Causality and counterfactual analysis
|
|
- Charity Gardner
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Chapter 6.4 Causality and counterfactual analysis Daniel M. Hausman In chapter 6.2 of this book, Sander Greenland provides an introduction to contemporary views of causal inference (see also Pearl 2000) and makes two points relevant to summary measures of population health: i) that health gaps are not well-defined; and ii) that a multidimensional index of population health would be superior to a scalar measure. In theory, a multidimensional index of population health is attractive, because health itself is multidimensional. But the theoretical attractions of a multidimensional index have to be balanced against the practical dangers that those who make health policy would ignore most of the dimensions. Greenland and I are not particularly competent to judge these dangers, and I shall focus the remainder of my remarks on matters of causal inference. Greenland considers how investigators answer counterfactual questions concerning what the consequences would have been had some other action been taken. Such questions are closely related to questions about the consequences of proposed interventions. These are in part questions concerning the use of incomplete prior causal knowledge. I do not know how commonly accepted Greenland s views are among epidemiologists, but they are controversial among philosophers. Given the page constraints, contemporary philosophical controversies concerning the nature of counterfactuals and the relations between causation and counterfactuals will not be discussed in depth. I can only sketch the most influential view, which is due to David Lewis (Lewis 1973a; 1973b; 1979), and explain how it is related to Greenland s position. I shall argue that even a qualified acceptance of Lewis view undermines Greenland s critique of health gaps. I shall also show that Greenland s own philosophical premises do not support so strong a conclusion as the one he draws. The general problem is as follows. One begins with a suspicion that there is some relation between a variable, X, and some outcome variable, Y, though one also believes that Y depends on other variables, both known
2 310 Summary Measures of Population Health and unknown. The functional relation between X, Y and other variables may be probabilistic or deterministic, but it is never fully known. One can observe the actual value of X at some particular time, x 1, and the actual value of Y that results, y 1, but not the other values X could have had at that time, or other values that Y would have taken in response. Rather than observing how the outcome would have differed if X had had a different value, x 0 (and everything else at that time and place were the same), one can only observe how the outcome in fact differs when X = x 0 at a different time, and when there is no assurance that everything else is just the same. In this way, in Greenland s terminology, a measure of association is obtained, from which the measure of effect is inferred. As more is known about the functional relation between X, Y, and other variables, for which measures of association constitute evidence, a better answer will be possible to the counterfactual question about what the value of Y would have been if the value of X had been x 0. Although Greenland uses causal language, he is concerned with counterfactuals rather than causation. Greenland insists that the counterfactual question is well defined only when values of X are actions. When the values of X are not actions, the question: What would the value of Y have been if the value of X had been x 0? cannot be answered, because it is not known how the value of X became x 0 instead of x 1. If a heavy smoker, P, had not died of lung cancer at age 50 years because (counterfactually) P had never smoked, then P s life expectancy would be much longer than if P had not died of lung cancer because of a successful chemotherapy treatment. There is no answer to the question: How long would P have lived if P had not died of lung cancer until one specifies the action or intervention that would have brought it about that P had not died of lung cancer. Calculations of health gaps or years of life lost, such as the number of years of life lost to AIDS, pose exactly such allegedly ill-formed questions. It is unknown how long individuals with AIDS would live if they were not infected with AIDS, because there are different ways in which they might not have had AIDS, and their life expectancies would depend on how they were not infected. Health gaps are thus not well defined and the whole attempt to measure DALYs may be an irretrievable muddle. Why doesn t this difficulty apply equally to all counterfactuals? How does insisting that the values of X be actions circumvent the problems? Consider Greenland s own example: x 1 is the revocation of Kosovo s autonomy in 1988 and Y is mortality in Kosovo in The actual value of Y can, in principle, be observed. One then asks the counterfactual question: What would mortality in 1999 have been if Kosovo s autonomy had not been revoked in 1988 (if the value of X were x 0 )? The answer cannot be determined by observation, because no one can observe a counterfactual mortality rate. However, it could be assumed that the counterfactual mortality in 1999 would be the same as the actual mortality in 1988, subject to corrections for factors that are independent of
