IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE BEFORE THE HON BLE MR. JUSTICE A.N.VENUGOPALA GOWDA

Transcription

1 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE DATED THIS THE 4 TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2014 BEFORE THE HON BLE MR. JUSTICE A.N.VENUGOPALA GOWDA REVIEW PETITION NOS.310/2014 & /2014 IN W.P.NOS /2012 (S-RES) C/W R.P.NOS.311/2014 & /2014, 299/2014 IN W.P.NOS /2013 (S-RES) AND R.P.NOS.300/2014 & 594/2014 IN WRIT PETITION NOS /2012 (S-RES) R.P. NOS.310/2014 & /2014 BETWEEN: 1. DR. PRIYA RANGANATH D/O D.S. RAJAN, AGED 41 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANOTOMY BANGALORE DR. PUSHPALATHA M D/O MUNIGANGAPPA AGED 45 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANOTOMY 3. DR. M S RAJESHWRI D/O DR. M SANNAMARAPPA AGED 46 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANOTOMY

2 2 4. DR. B GIRIJA D/O DR. G BASAVARAJU AGED 45 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 5. DR. M S KUSUMADEVI D/O M S MAHADEVAPPA AGED 41 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 6. DR. VENKATESH S., S/O M. SRINIVAS AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 7. DR. S SRINIVASULU NAIDU S/O L. VENKATANARAYANA AGED 40 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 8. DR. B V MARUTHI PRASAD S/O B P VENUGOPAL AGED 40 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY 9. DR. VIBHA C

3 3 D/O DR. A C CHANNEGOWDA AGED 47 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY 10. DR. SREE LAKSHMI K W/O VIJAYASHANKAR T AGED 38 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PATHOLOGY 11. DR. ASHALATHA N W/O DR. N M SRINIVAS AGED 42 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PATHOLOGY 12. DR. C NIRMALA D/O B CHANDRAN AGED 45 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PATHOLOGY 13. DR. LATHA B D/O SRI BORANAIK AGED 46 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PATHOLOGY 14. DR. AMBICA R, D/O M RANGAIAH AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF MICROBIOLOGY

4 4 15. DR. ASIMA BANU, D/O JAVEED ZIA AGED 41 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF MICROBIOLOGY 16. DR. JYOTI S KABBIN D/O SHANTHAVEER, AGED 42 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF MICROBIOLOGY 17. DR. KALA YADAV M L D/O LOKARAMUDU, AGED 39 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF MICROBIOLOGY 18. DR. KAVITHA RAJARATHNA D/O K R PILLAI, AGED 44 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHARMACOLOGY 19. DR. BHEEMPPA HAVANUR S/O L G HAVANUR AGED 53 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC MEDICINE 20. DR. SATISH K V S/O K VENKATARAMAIAH

5 5 AGED 44 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC MEDICINE 21. DR. RIYAZ BASHA S S/O SARDAR BASHA AGED 38 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF P & S, M, 22. DR. N. RAMAKRISHNA REDDY S/O NARAYANAPPA AGED 47 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF P & S, M., 23. DR. JYOTHI JADHAV D/O K S JADHAV, AGED 47 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF P & S, M. 24. DR. ASHOK M L S/O DR. C A LAKSHMINARAYAN AGED 47 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 25. DR. K G PRAKASH S/O K N GOWDAIAH, AGED 53 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE

6 6 26. DR. RAVEENDRA K R., S/O K RAMAMURTHY AGED 50 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 27. DR. R MADHUMATHI, D/O B. RAMAIAH AGED 52 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 28. DR. SARALA SABAPATHY D/O A V MUNUSWAMY AGED 54 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRICS 29. DR. NATESH B H., S/O HANUMANTHAPPA AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRICS 30. DR. LEELAVATHY B., D/O HANUMANTHA RAJU AGED 54 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF SKIN AND S T D 31. DR. B L SHASHI BHUSHAN S/O B V LAKSHMANA MURTHY AGED 44 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PULMONARY MEDICINE

7 7 32. DR. H C SURESH CHANDU S/O DR. H D CHIKKARAMAIAH AGED 52 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY 33. DR. T S SUNIL KUMAR S/O T M SIDDE GOWDA AGED 44 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY 34. DR. DEEPAK S., S/O A C SHIVANNA AGED 51 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDICS 35. DR. PUTTAKEMPARAJU K V., S/O KEMPAIAH AGED 48 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDICS 36. DR. H C RAMANNA, S/O LATE CHANNAIAH AGED 60 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF RADIO DIAGNOSIS 37. DR. K L SHIVAKUMAR S/O LATE K L LINGAIAH AGED 57 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF E N T

8 8 38. DR. J. SURYANARAYANA S/O LATE J NARASIMHAIAH AGED 57 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ENT 39. DR. M DAKSHAYINI D/O LATE SRI B M MALLAIAH AGED 50 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF OPHTHALMOLOGY 40. DR. B N KALPANA D/O LATE B L NAGARAJA SETTY AGED 50 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF OPHTHALMOLOGY 41. DR. GOPALAKRISHNA B HUILGOL S/O B Y HUILGOL AGED 51 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O B G 42. DR. DEVIKA RANI D D/O K. DUGGAPPA GOWDA AGED 52 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 43. DR. R SHREYAVATHI D/O LATE RAGHURAM AGED 54 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR

9 9 DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 44. DR. PRABHA P D/O LATE P. VITTAL RAO AGED 55 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 45. DR. NAGESH N S., S/O SWAMY GOWDA AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF SURGICAL GASTROENTEROLOGY 46. DR. S BALAJI PAI, S/O L. SANJEEVA PAI AGED 48 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF NEURO SURGERY 47. DR. AMRESH SUBHASH BHAGANGARE S/O SUBHASH BHAGANGARE AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF NEURO SURGERY 48. DR. AKHILANDESHWARI B D/O DR. BALASUBRAMANIAN R AGED 39 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANATOMY 49. DR. SUMATHI S, D/O MR. D.SHEKAR

10 10 AGED 40 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANATOMY 50. DR. PUSHPA M S., D/O SHIVANNA M P AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANATOMY AND R ESEARCH INSTITUTE 51. DR. C LAVANYA VARMA, D/O MR. C H VARMA AGED 42 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANATOMY 52. DR. SUGUNA S, D/O DR. SOMASHEKAR S AGED 40 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 53. DR. SHASHIKALA K T D/O LATE K H THIMMAIAH AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 54. DR. SOWMYA R, D/O K.RAJARAM AGED 33 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 55. DR. PRASHANTH KUMAR B G., S/O G G BETIGERI AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR

