Bone and cortical bone thickness of mandibular buccal shelf for mini-screw insertion in adults

Similar documents
Optimal sites for orthodontic mini-implant placement assessed by cone beam computed tomography

Correlation between periodontal soft tissue and hard tissue surrounding incisors in skeletal Class III patients

Original Article. Hyo-Won Ahn a ; Sung Chul Moon b ; Seung-Hak Baek c

Dental arch response to Haas-type rapid maxillary expansion anchored to deciduous vs permanent molars: A multicentric randomized controlled trial

Changes in Occlusal Relationships in Mixed Dentition Patients Treated with Rapid Maxillary Expansion

Dentoskeletal changes following mini-implant molar intrusion in anterior open bite patients

Clinical Study Report Synopsis Drug Substance Naloxegol Study Code D3820C00018 Edition Number 1 Date 01 February 2013 EudraCT Number

Evaluation of canting correction of the maxillary transverse occlusal plane and change of the lip canting in Class III two-jaw orthognathic surgery

Severe Gummy Smile with Class II Malocclusion Treated with LeFort I Osteotomy Combined with Horseshoe Osteotomy and Intraoral Vertical Ramus

Morphologic evaluation of the incisive canal and its proximity to the maxillary central incisors using computed tomography images

Esthetic Influence of Negative Space in the Buccal Corridor during Smiling

Mandibular vertical asymmetry in adult orthodontic patients with different vertical growth patterns: A cone beam computed tomography study

Skeletal and Soft Tissue Point A and B Changes Following Orthodontic Treatment of Nepalese Class I Bimaxillary Protrusive Patients

A Comparison Study of Upper Airway among Different Skeletal Craniofacial Patterns in Nonsnoring Chinese Children

Interseptal bone reduction on the rate of maxillary canine retraction

A Long-term Study on the Expansion Effects of the Cervical-pull Facebow With and Without Rapid Maxillary Expansion

Occlusal Morphology 1 Year after Orthodontic and Surgical-Orthodontic Therapy

A comparison of treatment effects of total arch distalization using modified C-palatal plate vs buccal miniscrews

Treatment time, outcome, and anchorage loss comparisons of self-ligating and conventional brackets

Three-dimensional positional assessment of glenoid fossae and mandibular condyles in patients with Class II subdivision malocclusion

Three-dimensional tooth crown size symmetry in cleft lip and cleft palate

Original Article. Heon-Mook Park a ; Yang-Ku Lee b ; Jin-Young Choi c ; Seung-Hak Baek d

The main occluding area in normal occlusion and mandibular prognathism

Influence of lateral cephalometric radiography in orthodontic diagnosis and treatment planning

Københavns Universitet

Long-term Skeletal Changes with Rapid Maxillary Expansion:

A Comparative Study of Two Methods of Quantifying the Soft Tissue Profile

Soft tissue response after Class III bimaxillary surgery Impact of surgical change in face height and long-term skeletal relapse

Original Article. Shushu He a ; Jinhui Gao b ; Peter Wamalwa c ; Yunji Wang d ; Shujuan Zou e ; Song Chen f

Stability of anterior crossbite correction: A randomized controlled trial with a 2-year follow-up

Anchorage Control in Bioprogressive vs Straight-wire Treatment

Long-Term Profile Changes Associated with Successfully Treated Extraction and Nonextraction Class II Division 1 Malocclusions

Condylar displacement between centric relation and maximum intercuspation in symptomatic and asymptomatic individuals

Skeletal and dental effects of molar distalization using a modified palatal anchorage plate in adolescents

Dynamic smile evaluation in different skeletal patterns

An Occlusal and Cephalometric Analysis of Maxillary First and Second Premolar Extraction Effects

Correcting maxillary dental asymmetries without

Study of Stress Distribution in the Tibia During Stance Phase Running Using the Finite Element Method

Comparison of two early treatment protocols for anterior dental crossbite in the mixed dentition: A randomized trial

Eruption of the permanent maxillary canines in relation to mandibular second molar maturity

ENERGY CONTENT OF BARLEY

Original Article INTRODUCTION

Intraarch and Interarch Relationships of the Anterior Teeth and Periodontal Conditions

Assessment of Depression in Multiple Sclerosis. Validity of Including Somatic Items on the Beck Depression Inventory II

Single-Molecule Studies of Unlabelled Full-Length p53 Protein Binding to DNA

Finite Element Analysis of MOD Prosthetic Restored Premolars

Prevalence of TMJ Disc Displacement in a Pre-Orthodontic Adolescent Sample

Dentofacial Effects of Asymmetric Headgear and Cervical Headgear with Removable Plate on Unilateral Molar Distalization

Original Article. So-Jeong Jang a ; Dong-Soon Choi b ; Insan Jang c ; Paul-Georg Jost-Brinkmann d ; Bong-Kuen Cha b

Biomechanics Orthodontics

Dental archforms in dentoalveolar Class I, II and III

Skeletal, Dental and Soft-Tissue Changes Induced by the Jasper Jumper Appliance in Late Adolescence

Geographical influence on digit ratio (2D:4D): a case study of Andoni and Ikwerre ethnic groups in Niger delta, Nigeria.

