U.S. Department of Justice Office of Justice Programs Presented by E. Ann Carson and Margaret Noonan Statisticians Corrections Unit Aging and mortality in the state prison population BUREAU OF JUSTICE STATISTICS
U.S. Department of Justice Office of Justice Programs Presented by E. Ann Carson Statistician Corrections Unit Aging of the state prison population, 1993-2013 BUREAU OF JUSTICE STATISTICS
Disclosure I have no actual or potential conflict of interest in relation to this presentation. 3
Presentation outline How has the age of the state prison population changed over time? What is contributing to the change in the age distribution of the state prison population? Admissions Stock population What are the implications of an older prison population? 4
50000 State prisoners sentenced to more than one year by age, December 31, 1993, 2003, 2013 45000 40000 35000 30000 25000 20000 1993 2003 2013 15000 10000 5000 0 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70 72 74 Source: National Corrections Reporting Program data tool 5
6
Reasons for an increase in older offenders in the prison population More older persons are being admitted Aging U.S. population Arrest rate of older persons Higher admission rate given arrest Older persons serving longer periods of time Offense distribution Criminal history Enhanced sentences 7
8
Age distribution, U.S. resident and prison populations, December 31, 1993, 2003, 2013 Sources: BJS, National Corrections Reporting Program data tool, U.S. Census Bureau postcensal estimates 9
10
Percent of age group Percent of age group Sentenced state prisoners admitted for violent and drug offenses, by age, 1993, 2003, 2013 Violent offenses Drug offenses 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 18-29 30-39 40-54 55+ 18-29 30-39 40-54 55+ Age at admission Age at admission 1993 2003 2013 1993 2003 2013 Source: BJS, National Corrections Reporting Program data tool 11
Percent of age group Percent of age group Sentenced state prisoners convicted of violent and drug offenses, by age, 1993, 2003, 2013 Violent offenses Drug offenses 70 70 60 60 50 50 40 40 30 30 20 20 10 10 0 18-29 30-39 40-54 55+ 0 18-29 30-39 40-54 55+ Age on December 31 Age on December 31 1993 2003 2013 1993 2003 2013 Source: BJS, National Corrections Reporting Program data tool 12
Cumulative rearrest rates for released prisoners from 30 states, 2005 Source: BJS, Recidivism of State Prisoners Released in 2005, NCJ 244205; http:///content/pub/pdf/rprts05p0510.pdf Age at prison release Years since prison release All offenses 1 year 5 year 24 or younger 51.3 % 84.1 % 25 29 45.4 80.3 30 34 43.4 77.0 35 39 44.4 78.1 40 or older 37.3 69.2 Violent offenses 1 year 5 year 24 or younger 45.6 % 80.4 % 25 29 39.6 76.7 30 34 38.6 72.0 35 39 42.1 74.0 40 or older 31.5 60.7 Drug offenses 1 year 5 year 24 or younger 50.0 % 85.4 % 25 29 44.3 80.4 30 34 41.2 76.1 35 39 40.7 77.0 40 or older 38.7 71.2 13
Reimprisonment of prisoners released from state prison in 1994, by age at release Percent reimprisoned after -- Age at release 1 year 3 years 20 or younger 16.0 % 35.3 % 21 to 25 12.7 29.8 26 to 30 11.6 28.0 31 to 35 10.3 25.8 36 to 40 10.5 24.5 41 or older 6.7 17.9 Source: BJS Prisoner Recidivism Analysis Tool 1994, http:///index.cfm?ty=datool&surl=/recidivism/index.cfm# 14
Source: A Primer:Three Strikes The impact after more than a decade, Legislative Analyst s Office, October 2005; http://www.lao.ca.gov/2005/3_strikes/3_strikes_102005.htm, accessed 2/29/16 15
Percent of age group serving sentences enhanced under 2 and 3 strikes laws Age at census January, 2010 September 2015 18-19 5.6 % 7.1 % 20-24 11.4 19.7 25-29 17.3 27.2 30-34 22.1 29.5 35-39 27.0 32.6 40-44 30.8 31.3 45-49 34.0 35.9 50-54 33.7 38.8 55-59 31.5 42.5 60 plus 21.3 31.1 Number of offenders 41,009 39,436 Source: California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation Second and Third Striker Felons and monthly population reports, http://www.cdcr.ca.gov/reports_research/index.html, accessed 3/2/2016 16