11 11 DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY 56. DR. ANITHA M., D/O M SATHYANARAYANA AGED 33 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY 57. DR. MURULILDHARA KRISHNA S/O DR. CHIKKAMOGA S AGED 40 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY 58. DR. SUJATHA MAITRA, D/O S C MAITRA AGED 45 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY 59. DR. G S SHARADAMANI D/O LATE SRI G S SHAMANNA AGED 62 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PATHOLOGY 60. DR. VANI RAVI KUMAR, D/O K R BHAT AGED 47 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PATHOLOGY 61. DR. LAKSHMIBAI B MALLAPPA W/O DR. S V BALAKRISHNA

12 12 AGED 52 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PATHOLOGY 62. DR. SHANTHALA G B., D/O G K BASAVARAJAPPA AGED 39 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF MICROBIOLOGY 63. DR. SUSHMA M., D/O MURARAIAH M AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHARMACOLOGY 64. DR. PRAVEEN PANCHAKSHARAMATH S/O C. PANCHAKSHARIMATH AGED 33 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHARMACOLOGY 65. DR. LAXMINARAYANA KAMATH S/O SARVOTHAM KAMATH AGED 44 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PHARMACOLOGY 66. DR. C N SUMANGALA, W/O S RAMESH AGED 41 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC MEDICINE 67. DR. SUESH V

13 13 S/O LATE R C VENKATACHALAPATHI AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC MEDICINE 68. DR. RAVISH K S., S/O SHIVALINGA MURTHY AGED 41 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE (P & S M) 69. DR. M B RAMAMURTHY S/O K R BASAPPA, AGED 50 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE (P & S M) 70. DR. SHOBHA, D/O I. RAMAKRISHNA BHAT AGED 52 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE (P & S M) 71. DR. AMITA, D/O PRABIR KUMAR AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE (P & S M) 72. DR. SARASWATHI S., D/O SAKRA NAIK AGED 39 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE (P & S M) 73. DR. NIRMALA A C., D/O SRI H CHANDRAIAH

14 14 AGED 50 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 74. DR. N NARAYANA SWAMY, S/O MADAPPA AGED 56 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 75. DR. H R JAGADISH, S/O M RAMAIAH AGED 43 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 76. DR. JAYACHANDRA, S/O VENKATARAMAPPA AGED 52 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 77. DR. V SRINIVASA, S/O LATE V VENKATAPPA AGED 50 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 78. DR. MANJUNATHA R., S/O M RAME GOWDA AGED 47 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 79. DR. KAVYA S T., D/O LATE G THIMMAIAH AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE

15 DR. DIWAKAR T N S/O NARASIMHA MURTHY G H AGED 45 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 81. DR. PRASHANTH V N., S/O N NAGARAJA AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 82. DR. G N ARAVIND S/O G R NAGARAJAIAH SETTY AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 83. DR. H SIVARANJANI, D/O H SIVAPRASAD AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 84. DR. SREE RANGA P C S/O DR. P R CHIDANANDAPPA AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 85. DR. PRABHU S., S/O S SUBRAMANI AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR

16 16 DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 86. DR. PRAMOD K., S/O DR K H KENCHAPPA AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL MEDICINE 87. DR. LAKSHMI M., AGED 41 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRIC 88. DR. SAHANA DEVADAS D/O DR. K P DEVADAS, AGED 48 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRIC 89. DR. DHANALAKSHMI K D/O LATE DR. K MAHALINGA AGED 51 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRIC 90. DR. J PRAKASH, S/O B K JAVARAPPA AGED 56 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRIC BANGALORE DR. CHIKKANARASA REDDY P S S/O LATE SANJEEVAIAH P

17 17 AGED 42 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRIC 92. DR. C.GAYATHRI DEVI, D/O CHINNAPPA, AGED 49 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRIC, BANGALORE MAEDICAL COLLEGE,, BANGALORE DR. ANJANA MURTHY K., D/O KEMPAIAH, AGED 45 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PAEDIATRIC,, BANGALORE DR. T.N.REVATHI, D/O DR.T.G. NARASIMHAN, AGED 51 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF SKIN & STD, 95. DR. ASHA G.S. D/O LATE G. SHANMUKHAPPA, AGED 51 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF SKIN & STD, 96. DR. VIJAYALAKSHMI G.N., W/O N.K.SRIDHAR, AGED 40 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY,, BANGALORE

18 DR. HARINDRANATH H.RANGANATH, S/O K.H. RANGANATH, AGED 50 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 98. DR. SHASHIKALA V., D/O VENKATARAMAIAH, AGED 52 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 99. DR.C.K.SHASHIKALA, W/O LATE C.N.KANTHARAJU, AGED 55 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 100. DR.RAVIKAR JAYARAJ, S/O P.J.JAYARAJ, AGED 56 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 101. DR.G.RAJASHEKARA BABU, S/O R.GANGAPPA, AGED 51 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 102. DR. AJITHA M.B., D/O B.G.MUGADUR, AGED 44 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY,

19 DR. SRINIVAS N.M., S/O MASANA SHETTY, AGED 45 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 104. DR.MIR MD. NOORUL HASSAN, S/O MIR MD.KHALIM, AGED 45 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 105. DR.T.KEMPARAJU, S/O LATE THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 106. SRI VEVEK S. REVANKAR, S/O G.SHIVASHANKAR SHET, AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 107. DR. BHANU PRAKASH K.R. S/O DR. RAMANNA K.M., AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY, 108. DR. RAJKUMAR P.N., S/O PARAMESHWAR K. NARAYANAKAR, AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SURGERY,

20 DR. VANAMALI B.S., D/O SEETHARAMAIAH, AGED 42 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDIC, 110. DR. PURUSHOTHAM V J., S/O JAWARAYYA, AGED 52 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDIC, 111. DR. SHARATH KUMAR P.V., S/O P.V.NAIK, AGED 39 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDIC, 112. DR.H. MANJUNATHA, S/O B.K.HALAPPA, AGED 58 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDIC, 113. DR. S. RAMACHANDRA, S/O SUBBA SETTY, AGED 55 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDIC, 114. DR. K.G. GOPALAKRISHNA, S/O GIRIGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDIC,

