Enterprise Interest No
SY-05 Pulmonary Pathology: Options for targeted therapy in lung cancer Liquid biopsy in thoracic oncology Where are we now? Paul Hofman Laboratory of Clinical and Experimental Pathology Liquid Biopsy Laboratory & FHU OncoAge University Côte d Azur, Nice, Fr (www.oncoage.org)
Agenda Brief background Potential usefulness of a liquid biopsy in lung cancer The only current approach in a daily routine practice What s the future for CTCs detection? A couple of perspectives (among others) Conclusion
Agenda Brief background Potential usefulness of a liquid biopsy in lung cancer The only current approach in a daily routine practice What s the future for CTCs detection? A couple of perspectives (among others) Conclusion
The right drug The right patient The right time Stratified medicine in thoracic oncology The right approach The right cost
The right turnaround time The right drug The right patient The right time Stratified medecine in thoraciccer patients Liquid and/or tissue biopsies? The right approach The right cost
The different compartments of a liquid biopsy Circulating Tumor Cells Platelets Healthy tissue cfdna ctdna(tumoral) Tumor tissue Red blood cells Immune cells Exosomes Apoptotic cells
Free tumor DNA Exosomes Free DNA Free germinal DNA Free RNA Free microrna ***** *** *** ** **** *** ** Hofman et al, Curr Mol Med, 2014
Agenda Brief background Potential usefulness of a liquid biopsy in lung cancer The only current approach in a daily routine practice What s the future for CTCs detection? A couple of perspectives (among others) Conclusion
Many opportunities in lung cancer patients Screening and early detection of cancer Risk of metastatic relapse (prognosis) Stratified medicine Development of therapies Monitoring relapse and resistance Tumor heterogeneity
Ilie M et al, Ann Oncol 2012; Hofman P, Cancers 2017a; Hofman P, Cancers 2017b
Morphology IHC (D5F3 clone) FISH Genotyping Tumor tissue (FFPE) EGFR, KRAS, BRAF pyrosequencing (Qiagen) MGG ICC CTCs (ISET) Abbott Molecular Ilie et al, Ann Oncol 2012 Hofman, Cancers 2017a Hofman, Cancers 2017b
% Overall Survival % Disease-free survival Detection of CTCs by cytomorphology analysis Prognosis biomarker in NSCLC patients undergoing surgery (stages I-II) < 50 CNHC n = 27 (56%) < 50 CNHC n = 45 (57%) 50 CNHC n = 21 (44%) P = 0.002 Log-rank = 8.97 P = 0.001 Log-rank = 12.10 Time (months) Time (months) Stage IA Stage IB Hofman et al, Clin Cancer Res, 2011 Hofman et al, Int J Cancer, 2011 Hofman et al Am J Clin Pathol,2011 Hofman et al, Am J Clin Pathol, 2011 Hofman et al, Cytopathology, 2011 Hofman et al, Cancer Cytopathol, 2016
Agenda Brief background Potential usefulness of a liquid biopsy in lung cancer The only current approach in a daily routine practice What s the future for CTCs detection? A couple of perspectives (among others) Conclusion
Detection of EGFR mutations (both activating and resistant) from cfdna extracted from plasma sample The only test to be used clinically in a daily routine practice to date
Clinical utility of fluid/liquid biopsy / cfdna Sensitivity about 65%
Clinical indications for liquid biopsy for EGFR mutation detection in lung cancer at baseline WHEN? - No tissue sample available - Low percentage of cancer cells in FFPE sample - DNA of low quality and/or no DNA amplification - Inappropriate fixation - Long turnaround time to get the results Hofman & Popper, Virchows Archiv 2016
Stage IIIb/IV lung ADC with EGFR activating mutation treated with EGFR TKI Clinical indications for liquid biopsy for EGFR mutation detection in lung cancer at progression under EGFR TKI Disease progression T790M + 3 rd generation EGFR TKI Liquid biopsy T790M + 3 rd generation EGFR TKI T790M - Tissue biopsy T790M - Chemotherapy
ARMS ddpcr NGS Sensitivity ++ +++ + Coverage - - +++ Quantification ++ +++ + IVD kits +++ - ++ Costs (equip) +++ + ++ Costs (reag) ++ + + TAT +++ +++ +
Agenda Brief background Potential usefulness of a liquid biopsy in lung cancer The only current approach in a daily routine practice What s the future for CTCs detection? A couple of perspectives (among others) Conclusion
Hofman et al, Curr Mol Med, 2014
Advantages and limitations of the detection of circulating tumor cells Advantages Limitations Ilié & Hofman, Ann Transl Med, 2014 Hofman & Popper, Virch Archiv 2016
Advantages and limitations of the detection of circulating free DNA Advantages Limitations Ilié & Hofman, Ann Transl Med, 2014 Hofman & Popper, Virch Archiv 2016
Oncotarget 2017
Intensity scoring in tissue and CTCs with the SP44 clone (Ventana) Oncotarget 2017
Current development Liquid biopsy in the field of immunotherapy AACR 2016 manuscript in revision, 2017
Agenda Brief background Potential usefulness of a liquid biopsy in lung cancer The only current approach in a daily routine practice What s the future for CTCs detection? A couple of perspectives (among others) Conclusion
Improvement of our knowledge in lung cancer pathophysiology Hofman et al, Curr Mol Med, 2014 ;;;;;;;;;
Toward the concept of a «liquid microenvironment» Interaction between circulating tumour cells and blood cells (platelets, myeloid cells and lymphocytes) A new world for new perspective in research investigation for lung cancer patients Neutrophils CTCs
Neutrophil
Platelets CTCs From Best et al, Cancer Cell 2017 ISET filter; LPCE, Nice, Fr TEP RNA profiles allow for blood-based early lung cancer diagnostic
Screening test for lung cancer?
Blood fitration method COPD Patients rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrryyyy yyyyyyyyyyr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrryyyr Detection of CTCs using blood filtered through a filter.. Working with a kind of piston coffeemaker! rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr! rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrryyyy yyyyyyyyyyr
Patient LH/298 40 P/Y Severe COPD November 2009 Ilie & Hofman, PLoS One 2014 Hofman et al, Curr Opin Oncol, 2017
ISET Technology Patient LH/298 40 P/Y Severe COPD November 2009 8 mm Ilie & Hofman, PLoS One 2014 Hofman et al, Curr Opin Oncol, 2017
Patient LH/298 December 2011 ct1n0m0 Ilie & Hofman, PLoS One 2014 Hofman et al, Curr Opin Oncol, 2017
«Sentinel» Circulating Tumor Cells Allow Early Diagnosis of Lung cancer in Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Ilie & Hofman PLoS One 2014 Hofman, Curr Opin Oncol, 2017
Agenda Brief background Potential usefulness of a liquid biopsy in lung cancer The only current approach in a daily routine practice What s the future for CTCs detection? A couple of perspectives (among others) Conclusion
Liquide biopsy for lung cancer in 2017 In routine now, assessment of EGFR status in cf-dna Coming soon, assessment of various genomic alteration by NGS Perspectives: Early diagnosis of lung cancer (RNA, microrna, CTCs, DNA methylation) Predictive biomarker (s) for immunotherapy response Screening of lung cancer onset in a high risk population
Compagny X We still need to be aware! Can tissue biopsy be replaced by liquid biopsy? Ilié M and Hofman P, Transl Lung Cancer Res, 2016 Aug;5(4):420-3
Team LPCE 2017