Brainwaves feature classification by applying K-Means clustering using single-sensor EEG

Similar documents
Principal component analysis implementation for brainwave signal reduction based on cognitive activity

On the Use of Brainprints as Passwords

Quick detection of QRS complexes and R-waves using a wavelet transform and K-means clustering

A Brain Computer Interface System For Auto Piloting Wheelchair

MATERIALS AND METHODS In order to perform the analysis of the EEG signals associated with the imagination of actions, in this

NeuroSky s esense Meters and Detection of Mental State

Northeast Center for Special Care Grant Avenue Lake Katrine, NY

Classification of EEG signals in an Object Recognition task

MUSIC is important for people because it pleasure

Empirical Mode Decomposition based Feature Extraction Method for the Classification of EEG Signal

The impact of numeration on visual attention during a psychophysical task; An ERP study

Analysis of EEG Signal for the Detection of Brain Abnormalities

Selection of Feature for Epilepsy Seizer Detection Using EEG

COMPARING EEG SIGNALS AND EMOTIONS PROVOKED BY IMAGES WITH DIFFERENT AESTHETIC VARIABLES USING EMOTIVE INSIGHT AND NEUROSKY MINDWAVE

Restoring Communication and Mobility

Enhancement of Twins Fetal ECG Signal Extraction Based on Hybrid Blind Extraction Techniques

ISSN: (Online) Volume 3, Issue 7, July 2015 International Journal of Advance Research in Computer Science and Management Studies

Development of Biofeedback System Adapting EEG and Evaluation of its Response Quality

An Overview of BMIs. Luca Rossini. Workshop on Brain Machine Interfaces for Space Applications

Novel single trial movement classification based on temporal dynamics of EEG

ERP Feature of Vigilance. Zhendong Mu

COMPARATIVE STUDY ON FEATURE EXTRACTION METHOD FOR BREAST CANCER CLASSIFICATION

Development of 2-Channel Eeg Device And Analysis Of Brain Wave For Depressed Persons

Emotion Detection Using Physiological Signals. M.A.Sc. Thesis Proposal Haiyan Xu Supervisor: Prof. K.N. Plataniotis

Brain Computer Interface. Mina Mikhail

DISCRETE WAVELET PACKET TRANSFORM FOR ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM- BASED EMOTION RECOGNITION IN THE VALENCE-AROUSAL SPACE

WAVELET ENERGY DISTRIBUTIONS OF P300 EVENT-RELATED POTENTIALS FOR WORKING MEMORY PERFORMANCE IN CHILDREN

A Pilot Study on Emotion Recognition System Using Electroencephalography (EEG) Signals

DATA MANAGEMENT & TYPES OF ANALYSES OFTEN USED. Dennis L. Molfese University of Nebraska - Lincoln

ANALYSIS OF BRAIN SIGNAL FOR THE DETECTION OF EPILEPTIC SEIZURE

Emotion Detection from EEG signals with Continuous Wavelet Analyzing

Improved Intelligent Classification Technique Based On Support Vector Machines

Speed - Accuracy - Exploration. Pathfinder SL

This is a repository copy of Facial Expression Classification Using EEG and Gyroscope Signals.

High-Accuracy User Identification Using EEG Biometrics

Assessment of Reliability of Hamilton-Tompkins Algorithm to ECG Parameter Detection

Mental State Recognition by using Brain Waves

What is EEG Neurofeedback?

Grand Challenges in. EEG based Brain-Computer Interface. Shangkai Gao. Dept. of Biomedical Engineering Tsinghua University, Beijing, China

Removing ECG Artifact from the Surface EMG Signal Using Adaptive Subtraction Technique

Facial Expression Biometrics Using Tracker Displacement Features

Error Detection based on neural signals

Simultaneous Real-Time Detection of Motor Imagery and Error-Related Potentials for Improved BCI Accuracy

ERP Components and the Application in Brain-Computer Interface

Neurostyle. Medical Innovation for Better Life

FREQUENCY DOMAIN BASED AUTOMATIC EKG ARTIFACT

Analysis of the Effect of Cell Phone Radiation on the Human Brain Using Electroencephalogram

Classification of People using Eye-Blink Based EOG Peak Analysis.