3 Causality and counterfactual analysis 311 whether autonomy was revoked. In this way, estimates of what mortality would have been in 1999 if Kosovo s autonomy had not been revoked can be obtained and one can offer a fallible answer to the counterfactual question. Notice that the increased mortality in 1999 was due to the fact that Kosovo s autonomy was revoked in just the way it was. If its autonomy were revoked by a Yugoslav government dominated by ethnic Albanians, as part of an effort to impose Kosovo s culture and interests on the whole of Yugoslavia, its effects would presumably have been very different. Consequently, it matters a great deal how x 0, the non-revocation, is specified. A non-revocation is not of course any specific kind of action, although a specific non-revocation could be identical to some particular action (or actions). The hypothetical non-revocation Greenland refers to, x 0, is presumably a specific complicated set of actions that differs from the actions the Yugoslav government took in 1988 as little as possible, apart from not revoking Kosovo s autonomy. According to Lewis theory (Lewis 1973b), a counterfactual such as: If Yugoslavia had not revoked Kosovo s autonomy in 1988, ethnic cleansing would not have occurred in Kosovo in 1999, is true if and only if some possible world without the revocation and without ethnic cleansing is more similar to the actual world than any possible world without revocation and with the ethnic cleansing. Notice that Lewis does not rely on causal knowledge to evaluate the truth of the counterfactual. This is important, because Lewis hopes to define causation in terms of chains of counterfactual dependence (Lewis 1973a). Lewis account of counterfactuals depends on a theory of similarity among possible worlds (Lewis 1979). In its simplest outline, the possible worlds in which Kosovo s autonomy is not revoked that are most similar to the actual world will be identical to the actual world until shortly before the moment in 1988 when Yugoslavia revoked Kosovo s autonomy. Then, despite the occurrence of the causal antecedents for the revocation, the revocation miraculously fails to occur. Apart from lacking the revocation, the closest possible worlds will differ very little from the actual world at the moment when Kosovo s autonomy was in fact revoked. History then runs on, according to the same laws as those that govern the actual world. One relies on those laws to predict what the result would be if Yugoslavia had not revoked Kosovo s autonomy when it did. Several quite different possible worlds may be equally similar to the actual world, and the counterfactual will not be true, unless ethnic cleansing does not occur in any of those worlds. Although Greenland does not explicitly talk about similarity between possible worlds, he relies implicitly on some such notion in specifying what action x 0, the non-revocation, is. What then of counterfactuals like those Greenland criticizes, such as: If P had not died of lung cancer at age 50 years, then P would have lived for at least 20 years more. According to Lewis, this counterfactual is no more difficult to evaluate than the counterfactual concerning what would
4 312 Summary Measures of Population Health have been the case if the Yugoslavs had not revoked Kosovo s autonomy. Are possible worlds in which P lives for at least 20 years after not dying of lung cancer at age 50 more similar to the actual world than possible worlds in which P does not die of lung cancer and dies before age 70? Possible worlds in which P never smoked are less similar to the actual world than possible worlds in which P lives just the same life until age 50, contracts lung cancer, but fails to die of it because of a spontaneous remission. We have data on the general life expectancy of people who have lung cancers resembling P s, yet who do not die of them in circumstances like those in which P does in fact die of lung cancer. Thus we have some basis to judge whether it is true that if P had not died of lung cancer at age 50, then P would have lived at least 20 years more. Since a possible world in which