Characterization of knee alignment in children with mucopolysaccharidosis types I and II and outcome of treatment with guided growth

Similar documents
LATE RESULTS OF TRANSFER OF THE TIBIAL TUBERCLE FOR RECURRENT DISLOCATION OF THE PATELLA1

CheckMate 153: Randomized Results of Continuous vs 1-Year Fixed-Duration Nivolumab in Patients With Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

THE EVALUATION OF DEHULLED CANOLA MEAL IN THE DIETS OF GROWING AND FINISHING PIGS

Global Intellectual Deficits in Cystinosis

Supplementary Online Content

EVALUATION OF DIFFERENT COPPER SOURCES AS A GROWTH PROMOTER IN SWINE FINISHING DIETS 1

PNEUMOVAX 23 is recommended by the CDC for all your appropriate adult patients at increased risk for pneumococcal disease 1,2 :

ENERGY CONTENT OF BARLEY

Efficacy of Pembrolizumab in Patients With Advanced Melanoma With Stable Brain Metastases at Baseline: A Pooled Retrospective Analysis

Comparison of three simple methods for the

WSU Tree Fruit Research and Extension Center, Wenatchee (509) ext. 265;

Emerging Options for Thromboprophylaxis After Orthopedic Surgery: A Review of Clinical Data

R Martino 1, P Romero 1, M Subirá 1, M Bellido 1, A Altés 1, A Sureda 1, S Brunet 1, I Badell 2, J Cubells 2 and J Sierra 1

Clinical Study Report Synopsis Drug Substance Naloxegol Study Code D3820C00018 Edition Number 1 Date 01 February 2013 EudraCT Number

The potential future of targeted radionuclide therapy: implications for occupational exposure? P. Covens

Biomechanical effects of medial-lateral tibial tunnel placement in posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Evaluation of treatment of late-onset tibia vara using gradual angulation translation high tibial osteotomy

Anemia in pediatric hemodialysis patients: Results from the 2001 ESRD Clinical Performance Measures Project

Vitamin D and Mushrooms: Enrichment With Pulsed UV Light. Michael Kalaras Department of Food Science The Pennsylvania State University

Bright Futures Medical Screening Reference Table 2 to 5 Day (First Week) Visit

A review of the patterns of docetaxel use for hormone-resistant prostate cancer at the Princess Margaret Hospital

BENIGN ulceration along the greater curvature of the pars media of the

Analysis of alternatives for insulinizing patients to achieve glycemic control and avoid accompanying risks of hypoglycemia

Assessment of Depression in Multiple Sclerosis. Validity of Including Somatic Items on the Beck Depression Inventory II

distraction cleaning Peaks cages specifications

EFFECTS OF INGREDIENT AND WHOLE DIET IRRADIATION ON NURSERY PIG PERFORMANCE

Review article. Key words non specific low back pain, exercise therapy, stretching, motor control. Grade D

Original Article. T Akter 1, N Islam 2, MA Hoque 3, S Khanam 4, HA khan 5, BK Saha 6. Abstract:

Opioid Use and Survival at the End of Life: A Survey of a Hospice Population

Dose-dependent effect of daptomycin on the artificial prolongation of prothrombin time in coagulation abnormalities: in vitro verification

XII. HIV/AIDS. Knowledge about HIV Transmission and Misconceptions about HIV

ORIGINAL ARTICLE. Diagnostic Signs of Accommodative Insufficiency. PILAR CACHO, OD, ÁNGEL GARCÍA, OD, FRANCISCO LARA, OD, and M A MAR SEGUÍ, OD

SYNOPSIS Final Abbreviated Clinical Study Report for Study CA ABBREVIATED REPORT

Review TEACHING FOR GENERALIZATION & MAINTENANCE

Addendum to the Evidence Review Group Report on Aripiprazole for the treatment of schizophrenia in adolescents (aged years)

Study of Stress Distribution in the Tibia During Stance Phase Running Using the Finite Element Method

Invasive Pneumococcal Disease Quarterly Report. July September 2017

27 June Bmnly L. WALTER ET AL.: RESPONSE OF CERVICAL CANCERS TO IRRADIATION

Body mass index, waist-to-hip ratio, and metabolic syndrome as predictors of middle-aged men's health

Analysis of Regulatory of Interrelated Activity of Hepatocyte and Hepatitis B Viruses

Supplementary Online Content

Hallux valgus and cartilage degeneration in the first metatarsophalangeal joint

Severe Gummy Smile with Class II Malocclusion Treated with LeFort I Osteotomy Combined with Horseshoe Osteotomy and Intraoral Vertical Ramus

Influence of lateral cephalometric radiography in orthodontic diagnosis and treatment planning

Using Paclobutrazol to Suppress Inflorescence Height of Potted Phalaenopsis Orchids

