein receptor-negative mice. J Clin Invest. 1994;93:1885 1893. 59. Davies MR, Lund RJ, Hruska KA. BMP-7 is an efficacious treatment of vascular calcification in a murine model of atherosclerosis and chronic renal failure. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2003;14:1559 1567. 60. Davies MR, Lund RJ, Mathew S, Hruska KA. Low turnover osteodystrophy and vascular calcification are amenable to skeletal anabolism in an animal model of chronic kidney disease and the metabolic syndrome. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2005;16:917 928. 61. Mathew S, Tustison KS, Sugatani T, Chaudhary LR, Rifas L, Hruska KA. The mechanism of phosphorus as a cardiovascular risk factor in CKD. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2008;19:1092 1105. 62. El-Abbadi MM, Pai AS, Leaf EM, Yang HY, Bartley BA, Quan KK, Ingalls CM, Liao HW, Giachelli CM. Phosphate feeding induces arterial medial calcification in uremic mice: role of serum phosphorus, fibroblast growth factor-23, and osteopontin. Kidney Int. 2009;75:1297 1307. 63. Adeney KL, Siscovick DS, Ix JH, Seliger SL, Shlipak MG, Jenny NS, Kestenbaum BR. Association of serum phosphate with vascular and valvular calcification in moderate CKD. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2009;20: 381 387. 64. Nasrallah MM, El-Shehaby AR, Salem MM, Osman NA, El SE, Sharaf El Din UA. Fibroblast growth factor-23 (FGF-23) is independently

262 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 correlated to aortic calcification in haemodialysis patients. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2010;25:2679 2685. 65. Rix M, Andreassen H, Eskildsen P, Langdahl B, Olgaard K. Bone mineral density and biochemical markers of bone turnover in patients with predialysis chronic renal failure. Kidney Int. 1999;56:1084 1093. 66. Sancho JJ, Duh QY, Oms L, Sitges-Serra A, Hammond ME, Arnaud CD, Clark OH. A new experimental model for secondary hyperparathyroidism. Surgery. 1989;106:1002 1008. 67. Vercauteren SR, Ysebaert DK, De Greef KE, Eyskens EJ, De Broe ME. Chronic reduction in renal mass in the rat attenuates ischemia/ reperfusion injury and does not impair tubular regeneration. JAmSoc Nephrol. 1999;10:2551 2561. 68. Oste L, Behets GJ, Dams G, Bervoets AR, Marynissen RL, Geryl H, Van H, V, De Broe ME, D Haese PC. Role of dietary phosphorus and degree of uremia in the development of renal bone disease in rats. Ren Fail. 2007;29:1 12. 69. Mizobuchi M, Ogata H, Hatamura I, Koiwa F, Saji F, Shiizaki K, Negi S, Kinugasa E, Ooshima A, Koshikawa S, Akizawa T. Up-regulation of Cbfa1 and Pit-1 in calcified artery of uraemic rats with severe hyperphosphataemia and secondary hyperparathyroidism. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2006;21:911 916. 70. Koleganova N, Piecha G, Ritz E, Schmitt CP, Gross ML. A calcimimetic (R-568), but not calcitriol, prevents vascular remodeling in uremia. Kidney Int. 2009;75:60 71. 71. Lopez I, Guilera-Tejero E, Mendoza FJ, Almaden Y, Perez J, Martin D, Rodriguez M. Calcimimetic R-568 decreases extraosseous calcifications in uremic rats treated with calcitriol. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2006;17: 795 804. 72. Noonan W, Koch K, Nakane M, Ma J, Dixon D, Bolin A, Reinhart G. Differential effects of vitamin D receptor activators on aortic calcification and pulse wave velocity in uraemic rats. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2008;23:3824 3830. 