Fundamentals of Spine MRI and Essential Protocols

The Acute Time Course of Concurrent Activation Potentiation

Reliability of digital orthodontic setups

Gender Differences in Class III Malocclusion

Linear measurements using virtual study models A systematic review

Temperature Rise During Orthodontic Bonding With Various Light-curing Units An In Vitro Study

Restorative planning for hemisection surgery: a technique report

Are the Lower Incisors the Best Predictors for the Unerupted Canine and Premolars Sums? An Analysis of a Peruvian Sample

Factors affecting orthodontists management of the retention phase

The Effects of Small Sized Rice Bowl on Carbohydrate Intake and Dietary Patterns in Women with Type 2 Diabetes

Nickel and Chromium Levels in the Saliva and Serum of Patients With Fixed Orthodontic Appliances

Technetium-Labeled Methylene Diphosphonate Uptake in Maxillary Bone During and After Rapid Maxillary Expansion

Modified tandem traction bow appliance compared with facemask therapy in treating Class III malocclusions

Occlusal Status in Asian Male Adults:

The influence of malocclusion on masticatory performance

Soft Tissue Changes with Fixed Functional Appliances in Class II division 1

Effect of Light-Emitting Diode on Bond Strength of Orthodontic Brackets

Maxillary first molar agenesis and other dental anomalies

Lipase and Pancreatic Amylase Activities in Tissues and in Patients with Hyperamylasemia

Meat and Food Safety. B.A. Crow, M.E. Dikeman, L.C. Hollis, R.A. Phebus, A.N. Ray, T.A. Houser, and J.P. Grobbel

ORIGINAL ARTICLE. Diagnostic Signs of Accommodative Insufficiency. PILAR CACHO, OD, ÁNGEL GARCÍA, OD, FRANCISCO LARA, OD, and M A MAR SEGUÍ, OD

Using Paclobutrazol to Suppress Inflorescence Height of Potted Phalaenopsis Orchids

EFFECTS OF AN ACUTE ENTERIC DISEASE CHALLENGE ON IGF-1 AND IGFBP-3 GENE EXPRESSION IN PORCINE SKELETAL MUSCLE

CheckMate 153: Randomized Results of Continuous vs 1-Year Fixed-Duration Nivolumab in Patients With Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

Children with Class III Malocclusion: Development of Multivariate Statistical Models to Predict Future Need for Orthognathic Surgery

Dental Arch Dimensions in Class II division 1 Malocclusions with Mandibular Deficiency

Periodontopathogens around the surface of mini-implants removed from orthodontic patients

A Cineradiographic Study of Deglutitive Tongue Movement and Nasopharyngeal Closure in Patients with Anterior Open Bite

Recently, the National Lung Screening Trial demonstrated that three annual low-dose

Staffing Model for Dental Wellness and Readiness

Correlation of Skeletal Maturation Stages Determined by Cervical Vertebrae and Hand-wrist Evaluations

Three-dimensional Facial Morphometry of Attractive Children and Normal Children in the Deciduous and Early Mixed Dentition

Optimizing Metam Sodium Fumigation in Fine-Textured Soils

Diffusion Tensor Scalars Vary with Age and Across Spinal Levels in Children

Invasive Pneumococcal Disease Quarterly Report. July September 2017

Long-term Effectiveness and Treatment Timing for Bionator Therapy

Trends in antihypertensive and lipidlowering therapy in subjects with type II diabetes: clinical effectiveness or clinical discretion?

Which Hard and Soft Tissue Factors Relate with the Amount of Buccal Corridor Space during Smiling?

Effect on Glycemic, Blood Pressure, and Lipid Control according to Education Types

WSU Tree Fruit Research and Extension Center, Wenatchee (509) ext. 265;

Comparison of three simple methods for the

Evaluation of the TEST 1 erythrocyte sedimentation rate system and intra- and inter-laboratory quality control using new latex control materials

Agenesis of Third Molar Germs Depends on Sagittal Maxillary Jaw Dimensions in Orthodontic Patients in Japan

ASK AN EXPERT THINGS YOU WANT TO KNOW

Metabolic Syndrome and Health-related Quality of Life in Obese Individuals Seeking Weight Reduction

Associations between the risk of tooth agenesis and single-nucleotide polymorphisms of MSX1 and PAX9 genes in nonsyndromic cleft patients

Communication practices and preferences between orthodontists and general dentists

Transcription:

Originl Article Bone nd corticl bone thickness of mndibulr buccl shelf for mini-screw insertion in dults Riccrdo Nucer ; Antonino Lo Giudice b ; Angel Mire Bellocchio b ; Pol Spinuzz b ; Alberto Cprioglio c ; Letizi Perillo d ; Giovnni Mtrese e ; Gincrlo Cordsco f ABSTRACT Objective: To nlyze the buccl bone thickness, bone depth, nd corticl bone depth of the mndibulr buccl shelf (MBS) to determine the most suitble sites of the MBS for mini-screw insertion. Mterils nd Methods: The smple included cone-bem computed tomogrphic (CBCT) records of 30 dult subjects (men ge 30.9 6 7.0 yers) evluted retrospectively. All CBCT exmintions were performed with the i-cat CBCT scnner. Ech exm ws converted into DICOM formt nd processed with OsiriX Medicl Imging softwre. Proper view sections of the MBS were obtined for quntittive nd qulittive evlution of bone chrcteristics. Results: Mesil nd distl second molr root scn sections showed enough buccl bone for miniscrew insertion. The evlution of bone depth ws performed t 4 nd 6 mm bucclly to the cementoenmel junction. The mesil root of the mndibulr second molr t 4 nd 6 mm showed verge bone depths of 18.51 mm nd 14.14 mm, respectively. The distl root of the mndibulr second molr showed verge bone depths of 19.91 mm nd 16.5 mm, respectively. All sites showed corticl bone depth thickness greter thn 2 mm. Conclusions: Specific sites of the MBS offer enough bone quntity nd dequte bone qulity for mini-screw insertion. The insertion site with the optiml ntomic chrcteristics is the buccl bone corresponding to the distl root of second molr, with screw insertion 4 mm buccl to the cementoenmel junction. Considering the corticl bone thickness of optiml insertion sites, predrilling is lwys recommended in order to void high insertion torque. (Angle Orthod. 2017;87:745 751.) KEY WORDS: Mndibulr buccl shelf; Mini-screw; Mini-implnts; Skeletl nchorge; Extrlveolr orthodontic nchorge; Temporry nchorge devices Assistnt Professor, Deprtment of Biomedicl nd Dentl Sciences nd Morphofunctionl Imging, Section of Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, University of Messin, Messin, Itly. b Reserch Assistnt, Deprtment of Biomedicl nd Dentl Sciences nd Morphofunctionl Imging, Section of Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, University of Messin, Messin, Itly. c Associte Professor, Hed of Orthodontic Unit nd Chir of the Orthodontic Postgrdute Progrm, Deprtment of Surgicl nd Morphologicl Sciences, Section of Orthodontics, School of Medicine, University of Insubri, Vrese, Itly. d Associte Professor, Hed of Orthodontic Unit nd Chir of the Orthodontic Postgrdute Progrm, Multidisciplinry Deprtment of Medicl-Surgicl nd Dentl Specilties, Second University of Nples, Nples, Itly. e Associte Professor, Deprtment of Biomedicl nd Dentl Sciences nd Morphofunctionl Imging, Section of Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, University of Messin, Messin, Itly. f Full Professor nd Chir, Deprtment of Biomedicl nd Dentl Sciences nd Morphofunctionl Imging, Section of Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, University of Messin, Messin, Itly. INTRODUCTION Orthodontic mini-screws hve ttined widespred use recently, providing skeletl nchorge to improve orthodontic mechnics. 1 3 Mini-screws hve demonstrted good ptient cceptnce 4 nd reltively low filure rtes, reported t round 13.5%. 5,6 Primry stbility is key fctor for successful mini-screw plcement. 7 Antomicl fctors ffecting the stbility of mini-screws re bone chrcteristics (bone density, Corresponding uthor: Dr Riccrdo Nucer, c/o AOU Policlinico G. Mrtino, UOC di Odontoitri e Odontostomtologi, Vi Consolre Vleri 1, 98125 Messin, Itly (e-mil: riccrdo.nucer@gmil.com) Accepted: April 2017. Submitted: Jnury 2017. Published Online: June 09, 2017 Ó 2017 by The EH Angle Eduction nd Reserch Foundtion, Inc. DOI: 10.2319/011117-34.1 745