Input from external experts and manufacturer on the 2 nd draft project plan Stool DNA testing for early detection of colorectal cancer

The RUTHERFORD-2 trial in heterozygous FH: Results and implications

Quantifying perceived impact of scientific publications

Handgrip exercise elevates basilic venous hemodynamic parameters in healthy subjects

Characteristics of hip involvement in patients with ankylosing spondylitis in Korea

Effects of physical exercise on working memory and prefrontal cortex function in post-stroke patients

Community. Profile Yellowstone County. Public Health and Safety Division

Effect on Glycemic, Blood Pressure, and Lipid Control according to Education Types

Normal range of spinal mobility

Community. Profile Lewis & Clark County. Public Health and Safety Division

Community. Profile Missoula County. Public Health and Safety Division

Hospital. 50%1. of the body surface, that is, such patients in. area of full-thickness skin-loss are percentages of the

Community. Profile Big Horn County. Public Health and Safety Division

Risks for All-Cause Mortality: Stratified by Age, Estimated Glomerular Filtration Rate and Albuminuria

Histologic and Biomechanical Studies of Tendon-To-Bone Healing After Autologous and Allogeneic Bone Transplants

Correlation of Skeletal Maturation Stages Determined by Cervical Vertebrae and Hand-wrist Evaluations

URINARY incontinence is an important and common

Safety and Tolerability of Subcutaneous Sarilumab and Intravenous Tocilizumab in Patients With RA

Community. Profile Powell County. Public Health and Safety Division

Y. Yazici 1, D. Moniz Reed 2, C. Klem 2, L. Rosenblatt 2, G. Wu 2, J.M. Kremer 3

Recall Bias in Childhood Atopic Diseases Among Adults in The Odense Adolescence Cohort Study

Analysis of Risk Factors for the Development of Incisional and Parastomal Hernias in Patients after Colorectal Surgery

Arthroscopic Anatomy of Shoulder

University of Texas Health Science Center, San Antonio, San Antonio, Texas, USA

Risk of Colorectal Cancer by Subsite in a Swedish Prostate Cancer Cohort

Community. Profile Anaconda- Deer Lodge County. Public Health and Safety Division

Trends in antihypertensive and lipidlowering therapy in subjects with type II diabetes: clinical effectiveness or clinical discretion?

STATISTICAL DATA ANALYSIS IN EXCEL

Introduction. These patients benefit less from conventional chemotherapy than patients identified as MMR proficient or microsatellite stable 3-5

Urinary Tract Infection in Men

Eruption of the permanent maxillary canines in relation to mandibular second molar maturity

Long-term Skeletal Changes with Rapid Maxillary Expansion:

Health-Related Quality of Life and Symptoms of Depression in Extremely Obese Persons Seeking Bariatric Surgery

Esthetic Influence of Negative Space in the Buccal Corridor during Smiling

Invasive Pneumococcal Disease Quarterly Report July September 2018

BMI and Mortality: Results From a National Longitudinal Study of Canadian Adults

of comorbid conditions, interventions Diagnosis and treatment, treatment reduction of risk factors for CVD to slow disease progression,

Multiple sclerosis (MS) affects approximately. Triaging Patients with Multiple Sclerosis in the Emergency Department. Room for Improvement

Original Article INTRODUCTION. Korean Diabetes J 2010;34: doi: /kdj pissn eissn

Feeding state and age dependent changes in melaninconcentrating hormone expression in the hypothalamus of broiler chickens

THE natural course of sciatica 22,17,23 is favourable in most

Metabolic Syndrome and Health-related Quality of Life in Obese Individuals Seeking Weight Reduction

Community. Profile Carter County. Public Health and Safety Division

A Comparative Study of Two Methods of Quantifying the Soft Tissue Profile

Estimating the impact of the 2009 influenza A(H1N1) pandemic on mortality in the elderly in Navarre, Spain

Appendix J Environmental Justice Populations

MOLECULAR AND CLINICAL ONCOLOGY 5: , 2016

Single-Molecule Studies of Unlabelled Full-Length p53 Protein Binding to DNA

Comparison of autologous peripheral blood stem cell dosing by ideal vs actual body weight

Flexion Contracture Following Primary Total Knee Arthroplasty: Risk Factors and Outcomes

Results of Radionuclide Assessment of Cardiac Function Following Transplantation of the Heart

Addressing pediatric intoeing

Nonpharmacologic Interventions for Treatment-Resistant Depression in Adults Executive Summary

Transcription:

J Child Orthop (205) 9:227 233 DOI 0.7/s832-05-066-0 ORIGINAL CLINICAL ARTICLE Chrcteriztion of knee lignment in children with mucopolyscchridosis types I nd II nd outcome of tretment with guided growth Elizbeth Ashby Deborh Estwood Received: 2 December 204 / Accepted: 25 My 205 / Published online: 6 June 205 The Author(s) 205. This rticle is published with open ccess t Springerlink.com Abstrct Purpose To describe knee lignment in children of different ges with severe mucopolyscchridosis (MPS) I nd II nd the outcome of tretment with guided growth in ptient subgroup. Methods This is retrospective observtionl study of 58 knees in 29 children with severe MPS I nd II. Long-leg stnding rdiogrphs were evluted to determine mechnicl xis devition, mechnicl lterl distl femorl ngle nd medil proximl tibil ngle t different ges throughout childhood. The chnge in deformity in individul children over time is reported. 20 knees in 0 ptients were treted with guided growth using eightpltes. Rdiogrphic mesurements were recorded t the time of plte insertion, t plte removl nd t yer following removl. Results At 8 yers of ge, ll MPS I children nd threequrters of MPS II children hd vlgus knee lignment. There ws deformity progression in two-thirds of MPS I knees nd hlf of MPS II knees. Guided growth corrected the deformities. There ws recurrence in most cses yer fter plte removl. Conclusions Knee deformity is common in children with severe MPS I nd II. Guided growth cn be considered where there is significnt nd/or or progressive deformity with the im of hlting progression nd correcting existing & Deborh Estwood deborh.estwood@gosh.nhs.uk Elizbeth Ashby elizbethshby@doctors.org.uk Deprtment of Orthopedic Surgery, Gret Ormond Street Hospitl for Children, Gret Ormond Street, London WCN 3JH, UK deformity nd thus minimizing the risk of gross deformity. Ptients should be wre of the high rte of recurrence nd the need for repet surgery. Keywords Mucopolyscchridoses Knee lignment Guided growth Introduction The mucopolyscchridoses (MPS) re group of lysosoml storge diseses chrcterized by the bsence, reduction or mlfunctioning of lysosoml enzyme. Cellulr glycosminoglycns (GAGs) ccumulte nd led to tissue nd multi-orgn dysfunction. There re different types of MPS bsed on the dysfunctionl enzyme. This study focuses on MPS I nd II. The prevlence of MPS I nd II is pproximtely in,000 [, 2]. MPS I is n utosoml recessive disorder chrcterized by dysfunctionl -L-iduronidse leding to ccumultion of dermtn sulphte nd heprn sulphte. MPS I is recognized s spectrum of disorders tht re split into severe nd ttenuted form; however, they re biochemiclly identicl. MPS II is n X-linked recessive disorder chrcterized by dysfunctionl iduronte sulphtse leding to ccumultion of the sme GAGs s in MPS I. MPS II encompsses spectrum of disorders tht re divided into 2 brod subtypes severe form chrcterized by the presence of cognitive impirment nd less severe form with no cognitive impirment. Infnts with MPS I nd II typiclly hve norml development for the first 6-2 months of life [3]. Without tretment, children with severe MPS I usully die in their first decde [4]. Children with ttenuted MPS I hve