P never smoked would be very unlike the actual world, one does not examine such a world to determine what would be the case if P had not died of lung cancer. In addition, Lewis framework permits one to consider counterfactuals with more complicated antecedents. For example, consider a counterfactual such as: If P had not died of lung cancer at age 50 years because P never smoked and never got lung cancer, then P would have lived to age 90. In evaluating this counterfactual, possible worlds that diverged from the actual world long ago when P in fact began smoking are considered. Whatever counterfactual is considered, the indeterminacy that concerns Greenland evaporates. Lewis views on similarity among possible worlds and his views of the evaluation of counterfactuals have been questioned elsewhere (Hausman 1998). When the consequence of some counterfactual antecedent depends on how it comes about, it is not always justifiable to suppose that it comes about in just one special way, as if by a miracle or intervention. When it is asked, for example, what is the average number of years of life lost owing to lung cancer, it is necessary to specify the possible state of affairs in which individuals no longer died of lung cancer. For example, do people not die of lung cancer because of interventions designed to stop causes of lung cancer, such as smoking or air pollution; or because of an intervention that interferes with the mechanisms by which these cause lung cancer; or because of improvements in treating lung cancer? Without some such specification, the question: How much longer (on average) would people live if they did not die of lung cancer? has no correct answer. There are, however, two reasons to doubt whether this is a serious problem in practice. First, in some cases the consequence of the non-occurrence of some health state (or some cause of death) will not be so sensitive to the way the health state or cause of death might be prevented. Although the calculation of the health gap caused by malaria will depend on whether one supposes malaria is eliminated by vaccination, by mosquito eradication, or by an effective treatment, the differences are not so large as to make the calculation meaningless. Second, I would conjecture that in assessing health gaps, health analysts typically assume that the
5 Causality and counterfactual analysis 313 counterfactual alternative to the death or disability resulting from a particular disease involves a last-minute intervention of the sort Lewis discusses. For example, one would naturally take the health gap caused by malaria to be the difference between the current state of health where malaria is prevalent and the state of health that would obtain in much the same conditions if there were a vaccine without side-effects or if there were a successful mosquito eradication programme. It is obvious that the benefits of an actual anti-malarial medication might be much less. Greenland s indeterminacy still exists, but at least in cases such as this one the indeterminacy is mild, and ignoring it would not be the greatest of the simplifications and idealizations required in order to define a summary measure of population health. References Hausman D (1998) Causal asymmetries. Cambridge University Press, New York. Lewis D (1973a) Causation. Journal of Philosophy, 70: Lewis D (1973b) Counterfactuals. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA. Lewis D (1979) Counterfactual dependence and time s arrow. Noûs, 13: Pearl J (2000) Causality: models, reasoning and inference. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
6
Herbert A. Simon Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA
Health Economics, Policy and Law (2008), 3: 79 83 ª Cambridge University Press 2008 doi:10.1017/s1744133107004343 Response Valuing health properly DANIEL M. HAUSMAN* Herbert A. Simon Professor, Department
More informationUNCORRECTED PROOF. Daniel Steel / Across the Boundaries 01-DanielSteel-chap01 Page Proof page :48pm ACROSS THE BOUNDARIES
Daniel Steel / Across the Boundaries 01-DanielSteel-chap01 Page Proof page 1 15.6.2007 9:48pm ACROSS THE BOUNDARIES Daniel Steel / Across the Boundaries 01-DanielSteel-chap01 Page Proof page 2 15.6.2007
More informationEpidemiologic Causation: Jerome Cornfield s Argument for a Causal Connection between Smoking and Lung Cancer
EpidemiologicCausation:JeromeCornfield sargument foracausalconnectionbetweensmokingandlung Cancer RogerStanev ** rstanev@interchange.ubc.ca ABSTRACT Acentralissueconfrontingbothphilosophersandpractitionersinformulatingananalysisofcausationis
More informationPSYCHOLOGICAL CONSCIOUSNESS AND PHENOMENAL CONSCIOUSNESS. Overview
Lecture 28-29 PSYCHOLOGICAL CONSCIOUSNESS AND PHENOMENAL CONSCIOUSNESS Overview David J. Chalmers in his famous book The Conscious Mind 1 tries to establish that the problem of consciousness as the hard