Computational Neuroscience. Instructor: Odelia Schwartz

Detecting emotion from EEG signals using the emotive epoc device

Segmentation of Tumor Region from Brain Mri Images Using Fuzzy C-Means Clustering And Seeded Region Growing

CHAPTER 6 INTERFERENCE CANCELLATION IN EEG SIGNAL

An Edge-Device for Accurate Seizure Detection in the IoT

A Study of Smartphone Game Users through EEG Signal Feature Analysis

Passthoughts on the Go: Effect of Exercise on EEG Authentication (Extended Version)

Physiology Unit 2 CONSCIOUSNESS, THE BRAIN AND BEHAVIOR

Neuro Approach to Examine Behavioral Competence: An Application of Visible Mind-Wave Measurement on Work Performance

Implementation of Image Processing and Classification Techniques on EEG Images for Emotion Recognition System

Heart Abnormality Detection Technique using PPG Signal

Human Emotions Identification and Recognition Using EEG Signal Processing

Detection and Plotting Real Time Brain Waves

Minimum Feature Selection for Epileptic Seizure Classification using Wavelet-based Feature Extraction and a Fuzzy Neural Network

Working Memory Impairments Limitations of Normal Children s in Visual Stimuli using Event-Related Potentials

Vital Responder: Real-time Health Monitoring of First- Responders

Biomedical Research 2013; 24 (3): ISSN X

INVESTIGATING THE IMPACT

Heart Rate Calculation by Detection of R Peak

Physiology Unit 2 CONSCIOUSNESS, THE BRAIN AND BEHAVIOR

Preliminary Study of EEG-based Brain Computer Interface Systems for Assisted Mobility Applications

sensors ISSN

Testing the Accuracy of ECG Captured by Cronovo through Comparison of ECG Recording to a Standard 12-Lead ECG Recording Device

The Application of Music Therapy For Children with Autism Based On Facial Recognition Using Eigenface Method

Automatic Detection of Heart Disease Using Discreet Wavelet Transform and Artificial Neural Network

ABSTRACT 1. INTRODUCTION 2. ARTIFACT REJECTION ON RAW DATA

Modifying the Classic Peak Picking Technique Using a Fuzzy Multi Agent to Have an Accurate P300-based BCI

Event Related Potentials: Significant Lobe Areas and Wave Forms for Picture Visual Stimulus

DETECTION AND CORRECTION OF EYE BLINK ARTIFACT IN SINGLE CHANNEL ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM (EEG) SIGNAL USING A SIMPLE k-means CLUSTERING ALGORITHM

Toward a noninvasive automatic seizure control system with transcranial focal stimulations via tripolar concentric ring electrodes

PCA Enhanced Kalman Filter for ECG Denoising

Unsupervised MRI Brain Tumor Detection Techniques with Morphological Operations

International Journal of Advance Engineering and Research Development EARLY DETECTION OF GLAUCOMA USING EMPIRICAL WAVELET TRANSFORM

A Survey on Localizing Optic Disk

arxiv: v1 [cs.lg] 4 Feb 2019

Automatic Detection of Epileptic Seizures in EEG Using Machine Learning Methods

Electroencephalography (EEG) based automatic Seizure Detection and Prediction Using DWT

Hybrid EEG-HEG based Neurofeedback Device

Statistical analysis of epileptic activities based on histogram and wavelet-spectral entropy

COMPUTER AIDED DIAGNOSTIC SYSTEM FOR BRAIN TUMOR DETECTION USING K-MEANS CLUSTERING

A Sleeping Monitor for Snoring Detection

Patients EEG Data Analysis via Spectrogram Image with a Convolution Neural Network

PHYSIOLOGICAL RESEARCH

AVR Based Gesture Vocalizer Using Speech Synthesizer IC

Cancer Cells Detection using OTSU Threshold Algorithm

HST 583 fmri DATA ANALYSIS AND ACQUISITION

Neurofeedback for ASD AND ADHD

EEG-Based Brain Computer Interface System for Cursor Control Velocity Regression with Recurrent Neural Network

A Review Study of Brian Activity-Based Biometric Authentication

EEG based analysis and classification of human emotions is a new and challenging field that has gained momentum in the

Neuro Q no.2 = Neuro Quotient

Transcription:

International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics ISSN: 2442-6571 167 Brainwaves feature classification by applying K-Means clustering using single-sensor EEG Ahmad Azhari a,1,*, Leonel Hernandez b,2 a Informatics Department, Universitas Ahmad Dahlan, Indonesia b Institucion Universitaria ITSA, Colombia 1 ahmad.azhari@tif.uad.ac.id *; 2 lhernandezc@itsa.edu.co * corresponding author ARTICLE INFO Article history: Received November 20, 2016 Revised November 28, 2016 Accepted November 28, 2016 Keywords: EEG Brainwaves Cognitive Task Kmeans Clustering AB ST R ACT The use of brainwave signal is a step in the introduction of the individual identity using biometric technology based on characteristics of the body. Brainwave signal has unique characteristics and different on each individual because the brainwave cannot be read or copied by people so it is not possible to have a similarity of one person with another person. To be able to process the identification of individual characteristics, which obtained from the signal brainwave, required a pattern of brain activity that is prominent and constant. Cognitive activity testing using a single-sensor EEG (Electroencephalogram) divided into two categories, called the activity of cognitive involving the ability of the right brain (creativity, imagination, holistic thinking, intuition, arts, rhythms, nonverbal, feelings, visualization, tune of songs, daydreaming) and the left brain (logic, analysis, sequences, linear, mathematics, language, facts, think in words, word of songs, computation) give a different cluster based on two times the test on mathematical activities (no cluster slices of experiment 1 and experiment 2). The result showed that cognitive activity based on math activity can provide a signal characteristic that can be used as the basis for a brain-computer interface applications development by utilizing EEG single-sensor. Copyright 2016 International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics. All rights reserved. I. Introduction The brainwaves signal has different typical and characteristic of the individual, brainwaves can not be imitated or read by people so it is not possible to have similarity. Identity recognition is necessary to distinguish the characteristics of an individual. Introduction to identity aims to recognize the identity of the person appropriately. Development of the introduction of identity is done using biometrics technology that aims to do self-introduction by using parts of the body or human behavior. Identity recognition development is done using biometric technology to self-recognition by using parts of the body or human behavior. The use of brainwaves signal is one example of identity recognition using biometric technology based on body parts. The use of EEG for identification evolves with the rapid development of science in the field of biomedicine [1] [11], While the use of EEG for security authentication progressed due to the development of image processing in the field of biometrics [12], [13]. The use of brainwaves as a medium for authenticating users has several advantages over other biometric authentication systems such as fingerprints or iris scans, since brainwaves and minds can not be read by others [13]. Reference [12] mentioned that the latest biometrics technology is the emergence of cognitive (cognitive biometrics), i.e. the technology biometrics obtained based on the specific response of the human brain as a trigger, the response, in this case, arises from the cognitive aspect of brainwaves caused by granting some of tasks which stimulate the cognitive response of the brain. Characteristics of brainwaves become very strong when a person is exposed to specific stimuli. The signal measured by the frequency of brainwaves and differentiated based on recording time. To record and measure DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.26555/ijain.v2i3.86 W : http://ijain.org E : info@ijain.org