73. Cozzolino M, Staniforth ME, Liapis H, Finch J, Burke SK, Dusso AS, Slatopolsky E. Sevelamer hydrochloride attenuates kidney and cardiovascular calcifications in long-term experimental uremia. Kidney Int. 2003;64:1653 1661. 74. Haffner D, Hocher B, Muller D, Simon K, Konig K, Richter CM, Eggert B, Schwarz J, Godes M, Nissel R, Querfeld U. Systemic cardiovascular disease in uremic rats induced by 1,25(OH)2D3. J Hypertens. 2005;23: 1067 1075. 75. Lopez I, Mendoza FJ, guilera-tejero E, Perez J, Guerrero F, Martin D, Rodriguez M. The effect of calcitriol, paricalcitol, and a calcimimetic on extraosseous calcifications in uremic rats. Kidney Int. 2008;73:300 307. 76. Mizobuchi M, Finch JL, Martin DR, Slatopolsky E. Differential effects of vitamin D receptor activators on vascular calcification in uremic rats. Kidney Int. 2007;72:709 715. 77. Kawata T, Nagano N, Obi M, Miyata S, Koyama C, Kobayashi N, Wakita S, Wada M. Cinacalcet suppresses calcification of the aorta and heart in uremic rats. Kidney Int. 2008;74:1270 1277. 78. Debiec H, Lorenc R. Influence of lactose on phosphate metabolism in rats. Br J Nutr. 1988;59:87 92. 79. Favus MJ, ngeid-backman E. Effects of lactose on calcium absorption and secretion by rat ileum. Am J Physiol. 1984;246:G281 G285. 80. Neves KR, Graciolli FG, dos Reis LM, Graciolli RG, Neves CL, Magalhaes AO, Custodio MR, Batista DG, Jorgetti V, Moyses RM. Vascular calcification: contribution of parathyroid hormone in renal failure. Kidney Int. 2007;71:1262 1270. 81. Kaspareit-Rittinghausen J, Deerberg F, Wcislo A. Hereditary polycystic kidney disease. Adult polycystic kidney disease associated with renal hypertension, renal osteodystrophy, and uremic enteritis in SPRD rats. Am J Pathol. 1991;139:693 696. 82. Kaspareit-Rittinghausen J, Deerberg F, Rapp KG, Wcislo A. A new rat model for polycystic kidney disease of humans. Transplant Proc. 1990; 22:2582 2583. 83. Brown JH, Bihoreau MT, Hoffmann S, Kranzlin B, Tychinskaya I, Obermuller N, Podlich D, Boehn SN, Kaisaki PJ, Megel N, Danoy P, Copley RR, Broxholme J, Witzgall R, Lathrop M, Gretz N, Gauguier D. Missense mutation in sterile alpha motif of novel protein SamCystin is associated with polycystic kidney disease in (cy/ ) rat. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2005;16:3517 3526. 84. Moe SM, Chen NX, Seifert MF, Sinders RM, Duan D, Chen X, Liang Y, Radcliff JS, White KE, Gattone VH. A rat model of chronic kidney disease-mineral bone disorder. Kidney Int. 2009;75:176 184. 85. Wyngaarden JB, Dunn JT. 8-Hydroxyadenine as the intermediate in the oxidation of adenine to 2, 8-dihydroxyadenine by xanthine oxidase. Arch Biochem Biophys. 1957;70:150 156. 86. de Vries A, Sperling O. Implications of disorders of purine metabolism for the kidney and the urinary tract. Ciba Found Symp. 1977;(48): 179 206. 87. Fye KH, Sahota A, Hancock DC, Gelb AB, Chen J, Sparks JW, Sibley RK, Tischfield JA. Adenine phosphoribosyltransferase deficiency with renal deposition of 2,8-dihydroxyadenine leading to nephrolithiasis and chronic renal failure. Arch Intern Med. 1993;153:767 770. 88. Yokozawa T, Zheng PD, Oura H, Koizumi F. Animal model of adenineinduced chronic renal failure in rats. Nephron. 1986;44:230 234. 89. Okada H, Kaneko Y, Yawata T, Uyama H, Ozono S, Motomiya Y, Hirao Y. Reversibility of adenine-induced renal failure in rats. Clin Exp Immunol. 1999;3:82 88. 