21 DR. S.A.SOMASHEKARA, S/O MARIGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ORTHOPAEDIC, 116. DR. T. ARVL DASAN, S/O MR. D.THANGARAJ, AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF RADIO DIAGNOSIS, 117. DR. RAVI N, S/O N.S.NINGAPPA, AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF RADIO DIAGNOSIS, 118. DR. K.S.VEDARAJU, S/O LATE K.T. SHAMACHAR, AGED 56 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF RADIO DIAGNOSIS, 119. DR. AMRUT SADASHIV KADAN, S/O MR. SADASHIV R.KADAN, AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF RADIO THERAPY, 120. DR. SAROJAMMA, D/O P.M.MUNIVENKATAPPA, AGED 58 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF E.N.T,

22 DR. KARTHIK S., S/O DR.M.SHAMANNA, AGED 40 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF E N T, 122. DR. NAGARAJU G, S/O GANGASHETTAPPA R., AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF OPHTHALMOLOGY, 123. DR. NISHAT SULIANA KHAYOOM D/O ABDUL KHAYOOM, AGED 47 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF OPHTHALMOLOGY, 124. DR. SHASHIDHAR S S/O LATE S.M.SATHYANARAYANA SWAMY, AGED 43 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF OPHTHALMOLOGY, 125. DR. BHARATHI N., D/O G.K.NARASIMHA MURTHY, AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF OPHTHALMOLOGY, 126. DR. B.N.VISWANATH, S/O B.K.NARASIMHAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF OPHTHALMOLOGY,

23 DR. G.SUNANDA BAI, D/O GANGA NAIK, AGED 56 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O.B.G, 128. DR. K.M.SUNANDA, D/O. K. MUDDAPPA, AGED 54 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O B G, 129. DR. SURESH S.KANAKANNAVAR, S/O SHANTHESH H.KANAKANNAVAR, AGED 54 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O B G, 130. DR. VIJAYALAKSHMI M NAYAK, D/O MAHABALA NAIK, AGED 60 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O.B.G DR. K.SRINIVAS, S/O DR. K.KRISHNA, AGED 47 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O.B.G., 132. DR. ASHOK KUMAR DAVOOR, S/O. SHIVAPPA M., AGED 43 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O.B.G.,

24 DR. M. KRISHNA VENI, D/O. T.S. MADAIAH, AGED 56 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O.B.G., 134. DR. SUDHA H.C., D/O. H.S. CHIKKASIDDAIAH, AGED 47 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF O.B.G., 135. DR. SUDHEESH K., S/O. MR. KANNAN C., AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 136. DR. RAMESH R., S/O. R. REVANNA AGED 49 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 137. DR. DAYANANDA V.P. S/O. LATE VENKATARAMAIAH AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 138. DR. VASANTHA KUMAR J., S/O. JANARDHANA AGED 49 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY

25 DR. M. SATHEESHA, S/O. LATE B. MUNIYAPPA, AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 140. DR. VIJAYAKUMAR H.N., S/O NARAYANAPPA AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY 141. DR. DIVYAPRAKASH M., S/O. K. MADA AGED 42 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF CARDIOLOGY 142. RAMESH K.T., S/O. THAMMANNA GOWDA, AGED 41 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PLASTIC SURGERY 143. DR. SMITHA S. SEGU, D/O. SRIRAM S. SEGU AGED 46 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PLASTIC SURGERY 144. DR. YOGISHWARAPPA C.N., S/O. NAGAPPA AGED 46 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF PLASTIC SURGERY

26 DR. NAGESH S.A., S/O. LATE S. ANANTH, AGED 49 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF NEURO SURGERY 146. DR. ELVIS RODRIGUES, S/O. ALPHONSO J. RODRIGUES AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF NEURO SURGERY 147. DR. PRAVEEN KUMAR, S/O. P. SHIVAKUMAR SWAMY, AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF NEUROLOGY 148. DR. PANCHAKSHARI PRASANNA B.K., S/O. H.T. KRISHNAPPA, AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF TRANSFUSION MEDICINE 149. DR. DHEEMANTHA P., S/O. NALLURU PRASAD R.K., AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF TRANSFUSION MEDICINE 150. DR. M.S. VIJAYAKUMAR, S/O. M.R. SUBBANNA, AGED 59 YEARS, LECTURER IN PHYSIOLOGY

27 DR. RAGHAVENDRA B.M., S/O. B.L. MANJEGOWDA, AGED 35 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL MEDICINE 152. DR. HEMACHANDRA P., S/O. LATE SRI PUTTAMAREGOWDA D.M., AGED 34 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL MEDICINE 153. DR. G.V. GIRI, S/O. G.V.R. RAO AGED 55 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL MEDICINE 154. DR. B.C. PRAKASH, S/O. C.CHIKKAIAH, AGED 39 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL MEDICINE 155. DR. ANIL KUMAR H., S/O. HANUMANNA, AGED 34 YEARS, LECTURER IN PAEDIATRICS 156. DR. KASTURI P., W/O. LOGANATHAN, AGED 55 YEARS, LECTURER IN PSYCHIATRY SURGERY

28 DR. MADHUSUDHAN S., S/O. SHIVAPPA M., AGED 39 YEARS, LECTURER IN PSYCHIATRY SURGERY 158. DR. C. GURU PRASAD, S/O. C. RAMACHANDRA, AGED 33 YEARS, LECTURER IN PSYCHIATRY SURGERY 159. DR. SHANKAR K., S/O. V. KUMAR AGED 31 YEARS, LECTURER IN PSYCHIATRY SURGERY 160. DR. SHILPA K., D/O. KAPANI GOWDA K.S., AGED 34 YEARS, LECTURER IN SKIN & S T D, 161. DR. ESHWARI L., D/O. MR. G. LOGANATHAN, AGED 36 YEARS, LECTURER IN SKIN & S T D, 162. DR. ROHIT G.R., S/O. RANGAIAH G.Y., AGED 35 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL SURGERY

29 DR. SANTHOSH C.S., S/O. C.M. SHIVASHANKAR, AGED 34 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL SURGERY 164. DR. PREM KUMAR, S/O. M. ANANDAN, AGED 36 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL SURGERY 165. DR. MALLIKARJUNA M.N., S/O. NIJALINGAPPA M.N., AGED 37 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL SURGERY 166. DR. SRIHARI B.G., S/O. G. GANGADHAR SWAMY, AGED 34 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL SURGERY 167. DR. SUNIL B., S/O. G. BASAVARAJANNA, AGED 35 YEARS, LECTURER IN ORTHOPAEDIC 168. DR. DAYANAND M., S/O. R. MANJUNATH, AGED 54 YEARS, LECTURER IN ORTHOPAEDIC 169. DR. CHINMAYEE J.T.,