228 J Child Orthop (205) 9:227 233 reltively norml life expectncy, but with significnt morbidity [4]. Without tretment, children with severe MPS II typiclly die in the second decde of life [5]. Those with the less severe form cn survive until their fifth or sixth decde [4]. A rnge of skeletl rdiogrphic bnormlities known s dysostosis multiplex re ssocited with MPS I [4] including hypoplstic vertebrl bodies (resulting in kyphosis nd scoliosis), poor growth of long bones, hip dysplsi nd genu vlgum [6, 7]. The rte of genu vlgum in MPS I is between 52 [8] nd70%[9]. The deformity is thought to originte from filure of ossifiction of the lterl mrgin of the proximl tibil metphysis [6]. Dysostosis multiplex is less drmtic in MPS II [0]. The incidence of genu vlgum is unknown. Hemtopoietic stem cell trnsplnttion (HSCT) is used to tret severe MPS I []. Donor cells synthesise continuous endogenous supply of the deficient enzyme leding to incresed life expectncy nd improved cognitive nd physicl function. HCST hs mortlity rte of 5 % [2]. It hs been used to tret MPS II [3] but is not usul prctice. HCST hs little effect on the musculoskeletl system [4]. Odontoid hypoplsi shows some improvement [5] but hip dysplsi nd genu vlgum continue to progress [6, 7]. This my be due to poor vsculrity of the ground substnce of musculoskeletl tissues precluding enzyme ccess. Enzyme replcement therpy (ERT) is used to tret ttenuted MPS I nd severe nd ttenuted MPS II. In ttenuted MPS I, recombinnt humn -L-iduronidse results in short- nd medium-term clinicl improvements [8]. Enzymes re unble to cross the blood brin brrier so provide no cognitive benefit in severe MPS I. Recombinnt humn iduronte-2-sulftse is beneficil in severe [9] nd ttenuted MPS II [20]. Although ERT cn improve joint rnge of motion, no improvement is seen in hip dysplsi or genu vlgum [2]. Improved life expectncy nd qulity of life, resulting from HSCT nd ERT, hve resulted in more ptients nd doctors considering surgicl intervention for genu vlgum. Surgicl correction of knee deformity using guided growth ws first reported using stples [22]. More recently, the use of eight-pltes hs been described [8] but timing, indictions nd recurrence rtes remin uncler. The ims of this retrospective observtionl study re three-fold. Firstly, to describe knee deformity in children of different ges with severe MPS I nd II. Secondly, to describe deformity progression in individul children, nd thirdly, to report the outcome of tretment with guided growth in subgroup of ptients who demonstrted progressive deformity. Mterils nd Methodology All ptients with MPS I or II, who were treted t our institution between Jnury 2004 nd December 204, with minimum of one full-length stnding leg X-ry were included in the study. X-rys were stndrdised with ptelle fcing forwrd, level pelvis nd mesurement bll on ech film. A totl of 29 children (58 legs) were included in the study 7 children with severe MPS I nd 2 children with severe MPS II. There were 0 mles nd 7 femles in the MPS I group. The MPS II group ws entirely mle. All MPS I ptients hd received HSCT (2/7 subsequently received ERT). All MPS II ptients were receiving ERT. Tretments were strted prior to rdiogrphic ssessment of knee lignment. The Picture Archiving nd Communiction System ws used to determine the lignment of ech knee by mesuring mechnicl xis devition (MAD). MAD ws clssified s pssing through one of four zones. A positive vlue indicted vlgus knee nd negtive vlue indicted vrus knee. Zones were clculted in reltion to the width of the tibil plteu (Fig. ). The source of knee deformity ws determined by mesuring the mechnicl lterl distl femorl ngle (mldfa) nd the medil proximl tibil ngle (MPTA). The men nd rnge of ech rdiogrphic mesure is reported for X-rys between the ges of 2 nd 9 yers for MPS I nd between the ges of 4 nd 3 yers for MPS II (or within 6 months of ech time