90. Katsumata K, Kusano K, Hirata M, Tsunemi K, Nagano N, Burke SK, Fukushima N. Sevelamer hydrochloride prevents ectopic calcification and renal osteodystrophy in chronic renal failure rats. Kidney Int. 2003; 64:441 450. 91. Price PA, Roublick AM, Williamson MK. Artery calcification in uremic rats is increased by a low protein diet and prevented by treatment with ibandronate. Kidney Int. 2006;70:1577 1583. 92. Neven E, Persy V, Dauwe S, De ST, De Broe ME, D Haese PC. Chondrocyte rather than osteoblast conversion of vascular cells underlies medial calcification in uremic rats. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2010;30:1741 1750. 93. Terai K, Nara H, Takakura K, Mizukami K, Sanagi M, Fukushima S, Fujimori A, Itoh H, Okada M. Vascular calcification and secondary hyperparathyroidism of severe chronic kidney disease and its relation to serum phosphate and calcium levels. Br J Pharmacol. 2009;156: 1267 1278. 94. Nikolov IG, Joki N, Nguyen-Khoa T, Ivanovski O, Phan O, Lacour B, Drueke TB, Massy ZA, dos Reis LM, Jorgetti V, Lafage-Proust MH. Chronic kidney disease bone and mineral disorder (CKD-MBD) in apolipoprotein E-deficient mice with chronic renal failure. Bone. 2010; 47:156 163. 95. Neven E, Dams G, Postnov A, Chen B, De Clerck N. De Broe ME, D Haese PC, Persy V. Adequate phosphate binding with lanthanum carbonate attenuates arterial calcification in chronic renal failure rats. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2009;24:1790 1799. 96. Ahmad PJ, Trcka D, Xue S, Franco C, Speer MY, Giachelli CM, Bendeck MP. Discoidin domain receptor-1 deficiency attenuates atherosclerotic calcification and smooth muscle cell-mediated mineralization. Am J Pathol. 2009;175:2686 2696. 97. Bro S, Borup R, Andersen CB, Moeller F, Olgaard K, Nielsen LB. Uremia-specific effects in the arterial media during development of uremic atherosclerosis in apolipoprotein E-deficient mice. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2006;26:570 575. 98. Rattazzi M, Bennett BJ, Bea F, Kirk EA, Ricks JL, Speer M, Schwartz SM, Giachelli CM, Rosenfeld ME. Calcification of advanced atherosclerotic lesions in the innominate arteries of ApoE-deficient mice: potential role of chondrocyte-like cells. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2005;25:1420 1425. 99. Shanahan CM, Cary NR, Metcalfe JC, Weissberg PL. High expression of genes for calcification-regulating proteins in human atherosclerotic plaques. J Clin Invest. 1994;93:2393 2402. 100. Tyson KL, Reynolds JL, McNair R, Zhang Q, Weissberg PL, Shanahan CM. Osteo/chondrocytic transcription factors and their target genes exhibit distinct patterns of expression in human arterial calcification. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2003;23:489 494. 101. Moe SM, O Neill KD, Duan D, Ahmed S, Chen NX, Leapman SB, Fineberg N, Kopecky K. Medial artery calcification in ESRD patients is associated with deposition of bone matrix proteins. Kidney Int. 2002; 61:638 647. 102. Neven E, Dauwe S, De Broe ME, D Haese PC, Persy V. Endochondral bone formation is involved in media calcification in rats and in men. Kidney Int. 2007;72:574 581. 103. Russo D, Miranda I, Ruocco C, Battaglia Y, Buonanno E, Manzi S, Russo L, Scafarto A, Andreucci VE. The progression of coronary artery calcification in predialysis patients on calcium carbonate or sevelamer. Kidney Int. 2007;72:1255 1261. 104. Chertow GM, Burke SK, Raggi P. Sevelamer attenuates the progression of coronary and aortic calcification in hemodialysis patients. Kidney Int. 2002;62:245 252.