More informationMeasuring the burden of disease John Broome
Measuring the burden of disease John Broome 1. Introduction A important part of the WHO s work has been to develop and publish summary measures of the burden of disease for different nations. The WHO aims
More informationA Difference that Makes a Difference: Welfare and the Equality of Consideration
84 A Difference that Makes a Difference: Welfare and the Equality of Consideration Abstract Elijah Weber Philosophy Department Bowling Green State University eliweber1980@gmail.com In Welfare, Happiness,
More informationArtificial Intelligence Programming Probability
Artificial Intelligence Programming Probability Chris Brooks Department of Computer Science University of San Francisco Department of Computer Science University of San Francisco p.1/25 17-0: Uncertainty
More informationAssignment 4: True or Quasi-Experiment
Assignment 4: True or Quasi-Experiment Objectives: After completing this assignment, you will be able to Evaluate when you must use an experiment to answer a research question Develop statistical hypotheses
More informationSupplement 2. Use of Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs)
Supplement 2. Use of Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) Abstract This supplement describes how counterfactual theory is used to define causal effects and the conditions in which observed data can be used to
More informationEffective Intentions: The Power of Conscious Will
Book Review Effective Intentions: The Power of Conscious Will Alfred R. Mele Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2009 Marco Fenici* fenici@unisi.it Mele s book is a concise analysis of much research in neurophysiology
More information20. Experiments. November 7,
20. Experiments November 7, 2015 1 Experiments are motivated by our desire to know causation combined with the fact that we typically only have correlations. The cause of a correlation may be the two variables
More informationComments on David Rosenthal s Consciousness, Content, and Metacognitive Judgments
Consciousness and Cognition 9, 215 219 (2000) doi:10.1006/ccog.2000.0438, available online at http://www.idealibrary.com on Comments on David Rosenthal s Consciousness, Content, and Metacognitive Judgments
More informationIntentional Action and Side Effects in Ordinary Language. The chairman of the board of a company has decided to implement
Intentional Action and Side Effects in Ordinary Language JOSHUA KNOBE Knobe, J. (2003). Intentional Action and Side Effects in Ordinary Language. Analysis, 63, 190-193. The chairman of the board of a company
More informationDiscussion. Re C (An Adult) 1994
Autonomy is an important ethical and legal principle. Respect for autonomy is especially important in a hospital setting. A patient is in an inherently vulnerable position; he or she is part of a big and
More informationIn Support of a No-exceptions Truth-telling Policy in Medicine
In Support of a No-exceptions Truth-telling Policy in Medicine An odd standard has developed regarding doctors responsibility to tell the truth to their patients. Lying, or the act of deliberate deception,
More informationtwo ways in which things can be colloquially called the same : being that very thing, and not another being like and undistinguishable
Williams: A Paradox of Personal Identity 1. Bernard Williams: Recently deceased. Williams had broad interests: he worked in metaphysics, epistemology, and the history of philosophy. His most famous and
More informationIntentional Horizons
Mind Knowledge Communication Intentional Horizons The Mind from an Epistemic Point of View von Magdalena Balcerak Jackson 1. Auflage mentis 2009 Verlag C.H. Beck im Internet: www.beck.de ISBN 978 3 89785
More information1. Before starting the second session, quickly examine total on short form BDI; note
SESSION #2: 10 1. Before starting the second session, quickly examine total on short form BDI; note increase or decrease. Recall that rating a core complaint was discussed earlier. For the purpose of continuity,
More informationThe Emotional Survival Training Manual
Very often, when people have difficulty coping with reality, their primary problem is simply that they never had the opportunity to learn practical coping skills. Their emotional development was missing
More information1 The conceptual underpinnings of statistical power
1 The conceptual underpinnings of statistical power The importance of statistical power As currently practiced in the social and health sciences, inferential statistics rest solidly upon two pillars: statistical
More informationGCSE EXAMINERS' REPORTS