746 NUCERA, LO GIUDICE, BELLOCCHIO, SPINUZZA, CAPRIOGLIO, PERILLO, MATARESE, CORDASCO bone depth, corticl bone thickness), soft tissue chrcteristics (mucos vs ttched gingiv, tissue thickness, mobility nd proximity to the frenum), nd the proximity of specific ntomicl structures (roots, nerves, vessels, sinus/nsl cvities). Different sites hve been used for mini-screw insertion: pltl bone, 7,8 the pltl side of the mxillry lveolr process, 9 the mndibulr retromolr re, 10 the infrzygomtic crest, 11 the mxillry nd mndibulr bucco lveolr corticl plte, 12 nd the posterior pltl lveolr process. 7 Recently, the mndibulr buccl shelf (MBS) hs been proposed 13 s suitble extr-lveolr mini-screw insertion site. The MBS is locted bilterlly in the posterior prt of the mndibulr body, buccl to the roots of the first nd second molrs nd nterior to the oblique line of the mndibulr rmus. To dte, no quntittive nd qulittive bone ssessment of the MBS hs been performed for miniscrew insertion. The im of this study ws to nlyze the buccl bone thickness, bone depth, nd corticl bone depth of the MBS to determine the most suitble sites of the MBS for mini-screw insertion. MATERIALS AND METHODS The smple of this retrospective study included cone-bem computed tomogrphic (CBCT) records of 30 subjects (men ge 30.9 6 7.0 yers), including 15 mles (men ge 31.2 6 7.7 yers) nd 15 femles (30.7 6 5.2 yers) selected from the digitl rchive of privte prctice. The CBCT exms were performed between June 2012 to November 2015 nd were preselected if the exmined subjects fulfilled the following selection criteri: Cucsin subjects, ged between 20 nd 41 yers, with n bsence of periodontl disese, no metllic restortions in the first or second permnent mndibulr premolrs nd molrs, no missing teeth except for third molrs, no genetic syndromes or crniofcil dysmorphism, no history of fcil trum, nd no previous orthognthic surgery tretment. Seventy-six ptients fulfilled the selection criteri (35 mle nd 41 femle). The ptients were divided ccording to sex, nd ech of the two smples ws ordered by ge from the youngest to the oldest ptient. These two lists of ptients were used to ssign number to ech ptient from 1 to 35 for the mle list nd from 1 to 41 for the femle list. A rndom sequence genertor (http://www.rndomizer.org) ws used to generte two lists of rndomized numbers of 35 nd 41 numbers, respectively. The first 15 numbers of both rndom lists were selected nd the corresponding CBCT exms were included in the study. According to this method, blnced block rndomiztion bsed on ptients sex ws pplied to select the included CBCT exms. The protocol of this study ws pproved by the humn reserch ethicl committee (Approvl No. 102/16). All CBCT exmintions were performed with the i-cat CBCT scnner (Imging Sciences Interntionl, Htfield, P) fter setting the cquisition prmeters s follows: 120 kv, 5 ma, nd 4- to 6-second exposure time. Ech exm ws converted to digitl imging nd communictions in medicine (DICOM) formt. DICOM files were processed using the OsiriX Medicl Imging 32-bit softwre (Pixmeo, Genev, Switzerlnd; www. osirix-viewer.com). The following procedure ws used to obtin proper view sections of the MBS for quntittive nd qulittive evlution of bone chrcteristics. Three preliminry reference lines were considered, s shown by the softwre interfce, corresponding to the three conventionl scn plnes (sgittl: yellow line; xil: violet line; nd coronl: blue line). These view scn plnes were reoriented ccording to the following method: the furction point of the right nd left first molr nd the furction point of the right second molr were identified nd the xil view scn plne ws reoriented in order to pss through these three furction points. In this reoriented xil scn plne, two points were identified t the center of the dentolveolr process t the level of the mesil root of the mndibulr first molr nd the distl root of the second molr. These points were used s references to reorientte the sgittl view scn plne section in order to identify the mesio-distl direction of the mndibulr lveolr process in the molr segment. Finlly, the coronl view scn plne ws reoriented in order to best fit the direction of the two-thirds coronl long xes of these four roots (Figure 1): mesil nd distl first molr roots, mesil nd distl second molr roots. This procedure identified four coronl view sections used to investigte the MBS bone chrcteristics. It ws repeted for both the right nd left sides. A modified version of the method reported in previous publictions 14,15 ws performed to identify specific prmeters evluting bone quntity nd qulity on ech coronl view section. This methodology included the following steps: Identifiction of the vestibulr cementoenmel junction (CEJ) on ech scn view root section; Evlution of the buccl totl bone thickness on two horizontl reference lines locted piclly t 6 mm (TotThick-t-6) nd 11 mm (TotTick-t-11) from the CEJ (Figure 2); nd Apico-coronl totl bone depth (corticl þ medullry bone) nd corticl coronl bone depth were mesured on two verticl reference lines bucclly locted