Neven and D Haese Uremic Animal Models for Vascular Calcification 263 105. Block GA, Spiegel DM, Ehrlich J, Mehta R, Lindbergh J, Dreisbach A, Raggi P. Effects of sevelamer and calcium on coronary artery calcification in patients new to hemodialysis. Kidney Int. 2005;68:1815 1824. 106. Qunibi W, Moustafa M, Muenz LR, He DY, Kessler PD, az-buxo JA, Budoff M. A 1-year randomized trial of calcium acetate versus sevelamer on progression of coronary artery calcification in hemodialysis patients with comparable lipid control: the Calcium Acetate Renagel Evaluation-2 (CARE-2) study. Am J Kidney Dis. 2008;51: 952 965. 107. Barreto DV, Barreto FC, de Carvalho AB, Cuppari L, Draibe SA, Dalboni MA, Moyses RM, Neves KR, Jorgetti V, Miname M, Santos RD, Canziani ME. Phosphate binder impact on bone remodeling and coronary calcification results from the BRiC study. Nephron Clin Pract. 2008;110:c273 c283. 108. London GM, Marchais SJ, Guerin AP, Boutouyrie P, Metivier F, de Vernejoul MC. Association of bone activity, calcium load, aortic stiffness, and calcifications in ESRD. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2008;19: 1827 1835. 109. Phan O, Ivanovski O, Nikolov IG, Joki N, Maizel J, Louvet L, Chasseraud M, Nguyen-Khoa T, Lacour B, Drueke TB, Massy ZA. Effect of oral calcium carbonate on aortic calcification in apolipoprotein E-deficient (apoe / ) mice with chronic renal failure. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2008;23:82 90. 110. Phan O, Ivanovski O, Nguyen-Khoa T, Mothu N, Angulo J, Westenfeld R, Ketteler M, Meert N, Maizel J, Nikolov IG, Vanholder R, Lacour B, Drueke TB, Massy ZA. Sevelamer prevents uremia-enhanced atherosclerosis progression in apolipoprotein E-deficient mice. Circulation. 2005;112:2875 2882. 111. Block GA, Martin KJ, de Francisco AL, Turner SA, Avram MM, Suranyi MG, Hercz G, Cunningham J, Abu-Alfa AK, Messa P, Coyne DW, Locatelli F, Cohen RM, Evenepoel P, Moe SM, Fournier A, Braun J, McCary LC, Zani VJ, Olson KA, Drueke TB, Goodman WG. Cinacalcet for secondary hyperparathyroidism in patients receiving hemodialysis. N Engl J Med. 2004;350:1516 1525. 112. Molostvov G, James S, Fletcher S, Bennett J, Lehnert H, Bland R, Zehnder D. Extracellular calcium-sensing receptor is functionally expressed in human artery. Am J Physiol Renal Physiol. 2007;293: F946 F955. 113. Smajilovic S, Hansen JL, Christoffersen TE, Lewin E, Sheikh SP, Terwilliger EF, Brown EM, Haunso S, Tfelt-Hansen J. Extracellular calcium sensing in rat aortic vascular smooth muscle cells. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2006;348:1215 1223. 114. Goodman WG, Hladik GA, Turner SA, Blaisdell PW, Goodkin DA, Liu W, Barri YM, Cohen RM, Coburn JW. The calcimimetic agent AMG 073 lowers plasma parathyroid hormone levels in hemodialysis patients with secondary hyperparathyroidism. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2002;13: 1017 1024. 115. Ishii H, Wada M, Furuya Y, Nagano N, Nemeth EF, Fox J. Daily intermittent decreases in serum levels of parathyroid hormone have an anabolic-like action on the bones of uremic rats with low-turnover bone and osteomalacia. Bone. 2000;26:175 182. 