It s Not In Your Head Or Is It? Howard P. Levy, M.D., Ph.D. Assistant Professor, Johns Hopkins University August 10-11, 2012 Ehlers Danlos National Foundation 2012 National Learning Conference Cincinnati, OH
Disclosures No financial disclosures or conflicts of interest
Learning Objectives Describe psychological factors that may exacerbate pain in patients with EDS Discuss the role of psychological approaches in the management of pain
It s Not In Your Head Dislocations/Subluxations Acute & chronic muscle spasm Neuropathic pain Degenerative arthritis and others
Yes It Is Pain is a subjective experience Mood and attitude Goals and expectations Fears Avoidance, disability, isolation and others
And that helps me how? Avoid psychologic pain escalation Learn psychologic pain control Less pain Less medication Fewer side effects
Pain Experience Modifiers Emotional state Thoughts Beliefs Intentions Injuries to social relationships Memories of past injuries Emotional state of close others Kozlowska et al (2008) Harv Rev Psychiatry 16:136
In Other Words Psychological distress exacerbates pain Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131; Branson et al (2011) Harv Rev Psychiatry 19:259 Recall a very happy time Minimal impact of dislocation/subluxation? Recall a very bad/sad time Effect of minimal trauma/injury?
Emotional State Common in EDS: Anxiety & Depression Low self-confidence Negative thinking Hopeless/helpless Desperation Low self-efficacy Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131; Branson et al (2011) Harv Rev Psychiatry 19:259; Castori et al(2010) Am J Med Genet A. 152A:556; Hagberg et al (2004) Orthod Craniofac Res. 7:178; Rombaut et al (2011) Arthritis Rheum. 63:1979
Thoughts & Beliefs Pain will harm me Intense self-awareness/hypervigilance Waiting for the next shoe to drop Amplifies pain experience Similar to cancer survivors? Assumption of normal vs. assumption of abnormal Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131
Expectation Management (Intentions) Missing a high bar HIGH BAR ACTUAL EXPERIENCE Exceeding a low bar LOW BAR Effect on mood? On pain experience?
Expectation Management No pain High Bar No dislocations or subluxations Normal activity tolerance Low Bar Less pain Fewer dislocation or subluxations Improved activity tolerance
Injuries to Social Relationships Disbelief by friends/relatives Reduced ability to socialize Resentment, distrust, hostility between patient/family and health care team Marginalization, isolation, despair Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131; Branson et al (2011) Harv Rev Psychiatry 19:259
Memories of past injuries Fear of pain and/or joint instability Anticipation of negative experience Avoidance behavior Exacerbates dysfunction and disability Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131; Branson et al (2011) Harv Rev Psychiatry 19:259
Fear Disbelief Anger Distrust Emotional State of Close Others Anxiety, depression, etc Partners, Parents, Sibs, Children, Extended Family, Friends, Providers
How/Why? Probably not completely understood Pain & emotion co-localize in brain Endorphins Induced by emotion & exercise Modulate pain Natural opioids Centrally acting meds Opioids, sedatives, antidepressants
Complicating Factors PTSD Resistance to accepting psych etiology Response to prior misdiagnoses & accusations It s not in my head it s real Stigma, perceived weakness, crazy
Therapy Build/repair relationship with healthcare providers. Clinician must believe pain and other symptoms are real (validate) Patient must believe that there are psych components in pain experience and management strategy (trust)
Therapy Focus on chronic rather than acute pain management Establish reasonable expectations (exceed a low bar) Distraction Hypnosis Meditation Branson et al (2011) Harv Rev Psychiatry 19:259
Counseling For depression, anxiety, PTSD For accepting, coping & living with pain, dysfunction & disability Consider thoughts/feelings of close others Separate counseling Group counseling Work on patient s response to them. Requires patient acceptance/willingness
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Pain is influenced by cognition, affect and behavior Goal: manage pain & reduce negative consequences Focus on thoughts/beliefs re: pain & associated behaviors and avoidances Can improve pain, disability & mood Requires active patient participation Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131; Eccleston et al (2009) Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2:CD007407
Unhelpful Thoughts Pain means damage; if doing something hurts I should avoid it it s hopeless, I should just accept that I ll end up in a wheelchair I ve got wear and tear, better not use my joints or they ll wear out even quicker I need to rest more, if you feel tired it means you ve been doing too much My pain is a sign of whether I am better, I won t be better until my pain has gone Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131
Eccleston et al (2009) Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2:CD007407 Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Education (and insight) Self-efficacy, locus of control Recover function; overcome fears Distraction Relaxation (breathing exercises, muscle relaxation, guided imagery) Biofeedback Reward positive behaviors Baeza-Velasco et al (2011) Rheumatol Int. 31:1131;
Counseling Work towards positive thinking Assumption of normal Control fear Self-efficacy
Antidepressant Medication Reduce anxiety & depression Lessens subjective pain experience Directly treat pain Especially neuropathic Some improve restorative sleep Less pain
Example Branson et al (2011) Harv Rev Psychiatry 19:259 Adolescent with EDS & recurrent joint pain Poorly controlled episodes progressive escalation in pain and decline in function Meds didn t help w/pain, but caused many SE Hostile relationship w/healthcare teams-- abandoned, disengaged, blame (both directions)
Problems: Example Fear of impending subluxation much more common than actual dislocation Anxiety, anger & hopelessness Pain behaviors out of proportion to actual pain Always rated severity 10/10 Passivity Prior care focused on acute rather than chronic pain management
Solutions: Example Physical rehabilitation & bracing Education to self-manage non-acute pain Predictable daily schedule & expectations Minimize meds, use predictable schedule Distraction Avoid directly asking about or discussing pain Repair medical relationships Avoid ER/acute pain models Eventual engagement in counseling
Mind Over Matter Unchecked psychological distress can amplify pain A disciplined mind can reduce pain
Summary 90% of the game is half mental -Yogi Berra