point). No child with MPS I hd limb lignment X-ry performed under the ge 4 3 2 - -2-3 -4 0 Fig. Rdiogrph showing the zones of the knee. Zone 0 is verticl line through the centrl point of the tibil plteu (thick white line). Ech hlf of the tibil plteu is divided into two. Zone is locted next to the centrl line nd zone 2 is more peripherl. A verticl line is drwn on either side of the knee t distnce equl to the width of the tibil hemi-plteu. Zone 3 lies between the tibil plteu nd this line nd zone 4 lies outside this line. The mechnicl xis devition zones hve positive vlues in vlgus knee nd negtive vlues in vrus knee

J Child Orthop (205) 9:227 233 229 Tble Number nd timing of full-length leg X-rys used to ssess knee lignment over time MPS I MPS II Number of knees evluted 24 6 Men number of knee X-rys tken (rnge) 4.8 (3-2) 3.6 (3-5) Men ge t first X-ry (rnge) 6.9 yers (2.3 0.4) 7.5 yers (4.2 3.8) Men ge t finl X-ry (rnge) 0.0 yers (5.2 3.0).2 yers (5.8 6.2) Men time between first nd finl X-ry (rnge) 3. yers (.0 4.9) 3.7 yers (0.9 5.) of 2 yers nd no child with MPS II hd n X-ry performed under the ge of 4 yers. Corrective surgery ws performed t men ge of 9 yers in MPS I nd 3 yers in MPS II. Rdiogrphs fter the implementtion of guided growth techniques re not reported in this prt of the study s they would not be representtive of nturl progression. In totl, 67 rdiogrphs (34 knees) in children with MPS I nd 37 rdiogrphs (74 knees) in children with MPS II were evluted. To ssess disese progression in individul children, only those with minimum of 3 X-rys prior to ny surgicl intervention were included for nlysis. There were 2 children with MPS I (24 knees) nd 8 children with MPS II (6 knees). Detils of the number nd timing of X-rys re shown in Tble. Rdiogrphic findings on the initil X-ry were compred to those on the finl X-ry. To ssess the rte of disese progression, the chnge in rdiogrphic ppernce ws divided by the time tken for the chnge to occur. A totl of 0 children (7 with MPS I nd 3 with MPS II) were treted with guided growth using Orthofix eightpltes. Indictions for surgery included MAD through zone 3 or higher or MAD through zone 2 together with evidence of deformity progression. The origin of the knee deformity ws estblished from the mldfa nd MPTA. Eight-pltes were inserted into the proximl tibi nd/or the distl femur s pproprite. Rdiogrphic mesurements t the time of eight-plte insertion, t eight-plte removl nd t yer following eight-plte removl re reported. Mechnicl xis devition / Zone Mechnicl xis devition / Zone b 4 3 2 0 - -2 4 3 2 0 - -2 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Age / yers 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 2 3 Age / yers Fig. 2 Mechnicl xis devition in children with MPS I t different ges. Grey dot represents the men vlue nd the blck line represents the rnge. b Mechnicl xis devition in children with MPS II t different ges. Grey dot represents the men vlue nd the blck line represents the rnge Results Knee lignment in children of different ges The MAD, mldfa nd MPTA were ssessed in 29 children (58 legs) t different ges. Results re shown in Figs. 2, 3 nd 4, respectively, highlighting the differences between MPS I nd II ptients. Deformity progression in individul children Deformity progression over time ws ssessed in 20 children (40 knees). Results re shown in Tble 2. In knees with progressive deteriortion in mechnicl xis devition, the men rte of chnge in MPS I ws 0.5 zones/yer (rnge 0.20.0) nd in MPS II ws 0.59 zones/yer (rnge 0.33.54). Results of tretment with guided growth A totl of 0 children (20 knees) were treted with guided growth. The pltes were removed in 6 cses (2 knees); detils re given in Tble 3. There ws correction of deformity to MAD zone, 0 or in ll cses. The men time pltes remined in situ ws.6 yers. Deformity recurred in 3 children (6 knees) following plte removl.