116. Wada M, Ishii H, Furuya Y, Fox J, Nemeth EF, Nagano N. NPS R-568 halts or reverses osteitis fibrosa in uremic rats. Kidney Int. 1998;53: 448 453. 117. Joki N, Nikolov IG, Caudrillier A, Mentaverri R, Massy ZA, Drueke TB. Effects of calcimimetic on vascular calcification and atherosclerosis in uremic mice. Bone. 2009;45 Suppl 1:S30 S34. 118. Floege J, Raggi P, Block GA, Torres PU, Csiky B, Naso A, Nossuli K, Moustafa M, Goodman WG, Lopez N, Downey G, Dehmel B, Chertow GM. Study design and subject baseline characteristics in the ADVANCE Study: effects of cinacalcet on vascular calcification in haemodialysis patients. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2010;25:1916 1923. 119. Cunningham J, Danese M, Olson K, Klassen P, Chertow GM. Effects of the calcimimetic cinacalcet HCl on cardiovascular disease, fracture, and health-related quality of life in secondary hyperparathyroidism. Kidney Int. 2005;68:1793 1800. 120. Tamura K, Suzuki Y, Matsushita M, Fujii H, Miyaura C, Aizawa S, Kogo H. Prevention of aortic calcification by etidronate in the renal failure rat model. Eur J Pharmacol. 2007;558:159 166. 121. Hashiba H, Aizawa S, Tamura K, Shigematsu T, Kogo H. Inhibitory effects of etidronate on the progression of vascular calcification in hemodialysis patients. Ther Apher Dial. 2004;8:241 247. 122. Nitta K, Akiba T, Suzuki K, Uchida K, Watanabe R, Majima K, Aoki T, Nihei H. Effects of cyclic intermittent etidronate therapy on coronary artery calcification in patients receiving long-term hemodialysis. Am J Kidney Dis. 2004;44:680 688. 123. Lomashvili KA, Monier-Faugere MC, Wang X, Malluche HH, O Neill WC. Effect of bisphosphonates on vascular calcification and bone metabolism in experimental renal failure. Kidney Int. 2009;75:617 625. 124. Fleisch H, Russell RG, Straumann F. Effect of pyrophosphate on hydroxyapatite and its implications in calcium homeostasis. Nature. 1966;212:901 903. 125. Lomashvili KA, Cobbs S, Hennigar RA, Hardcastle KI, O Neill WC. Phosphate-induced vascular calcification: role of pyrophosphate and osteopontin. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2004;15:1392 1401. 126. Schibler D, Russell RG, Fleisch H. Inhibition by pyrophosphate and polyphosphate of aortic calcification induced by vitamin D3 in rats. Clin Sci. 1968;35:363 372. 127. O Neill WC, Riser BL, Faugere MC, Malluche HM, Lomashvili KA. Treatment of uremic vascular calcification with pyrophosphate. JAm Soc Nephrol. 2009;20(suppl):TH-FC156. Abstract. 128. Malyszko J, Wolczynski S, Skrzydlewska E, Malyszko JS, Mysliwiec M. Vitamin K status in relation to bone metabolism in patients with renal failure. Am J Nephrol. 2002;22:504 508. 129. Rennenberg RJ, de Leeuw PW, Kessels AG, Schurgers LJ, Vermeer C, van Engelshoven JM, Kemerink GJ, Kroon AA. Calcium scores and matrix Gla protein levels: association with vitamin K status. Eur J Clin Invest. 2010;40:344 349. 130. Spronk HM, Soute BA, Schurgers LJ, Thijssen HH, De Mey JG, Vermeer C. Tissue-specific utilization of menaquinone-4 results in the prevention of arterial calcification in warfarin-treated rats. J Vasc Res. 2003;40:531 537. 