BONE THICKNESS OF MANDIBULAR BUCCAL SHELF 747 Figure 1. Softwre interfce; reoriented reference scn lines (sgittl: yellow line; xil: violet line; nd coronl: blue line) in order to best fit the direction of the long xes of the mesil root of the second left mndibulr molr. t 4 mm (TotDepth-t-4 nd CortDepth-t-4) nd 6 mm (TotDepth-t-6 nd CortDepth-t-6) from the CEJ (Figure 3). The corticl bone depth ws mesured considering only the coronl corticl plte becuse it ws ssumed tht only the corticl bone plte intercts with the miniscrew during mini-screw insertion. A set of eight mesurements ws tken for ech scn root plne ssessing the totl nd corticl bone depth in n picl direction (t 4 nd 6 mm from the CEJ bucclly) nd bone thickness in buccl direction (t 6 nd 11 mm from the CEJ piclly). All mesurements were tken by the sme expert opertor (AMB). Sttistics A preliminry nlysis ws run on 10 subjects to obtin dt for power nlysis evlution. The MBS bone thicknesses mesured on horizontl reference line piclly locted t 6 mm from CEJ (TotThick-t-6) of the mesil nd distl roots of the right second molr were compred, nd the difference in mens of 1.81 mm nd the stndrd devition (SD) of 2.47 mm were used s outcomes to perform the power nlysis clcultion. The results of the power nlysis indicted Figure 2. The bucco-lingul thicknesses of totl bone (corticl þ medullry bone) nd corticl bone were mesured on two horizontl reference lines piclly locted t 6 mm (TotThick-t-6) nd 11 mm from the CEJ (TotTick-t-11).

748 NUCERA, LO GIUDICE, BELLOCCHIO, SPINUZZA, CAPRIOGLIO, PERILLO, MATARESE, CORDASCO Tble 1. Descriptive Sttistics of Totl Buccl Bone Thickness Vlues of Different Root Sites Mesured on Two Horizontl Reference Lines t 6 mm Apicl to the Cementoenmel Junction (CEJ) (TotThick-t-6) nd 11 mm picl to the CEJ (TotTick-t-11). Dt Considered Suitble for Mini-Screw Insertion Are Lbeled with the Light Gry Color; the Dt Considered s Nonsuitble Are Lbeled with the Drk Gry Color Figure 3. The pico-coronl bone depth thicknesses of totl bone (corticl þ medullry bone) nd coronl corticl bone were mesured on two verticl reference lines bucclly locted t 4 mm (TotDeptht4 nd CortDepth-t-4) nd 6 mm (TotDepth-t6 nd CortDepth-t- 6) from the CEJ. tht in order to rech 80% of power it ws necessry to nlyze smple of 30 subjects. Preliminry dt nlysis of ll smples suggested norml distribution (Shpiro-Wilk test) nd equlity of vrinces (Levene s test). Descriptive sttistics were performed reporting men, SD, mximum nd minimum vlues for ech prmeter nd for ll root scn sections. The descriptive sttistics were used to perform preliminry evlution of the potentilly suitble sites for mini-screw insertion. The insertion sites were considered suitble if they presented minimum horizontl bone thickness of 5 mm (1.7 mm of root sfety distnce, 1.6 mm of screw dimeter, 1.7 mm of corticl buccl bone sfety distnce) nd minimum verge verticl bone thickness of 6 mm (which represents the minimum stndrd mini-screw length). The potentilly suitble sites were compred using inferentil sttistics to detect significnt bone thickness differences. Unpired t-tests were used to compre dt derived from different root scn sections. Pired t-tests were used to compre dt obtined from the sme scn root sections t different verticl loctions from the CEJ. In order to ssess the methodologicl error, view section identifiction nd mesurement of prmeters were repeted for 10 rndomly selected ptients 1 week prt. Pired t-tests nd intrclss correltion coefficients (ICCs) were used to ssess the intropertor relibility. The mgnitude of the rndom error ws ssessed using the Dhlberg formul. No differences (P,.05) were found between the two redings; First column bbrevitions: R1M-m indictes right first molr mesil root; L1M-m, left first molr mesil root; R1M-d, right first molr distl root; L1M-d, left first molr distl root; R2M-m, right second molr mesil root; L2M-m, left second molr mesil root; R2M-d, right second molr distl root; nd L2M-d, left second molr distl root. ll mesurements were highly relible, with the ICC vrying from 0.76 to 0.84. Rndom error rnged from 0.5 to 0.9 mm. SPSS Sttistics softwre (version 17.0; IBM Corportion, Armonk, NY) ws used for ll sttisticl nlyses. The significnce levels for ll tests were set t P,.05. RESULTS Descriptive sttistics re reported in Tble 1 for totl bone thickness. Tbles 2 nd 3 report descriptive sttistics for totl bone depth nd corticl bone depth, respectively. In Tbles 1 nd 2, the dt cells reporting Tble 2. Descriptive Sttistics of Totl Bone Depth Vlues of Different Root Sites Mesured on Two Verticl Reference Lines t 4 mm Buccl to the Cementoenmel Junction (CEJ) (Tot-Depth-t-4) nd 6 mm buccl to the CEJ (TotDepth-t-6). Dt Considered Suitble for Mini-Screw Insertion Are Lbeled with the Light Gry Color; the Dt Considered s Nonsuitble Are Lbeled with the Drk Gry Color. The Abbrevitions in the First Column Are Explined in the Tble 1 Footnote