230 J Child Orthop (205) 9:227 233 mldfa/ b mldfa/ 98 96 94 92 88 86 84 82 80 78 98 96 94 92 88 86 84 82 80 78 Correction ws mintined in one ptient (2 legs) who ws skeletlly mture t the time of plte removl. Detils of the 4 children (8 knees) where eight-pltes remined in situ re given in Tble 4. The MAD is showing improvement in ll cses. Discussion 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Age / yers 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 2 3 Age / yers Fig. 3 Mechnicl lterl distl femorl ngle (mldfa) in children with MPS I t different ges. Grey dot represents the men vlue nd the blck line represents the rnge. The hevy horizontl line highlights the norml vlue of 88. b Mechnicl lterl distl femorl ngle (mldfa) in children with MPS II t different ges. Grey dot represents the men vlue nd the blck line represents the rnge. The hevy horizontl line represents the norml vlue of 88 Knee deformity is common in children with MPS types I nd II. Knee lignment in MPS hs previously been described using the tibio-femorl ngle only [8, 22]. Children with MPS hve high incidence of hip dysplsi [8] nd therefore norml tibio-femorl ngle my not correlte with norml mechnicl xis. It is for this reson tht MAD ws used in this study. In MPS I, grdul increse in the men MAD ws seen in children of incresing ge. This trend ws less cler in children with MPS II. All MPS I children [8 yers hd vlgus knee lignment. In MPS II children, 75 %[8 yers hd vlgus knee lignment, 2 % hd vrus lignment nd 4 % hd neutrl lignment. MPS I children tended to hve mmpta/ b mmpta/ 05 95 85 05 95 85 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Age / yers 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 2 3 Age / yers Fig. 4 Medil proximl tibil ngle (MPTA) in children with MPS I t different ges. Grey dot represents the men vlue nd the blck line represents the rnge. The hevy horizontl line represents the norml vlue of 88. b Medil proximl tibil ngle (MPTA) in children with MPS II t different ges. Grey dot represents the men vlue nd the blck line represents the rnge. The hevy horizontl line represents the norml vlue of 88 Tble 2 Chnge in mechnicl xis devition in individul children with time Chnge in MAD with time MPS I MPS II Deteriortes 5/24 (63 %) 8/6 (50 %) Remins constnt 9/24 (37 %) 6/6 (38 %) Improves 0/24 (0 %) 2/6 (2 %) greter knee deformity thn MPS II children of the sme ge. No MPS II child hd MAD through zone 4, lthough seven MPS I children did. With incresing ge, there ws no chnge in the mldfa in children with MPS I nd MPS II. A vlgus distl femur (mldfa B 85 ) ws more common in MPS I nd vrus distl femur (mldfa C 9 ) ws more common in MPS II. In MPS I children of incresing ge, there ws stedy increse in the men MPTA. There ws no cler trend in MPS II. All MPS I children[8 yers hd vlgus proximl tibi (mmpta C 9 ). In MPS II children[8 yers, 69 %