131. Schurgers LJ, Spronk HM, Soute BA, Schiffers PM, DeMey JG, Vermeer C. Regression of warfarin-induced medial elastocalcinosis by high intake of vitamin K in rats. Blood. 2007;109:2823 2831. 132. Westenfeld R, Schafer C, Kruger T, Haarmann C, Schurgers LJ, Reutelingsperger C, Ivanovski O, Drueke T, Massy ZA, Ketteler M, Floege J, Jahnen-Dechent W. Fetuin-A protects against atherosclerotic calcification in CKD. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2009;20:1264 1274. 133. Aikawa E, Aikawa M, Libby P, Figueiredo JL, Rusanescu G, Iwamoto Y, Fukuda D, Kohler RH, Shi GP, Jaffer FA, Weissleder R. Arterial and aortic valve calcification abolished by elastolytic cathepsin S deficiency in chronic renal disease. Circulation. 2009;119:1785 1794. 134. Verberckmoes SC, Persy V, Behets GJ, Neven E, Hufkens A, Zebger-Gong H, Muller D, Haffner D, Querfeld U, Bohic S, De Broe ME, D Haese PC. Uremia-related vascular calcification: more than apatite deposition. Kidney Int. 2007;71:298 303. 135. Bobryshev YV. Transdifferentiation of smooth muscle cells into chondrocytes in atherosclerotic arteries in situ: implications for diffuse intimal calcification. J Pathol. 2005;205:641 650. 136. Day TF, Yang Y. Wnt and hedgehog signaling pathways in bone development. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2008;90 Suppl 1:19 24. 137. Nakashima K, de Crombrugghe B. Transcriptional mechanisms in osteoblast differentiation and bone formation. Trends Genet. 2003;19: 458 466. 138. Qiao JH, Mertens RB, Fishbein MC, Geller SA. Cartilaginous metaplasia in calcified diabetic peripheral vascular disease: morphologic evidence of enchondral ossification. Hum Pathol. 2003;34:402 407. 139. Shanahan CM, Cary NR, Salisbury JR, Proudfoot D, Weissberg PL, Edmonds ME. Medial localization of mineralization-regulating proteins in association with Monckeberg s sclerosis: evidence for smooth muscle cell-mediated vascular calcification. Circulation. 1999;100:2168 2176. 140. Al-Aly Z, Shao JS, Lai CF, Huang E, Cai J, Behrmann A, Cheng SL, Towler DA. Aortic Msx2-Wnt calcification cascade is regulated by TNF-alpha-dependent signals in diabetic Ldlr / mice. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2007;27:2589 2596. 141. Speer MY, Yang HY, Brabb T, Leaf E, Look A, Lin WL, Frutkin A, Dichek D, Giachelli CM. Smooth muscle cells give rise to osteochondrogenic precursors and chondrocytes in calcifying arteries. Circ Res. 2009;104:733 741. 142. Doehring LC, Heeger C, Aherrahrou Z, Kaczmarek PM, Erdmann J, Schunkert H, Ehlers EM. Myeloid CD34 CD13 precursor cells transdifferentiate into chondrocyte-like cells in atherosclerotic intimal calcification. Am J Pathol. 2010;177:473 480. 143. Min H, Morony S, Sarosi I, Dunstan CR, Capparelli C, Scully S, Van G, Kaufman S, Kostenuik PJ, Lacey DL, Boyle WJ, Simonet WS. Osteoprotegerin reverses osteoporosis by inhibiting endosteal osteoclasts and prevents vascular calcification by blocking a process resembling osteoclastogenesis. J Exp Med. 2000;192:463 474.