168 International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics ISSN: 2442-6571 the activity of brainwaves required EEG which is designed to acquire, process, and editor of brain signals in the waveform or another form [2]. The increasing availability of wireless devices with a varied number of EEG sensor deployment and possible use of EEG device repeatedly without the risks and the limitations of using non-invasive methods to be attractive to be developed as a medium for self-identity recognition. To recognize the patterns of brain activity is automatically required EEG signal pattern recognition. The selection method of EEG signal pattern recognition precisely specifies the information to be obtained and specific form of EEG signals [14]. II. Related Work Research on identity recognition using EEG signal much done either in Indonesia and other countries. Klonovs et. al. conducted a study which aims to develop a mobile systems extraction characteristics and classification biometric authentication using EEG. The basis of this study is gaps between mobile web technology and EEG wireless equipment. Brainwaves measurement using the Emotiv Epoc EEG headset used 14 sensors. The research procedure used three tests component, memory based test, visualization test and stimuli based test. The signal is processed and separated from components contaminated by artifacts using blind source separation (BSS) method to get the main components that will be used for feature extraction. The feature extraction in this study using a zero-crossing rate (ZCR), coherence, power spectral density (PSD), cross correlation, wavelet transforms, and latencies. The results showed that there is a difference between different subjects based on the electric potential of biomedical obtained from statistical analysis that is mean and histogram. The most significant methods capable of indicating the typical feature of each individual is zero-crossing rate (ZCR) method, but the result is not so efficient therefor it takes more complex analysis techniques such as power spectral density (PSD) and wavelet analysis. PSD analysis retrieved the similarities in the histogram obtained from spectrogram image. The use of wavelet analysis can be used to measure the potential latency which was resurrected from the visual tests in the occipital lobe area [13]. Hong Bao using blind source separation (BSS) method for mental condition detection. This study aims to separate artifacts or noise from EEG data obtained from the EEG that uses many sensors (multi-channel). Other methods are also used to separate the signal from the artifacts such as event related potential (ERP), analysis of variance (ANOVA), and comparison method using Tukey-kramer. In this study feature extraction conducted by obtaining the average value of the amplitude, the average value of the power frequency, ratio frequency, and the correlation coefficient. As for the classification obtained using linear regression method, cross-validation, rank accuracy, significance, false discovery rate, class size imbalance, and resampling. By providing some tasks on individual the result shows that a classification with an accuracy of 31% for adults, 35% of adults and children together, and 24% for children [15]. III. Methodology A. Data Collection Data collection is conducted through data acquisition method that retrieves biometrics data from some people and process it into a signal for the following process. Data collection was performed using an EEG NeuroSky Mindset headset with a single sensor. Electrodes are placed in the FP1 position (frontal temporal) in of the skull or frontal lobe position. The process of EEG signals data retrieval process is done gradually and separately with 6 subjects with each subject performed two times data retrieval using a sampling frequency of 128 Hz per second and generate 2,560 data along for 20 seconds. EEG signals are generated from the stimulus in the form of cognitive tasks. There are nine types of cognitive tasks that used in EEG data collection process namely breath color, face, fingers, counting, objects, passthrough, singing, and sports. In this research, nine types of cognitive task were used to be based on previous research [14], [16] [18]. The whole task is based on psychological perceptions to get the imaginative and cognitive responses of the brain. The nine types of cognitive task are described below, each task in terms of its instructions for the subjects. 1. Breathing Task (Breath)

ISSN: 2442-6571 International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics 169 Subject closes the eyes and focuses on breathing for 20 seconds without the slightest movement of the limbs. 2. Object Counting Color Task (Color) Subjects are given the task of viewing the colors that appear on the screen and the subject is asked to remember the color and reapply the color column on the screen, this task lasts for 20 seconds silently. 3. Simulated Movement Finger (Finger) Subjects are asked to close their eyes and focus on simulating as if moving a finger without actually moving a finger for 20 seconds. 4. Simulated Facial Reconstruction (Face) The subject reconstructs a person's face in detail for 20 seconds, without making a sound and moving the limbs. 5. Simulated Object Reconstruction (Object) Subjects are given time to look at objects in detail then subjects are asked to close their eyes and focus to reconstruct the object in detail for 20 seconds without the slightest move the limbs. 6. Mathematical Counting Task (Math) The subject is given a matter of calculating the simple two-numbered multiplication, and solving the problem silently. For example: 15 x 16. The time given is 20 seconds. False and True is ignored in this task. 7. Simulated Password Recall Task (Pass-thought) The subject makes a sentence in the form of a combination of letters and numbers and subjects are asked to close their eyes and imagine the sentence for 10 seconds. 8. Song Recitation Task (Song) Subjects imagine for 20 seconds a song or sound with lyrics, without actually making a sound and moving the limbs. 9. Simulated Sport Task (Sport) The subject chooses a favorable sporting movement then the subject is asked to close his eyes and imagine in the mind of the exercise movement without actually moving the limbs. This task is done for 20 seconds. B. Signal Processing In terms of signal processing, biometric data is obtained from the result of the data collection using EEG will be grouped by subject, cognitive task, and time data collection. Furthermore, the data will be feature extraction which aims to get the characteristics differences that represent the main characteristics of the signal. The extraction performed by mean, standard deviation skewness, kurtosis, and entropy. Mean measure of data distribution, standard deviation measures variations of data distribution, skewness measures the asymmetric level of data distribution, kurtosis measures how flat or high the distribution of data is to a normal distribution, and entropy is used to measure the randomness of the data distribution. If mean (x ), standard deviation (σ), skewness (s), kurtosis (k), entropy (H) has the sum of data N and x i is pixel data i then color moment can be calculated by equation (1-5). mean = x = 1 N x N i=0 i standard deviation = σ = 1 N (x (N 1) i=0 i x ) 2 skewness = s = N i=0 (x i x ) 3 (Nσ 3 )