30 30 D/O. THRISHVA MURTHY J.B., AGED 33 YEARS, LECTURER IN OPHTHALMOLOGY 170 DR. SURESH H.H., S/O. HANUMANTHAIAH H.H., AGED 41 YEARS, LECTURER IN OPHTHALMOLOGY 171. DR. SHILPA Y.D., D/O. L. DEVEGOWDA, AGED 37 YEARS, LECTURER IN OPHTHALMOLOGY 172. DR. ASHA KIRAN T.R., D/O. DR. THAVARSINGH C. RATHOD AGED 33 YEARS, LECTURER IN O B G 173. DR. SAROJINI, D/O. VITTAL PRABHU, AGED 34 YEARS, LECTURER IN O B G 174. DR. PRATHIMA S., D/O. T.V. SHANKARA NARAYANA AGED 34 YEARS, LECTURER IN O B G

31 DR. KALEEMULLAH SHARIFF N., S/O. SHARIFF A.N., AGED 44 YEARS, LECTURER IN ANAESTHESIOLOGY 176. DR. BHASKARA B., S/O. BYREDDY R., AGED 33 YEARS, LECTURER IN ANAESTHESIOLOGY 177. DR. ANANDA P.S., S/O. PUTTAMADAIAH, AGED 39 YEARS, LECTURER IN ANAESTHESIOLOGY 178. DR. SHAKUNTHALA T.S., D/O. T. SANNAPPA, AGED 38 YEARS, LECTURER IN CARDIOLOGY 179. DR. PEDDI MANJUNATH, S/O. CHANNAPPA, AGED 35 YEARS, LECTURER IN PLASTIC SURGERY 180. DR. G. SRINIVAS, S/O. LATE C. GOPAL REDDY, AGED 42 YEARS, LECTURER IN NEUROLOGY...PETITIONERS

32 32 (BY SRI K.M. NATARAJ, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI SACHIN B.S., OF M/S. DHARMASHREE ASSOCIATES, ADVS.) AND: 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT, M.S. BUILDING, DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI ROAD BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION VIKASA SOUDHA BANGALORE , REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR, FORT, K.R. ROAD, BANGALORE RESPONDENTS (BY SRI Y.D. HARSHA, AGA FOR R1 & R2; SRI S.B. TOTAD, ADV. FOR R3) THESE REVIEW PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ORDER 47 RULE 1 OF CPC, PRAYING TO REVIEW THE ORDER DATED PASSED IN W.P.NOS /2012 (S-RES), ON THE FILE OF THE HON BLE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BENGALURU. IN R.P.NOS.311/2014 & /2014 BETWEEN: 1. DR. ANAND S/O. LATE H.S. KRISHNAMURTHY AGED 65 YEARS

33 33 PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY MANDYA DR. KRISHNA K S/O KEMPEGOWDA AGED 46 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY MANDYA DR. G. SHIVAKUMAR S/O S M GURULINGASWAMY AGED 43 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY MANDYA DR. LOKESH V C S/O CHAMUNDAIAH AGED 32 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY MANDYA DR. UMESH N P S/O PRABHAKARAIAH N V AGED 34 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY MANDYA DR. M S TRINESH GOWDA S/O LATE M. SHANKARANARAYANA AGED 46 YEARS PROFESSOR & HOD, DEPT. OF ANATOMY 7. DR. KATHIRESAN

34 34 D/O M KAYAMBOO AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANATOMY 8. DR. NAGALAKSHMI W/O G R SURESH AGED 46 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF ANATOMY 9. DR. SANJEEV KUMAR S/O SHIVAPUTHRAPPA Sr. GADAG AGED 37 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF ANATOMY 10. DR. D H RAJENDRA S/O D H MALLINATHAIAH AGED 52 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPARTMENT OF PHYSIOLOGY 11. DR. HEMA LATHA N R S/O DR. LOKESH, AGED 34 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY 12. DR. L. SHASHIKALA W/O A S KRISHNA, AGED 40 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY 13. DR. PUSHPA SARKAR S/O RAMESH SARKAR AGED 53 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY

35 DR. S K MAHADEVA S/O LATE KARIGOWDA AGED 47 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF BIOCHEMISTRY 15. DR. RAGHUNATH H S/O S HANUMANTHARAYA AGED 36 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF BIOCHEMISTRY 16. DR. B J MAHENDRA S/O C JAYAKRISHNAPPA AGED 45 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE 17. DR. HARISH B R S/O DR. RUDRESH B M AGED 42 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE 18. DR. VINAY M S/O N MUNINARAYANA SWAMY AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE 19. DR. MANJUNATH M S/O MR. MUDDE GOWDA AGED 41 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE

36 MR. B NAGARAJA GOUD S/O LATE SRI B CHINNABASAVANA GOUD AGED 35 YEARS STATICIAN CUM ASST. PROFESSOR DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE 21. DR. M R HARISH S/O M S RAJE GOWDA AGED 41 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF DERMATOLOGY 22. DR. SHASHIKUMAR B M S/O K MADEGOWDA, AGED 32 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF DERMATOLOGY 23. DR. RAVI D, S/O KALAPPA AGED 41 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF ENT 24. DR. VIJAY P S/O DR. MOHAN B P AGED 41 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ENT 25. DR. N K BALAJI, S/O DR. C KALEGOWDA AGED 32 YEARS SENIOR RESIDENT, DEPT. OF ENT 26. DR. PUTTASWAMY, S/O MALLAIAH AGED 50 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF FORENSIC MEDICINE

37 DR. K ASHWINI NARAYAN S/O DR. K S NARAYAN SWAMY AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF FORENSIC MEDICINE 28. DR. SHIVA KUMAR, S/O SHIVAKUMAR AGED 51 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF GENERAL MEDICINE 29. DR. G M PRAKASH S/O G MADEGOWDA AGED 51 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL MEDICINE 30. DR. REKHA M C W/O DR. NARASIMHA SWAMY P AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL MEDICINE 31. DR. CHANDRE GOWDA, S/O UJJANI GOWDA AGED 47 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL MEDICINE 32. DR. RAMAKRISHNA S., S/O LATE SIDDAYYA AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL MEDICINE 33. DR. L RAGHAVENDRA