J Child Orthop (205) 9:227 233 23 Tble 3 Detils of guided growth procedures performed on 6 children (2 knees) where the pltes hve been removed Child number Type of MPS Gender Side of opertion Bone primrily cusing deformity Age eight-plte(s) inserted/yers Age eight-plte(s) removed/yers Time eight-plte in situ/yers MAD Zone before eight-plte insertion MAD Zone fter eight-plte removl MAD Zone one yer fter removl I F Right Tibi/femur 6.5 8.0.5 4 0 4 Left Tibi/femur 6.5 8.0.5 4 3 2 I F Right Femur 7.3 8.7.4 3 3 Left Femur 7.3 8.7.4 4 3 3 I F Right Tibi/femur 9.6 0.7. 3 2 Left Tibi/femur 9.6 0.7. 3 0 4 II M Right Tibi.8 3.5.7 2 Left Tibi.8 3.5.7 3 5 I M Right Tibi 0.7 2.4.7 2 0 Left Tibi 0.7 2.4.7 4 6 II M Right Tibi 4.2 6.2 2.0 2 0 0 Left Tibi 4.2 6.2 2.0 3 Insufficient time elpsed to provide figures for ptients 4 nd 5 Tble 4 Detils of guided growth procedures performed on 4 children (8 knees) where the pltes remin in situ Child number Type of MPS Gender Side of opertion Bone primrily cusing deformity Age eight-plte(s) inserted/yers Time since eight-pltes inserted/yers MAD Zone before eight-plte insertion MAD Zone t present time with eight-pltes in-stu 7 I M Right Tibi 8.8 2. 3 2 Left Tibi 8.8 2. 4 2 8 I M Right Tibi 8.6 0.3 4 3 Left Tibi 8.6 0.3 4 3 9 I F Right Femur/tibi 9. 0.7 3 0 Left Femur/tibi 9. 0.7 3 0 0 II M Right Tibi 3.0. 3 2 Left Tibi 3.0. 3 0 hd vlgus proximl tibi nd 3 % hd neutrl lignment. No child of ny ge with MPS I or II hd vrus proximl tibi (mmpta B 85 ). In individul children, the MAD worsened over time in pproximtely two-thirds of MPS I knees nd hlf of MPS II knees. On verge, it took 2 yers for the MAD to progress one zone. In MPS I, the fstest deforming knee took yer to progress one MAD zone. In MPS II, the fstest deforming knee took \8 months to progress one MAD zone. Guided growth using eight-pltes dequtely corrected knee lignment in ll cses. Recurrence of deformity ws seen in three of four (75 %) cses t yer following plte removl. Correction ws mintined in cse. This ptient ws skeletlly mture t the time of eight-plte removl. X-rys of typicl MPS I ptient following eight-plte insertion nd removl re shown in Fig. 5. We believe there re 2 dvntges to treting skeletlly immture children with guided growth, despite deformity recurrence following plte removl. Firstly, deformity progression is delyed. The pltes remin in situ for men of.6 yers nd it tkes yer for deformity to recur following plte removl. Thus, there is no deformity progression for over 2 yers. In this time period, deformity progression of over one MAD zone (bsed on our results) would be expected if the pltes hd not been inserted. Secondly, deformity is not llowed to rech criticl level tht could limit function. The correltion between knee deformity nd function in children with MPS requires further reserch. Recurrent deformity cn be treted by reppliction of the guided growth principles. Knee deformity in children with MPS hs previously been reported. Stoop et l. [7] described genu vlgum in series of 3 knees in 3 children with MPS I. They reported

232 J Child Orthop (205) 9:227 233 Fig. 5 X-rys showing typicl improvement in knee lignment with insertion of eight-pltes nd recurrence of deformity following plte removl high MPTA in 2/3 knees. A similr result ws found in our series. Stoop et l. did not report overll knee lignment or the femorl contribution to knee deformity. They reported mximum MPTA vlue between the ges of 3 nd 5 yers. This differs from our study where the men MPTA continued to increse until t lest 9 yers of ge. Tretment with guided growth in MPS hs previously been reported. Tylor et l. [22] reported 5 ptients with MPS I treted with stpling of the medil tibil epiphysis. The tibio-femorl ngle corrected from men of 7 to 0. The contribution of the distl femur to the knee deformity nd recurrence rtes following stple removl re not reported. Odunusi et l. [8] described tretment with guided growth in 8 vlgus knees in children with MPS I using stples. There ws complete correction of deformity in 2 knees nd incomplete correction in 6 knees. Deformity recurred in 5 cses fter stple removl nd there ws incomplete follow-up in cse. There ws no recurrence in 2 knees. Both these ptients were ner skeletl mturity t the time of stple removl (ge 4 nd 5 yers, respectively). This is the sme s our study where there ws no recurrence in one ptient who hd reched skeletl mturity prior to plte removl. There re two possible strtegies for tretment with guided growth. The first strtegy involves performing surgery when knee lignment becomes uncceptble, e.g., when the MAD progresses to zone 3 on the ssumption tht gross deformity does lter git mechnics nd is ssocited with discomfort. Erly tretment would correct the MAD nd knee lignment would be mintined within specified limits to limit pin nd mintin function. A disdvntge is tht child my require two or three surgicl interventions during their childhood to chieve neutrl limb lignment t skeletl mturity. A second strtegy would be to dely tretment with guided growth until the child is nering skeletl mturity in n ttempt to chieve norml knee lignment t the time skeletl mturity is reched. An dvntge of this strtegy is tht it requires single opertion. A disdvntge is tht child my develop severe deformity tht limits function; correction of MAD in zone 4 my not occur so relibly s in younger child prticulrly s the rte of deformity correction vries between individuls, so it would be difficult to estimte the time of plte insertion. If pltes were inserted too erly they would need to be removed with the risk of deformity recurrence. If the pltes were inserted too lte there would be under-correction of the deformity. Our study hs severl strengths. It hs lrge study popultion for such rre condition, there re severl stnding long-leg X-rys for mny ptients llowing disese progression to be reported over time nd 3 importnt spects of knee lignment hve been reported (MAD, mldfa nd MPTA). This study lso hs weknesses. It ws performed retrospectively nd is bsed solely on rdiogrphic mesurements tht my not correlte to ptient symptoms. Rdiogrphs were tken t different ges nd t different time intervls. Deformity progression ws ssessed in individul knees over men time period of 3 yers. Studies with longer follow-up re necessry to ssess progression throughout childhood. For the tretment rm of this study, only 8 knees underwent -yer follow-up following plte removl, mking this cse series rther thn true study. Nevertheless, we hve shown tht guided growth hs the potentil to improve significnt deformity nd mintin it in the short term. Medicl tretments for MPS I nd MPS II [23, 24] hve improved life expectncy nd qulity of life, resulting in more ptients nd doctors considering guided growth to correct knee lignment. When considering surgery, it is