GCSE EXAMINERS' REPORTS SOCIOLOGY SUMMER 2016 Grade boundary information for this subject is available on the WJEC public website at: https://www.wjecservices.co.uk/marktoums/default.aspx?l=en Online Results
More informationReview. Chapter 5. Common Language. Ch 3: samples. Ch 4: real world sample surveys. Experiments, Good and Bad
Review Ch 3: samples Sampling terminology Proportions Margin of error Ch 4: real world sample surveys Questions to ask about a study Errors in sample surveys Concerns about survey questions Probability
More informationChapter 5: Producing Data
Chapter 5: Producing Data Key Vocabulary: observational study vs. experiment confounded variables population vs. sample sampling vs. census sample design voluntary response sampling convenience sampling
More informationEXPERIMENTAL DESIGN Page 1 of 11. relationships between certain events in the environment and the occurrence of particular
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN Page 1 of 11 I. Introduction to Experimentation 1. The experiment is the primary means by which we are able to establish cause-effect relationships between certain events in the environment
More informationChapter 02. Basic Research Methodology
Chapter 02 Basic Research Methodology Definition RESEARCH Research is a quest for knowledge through diligent search or investigation or experimentation aimed at the discovery and interpretation of new
More informationOn the diversity principle and local falsifiability
On the diversity principle and local falsifiability Uriel Feige October 22, 2012 1 Introduction This manuscript concerns the methodology of evaluating one particular aspect of TCS (theoretical computer
More informationBook review of Herbert I. Weisberg: Bias and Causation, Models and Judgment for Valid Comparisons Reviewed by Judea Pearl
Book review of Herbert I. Weisberg: Bias and Causation, Models and Judgment for Valid Comparisons Reviewed by Judea Pearl Judea Pearl University of California, Los Angeles Computer Science Department Los
More informationFunctionalist theories of content
Functionalist theories of content PHIL 93507 April 22, 2012 Let s assume that there is a certain stable dependence relation between the physical internal states of subjects and the phenomenal characters
More informationUNIT 5 - Association Causation, Effect Modification and Validity
5 UNIT 5 - Association Causation, Effect Modification and Validity Introduction In Unit 1 we introduced the concept of causality in epidemiology and presented different ways in which causes can be understood
More informationConclusion. The international conflicts related to identity issues are a contemporary concern of societies
105 Conclusion 1. Summary of the argument The international conflicts related to identity issues are a contemporary concern of societies around the world. It is only necessary to watch the news for few
More informationChapter 2 Epidemiology
Chapter 2 Epidemiology 2.1. The basic theoretical science of epidemiology 2.1.1 Brief history of epidemiology 2.1.2. Definition of epidemiology 2.1.3. Epidemiology and public health/preventive medicine
More informationplural noun 1. a system of moral principles: the ethics of a culture. 2. the rules of conduct recognized in respect to a particular group, culture,
eth ics plural noun [eth-iks] 1. a system of moral principles: the ethics of a culture. 2. the rules of conduct recognized in respect to a particular group, culture, etc.: Scientific ethics; Medical ethics;
More informationDiagramming and reasoning about causes. Phil 12: Logic and Decision Making Winter 2010 UC San Diego 2/24/2010
Diagramming and reasoning about causes Phil 12: Logic and Decision Making Winter 2010 UC San Diego 2/24/2010 Review Mill s methods: designed to identify the likely cause from amongst possible causes Method
More informationReasoning About and Graphing Causes
Reasoning About and Graphing Causes Review Distinguish necessary and sufficient causes Most causes are neither necessary nor sufficient Rather, contributory or partial Increase or decrease the likelihood
More informationReview of Tim Bayne s The Unity of Consciousness
Review of Tim Bayne s The Unity of Consciousness Angela Mendelovici amendel5@uwo.ca July 21, 2011 Tim Bayne, The Unity of Consciousness, Oxford University Press, 2010, 341pp., $55.00 (hbk), ISBN 9780199215386.
More informationCHAPTER 2 APPLYING SCIENTIFIC THINKING TO MANAGEMENT PROBLEMS
Cambodian Mekong University is the university that cares for the value of education MN 400: Research Methods CHAPTER 2 APPLYING SCIENTIFIC THINKING TO MANAGEMENT PROBLEMS Teacher: Pou, Sovann Sources of
More informationCausation. Producing vs. Predicting
Causation Producing vs. Predicting 1 What is Causation? Cause and effect is a concept that scientists use a lot, but it is also a common sense notion. Many ordinary verbs express causal relations, e.g.