38 38 S/O K N LINGEGOWDA AGED 33 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL MEDICINE 34. DR. SUMANGALA B, D/O BASAVARAJAIAH AGED 50 YEARS PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF MICROBIOLOGY 35. DR. A M KEERTHI S/O LATE A L MAHADEVAPPA AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MICROBIOLOGY 36. DR. SHANUMKHAPPA, S/O S VENKAPPA AGED 38 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MICROBIOLOGY 37. DR. MAMATHA P SAMAGA W/O DR. SATHEESH RAO A K AGED 32 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MICROBIOLOGY 38. DR. LALITHA SHIVANNA D/O LATE PATEL SATHANUR KALEGOWDA AGED 65 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF OBG 39. DR H C SAVITHA, D/O M E MOHAN AGED 44 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG

39 DR. KAVYASHREE G., W/O DR. RAMESH H C AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG 41. DR. MANOHAR R., S/O RANGASWAMY R AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG 42. DR. SANJAYKUMAR C S/O CHIKKARASAIAH AGED 32 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG 43. DR. PRADEEP M R S/O RAMACHANDRA M R AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT OF OBG 44. DR. S L VIDYA PRASAD S/O S C LINGAIAH, AGED 53 YEARS PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF ORTHOPAEDICS 45. DR. RAMESH N T., S/O THIMMAIAH AGED 46 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ORTHOPAEDICS 46. DR. A PANDARINATH S/O LATE M V A N RAO AGED 56 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ORTHOPAEDICS

40 DR. A B PUTTASWAMY GOWDA S/O BASAVEGOWDA AGED 60 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ORTHOPAEDICS 48. DR. THAMMANNA P S S/O SINGRI GOWDA, AGED 49 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PAEDIATRICS 49. DR. SRIDHAR P V S/O MR. K VEERAGOWDA AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PAEDIATRICS 50. DR. KEERTHI B J S/O B T JAYARAM AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PAEDIATRICS 51. DR. S SHIVAKUMAR S/O MR. V SUNDARAM AGED 51 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY 52. DR. M S SIDDEGOWDA S/O SIDDE GOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY

41 DR. MALATHI B G., D/O K GOVINDAIAH AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY 54. DR. B KALA, D/O P BASAVAIAH AGED 55 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY 55. DR. MURALIDHAR BHAT Y S/O RAGHUVEER BHAT Y AGED 44 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY 56. DR. MANJULA MANCHALE K W/O DR. PRAVEEN B BIRADAR AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY 57. DR. M R MANJUNATH, S/O M P RAMARAJU AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY 58. DR. H P SHIVAPRASAD S/O LATE H PANCHEGOWDA AGED 54 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY, MANDYA DR. SHASHI KUMAR N S S/O N SIDDAIAH, AGED 38 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY,

42 42 MANDYA DR. NAGARAJAIAH B H S/O HANUMANTHARAYAPPA AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY, MANDYA DR. VIDYA R, W/O CHANDRAMOHAN AGED 30 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY, MANDYA DR. V L NANDISH S/O LATE LINGADEVARU AGED 56 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF GENERAL SURGERY MANDYA DR. C M PARAMESHWARA S/O K H MUNIKRISHNA AGED 41 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL SURGERY MANDYA DR. K H GOPALAKRISHNA S/O HUCHANNA SETTY AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL SURGERY MANDYA DR. S V BALAKRISHNA S/O VAIDYANATHAN AGED 44 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL SURGERY MANDYA DR. K C CHANDRASHEKARAIAH S/O CHANNARAJAPPA, AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS SENIOR RESIDENT, DEPT. OF GENERAL SURGERY MANDYA

43 DR. RAMAIAH S/O MUNIVENKATAIAH AGED 55 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF ANATOMY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. H SIDDESH KUMAR S/O DR. RAMAKRISHNA SHETTY AGED 46 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OPTHALMOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. AMAR VARMA S/O DR. C KRISHNAMURTHY AGED 40 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF DENTISTRY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. S D MANDOLKAR S/O DODDAPPA AGED 44 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF GENERAL SURGERY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. P.D. DIXIT, AGED 62 YEARS PROFESSOR & HOD, DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. VASANT CHAVAN S/O ROOPASING AGED 53 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. SHIVANAND DODAMANI S/O MARKANDEYA DODAMANI AGED 53 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF ORTHOPAEDICS RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR

44 DR. CHANDAN SABLE S/O DHONDIRAM AMOGI SABALE AGED 37 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MICROBIOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. SHANKAR GOWDA IREDDY S/O SHARANAPPA AGED 37 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF DERMATOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. ANIL GUMASTHE, AGED 36 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PSYCHIATRY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. MD ARSHAD, AGED 32 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. MANISH K, AGED 36 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF FORENSIC MEDICINE RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. MAHESH KUMAR C H AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. NAMITA, AGED 37 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. PREMSAGAR WAGHMARE, AGED 38 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES,

45 45 RAICHUR DR. DIN PRAKASH RANJAN S/O LATE SRI HARI NARAYAN PRASAD AGED 37 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. INDER RAJ ITAGI AGED 44 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. RAMESH, AGED 34 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF BIOCHEMISTRY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. SHASHIKALA PRABHAKAR AGED 55 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PAEDIATRICS RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. SHIVAPPA HATNOOR AGED 39 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. SANTOSHKUMAR MULAGE AGED 42 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANATOMY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. SUHAS Y. CHOUDHARI AGED 49 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ENT RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. TIRUMAL RAO, AGED 38 YEARS

46 46 ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DENTAL DEPARTMENT RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. VENKATESH NAIK AGED 40 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MICROGIOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. VIJAYKUMAR MAHADEV PUJARI AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF BIOCHEMISTRY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. RAHUL CHOKHOBA KIRTE AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. K S RAJAKUMARI, AGED 55 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF OBG RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. RAGHUNANDAN M., AGED 31 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, RAICHUR DR. RAVI SHANKAR G AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANATOMY RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SICENCES, RAICHUR DR. MALLIKARJUNA S/O M ESHAPPA AGED 44 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF ANATOMY VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY

47 DR. PHANIRAJ S., S/O S NAGARAJ., AGED 42 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANATOMY VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. D KRISHNASWAMY S/O LATE D DYAMAIAH AGED 49 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF BIOCHEMISTRY VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. NOORJEHAN BEGUM D/O MD. HUSSAIN AGED 48 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. C BHARATH S/O LATE C BASAVANAPPA AGED 49 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT OF PATHOLOGY VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. M SHANTHI D/O V MANICKAM AGED 43 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. KRISHNA S., S/O B S SRINIVASAN AGED 44 YEARS, PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. MARI RAJ J., S/O J DODDA BASAPPA AGED 44 YEARS, PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. BASAVARAJ S., S/O VEERABHADRAPPA S AGED 45 YEARS, PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES

48 48 BELLARY DR. T GANGADHARA GOUD S/O LATE T MALLANA GOUD AGED 45 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. GADWALKAR SRIKANT R., S/O RAMACHARYA, AGED 53 YEARS PROFESSOR & HOD, DEPT. OF MEDICINE VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. M MALLIKARJUNA REDDY S/O M LINGA REDDY AGED 49 YEARS, PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. S L RAVI S/O S H LAKSHMANA AGED 49 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MEDICINE VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. SHASHIBHUSHAN J S/O A V GOPALAKRISHNA BHATT AGED 41 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MEDICINE VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. M VEERA SHANKAR S/O M. SANJEEVAPPA AGED 59 YEARS, PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. LAKSHMINARAYANA REDDY S/O M SHANKARA REDDY AGED 42 YEARS, PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. KARJIGI SIDDALINGAPPA

49 49 S/O KOTRABASAPPA AGED 59 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SKIN & STD VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. SURESH T S/O KRISHNAMURTHY ACHAR T AGED 54 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SKIN & STD BELLARY DR. VEERESH S/O HUSENAPPA AGED 48 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SKIN BELLARY DR. VIDYADHAR A KINHAL S/O LATE ANANTACHAR KINHAL AGED 55 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF SURGERY BELLARY DR. CHANNANNA S/O CHIDAMBER RAO, AGED: 51 YEARS PROFESSOR, 117. DR. K.B. PHULEKAR S/O LATE BHIMANNA AGED: 60 YEARS, PROFESSOR 118. DR. PRABHU HUBLI S/O CHANDRAPPA HUBLI AGED:49 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SURGERY

50 DR. D. PRABHANJAN KUMAR S/O LATE D. KRISHNA MURTHY RAO, AGE: 55 YEARS PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF ORTHOPAEDICS, 120. DR. GURUDUTH G.V. S/O DR. G. VENKAT RANGAN AGED: 47 YEARS, PROFESSOR 121. DR. E. VENKATESHULU S/O LATE ELLUNI RAMANJANEYULU AGED: 46 YEARS, PROFESSOR & UNIT CHIEF, DEPT. OF ORTHOPAEDICS, 122. DR. S. SATYANANDA RAO S/O LATE S. PANDURANGA RAO, AGED: 58 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD, DEPT. OF ENT, 123. DR. MANJUNATH N., S/O AYYANNA N., AGED: 46 YEARS PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF ENT, 124. DR. G. SHANKAR S/O G. NARAYANA SWAMY AGED: 47 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ENT, 125. DR. G. PAVAN, S/O G. DHRUVA RAO AGED: 44 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ENT,

51 DR. A.A. KHAZI S/O ABDUL REHAMAN AGED: 59 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF OBG, 127. DR. JOSHI SUYAJNA D. S/O LATE D.R.K. JOSHI AGED: 57 YEARS, PROFESSOR 128. DR. MUMTAZ D. BENDIGERI W/O DR. N.M. INAMDAR AGED: 59 YEARS, PROFESSOR 129. DR. SHANKAR J. S/O IRAPPA JIRANKALI AGED: 52 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG 130. DR. SUMAN S. GADDI W/O DR. S.F. GADDI, AGED:58 YEARS PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF OBG 131. DR. VIJAYA S. HARASOOR S/O DR. S.S. HARASOOR AGED: 50 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG 132. DR. VASANT SHIVAPPA SHET S/O LATE SHIVAPPA PADMANABH SHET

52 52 AGED: 60 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD DEPT. OF UROLOGY 133. DR. N. IMPAD ALI S/O N. MOHAMMED SULAIMAN AGED: 43 YEARS, PROFESSOR & HOD 134. DR. A. SRINIVASA MURTHY S/O A. SHIVAPPA AGED: 59 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ANAESTHISIOLOGIST 135. DR. SRINIVASALU D. S/O D. NARAYAN REDDY AGED: 46 YEARS, PROFESSOR 136. DR. U. SOLOMON KRUPANIDHI S/O LATE U. SHANTHUDU AGED: 52 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 137. DR. V. MALLIKARJUNA S/O N. NAGENDRA, AGED: 39 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY 138. DR. SATISH M., S/O M. HANUMANTHA RAO AGED: 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY 139. DR. BASAVARAJ R., S/O INDUSHEKAR R.

53 53 AGED 32 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PHYSIOLOGY 140. DR. K.A CHANDRASHEKAR S/O LATE K. AYYAPPA AGED 39 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 141. DR. SANDHYA H.P. W/O DR. VIJAY V. AGED 29 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 142. DR. HARISH RAO B. S/O B. GOPAL KRISHNA RAO AGED 44 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 143. DR. INDUMATI V., W/O V. YOGIRAJ AGED 41 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 144. DR.SADANANDA ADIGA M.N. S/O NARASIMHA ADIGA M.S., AGED 45 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR. R.BHEEMASEN, S/O.R. SHESHANNA, AGED 60 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF BIOCHEMISTRY, BELLARY DR.MAHARUDRA SHEKHANAWAR S/O SHIVAPPA, AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR,

54 54 BELLARY DR. SATISHKUMAR D S/O D.G.DEVENDRAPPA, AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR. VIJAY. V., S/O VENKATAIAH, AGED 32 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR. RAJESHWARI W/O DR. VISHWANATH, AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 150. DR.Y. VISHWANATH, S/O C.YAMANAPPA, AGED 42 YEARS, PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PHARMACOLOGY, BELLARY DR. SURESH S.KENDRI S/O SANNASEDEPPA, AGED 51 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, 152. DR. MURGESH J.V. S/O VEERABHADRAPPA J.M., AGED 40 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR.UMESH G.WARI S/O GULAPPA N WARI, AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR. NAGAREKHA KULKARNI S/O DR. PHANIRAJ G.,