J Child Orthop (205) 9:227 233 233 importnt to tret the source of the deformity (tibi, femur or both). Surgery should only be considered if the deformity is sufficiently severe or shows evidence of progression. This study shows tht not ll deformities progress in the medium-term. Ptients should be wre of the high rte of deformity recurrence following plte removl nd the need for further surgery in the future. It remins to be seen whether guided growth tretments cn deliver stright leg t skeletl mturity in children with MPS I nd MPS II. Acknowledgements Neither uthor ws in receipt of ny funding. Conflict of interest D. M. Estwood nd E. Ashby declre tht they hve no conflict of interest. Ethicl pprovl This rticle does not contin ny studies with humn prticipnts or nimls performed by ny of the uthors. Informed consent All ptients undergoing surgicl procedures were subject to informed consent. Open Access This rticle is distributed under the terms of the Cretive Commons Attribution 4.0 Interntionl License (http://cretivecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, nd reproduction in ny medium, provided you give pproprite credit to the originl uthor(s) nd the source, provide link to the Cretive Commons license, nd indicte if chnges were mde. References. Meikle PJ, Hopwood JJ, Clgue AE, Crey WF (999) Prevlence of lysosoml storge disorders. JAMA 28:249 254 2. Young ID, Hrper PS (982) Incidence of Hunter s syndrome. Hum Genet 60:39 392 3. Pstores GM, Arn P, Beck M, Clrke JT, Guffon N, Kpln P, Muenzer J, Norto DY, Shpiro E, Thoms J, Viskochil D, Writh JE (2007) The MPS I registry: design, methodology, nd erly findings of globl disese registry for monitoring ptients with Mucopolyscchridosis Type I. Mol Genet Metb 9:37 47 4. Neufeld E, Muenzer J (200) The mucopolyscchridoses. In: Scriver CR, Beudet AL, Sly WS, Vlle D, Childs B, Kinzler KW, Vogelstein B (eds) The Metbolic nd Moleculr Bsis of Inherited Disese, 8th edn. McGrw-Hill, New York, pp 342 3452 5. Mrtin R, Beck M, Eng C, Giuglini R, Hrmtz P, Muñoz V, Muenzer J (2008) Recognition nd dignosis of mucopolyscchridosis II (Hunter syndrome). Peditrics 2:377 386 6. Field RE, Buchnn JA, Copplemns MG, Aichroth PM (994) Bone-mrrow trnsplnttion in Hurler s syndrome. Effect on skeletl development. J Bone Joint Surg Br 76:975 98 7. Stoop FJ, Kruyt MC, vn der Linden MH, Skkers RJ, vn Hsselt PM, Cstelein RM (203) Prevlence nd development of orthopedic symptoms in the dutch hurler ptient popultion fter hemtopoietic stem cell trnsplnttion. JIMD Rep 9:7 29 8. Odunusi E, Peters C, Krivit W, Ogilvie J (999) Genu vlgum deformity in Hurler syndrome fter hemtopoietic stem cell trnsplnttion: correction by surgicl intervention. J Peditr Orthop 9:270 274 9. vn der Linden MH, Kruyt MC, Skkers RJ, de Koning TJ, Oner FC, Cstelein RM (20) Orthopedic mngement of Hurler s disese fter hemtopoietic stem cell trnsplnttion: systemtic review. J Inherit Metb Dis 34:657 669 0. Nyhn WN, Brshop BA, Oznd PT (2005) Atls of Metbolic Diseses, 2nd edn. Hodder Arnold, London. Hobbs JR, Hugh-Jones K, Brrett AJ, Byrom N, Chmbers D, Henry K, Jmes DC, Lucs CF, Rogers TR, Benson PF, Tnsley LR, Ptrick AD, Mossmn J, Young EP (98) Reversl of clinicl fetures of Hurler s disese nd biochemicl improvement fter tretment by bone-mrrow trnsplnttion. Lncet 2(8249):709 72 2. Boelens JJ, Wynn RF, O Mer A, Veys P, Bertrnd Y, Souillet G, Writh JE, Fischer A, Cvzzn-Clvo M, Sykor KW, Sedlcek P, Rovelli A, Uiterwl CS, Wulffrt N (2007) Outcomes of hemtopoietic stem cell trnsplnttion for Hurler s syndrome in Europe: risk fctor nlysis for grft filure. Bone Mrrow Trnsplnt 40:225 233 3. Tnk A, Okuym T, Suzuki Y, Ski N, Tkkur H, Swd T, Tnk T, Otomo T, Ohshi T, Ishige-Wd M, Ybe H, Ohur T, Suzuki N, Kto K, Adchi S, Kobyshi R, Mugishim H, Kto S (202) Long-term efficcy of hemtopoietic stem cell trnsplnttion on brin involvement in ptients with mucopolyscchridosis type II: ntionwide survey in Jpn. Mol Genet Metb 07:53 520 4. Guffon N, Souillet G, Mire I, Strczek J, Guibud P (998) Follow-up of nine ptients with Hurler syndrome fter bone mrrow trnsplnttion. J Peditr 33:9 25 5. Hite SH, Peters C, Krivit W (2000) Correction of odontoid dysplsi following bone-mrrow trnsplnttion nd engrftment (in Hurler syndrome MPS H). Peditr Rdiol 30:464 470 6. Souillet G, Guffon N, Mire I, Pujol M, Tylor P, Sevin F, Bleyzc N, Mulier C, Durin A, Kebili K, Glmbrun C, Bertrnd Y, Froissrt R, Dorche C, Gebuhrer L, Grin C, Berrd J, Guibud P (2003) Outcome of 27 ptients with Hurler s syndrome trnsplnted from either relted or unrelted hemtopoietic stem cell sources. Bone Mrrow Trnsplnt 3:05 7 7. Vellodi A, Young EP, Cooper A, Writh JE, Winchester B, Meney C, Rmswmi U, Will A (997) Bone mrrow trnsplnttion for mucopolyscchridosis type I: experience of two British centres. Arch Dis Child 76:92 99 8. Jmeson E, Jones S, Writh JE (203) Enzyme replcement therpy with lronidse (Aldurzyme) for treting mucopolyscchridosis type I. Cochrne Dtbse Syst Rev 9:CD009354 9. Lmpe C, Bosserhoff AK, Burton BK, Giuglini R, de Souz CF, Bittr C, Muschol N, Olson R, Mendelsohn NJ (204) Long-term experience with enzyme replcement therpy (ERT) in MPS II ptients with severe phenotype: n interntionl cse series. J Inherit Metb Dis 37:823 829 20. d Silv EM, Strufldi MW, Andriolo RB, Silv LA (204) Enzyme replcement therpy with idursulfse for mucopolyscchridosis type II (Hunter syndrome). Cochrne Dtbse Syst Rev :CD00885 2. Sifuentes M, Doroshow R, Hoft R, Mson G, Wlot I, Diment M, Okzki S, Huff K, Cox GF, Swiedler SJ, Kkkis ED (2007) A follow-up study of MPS I ptients treted with lronidse enzyme replcement therpy for 6 yers. Mol Genet Metb :7 80 22. Tylor C, Brdy P, O Mer A, Moore D, Dowling F, Fogrty E (2008) Mobility in Hurler syndrome. J Peditr Orthop 28:63 68 23. Muenzer J, Writh JE, Clrke LA (2009) Mucopolyscchridosis I: mngement nd tretment guidelines. Peditrics :9 29 24. Muenzer J, Beck M, Eng CM, Escolr ML, Giuglini R, Guffon NH, Hrmtz P, Kmin W, Kmpmnn C, Koseoglu ST, Link B, Mrtin RA, Molter DW, Muñoz Rojs MV, Ogilvie JW, Prini R, Rmswmi U, Scrp M, Schwrtz IV, Wood RE, Writh E (2009) Multidisciplinry mngement of Hunter syndrome. Peditrics 24:228 9