BONE THICKNESS OF MANDIBULAR BUCCAL SHELF 749 Tble 3. Descriptive Sttistics of Corticl Coronl Thickness Vlues of Different Root Sites Mesured on Two Verticl Reference Lines t 4 (CortDepth-t-4) nd 6 mm (CortDepth-t-6) buccl to the Cementoenmel Junction. The Abbrevitions in the First Column Are Explined in the Tble 1 Footnote CortDepth-t-4 CortDepth-t-6 Evluted Root Sites Men SD Min b Mx c Men SD Min b Mx c R1M-m 7.20 6.94 0 20.75 2.38 5.21 0 16.27 L1M-m 7.66 5.53 0 19.85 4.63 5.27 0 14.73 R1M-d 7.45 5.57 0 17.15 4.34 5.76 0 19.19 L1M-d 5.19 2.38 0 13.2 7.58 6.14 0 21.28 R2M-m 6.63 4.86 2.24 19.62 7.45 6.60 0 21.87 L2M-m 5.45 3.77 0 18.58 7.45 6.68 0 21.93 R2M-d 6.07 5.32 1.24 21.9 10.46 8.08 0 23.23 L2M-d 4.94 3.35 1.9 17.78 6.99 6.31 0 20.48 SD indictes stndrd devition; b Min, minimum; nd c Mx, mximum. Vs indictes versus. vlues considered suitble for mini-screw insertion re lbeled with the light gry color, nd dt considered nonsuitble re lbeled with the drk gry color. Tble 4 reports the results of the inferentil sttistics. DISCUSSION To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study in the literture tht investigtes the ntomic skeletl chrcteristics of the MBS for mini-screw insertion. The MBS potentilly offers some clinicl dvntges compred to dento-lveolr interrdiculr mini-screw insertion sites. The MBS extends bucclly with considerble mount of bone, nd this extension llows clinicins to insert mini-screws in n orienttion prllel to the long xes of the molr roots. 13 This insertion modlity could offer clinicl dvntges by voiding possible screw-to-root contct during nteriorposterior dentl movements long the dento-lveolr process. Another dvntge could be reduced risk of screw-to-root contct during insertion, considering tht screw-to-root contct is one of the most frequent cuses of filure. 16 This chrcteristic could help to explin the observtions by Chng et l., 13 who reported lower filure rtes compred to those ssocited with mndibulr interrdiculr mini-screw insertion. In order to properly insert mini-screw in the MBS, n understnding of the ntomicl bone chrcteristics of this insertion site is essentil. Upon preliminry evlution, minimum cutoff vlue of the buccl extension of the MBS for sfe mini-screw insertion ws considered to be 5 mm of buccl bone thickness (1.7 mm of root sfety distnce, 1.6 mm of screw dimeter, 1.7 mm of corticl buccl bone sfety distnce). Descriptive sttisticl dt showed tht the totl buccl bone thickness increses in the distl nd in the picl portions of the MBS. The mount of buccl bone thickness ws evluted t two different verticl levels: 6 nd 11 mm picl to the CEJ. Distl root of the second molr scn sections, on both the right nd left sides, were the only sections tht showed n verge of more thn 5 mm of totl buccl bone thickness 6 mm picl to the CEJ (Tble 1). Both the mesil nd distl second molr root scn sections on both sides (right nd left) showed enough buccl bone for mini-screw insertion t 11 mm picl to the CEJ. Significnt differences (P,.05) in buccl bone thickness were found between mesurements t 6 nd 11 mm (Tble 4). Inferentil sttistics lso reveled tht the distl root of the second molr site Tble 4. Inferentil Sttistics of Buccl Bone Thickness Dt of Right nd Left Second Molr. The Abbrevitions in the First Column Are Explined in the Tble 1 Footnote Right Second Molr Left Second Molr Evluted Root Sites R2M-m R2M-d L2M-m L2M-d TotThick-t-6 3.76 (62.53) Vs** 5.57 (62.42) 4.25 (62.38) Vs** 5.63 (62.44) Vs* Vs* Vs* Vs* TotThick-t-11 6.86 (62.02) Vs** 7.88 (61.71) 7.04 (61.65) Vs** 7.71 (61.69) TotDepth-t-4 9.46 (63.64) Vs (NS) 8.81 (64.41) 8.44 (63.47) Vs (NS) 8.19 (62.8) Vs (NS) Vs (NS) Vs (NS) Vs (NS) TotDepth-t-6 8.69 (66.33) Vs (NS) 11.41 (67.44) 9.44 (65.96) Vs (NS) 9.34 (65.63) TotCort-t-4 6.63 (64.86) Vs (NS) 6.07 (65.32) 5.45 (63.77) Vs (NS) 4.94 (63.35) Vs (NS) Vs (*) Vs (NS) Vs (NS) TotCort-t-6 7.45 (66.6) Vs (NS) 10.46 (68.08) 7.45 (66.68) Vs (NS) 6.99 (66.31) NS indictes not significnt. ** Significnt difference with P,.05 (unpired t-test); * Significnt difference with P,.05 (pired t-test).

