LATERAL MENISCUS SLOPE AND ITS CLINICAL RELEVANCE IN PATIENTS WITH A COMBINED ACL TEAR AND POSTERIOR TIBIA COMPRESSION R. ŚMIGIELSKI, B. DOMINIK, U, ZDANOWICZ, Z. GAJEWSKI, K. SKIERBISZEWSKA, K. SIEWRUK, B. CISZKOWSKA-ŁYSOŃ HYPOTHESIS: the lateral meniscus has its own dedicated surface on the tibial plateau - the plateau s disruption leads to the reduction of the LM's support in turn resulting in progression of degenerative changes of the meniscus as well as articular surface. CAROLINA medical center
Robert Śmigielski, MD I am a consultant with Medacta International SA B. Dominik, MD I have no financial conflicts to disclose. U. Zdanowicz, MD I have no financial conflicts to disclose. K. Skierbiszewska, DVM I have no financial conflicts to disclose. K. Siewruk, DVM PhD I have no financial conflicts to disclose. Z. Gajewski, Prof. DVM PhD Dr Sc. I have no financial conflicts to disclose. B. Ciszkowska-Łysoń, MD PhD I have no financial conflicts to disclose.
OBJECTIVE BACKGROUND: Identification of disruptions in the congruency of the lateral meniscus (LM)' setting on the tibial plateau in case of patients with the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury combined with the damage to the posterior margin of the tibia is important due to the meniscus role in knee biomechanics. correct setting of the lateral meniscus on the tibial plateau HYPOTHESIS: The reduction of the meniscus support affecting its normal movement is a potential source of accelerated progression of degenerative changes of the meniscus and tibial plateau. AIM OF THE STUDY: to establish the proper setting of the lateral meniscus on the plateau and estimate possible outcomes of the disruption of LM s movement. HEALTHY KNEE - the so-called convex shape, by some authors called the domed shape of the lateral tibial plateau MRI, PD Fat Sat, sagittal plane Lustig
MATERIALS & METHODS CONTROL GROUP: MRI scans of 10 healthy volunteers STUDY GROUP: MRI scans of 10 painfree* ACL patients with a damage to the posterior margin of the tibia *a proper MRI examination of the lateral meniscus in full knee flexion is limited in case of patients with mild to severe knee pain) visual and measurement comparison of control and study group s scans determination of the position and setting of the lateral meniscus against the articular surface MRIs: scans done in maximum knee flexion (sagittal plane, PD) using GE 3.0T Discovery device).
STARTING MRI. PD sagittal plane. Healthy knee in extension (L) and in full flexion (R) Correct setting of the posterior part of the lateral meniscus. Convex (domed) shape of the posterior margin of lateral tibial condyle with the meniscus on its dedicated articular surface.
MRI. PD sagittal plane. Healthy knee in flexion. Posterior part of the lateral meniscus is not gliding to the back. MRI. PD sagittal plane. Healthy knee in full flexion. Posterior part of the lateral meniscus is gliding on its dedicated surface on the tibial plateau.
MRI, PD sagittal plane. Post acute ACL rupture knee in flexion: a bone bruising and minor compression (grade II) slightly changes the original convex (domed) shape of the tibial plateau, but it does not significantly affect the lateral meniscus movement on its dedicated surface; ligaments of the capsular meniscal attachments are swollen
A compression of the posterior margin of the tibia, grade II - knee in full extension Same patient, knee in full flexion Based on the findings of the pilot study, we drew a preliminary conclusion that in cases of a smaller compression (grades II-III) of the posterior margin of the tibia, the lateral meniscus loses its support in flexion, but retains it in extension.
RESULTS EXTENSION The control group s MRIs confirmed the lateral meniscus slope onto its dedicated surface on the posterior tibial plateau. The study group s images have also confirmed the incorrect setting of the lateral meniscus and its deformation in the maximal knee flexion recorded in cases when the compression fracture of the lateral posterior tibial plateau led to the significant reduction of the support required for the proper LM s movement. FLEXION
GRADE I TIBIAL PLATEAU COMPRESSION oedema resulting from the contusion of the bone, no changes in the shape of the plateau BASED ON A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY BASED ON A LARGE (300+) SAMPLE high incidence of posterior tibial fractures coinciding with ACL rupture but also as a separate injury Sag FAT SAT GRADE II slight compression, but the meniscus is still fully supported GRADES I & II do not require surgical intervention FAT SAT & STIR projections are a golden standard for bone bruising detection; literature analysis combines with the study and researchers own clinical experience concludes that FAT SAT best visualises both the oedema and the fracture (grades I through IV)
GRADE III TIBIAL PLATEAU COMPRESSION bone degradation, only about 50% tibial support for the meniscus remains Sag PD GRADE IV less than 50% tibial support for the meniscus GRADES III & IV require surgical intervention (if diagnosed as concurrence with ACL rupture recommended at the time of the primary ACLR to verify the extent of depression of the bone axial plane scans provide the best assessment 75% 25%
CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE MENISCUS MOVEMENT & TIBIAL PLATEAU CLINICAL RELEVANCE The lateral meniscus glides on its dedicated articular surface on the tibial plateau and the absence of the congruence between the LM and its dedicated slope appears to be a likely source of accelerated degeneration of both the meniscus and the adjoining articular surface of the tibia in patients with prior ACL injury. The results gathered so far should be considered preliminary findings and require further validation on a larger group and done in conditions allowing the assessment of the meniscus movement at more angles. The presented pilot study in combination with the retrospective MRIs analysis performed to design an intuitive compression tibial plateau fractures classification point to the importance of careful observation of the tibial plateau s surface in ACL patients due to the high incidence of compressions as well as tibia s role in supporting the meniscus proper movement, If cases of grades III or IV are diagnosed, surgical treatment is recommended to avoid long-term complications such as ACL rerupture and/or unsatisfactory outcomes.
REFERENCES Alici, T. et al. (2011) Relationship between meniscal tears and tibial slope on the tibial plateau. Eurasian J Med, 43, 146-151. Christensen, J.J. et al. (2015) Lateral Tibial Posterior Slope Is Increased in Patients With Early Graft Failure After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. Am J Sports Med, 43, 2510-2514. Ciuffreda, P. et al. (2013) Mechanism of traumatic knee injuries and MRI findings. Musculoskelet Surg, 97 Suppl 2, S127-35. Hudek, R. et al. (2011) Is Noncontact ACL Injury Associated with the Posterior Tibial and Meniscal Slope. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 469, 2377-2384. Lustig, S. et al. (2013) In vivo assessment of weight-bearing knee flexion reveals compartment-specific alterations in meniscal slope. Arthroscopy, 29, 1653-1660. Papalia, R. et al. (2015) Bone bruises in anterior cruciate ligament injured knee and long-term outcomes. A review of the evidence. Open Access J Sports Med, 6, 37-48. Song, G.Y. et al. (2016) Increased Medial Meniscal Slope Is Associated With Greater Risk of Ramp Lesion in Noncontact Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury. Am J Sports Med, 44, 2039-2046. Terzidis, I.P. et al. (2004) The appearance of kissing contusion in the acutely injured knee in the athletes. Br J Sports Med, 38, 592-596. Vedi, V. et al. (1999) Meniscal movement. An in-vivo study using dynamic MRI. J Bone Joint Surg Br, 81, 37-41. In case of any questions do not hesitate to contact us at: rsmigielski.contact@gmail.com