170 International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics ISSN: 2442-6571 kurtosis = k = N i=0 (x i x ) 4 (Nσ 4 ) N entropy = H = E[ log 2 P(x)] = i=0 P(x)log 2 P(x) bits C. Data Matching Data matching is conducted through K-Means clustering. The results will be grouped into K clusters (Fig. 1). Fig. 1. K-Means Clustering Flowchart There are steps stages in performing data matching using the K-Means clustering: a. The first step is to determine the number of clusters to be formed. b. The second step is initialization point of the cluster (centroid) randomly from a set of data to be grouped. c. The third step is to calculate the distance of any data to each centroid using Euclidean distance. d. The fourth stage is to choose the shortest distance between each data with the centroid. e. The fifth step is to determine the position of new centroid by calculating the average of data in the same centroid. f. The sixth step is to make sure the algorithm converged with data in the new centroid same with the initial centroid. If the two centroids have the same data then the process end. If not, back to step 3.

ISSN: 2442-6571 International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics 171 IV. Results Preliminary data obtained from the EEG will be extracted to produce characteristics. The results of the feature extraction are the value of the mean, the value of standard deviation, the value of skewness, the value of kurtosis, and the value of entropy. The results grouped by subject, cognitive task, and time data retrieval. Extraction of characteristic results data will then be performed against the data normalization and divided into 4 clusters using K- Means Clustering. After the specified number of cluster, the next step is to determine the initial focal point centroid randomly. Initialization centroid can be seen in Table 1. Table 1. Initialization Centroid Cluster Centroid Value 1 0.0395 2 0.8661 3 0.1242 4 0.2785 The next step is to determine the shortest distance between each data center point of each centroid. Determining the distance using the Euclidean method by selecting the closest distance or minimum value. The data is then grouped and distinguished by a cluster. Steps end when the data on the new centroid equal to data on the old centroid. Data clustering results can be shown in Table 2. Data in the same cluster group can be grouped and summed. The result of grouping data in a cluster shown in Table 3. Table 2. The result of grouping data in the cluster Cluster Centroid Sum 1 0.04 24 2 0.87 2 3 0.12 24 4 0.29 4 From the calculation results obtained four cluster groups. The first cluster has a cluster center at point 0.04 with the amount of same data 24 people. The second cluster, there are two people who have same data with a central cluster at the point of 0.87. The third cluster there are 24 people who have same data with a central cluster at the point of 0.12. The fourth cluster has a central cluster at the point of 0.29 with four people. Tests of cognitive activity using a single-sensor EEG performed in this study is divided into two categories, namely the activity of cognitive involving the ability of the right brain (creativity, imagination, holistic thinking, intuition, arts, rhythms, nonverbal, feelings, visualization, tune of songs, daydreaming) and left brain (logic, analysis, sequencing, linear, mathematics, language, facts, think in words, word of songs, computation). Based on research that has been conducted by three research subjects in two tests showed that mental activity involving the right brain's cognitive abilities (color, sing, sport). That can be shown in Table 3 and Fig. 2. Table 3. Clustering Result Subject Experiment 1 'Breath' 'Color' 'Face' 'Finger' 'Math' 'Object' 'PassThought' 'Sing' 'Sport' TesterA 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 TesterB 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 1 3 TesterC 3 3 3 2 3 4 1 1 3 Experiment 2 Subject 'Breath' 'Color' 'Face' 'Finger' 'Math' 'Object' 'PassThought' 'Sing' 'Sport' TesterA 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 TesterB 3 3 3 3 2 3 1 3 3 TesterC 1 3 2 3 4 2 1 1 3