55 55 AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY, 155. DR. SHOBHA P.BIRADAR W/O DR. RAVI, AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 156. DR. BINDU RANI K.M. D/O DR. K.J.MARISWAMY, AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 157. DR. DIVYA K.N. W/O DR. BALA SUBRAMANYA H, AGED 33 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR. LIBA SEBASTIAN D/O JOSEPH SEBASTIAN, AGED 40 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, 159. DR. SUREKHA Y.ASANGI W/O K. LAKSHMINARAYANA, AGED 40 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, 160. DR. SUMATHI S., W/O SANTHOSH ANAND A.S., AGED 42 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 161. DR. NARAYAN SHRIHARI S/O YALLAPPA, AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR,

56 DR. PUSHPALATHA.H D/O B.N.HANUMANTHAPPA, AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 163. DR. S.SHAFIYABI W/O.N.TOUSIF ALI, AGED 42 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 164. DR. V.YOGIRAJ S/O V. OMKARAPPA, AGED 47 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, 165. DR.CHAITANYA.R S/O G.RAJA GOPICHAND NAIK, AGED 33 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR.K.S.SRIDHARA S/O LATE K.SRINIVASAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, LECTURER IN STATISTICS, 167. DR. BELLARA RAGHAVENDRA S/O LATE B.SOMASHEKHAR, AGED 32 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 168. DR. RAMESH. K, S/O KUBA NAIK, AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR,

57 DR. SAMEERA A.R.B. S/O T. KHAJA MOINUDDIN, AGED 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 170. DR. G.SHYAMALA, W/O B.GOPAL, AGED 43 YEARS, PROFESSOR, 171. DR. B.K.RAVISHANKAR, S/O LATE B.K.DODDAMALAPPA, AGED 44 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, BELLARY DR. SOMASHEKHARA.G S/O LATE GOVINDAPPA, AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF MEDICINE, BELLARY DR. N.KOTRESH, S/O N.HALAPPA, AGED 47 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF MEDICINE, 174. DR. RAGHAVENDRA NAGAMMANAVAR S/O F.B. NAGAMMANAVAR AGED: 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF MEDICINE VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. SUNIL KUMAR, S/O NEELAKANT AGED: 31 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY

58 DR. SACHIN G.J., S/O DR. G. JAYAPPA AGED:34 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. VISHWANATH B, S/O SIDDAPPA B AGED 42 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. D. SUDHIR S/O LATE D. ASHOKA RAO AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PAEDIATRICS VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. B.K. SRIKANTH S/O DR. B.K. SRINIVASA MURTHY AGED 37 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BELLARY DR. RAJESH DEVARINTI S/O DR. D. VENKATESULU AGED 32 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 181. DR. S.CHIDAMBARA MURTHY S/O S.V. SAMBASIVIAH AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPT. OF SKIN & STD, 182. DR. LAKSHMIPATHI Y.P. S/O Y.K. PATTAR, AGED 34 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 183. DR. C. RAGHUVEER

59 59 S/O DR. C. KESHAVALU AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, 184. DR. M. SHIVA PRASAD S/O M. GOVINDARAJULU AGED 48 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SURGERY 185. DR. RAVI SHANKAR T.H.S. S/O SHANMUKHAPPA T.H. AGED 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SURGERY 186. DR. SHEKAPPA C.M. S/O CHANDAPPA C.M., AGED 35 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 187. DR. P. RAVI KUMAR REDDY S/O P. MALLIKARJUNA REDDY AGED 34 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SURGERY 188. DR. MOHD. SHAFIUDDIN S/O SHAIKH IMAMSAB AGED 48 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 189. DR. CHANDRAKUMAR P.C. S/O PUNDALIKAPPA, AGED 33 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF SURGERY

60 DR. S.B. RAJASHEKAR S/O LATE B. BASAVANA GOUDA AGED 31 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF GENERAL SURGERY 191. DR. SREENIVASA N S/O C. CHIDANANDAPPA AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 194. DR. Y. RAVI PRAKASH S/O Y. BASAVARAJ, AGED 32 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF ORTHOPEDICS 195. DR. SANTOSH S/O SADASHIV D. MANAGOLI AGED 32 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 196. DR. YOGESH R.B. S/O LATE RAMANNA BHAVIMANI AGED 42 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 197. DR. PARASAPPA BANDRAKALLI S/O HALAPPA BANDRAKALLI AGED 41 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 198. DR. KENGAL PRAHALLADA REDDY S/O K. SESHA REDDY AGED 57 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OPHTHALMOLOGY

61 DR. NIRMAL KUMAR B S/O S.C. BAGRECHA AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 198. DR. N. VIJAY S/O DR. K. NAGARAJ AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 199. DR. VEERENDRA KUMAR C.M. S/O VEERABHADRAIAH C.M. AGED 40 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 200. DR. CHANDRASHEKHAR T MOTHER: T. DODDA HULUGAMMA AGED: 41 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG 201. DR. VIJAYALAKSHMI B W/O J. RAMESH BABU AGED: 41 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 202. DR. K. RADHIKA RAO W/O K. NARAYANA ACHARYA AGED: 39 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 203. DR. SHAILA C W/O DR. GURUBASAVANA GOUD AGED: 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF OBG

62 DR. H.C. RAMARAJU S/O H.E. SREENIVASA AGED: 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 205. DR. USHARANI N W/O DR. C. RAGHUVEER AGED: 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 206. DR. SHIVA KUMAR H.C. S/O CHIDANANDAIAH H.M. AGED: 35 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 207. DR. S. BALA BHASKAR S/O V. SWAMINATHAN AGED: 47 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 208. DR. MALLANNA B.P. S/O LINGANNA B.P., AGED: 56 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 209. DR. G.VENKATESWARA RAO S/O G. KONDAIAH AGED: 50 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 210. DR. BALASUBRAMANYA H S/O H. SRINIVASAYYA, AGED: 38 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 211. DR. JYOTHSNA M

63 63 W/O B.K. SRIKANTH, AGED: 33 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 212. DR. PARIMALA W/O DR. DURUGAPPA H AGED 33 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 213. DR. MURALIKRISHNA J S/O VENKATASWAMY AGED 41 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PLASTIC SURGERY 214. DR. SOMASHEKHAR L. SAMAGANDI S/O UNGAPPA SAMAGANDI AGED 40 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PLASTIC SURGERY 215. DR. SANJEEV B. JOSHI S/O BHIMSEN JOSHI, AGED 44 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 216. DR. S. KOTRESH S/O LATE S. GANAPATHY AGED 40 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 217. DR. SRINIVAS T.R. S/O RAMANNA T., AGED 42 YEARS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 218. DR. VISHWANATH SIDRAMM