750 NUCERA, LO GIUDICE, BELLOCCHIO, SPINUZZA, CAPRIOGLIO, PERILLO, MATARESE, CORDASCO showed significntly thicker bone compred to the mesil root of the second molr on both the left nd right sides (P,.05), signifying the region of the distl root of the second molr s sfer zone for insertion, compred to the mesil root (Tble 4). Other thn the chrcteristic of horizontl bone thickness, evlution of the corono-picl (verticl) bone depth dimension of the MBS is lso importnt in order to select the proper screw length. Dt showed tht the sites of the MBS with dequte bone depth on verge re t the mesil nd distl roots of the second molr. Evlution of the verticl bone depth dimension of the MBS ws performed t 4 nd 6 mm buccl to the CEJ (Tble 2). The mesil root of the mndibulr second molr showed verge bone depth dimensions of 18.51 nd 14.14 mm t 4 nd 6 mm buccl to the CEJ, respectively. The distl root of the mndibulr second molr showed verge verticl bone depth dimensions of 19.91 nd 16.5 mm, respectively. These dt indicte tht the insertion sites evluted offer the opportunity to insert ny screw length commercilly vilble. The verge mount of bone depth dimension ws greter t 4 mm buccl to the CEJ compred to 6 mm buccl (Tble 2). However, no significnt differences were found compring bone depths between the 4- nd 6-mm insertion sites or between the mesil nd distl insertion sites of the second molrs (Tble 4). Only the bone depth difference mesured between the 4- nd 6-mm sites buccl to the distl right second molr ws found to be sttisticlly significnt (Tble 4); however, this difference would be cliniclly irrelevnt, considering the gret mount of vilble verticl bone depth t these loctions. The high stndrd devition of verticl bone dimensions t 6 mm buccl to the CEJ (TotDepth-t-6) of the mesil nd distl root scns of the mndibulr second molrs indictes the high ntomic vribility of the MBS. Minimum vlues t 6 mm buccl to the CEJ (Tble 2) were zero for ll the considered prmeters, indicting the presence of t lest one subject with reduced buccl extension of the MBS. The vribility of the MBS observed in this study emphsizes the importnce of preliminry clinicl evlution of potentil insertion sites on n individul bsis. Evlution of corticl bone thickness before miniscrew insertion is pproprite since pre-drilling my be indicted in order to improve primry stbility nd to void excessive insertion torque nd screw filure. 17 23 Corticl bone depth ws mesured (Tble 3) in order to evlute the necessity for pre-drilling in the MBS. All sites evluted displyed corticl bone thicknesses tht were greter thn 2 mm, with verge vlues t the distl root of the second molr of 5.5 mm mesured 4 mm lterl to the CEJ nd 8.72 mm mesured 6 mm Figure 4. Occlusl drwing of left mndibulr buccl shelf. A miniscrew representtion ws plced corresponding to the insertion site with the optiml ntomic chrcteristics. It is the zone of MBS djcent to the distl root of the second molr nd 4 mm buccl to the CEJ. lterl to the CEJ (Tble 3). These dt indicte tht pre-drilling is lwys recommended before mini-screw insertion in the buccl shelf in order to void excessive insertion torque. 16 One limittion of this study is tht it evluted only the bony ntomicl chrcteristics of possible MBS insertion sites. Evlution of the MBS periodontl soft tissue chrcteristics ws beyond the purpose of this study. However, in order to select the proper miniscrew insertion site, soft tissue should be considered, becuse mobility of the lveolr mucos cn ffect long-term mini-screw stbility. Moreover, this study evluted only Cucsins, nd the bony chrcteristics of the MBS could be different in other ethnic groups. Further studies re necessry to evlute MBS chrcteristics in different ethnic groups. However, the results of this study showed tht specific sites of the MBS (specificlly the distl root of the second molr) present gret mounts of bone tht my be dequte even when considering possible ethnic vritions. CONCLUSIONS Specific sites of the MBS offer enough bone quntity nd dequte bone qulity for mini-screw insertion. The insertion site of the MBS with the optiml ntomic chrcteristics is the buccl bone lterl to the distl root of the second molr, with screw insertion locted 4 mm buccl to the CEJ (Figure 4). For prticulr biomechnicl needs, it is possible to consider n insertion site lterl to the mesil root of