172 International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics ISSN: 2442-6571 Fig. 2. Visualization of Clustering result Cognitive activity "color" and the sport yield identical clusters of each subject in the two trials. Activities breath, finger, and object value consistent cluster in two trials, but only on the subject 1 and 2. While passtought activity, and sing give a consistent cluster in the two trials, only on the subject 1 and 3. Likewise with finger activity, which only gives consistent results on the subject 1. Activities math, is the only activity that provides different cluster results in two trials (no slices cluster of experiment 1 and experiment 2). V. Conclusion From the results of this study can be concluded that cognitive activity "Math" can provide signal characteristics that can be used as the basis of application development of brain computer interface by utilizing single sensors EEG using clustering method K-Means. References [1] I. Jayarathne, M. Cohen, and S. Amarakeerthi, BrainID: Development of an EEG-based biometric authentication system, in Information Technology, Electronics and Mobile Communication Conference (IEMCON), 2016 IEEE 7th Annual, 2016, pp. 1 6. [2] A. A. Ghodake and S. D. Shelke, Brain controlled home automation system, in Intelligent Systems and Control (ISCO), 2016 10th International Conference on, 2016, pp. 1 4. [3] Z. Pang, J. Li, H. Ji, and M. Li, A new approach for EEG feature extraction for detecting error-related potentials, in Progress in Electromagnetic Research Symposium (PIERS), 2016, pp. 3595 3597. [4] J. Katona, I. Farkas, T. Ujbanyi, P. Dukan, and A. Kovari, Evaluation of the NeuroSky MindFlex EEG headset brain waves data, in Applied Machine Intelligence and Informatics (SAMI), 2014 IEEE 12th International Symposium on, 2014, pp. 91 94.

ISSN: 2442-6571 International Journal of Advances in Intelligent Informatics 173 [5] B. Trowbridge, C. Rodriguez, J. Prine, M. Holzemer, J. McCormack, and R. Integlia, Gaming, fitness, and relaxation, in Games Entertainment Media Conference (GEM), 2015 IEEE, 2015, pp. 1 1. [6] M. Varela, Raw EEG signal processing for BCI control based on voluntary eye blinks, in 2015 IEEE Thirty Fifth Central American and Panama Convention (CONCAPAN XXXV), 2015, pp. 1 6. [7] Y. Yoshimura et al., The Brain s Response to the Human Voice Depends on the Incidence of Autistic Traits in the General Population, PLoS One, vol. 8, no. 11, p. e80126, Nov. 2013. [8] D. Bright, A. Nair, D. Salvekar, and S. Bhisikar, EEG-based brain controlled prosthetic arm, in Advances in Signal Processing (CASP), Conference on, 2016, pp. 479 483. [9] A. Patil, C. Deshmukh, and A. R. Panat, Feature extraction of EEG for emotion recognition using Hjorth features and higher order crossings, in Advances in Signal Processing (CASP), Conference on, 2016, pp. 429 434. [10] M. Diykh, Y. Li, and P. Wen, EEG Sleep Stages Classification Based on Time Domain Features and Structural Graph Similarity, IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng., vol. 24, no. 11, pp. 1159 1168, Nov. 2016. [11] A. Azhari, A. Susanto, and I. Soesanti, Studi Perbandingan: Cognitive Task Berdasarkan Hasil Ekstraksi Ciri Gelombang Otak.pdf, 2015, vol. 3.1, p. 7. [12] D. Putra and K. Gede, Sistem Verifikasi Biometrika Telapak Tangan dengan Metode Dimensi Fraktal dan Lacunarity, Maj. Ilm. Teknol. Elektro, vol. 8, no. 2, 2012. [13] J. Klonovs, C. K. Petersen, H. Olesen, and J. S. Poulsen, Development of a Mobile EEG-Based Feature Extraction and Classification System for Biometric Authentication, Aalborg University Copenhagen, 2012. [14] A. Azhari, Ekstraksi Ciri Gelombang Otak Menggunakan Alat Neurosky Mindset Berbasis Korelasi Silang.pdf, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Yogyakarta, 2015. [15] B. H. Tan, Using a low-cost eeg sensor to detect mental states, Carnegie Mellon University, 2012. [16] B. Johnson, T. Maillart, and J. Chuang, My thoughts are not your thoughts, 2014, pp. 1329 1338. [17] A. Saha, A. Konar, P. Das, B. Sen Bhattacharya, and A. K. Nagar, Data-point and feature selection of motor imagery EEG signals for neural classification of cognitive tasks in car-driving, in 2015 International Joint Conference on Neural Networks (IJCNN), 2015, pp. 1 8. [18] R. Zafar, A. S. Malik, H. U. Amin, N. Kamel, S. Dass, and R. F. Ahmad, EEG spectral analysis during complex cognitive task at occipital, in Biomedical Engineering and Sciences (IECBES), 2014 IEEE Conference on, 2014, pp. 907 910.