Implications of an aging prison population Costs From OIG report on federal prisoners: Aging inmates on average cost 8 percent more per inmate to incarcerate than inmates age 49 and younger.. In FY 2013, the average aging inmate cost $24,538 to incarcerate, whereas the average younger inmate cost $22,676. We found that this cost differential is driven by increased medical needs, including the cost of medication, for aging inmates.bop institutions with the highest percentages of aging inmates also spent 14 times more per inmate on medication ($684) than institutions with the lowest percentage ($49). Source: The Impact of an Aging Inmate Population on the Federal Bureau of Prisons, USDOJ Office of the Inspector General, May 2015, https://oig.justice.gov/reports/2015/e1505.pdf 17
Contact information E. Ann Carson Corrections Unit Bureau of Justice Statistics U.S. Department of Justice 202/616.2496 elizabeth.carson@usdoj.gov 18
U.S. Department of Justice Office of Justice Programs Presented by Margaret Noonan Statistician Corrections Unit March 17, 2016 Understand Mortality in State Prison BUREAU OF JUSTICE STATISTICS
2.2 Million Incarcerated State prisons and local jails hold the majority (90%) of the incarcerated population The majority of inmates are male 93% of state prisoners 88% of jail inmates The majority are either White, non-hispanic or Black, non-hispanic White (36% of prisoners; 36% of jail inmates) Black (40% of prisoners; 37% of jail inmates) Most are under the age of 35 49% of prisoners 60% of jail inmates 20
Prison Populations: Admissions, time served and offense Prisons admitted 630,000 sentenced prisoners in 2013 About half of prisoners are violent felons However, prisoners serve about 2 years before being released Most prisoners (95%) are eventually released 21
Deaths in Custody Reporting Program Began in 2000 with the passage of the Death in Custody Act Created the DCRP Reauthorized at the end of 2014 Collects individual level records on inmates who died in the custody of local jails and state prisons Nearly all jails participate (98% annually) All state departments of correction participate 22
DCRP: Death overview Despite the majority of prison and jail inmates serving their time without incident, a small proportion of inmates die annually Approximately 3,000 state prisoners Prisoners and jail inmates have different mortality profiles The majority (90%) of prisoner deaths are natural Cancer and heart disease are the top two causes of death 23
DCRP: Inmate and resident mortality Despite having an estimated biological age that is 10 years beyond the chronological age of the inmate, inmates have a lower mortality rate than the resident population. Prisoners: 274 per 100,000 Jail Inmates: 135 per 100,000 U.S. residents: 822 per 100,000 Risk factors limited for prisoners Firearms, automobiles Inmate movement is controlled Demographic differences Age is the largest contributor 24
Race-Hispanic Origin Distributions in State Prison and U.S. Resident Population, 2007 2012 Sources: National Corrections Reporting Program, National Prisoner Statistics Program, NCHS WONDER 25
What effect would a standardization have? BJS had previously done small-scale standardizations for prisons and jails State prisoner mortality rate was 19% lower than the resident population White and Hispanic death rates were slightly higher than their resident population counterparts Black, non-hispanic prisoners were 57% less likely to die than their resident population counterparts The jail standardization was limited to suicides and found that if the resident population resembled the jail population, the suicide rate in the resident population would increase 26
Most recent standardization project BJS established that adjusting for known demographic differences between the correctional population and the U.S. resident population reduced the mortality gap between residents and inmates. However, the earlier work was limited in scope Prisons overall mortality, e.g. not studied by cause Jails limited to suicides BJS decided to revisit the topic with the Understanding Mortality in State Prison: Do Male Prisoners Have an Elevated Risk of Death paper, which was published in Justice Research and Policy 27
Understand Mortality in State Prison paper The paper was limited to state prisoners and to males State prisoners account for more than half of the incarcerated population in the U.S. On average, state prisoner deaths account for 71% of deaths in incarcerated populations As a result, there is a larger number of cases to work with when looking at deaths by cause Between 2001-2010, there were 45,539 prisoner deaths v. 10,010 jail inmate deaths 28
Decedent characteristics 29
