Using particle models to understand digestion and absorption 1 During Key Stage 3 pupils will learn about the structure and function of the digestive system, the names of organs and their function. This is generally well understood. However, their understanding of how and why food is broken down and absorbed is less well understood. The visking tubing model of the gut can confuse pupils about the process of digestion and absorption as the model has limitations. The teaching of digestion provides a good mechanism for pupils to apply their knowledge of particles. At the same time emphasising the role of particle size can improve their understanding of digestion. Pupils could be asked to apply their knowledge to explain how energy drinks work. Most such drinks supply glucose at an appropriate concentration to be absorbed through the stomach wall almost immediately. This is because glucose is a small carbohydrate molecule and does not have to be broken down into smaller molecules before it can be absorbed into the blood. Other more complex carbohydrates do require digestion before absorption and are better for longer-term energy supply. More sophisticated sports drinks contain complex mixtures of different-sized carbohydrate molecules, designed to match the energy requirements of the athlete and nature of the sport.
2 The National Strategies Secondary Task 10: Try this as an alternative! You can look quickly at items 1 to 4 below, which may represent a fairly typical start to this topic, but you may want to spend more time on items 5 to 9, which focus on the role of molecule size within digestion. The true/false cards and the Predicting the digestion of starch task are intended for pupil use. 1. The topic can be introduced in the usual way. For example: drawing a life-size body on paper (e.g. wallpaper) and adding internal organs and labels check size and position of organs with textbook teach names of the parts (oesophagus, stomach, small intestine, etc.) and other key words, with careful pronunciation and other vocabulary strategies. 2. Ask pupils to think about the possible process of digestion and to suggest how food is digested. Scaffold their answers suggesting the framework: first, then, next, etc. 3. Ask pupils to find out the role of enzymes in the digestion of food using standard textbooks as a source of reference. 4. Use the Digestion true or false? cards as a card sort activity. Then take just the true cards and sort them into an approximate sequence to represent the process of digestion. There is more than one possible sequence. These could be attached to appropriate places on a wall poster if one is displayed. Invite faster workers to explain the mistakes in the false cards. Cards 1, 6, 9, 10, 11, 13 and 16 are the deliberately false statements. 5. Ask pupils to explain why enzymes are needed for digestion. Scaffold their answers by giving them the root Enzymes are needed in the process of digestion because Review their answers. How will you test to show that this has happened? 6. Once pupils are clear about their explanation, introduce the visking tubing experiment. Get them to predict what will happen and why. What do you know about the connection between glucose and starch? What do you know about the action of enzymes (amylase) on starch? What do you know about the visking tubing walls? What do you expect to happen? 7. Alternatively, you could use the Predicting the digestion of starch diagram labelling exercise as a group work activity. 8. Pupils can now carry out the visking tubing practical with a greater certainty of understanding the purpose and details of the practical work and how this is a model of digestion. 9. It is possible for pupils to model the process of digestion on a larger scale (see following page). 00587-2009PDF-EN-16 Crown copyright 2009
3 How to model the process of digestion on a larger scale
4 The National Strategies Secondary Digestion true or false? 1 The food molecules that get through the gut wall get passed out of your body when you go to the toilet. 2 Enzymes help break down large food molecules into smaller molecules. 3 Enzymes such as amylase in saliva start breaking down the starch in potato as you chew it. 4 Many food molecules are large and need to be broken down into smaller molecules. 5 In the large intestine water is extracted from the soup to leave a more solid waste. 6 Starch molecules are much smaller than molecules of sugars such as glucose. 7 The food and liquid is churned up to make a liquid like soup. 8 As the mashed-up food goes along the small intestine small molecules can get through the intestine wall. 9 In the stomach all the goodness is removed from the food to leave just waste. 10 Chewing protein molecules breaks them up into small molecules. 11 Enzymes in the human body work best at a temperature of 87 C. 12 The food molecules that get through the gut wall are picked up by the blood supply and carried round the body. 13 As the mashed-up food goes along the small intestine big molecules of starch can get through the intestine wall. 14 More digestive juices are added to the food in the stomach. 15 Only some molecules are able to go through the gut wall. 16 Enzymes are powerful acids that break down other chemicals. 00587-2009PDF-EN-16 Crown copyright 2009
5 Predicting the digestion of starch Draw arrows from each label to the correct part of the diagram Tap water Starch, water and amylase (enzyme) This will turn dark blue with iodine This is like the food inside the intestine This is like a piece of intestine At 37 o C, like body temperature The small molecules can get through the wall of the tubing This represents the blood supply This now contains water and sugars The enzyme is breaking down the starch into sugars This will go brown with Benedict s test This won t change colour with iodine Now consider the three suggested models to show digestion on a larger scale drawing; bead model; wet model. Are any of these three models suitable for use when you teach this topic? Be sure to consider the strengths and limitations of any model you might think of adopting (or you currently use). Are there any other advantages to this suggested approach which you might adopt?