64 64 S/O SIDRAM, AGED 42 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF NURO SURGERY 221. DR. ANVAR M.I. S/O M. IQBAL AHMED GONI AGED 36 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DEPT. OF NEPHROLOGY 222. DR. BASAVARAJ M. BIRADAR PATIL S/O MARUTEPPA B. BIRADAR PATIL AGED 37 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 223. DR. NARASIMHA MURTHY S/O KESHAVACHARYA AGED 61 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPT. OF PATHOLOGY 224. DR. KRISHNAGIRI SUNDARESH S/O K. BHIMA RAO AGED 43 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 223. DR. G. RAMA PRASAD S/O G. GURUVAIAH, AGED 64 YEARS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 224. DR. DEVENDRAPPA H., S/O H. THIPPESWAMY AGED 50 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 225. DR. SHIVA NAIK S/O M.J. RAMJI NAIK

65 65 AGED 38 YEARS, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR 226. DR. ASWANI KUMAR SINGH J., W/O LALMAN SINGH J AGED 46 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 227. DR. K. LAKSHMI NARAYANA S/O K.A. KONDAPPA AGED 52 YEARS, PROFESSOR 228. DR. KASA SOMASHEKAR S/O K.N. BASALINGAPPA AGED 45 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR... PETITIONERS (BY SRI K.M. NATARAJ, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI B.S. SACHIN OF M/S. DHARMASHREE ASSOCIATES, ADVS.) AND: 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT, M.S. BUILDING, DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI ROAD BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION VIKASA SOUDHA DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE MANDYA REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR.

66 66 4. RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES REPRSENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR HYDERABAD ROAD RAICHUR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR BELLARY RESPONDENTS THESE REVIEW PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ORDER 47 RULE 1 OF CPC, PRAYING TO REVIEW THE ORDER DATED PASSED IN W.P.NOS /2013 (S-RES), ON THE FILE OF THE HON BLE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BENGALURU. IN R.P.NO.299/2014 BETWEEN: Dr. HANUMANTHA PRASAD M., S/O. LATE B. MUNIYAPPA, AGED: 46 YEARS, PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ENT,, MANDYA PETITIONER (BY SRI K.M. NATARAJ, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI ARUNA SHYAM M., ADV.) AND: 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT, M.S. BUILDING, DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI ROAD BANGALORE

67 67 2. THE DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION VIKASA SOUDHA DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE MANDYA REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR. 4. RAICHUR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES REPRSENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR HYDERABAD ROAD RAICHUR VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR BELLARY RESPONDENTS THIS REVIEW PETITION IS FILED UNDER ORDER 47 RULE 1 OF CPC, PRAYING TO REVIEW THE ORDER DATED PASSED IN W.P.NOS /2013 INSOFAR AS THE PETITIONER IS CONCERNED. IN R.P.NOS.300/2014 & 594/2014 BETWEEN: 1. Dr. S. VENKATA RAGHAVA, S/O. N. SRINIVASA MURTHY, AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC MEDICINE,, BANGALORE Dr. MANJUNATH B.D., S/O. DODDATHIMMAIAH, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS, LECTURER IN GENERAL SURGERY,

68 68, BANGALORE PETITIONERS (BY SRI K.M. NATARAJ, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI ARUNA SHYAM M., ADV.) AND: 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT, M.S. BUILDING, DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI ROAD BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION VIKASA SOUDHA DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE , REP. BY ITS DIRECTOR, FORT, K.R. ROAD, BANGALORE RESPONDENTS THESE REVIEW PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ORDER 47 RULE 1 OF CPC, PRAYING TO REVIEW THE ORDER DATED PASSED IN W.P.NOS /2012 INSOFAR AS THE PETITIONERS ARE CONCERNED. THESE REVIEW PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:

69 69 O R D E R W.P.Nos /2012 filed by these petitioners, to quash an order dated of respondent No.1, insofar as giving effect to the revised AICTE pay scales to them from vide Annexure- Q and for a direction to respondent Nos.1 and 2 to extend the benefit of revised AICTE pay scales of pay to the petitioners with effect from , instead of vide Annexure-Q, was heard and allowed in part, by relying upon an order dated passed in W.P.Nos /2011. Seeking review of the said order and for extending the monetary benefits, with effect from , these review petitions were filed. 2. Subsequent to the filing of these review petitions, I.A.No.1/2014 having been filed in W.P.Nos /2011 by the petitioners therein, by an order dated , it was made clear and a direction was issued for the respondents, to pay the revised rates of Dearness Allowance under the scheme effective from and the other applicable

70 70 allowances such as House Rent Allowance, Transport Allowance, Children Education Allowance and the noncompounded advance increments which was taken effect from A memo dated was filed in these petitions, placing on record the aforesaid order. 4. While allowing in part, W.P.Nos /2012, on , it was found that the petitioners are similarly placed like the petitioners in W.P.Nos /2011 decided on and as such are entitled to similar monetary benefits. Since the order passed on in W.P.Nos /2011 directing the respondents to revise the pay scales of the writ petitioners therein, to bring it on par with the AICTE pay scales, as per the Notification dated and pay the consequential benefits with effect from and in view of the dismissal of W.A.Nos.1622/2013 and /2013, on the ground of delay on and the dismissal of SLP

71 71 Nos /2013 on , these petitioners were not granted the benefits as sought in the aforesaid writ petitions, with effect from In view of the order dated passed on I.A.No.1/2014 filed in W.P.Nos /2011, learned advocates for the respondents submitted that these petitions may be disposed of in similar terms. Submissions made by the learned advocates stands recorded. 6. Since the order passed on in W.P.Nos /2011 was clarified on , by allowing I.A.No.1/2014 filed therein, there is need to reconsider the writ petitions filed by these petitioners. 7. Because of the order passed on in W.P.Nos /2011, a case for review, in terms of Order XLVII Rule 1(1) of CPC is made out. In the result, these review petitions are allowed and consequently the order passed on in

72 72 W.P.Nos /2012 is set aside and said writ petitions stand restored for re-hearing. Re-list the said writ petitions for further hearing on Sd/- JUDGE ca