BONE THICKNESS OF MANDIBULAR BUCCAL SHELF 751 the second molr, but insertion will likely need to be more picl to ttin dequte buccl bone thickness. Becuse of ntomicl vrition mong individuls, potentil insertion sites should lwys be evluted on n individul bsis. Considering the corticl bone thickness of optiml insertion sites of the MBS, pre-drilling is lwys recommended in order to void high insertion torque. REFERENCES 1. Ppdopoulos MA, Trwneh F. The use of miniscrew implnts for temporry skeletl nchorge in orthodontics: comprehensive review. Orl Surg Orl Med Orl Pthol Orl Rdiol Endod. 2007;103:e6 e15. 2. Nienkemper M, Puls A, Ludwig B, Wilmes B, Drescher D. Multifunctionl use of pltl mini-implnts. J Clin Orthod. 2012;46:679 686. 3. Chndhoke TK, Nnd R, Uribe FA. Clinicl pplictions of predictble force systems, prt 2: miniscrew nchorge. J Clin Orthod. 2015;49:229 239. 4. Zwwi KH. Acceptnce of orthodontic miniscrews s temporry nchorge devices. Pt Pref Adher. 2014;8:933 937. 5. Ppgeorgiou SN, Zogkis IP, Ppdopoulos MA. Filure rtes nd ssocited risk fctors of orthodontic miniscrew implnts: met-nlysis. Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2012;142:577 595. 6. Ppdopoulos MA, Ppgeorgiou SN, Zogkis IP. Clinicl effectiveness of orthodontic miniscrew implnts: metnlysis. J Dent Res. 2011;90:969 976. 7. Bumgertel S. Corticl bone thickness nd bone depth of the posterior pltl lveolr process for mini-implnt insertion in dults. Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2011;140:806 811. 8. Grcco A, Lombrdo L, Cozzni M, Sicilini G. Quntittive cone-bem computed tomogrphy evlution of pltl bone thickness for orthodontic miniscrew plcement. Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2008;134:361 369. 9. Poggio PM, Incorvti C, Velo S, Crno A. Sfe zones : guide for miniscrew positioning in the mxillry nd mndibulr rch. Angle Orthod. 2006;76:191 197. 10. Poletti L, Silver AA, Ghislnzoni LT. Dentolveolr Clss III tretment using retromolr miniscrew nchorge. Prog Orthod. 2013;14:7. 11. Bumgertel S, Hns MG. Assessment of infrzygomtic bone depth for mini-screw insertion. Clin Orl Implnts Res. 2009;20:638 642. 12. Bumgertel S, Hns MG. Buccl corticl bone thickness for mini-implnt plcement. Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2009;136:230 235. 13. Chng C, Liu SS, Roberts WE. Primry filure rte for 1680 extr-lveolr mndibulr buccl shelf mini-screws plced in movble mucos or ttched gingiv. Angle Orthod. 2015;85:905 910. 14. Brunetto M, Andrini Jd S, Ribeiro GL, Locks A, Corre M, Corre LR. Three-dimensionl ssessment of buccl lveolr bone fter rpid nd slow mxillry expnsion: clinicl tril study. Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2013;143:633 644. 15. Mrtin R, Cioffi I, Frell M, et l. Trnsverse chnges determined by rpid nd slow mxillry expnsion lowdose CT-bsed rndomized controlled tril. Orthod Crniofc Res. 2012;15:159 168. 16. Kurod S, Ymd K, Deguchi T, Hshimoto T, Kyung HM, Tkno-Ymmoto T. Root proximity is mjor fctor for screw filure in orthodontic nchorge. Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2007;131:S68 S73. 17. Bumgertel S. Predrilling of the implnt site: is it necessry for orthodontic mini-implnts? Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2010;137:825 829. 18. Motoyoshi M, Yoshid T, Ono A, Shimizu N. Effect of corticl bone thickness nd implnt plcement torque on stbility of orthodontic mini-implnts. Int J Orl Mxillofc Implnts. 2007;22:779 784. 19. Mrquezn M, Mttos CT, Snt Ann EF, de Souz MM, Mi LC. Does corticl thickness influence the primry stbility of miniscrews?: systemtic review nd metnlysis. Angle Orthod. 2014;84:1093 1103. 20. Suzuki EY, Suzuki B. Plcement nd removl torque vlues of orthodontic miniscrew implnts. Am J Orthod Dentofcil Orthop. 2011;139:669 678. 21. Wilmes B, Drescher D. Impct of insertion depth nd predrilling dimeter on primry stbility of orthodontic miniimplnts. Angle Orthod. 2009;79:609 614. 22. Lim SA, Ch JY, Hwng CJ. Insertion torque of orthodontic miniscrews ccording to chnges in shpe, dimeter nd length. Angle Orthod. 2008;78:234 240. 23. Heidemnn W, Gerlch KL, Grobel KH, Kollner HG. Influence of different pilot hole sizes on torque mesurements nd pullout nlysis of osteosynthesis screws. J Crniomxillofc Surg. 1998;26:50 55.