Understanding Mortality : Methods To address the mortality differential between inmates and the U.S. resident population, BJS compared the two populations after adjusting for known differences Adjusted for Sex Race/Ethnicity Age Excluded MVA deaths in the majority of the analysis Data sources DCRP CDC Wonder model 30
Understand Mortality : Methods, continued Limited to male inmates Mortality varies by sex Men can t die of ovarian cancer Women can t die of prostate cancer Male account for the majority of state prisoners (93%) and prisoner deaths (96%) Ages 18 to 75 Less than 5% of prisoner deaths were of inmates age 76 or older 31
Percentage Distribution of State Prisoners and Deaths: State Prisons, 2007 2012 Source: National Corrections Reporting Program, National Prisoner Statistics Program 32
Understanding Mortality : Findings State prisoners who died demographically differed from other prisoners Of those who died Half were white, non-hispanic More than one-third were 55 or older More than two-thirds were violent offenders 33
Understand Mortality : Findings The major finding is that even after standardizing the U.S. resident population to resemble the prison population, the adjusted U.S. resident mortality rate was higher than prisoners Mortality rates post adjustment Resident population: 325 per 100,000 male U.S. residents Prison population: 259 per 100,000 male state prisoners Prior to standardization, male U.S. residents died from cancer (200) and heart disease (220) at three times the rate as their prisoner counterpart. Post-adjustment the rates were equal. Conversely, AIDSrelated and liver disease deaths remained higher in the prison population post-adjustment 34
35
Understand Mortality : Findings In addition to the analysis by cause, we compared prisoner mortality to U.S. resident mortality by age and race-hispanic origin. Overall, prisoners regardless of age group or race-hispanic origin died at a lower rate than their adjusted U.S. resident counterpart with one exception White males 45 and older 36
37
Understanding Mortality : Findings After assessing overall mortality by standardizing for age and race-hispanic origin differences, we revisited mortality by cause and split the findings by race Once split by race-hispanic origin, the mortality rates between male prisoners and their age-adjusted U.S. resident counterparts varied. For white, non-hispanic prisoners: cancer, heart disease For black, non-hispanic prisoners: disease of the kidney, AIDS-related causes and homicides For all inmates: diseases of the liver 38
39
Understanding Mortality : Discussion In most instances, the age-race adjusted resident population males had worse mortality outcomes than prisoners Cancer, heart disease and respiratory illnesses were about equal among prisoners and the U.S. resident pop, post-adjustment Suicide, drug/alcohol and homicides intoxication mortality rates increased in the resident population post adjustment Suggesting these causes maybe more due to being a male between the ages of 18 and 75 than being a prisoner Accidents were the only unnatural deaths whose mortality differed very little postadjustment 40
Understanding Mortality : Discussion Disease of the liver, septicemia and AIDS-related deaths were higher in the prison population even after adjusting the U.S. resident population by sex, race and age. Suggesting that these causes could be due to lifestyle lead prior to incarceration. Prisoners who died were different from the stock prisoner population Specifically, they were: Older than the stock population (73% were 45 or older) Older at admission (mid-to-late 40s) Disproportionate white and violent 41
Understanding Mortality : Discussion Why do white male prisoners experience a greater die-off than other raceethnic groups? Disproportionately violent offenders Disproportionately rapists and murderers On average, five years older at death than other prisoners Median age at death: 54 years Older at admission Median age at admission: 43 years White, non-hispanic inmates: 46 years of age Despite being older at admission, they served about 5 years prior to death. 42
Further areas of research We would like to do similar analysis with female prisoners We are currently working to reproduce the report with jail inmates We have begun work on assessing the effect of acute intoxication and history of substance abuse 43
Contact information Margaret Noonan Statistician Bureau of Justice Statistics Margaret.noonan@usdoj.gov 44