264 Circulation Research January 21, 2011 144. Jeziorska M, McCollum C, Wooley DE. Observations on bone formation and remodelling in advanced atherosclerotic lesions of human carotid arteries. Virchows Arch. 1998;433:559 565. 145. Simpson CL, Lindley S, Eisenberg C, Basalyga DM, Starcher BC, Simionescu DT, Vyavahare NR. Toward cell therapy for vascular calcification: osteoclast-mediated demineralization of calcified elastin. Cardiovasc Pathol. 2007;16:29 37. 146. Morony S, Tintut Y, Zhang Z, Cattley RC, Van G, Dwyer D, Stolina M, Kostenuik PJ, Demer LL. Osteoprotegerin inhibits vascular calcification without affecting atherosclerosis in ldlr(-/-) mice. Circulation. 2008; 117:411 420. 147. Price PA, June HH, Buckley JR, Williamson MK. Osteoprotegerin inhibits artery calcification induced by warfarin and by vitamin D. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2001;21:1610 1616. 148. Helas S, Goettsch C, Schoppet M, Zeitz U, Hempel U, Morawietz H, Kostenuik PJ, Erben RG, Hofbauer LC. Inhibition of receptor activator of NF-kappaB ligand by denosumab attenuates vascular calcium deposition in mice. Am J Pathol. 2009;175:473 478. 149. Persy V, Postnov A, Neven E, Dams G, De BM, D Haese P, De Clerck N. High-resolution X-ray microtomography is a sensitive method to detect vascular calcification in living rats with chronic renal failure. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2006;26:2110 2116. 150. Mathew S, Lund RJ, Strebeck F, Tustison KS, Geurs T, Hruska KA. Reversal of the adynamic bone disorder and decreased vascular calcification in chronic kidney disease by sevelamer carbonate therapy. JAm Soc Nephrol. 2007;18:122 130. 151. Henley C, Colloton M, Cattley RC, Shatzen E, Towler DA, Lacey D, Martin D. 1,25-Dihydroxyvitamin D3 but not cinacalcet HCl (Sensipar/ Mimpara) treatment mediates aortic calcification in a rat model of secondary hyperparathyroidism. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2005;20: 1370 1377. 152. Henley C, Davis J, Miller G, Shatzen E, Cattley R, Li X, Martin D, Yao W, Lane N, Shalhoub V. The calcimimetic AMG 641 abrogates parathyroid hyperplasia, bone and vascular calcification abnormalities in uremic rats. Eur J Pharmacol. 2009;616:306 313. 153. Tamura K, Suzuki Y, Hashiba H, Tamura H, Aizawa S, Kogo H. Effect of etidronate on aortic calcification and bone metabolism in calcitrioltreated rats with subtotal nephrectomy. J Pharmacol Sci. 2005;99: 89 94. 154. Matsui I, Hamano T, Mikami S, Fujii N, Takabatake Y, Nagasawa Y, Kawada N, Ito T, Rakugi H, Imai E, Isaka Y. Fully phosphorylated fetuin-a forms a mineral complex in the serum of rats with adenineinduced renal failure. Kidney Int. 2009;75:915 928.

Vascular Calcification in Chronic Renal Failure: What Have We Learned From Animal Studies? Ellen Neven and Patrick C. D'Haese Circ Res. 2011;108:249-264 doi: 10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.110.225904 Circulation Research is published by the American Heart Association, 7272 Greenville Avenue, Dallas, TX 75231 Copyright 2011 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 0009-7330. Online ISSN: 1524-4571 The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the World Wide Web at: http://circres.ahajournals.org/content/108/2/249 Permissions: Requests for permissions to reproduce figures, tables, or portions of articles originally published in Circulation Research can be obtained via RightsLink, a service of the Copyright Clearance Center, not the Editorial Office. Once the online version of the published article for which permission is being requested is located, click Request Permissions in the middle column of the Web page under Services. Further information about this process is available in the Permissions and Rights Question and Answer document. Reprints: Information about reprints can be found online at: http://www.lww.com/reprints Subscriptions: Information about subscribing to Circulation Research is online at: http://circres.ahajournals.org//subscriptions/