PRECISION (PERSONALIZED) NUTRITION ttitle OF TALK STEVEN H. ZEISEL M.D., Ph.D. Professor of Nutrition and Pediatrics University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Director, UNC Nutrition Research Institute We assume people are average steven_zeisel@unc.edu But we should assume that there are groups that differ in requirements People have different microbes in their gut (microbiome) These microbes see food often before we do and metabolize it. GENETIC VARIATION Epigenetics Marks on genes that retune metabolism. Single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) Many of us have variations in our genetic code. SNPs are mistakes that occur in at least 1% of the population. It is estimated that each of us has 50,000 such gene mistakes. 1
MICROBIOME, EPIGENETICS OR SNPS CAN RESULT IN INEFFICIENT METABOLISM Metabolism MUST ALSO HAVE DIET INFO TO ID NUTRITIONALLY RELEVANT MODULATORS Metabolism MICROBIOME, EPIGENETICS OR SNP Microbiome, epigenetics or SNP Diet The catalog of SNPs, epigenetic marks and microbiomes that change nutrient requirements will be the basis for practicing precision nutrition. Also important for diminishing variability in nutrition research Responders vs. nonresponders test diet Rx Precision Medicine Genetic test now required before treating a patient with the blood thinner Warfarin. HOW WILL PRECISION NUTRITION WORK? Personalized dosing based on a gene test is needed so that you aren t over- or under-dosed. From: www.sidra.org/ 2
Precision nutrition Gene variants can predict whether you drink > 4 cups of coffee and get a buzz when you drink coffee. Gene/SNP Allele spelling Africans Asians Caucasians CYP1A2 rs2472297 T >4cups C 2% 98% 0% 100% 23% 77% Predicting roadblocks in metabolism using genetic testing and then providing individualized nutrition advice. AHR Rs4410790 ADORA2A rs5751867 T C >4cups T C sensitive 53% 44% 66% 34% 63% 37% 49% 51% 37% 63% 39% 61% Renda et al. (2012). AJCN, 95(1):241 8. Yang et al. Psychopharm., 211(3):245 57 Heart attack and hypertension more likely if you are a slow metabolizer of caffeine and drink >4 cups/day. Fast metabolizers are not at risk. People with MTHFR SNPs need 10% more folate rs1801133 rs1801131 Gene/SNP CYP1A2 7625517 Allele spelling A fast C slow Africans Asians Caucasians 56% 67% 68% 44% 33% 32% Cornelius et al (2006) JAMA 295:1135 1141 Palatini et al (2009) Hypertension 27:1594 1601 Genotype and vitamin C ORs for being GSTM1 null, by quartile (Q) of serum vitamin C GSTs are a family of phase 2 enzymes that detoxify both naturally occurring and xenobiotic compounds by catalyzing the transfer and conjugation of glutathione to the molecule. GSTM1 gene is deleted in 50% of the human population. The concentration of serum vitamin C is higher in GSTM1 0 genotype Gladys Block et al. Am J Clin Nutr 2011;94:929-937 From Biomarkers in Medicine 2016 4:403-415 3
FTO polymorphisms effect on BMI risk is dependent on SFA The fat mass and obesityassociated gene (FTO) identified in GWAS as increasing risk for obesity. GOLDN study Rs9939609 17% AA BPRHS study Rs1121980 16% TT Dolores Corella et al. J. Nutr. 2011;141:2219-2225 ID people with metabolic bottlenecks due to SNPs and develop Rx to bypass problems Metabolism Medical Food formulated based on genetic roadblocks identified provides specific nutrients (metabolites) needed to bypass metabolic roadblocks People with health problem (e.g., fatty liver) test Has genetic roadblocks Medical Food Rx Resolved health problem (e.g., fatty liver) SNP signature Medical food No genetic roadblock Fatty liver is associated with metabolic syndrome and with increased risk for liver cancer Fatty liver occurs in many people when they become overweight or obese (75-100 million people in US). 4
Calories Fatty Liver Store fat in liver Export fat to tissues Characteristic gene signature in pathways that mediate export of fat. NAFLD PREDICTED BY SNP SIGNATURE 20 genes in 1-carbon, FA transport, FA synthesis pathways FASEB J. 2013 27:1674 89 Fatty liver Lowest Highest Group Group 0 1 Variant alleles 2 SNPs and SPERM DYSFUNCTION Deletion of Chdh results in poorly motile sperm % progressively motile sperm 80 60 40 20 0 *** CHDH+/+ CHDH+/- CHDH-/- FASEB J. 2014 28:2970 8. +/+ +/ / FASEB J. 2010; 24:2752-2761 Deletion of Chdh results in dysmorphic mitochondria +/+ / Deletion of Chdh results in low ATP % of Chdh ++ 150 100 50 [ATP] * Chdh+/+ Chdh+/ Chdh / 0 FASEB J.2010;24:2752-2761 FASEB J. 2010;24:2752-2761 5
Betaine restores ATP Men with CHDH rs12676 G233T X Chdh No betaine +betaine from FASEB Journal 24:2752 2761, 2010 CHDH rs12676 G233T have dysmorphic mitochondria CHDH rs12676 G233T have low ATP CHDH PLoS One. 2012;7::e36047. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0036047 PLoS One. 2012;7:e36047. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0036047 Europe Mexico Africa GG GT TT Need more choline rs12676 CHDH G T Asia NUTRITION CLINICAL STUDIES NEED TO BE ENHANCED BY NUTRIGENETICS Young women half need to eat choline, half don t. Mixed together large variation in data. Fatty liver versus muscle damage response to low choline. Mixed together confusing. Sperm dysfunction in men. 6
NGx studies can identify people with different requirements for a nutrient NUTRITION RESEARCH CAN BE ENHANCED BY NUTRIGENETICS When a nutrition intervention seems to identify a subset of responders: Identify genetic variants in responders and nonresponders. Helps reduce noise in study. Foundation of precision nutrition. Also important for diminishing variability in nutrition research Responders vs. nonresponders test diet Rx NUTRITION CLINICAL STUDIES NEED TO BE ENHANCED BY NUTRIGENETICS Young women half need to eat choline, half don t. Mixed together large variation in data. Fatty liver versus muscle damage response to low choline. Mixed together confusing. Sperm dysfunction in men. www.uncnri.org steven_zeisel@unc.edu 500 LAUREATE WAY KANNAPOLIS, NC 28081 WWW.UNCNRI.ORG 704-250-5000 7