More informationDenny Borsboom Jaap van Heerden Gideon J. Mellenbergh
Validity and Truth Denny Borsboom Jaap van Heerden Gideon J. Mellenbergh Department of Psychology, University of Amsterdam ml borsboom.d@macmail.psy.uva.nl Summary. This paper analyzes the semantics of
More informationWhy randomize? Rohini Pande Harvard University and J-PAL.
Why randomize? Rohini Pande Harvard University and J-PAL www.povertyactionlab.org Agenda I. Background on Program Evaluation II. What is a randomized experiment? III. Advantages and Limitations of Experiments
More informationDesigned Experiments have developed their own terminology. The individuals in an experiment are often called subjects.
When we wish to show a causal relationship between our explanatory variable and the response variable, a well designed experiment provides the best option. Here, we will discuss a few basic concepts and
More informationBrute Luck and Responsibility. Peter Vallentyne, University of Missouri-Columbia. April 6, 2013
Brute Luck and Responsibility Peter Vallentyne, University of Missouri-Columbia April 6, 2013 The issue of responsibility for the outcomes of one s choices is relevant to both ethics and political philosophy.
More informationAgainst Securitism, the New Breed of Actualism in Consequentialist Thought
1 Against Securitism, the New Breed of Actualism in Consequentialist Thought 2013 Meeting of the New Mexico-West Texas Philosophical Society Jean-Paul Vessel jvessel@nmsu.edu New Mexico State University
More informationPerception, Biology, Action, and Knowledge
Philosophy and Phenomenological Research Vol. LXXXVIII No. 2, March 2014 doi: 10.1111/phpr.12092 2014 Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, LLC Perception, Biology, Action, and Knowledge CHRISTOPHER
More informationBook Information Jakob Hohwy, The Predictive Mind, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013, ix+288, 60.00,
1 Book Information Jakob Hohwy, The Predictive Mind, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013, ix+288, 60.00, 978-0-19-968273-7. Review Body The Predictive Mind by Jakob Hohwy is the first monograph to address
More informationSMALL n IMPACT EVALUATION. Howard White and Daniel Phillips 3ie
SMALL n IMPACT EVALUATION Howard White and Daniel Phillips 3ie MY PRIORS Bad evaluation Good evaluation MY PRIORS MY PRIORS MY PRIORS All projectaffected persons (PAPs) DEFINITIONS I Impact evaluations
More informationEXPERIMENTAL METHODS 1/15/18. Experimental Designs. Experiments Uncover Causation. Experiments examining behavior in a lab setting
EXPERIMENTAL METHODS Experimental Designs Experiments examining behavior in a lab setting Controlled lab setting separates experiments from non-experiments Allows experimenter to know exactly what s causing
More informationobservational studies Descriptive studies
form one stage within this broader sequence, which begins with laboratory studies using animal models, thence to human testing: Phase I: The new drug or treatment is tested in a small group of people for
More informationBending it Like Beckham: Movement, Control and Deviant Causal Chains
Bending it Like Beckham: Movement, Control and Deviant Causal Chains MARKUS E. SCHLOSSER Forthcoming in Analysis This is the author s copy that may differ from the final print version Like all causal theories
More informationHosted by Department of Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method Lakatos Award Lectures
Hosted by Department of Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method Lakatos Award Lectures Dr Thomas Pradeu CNRS and University of Bordeaux Dr Brian Epstein Tufts Professor Hasok Chang Chair Cambridge Hashtag
More information2014 Philosophy. National 5. Finalised Marking Instructions
National Qualifications 2014 2014 Philosophy National 5 Finalised Marking Instructions Scottish Qualifications Authority 2014 The information in this publication may be reproduced to support SQA qualifications
More informationCharles R. Plott California Institute of Technology
The Rational Foundations of Economic Behavior," edited by K. Arrow, E. Colombatto, M. Perlaman and C. Schmidt. London: Macmillan and New York: St. Martin's Press, (1996):220-224. COMMENTS ON: DANIEL KAHNEMAN,..
More informationPerception and Mind-Dependence: Lecture 4
1 Recap Perception and Mind-Dependence: Lecture 4 (Alex Moran, apm60@cam.ac.uk) We considered several of the standard arguments against sense data. We saw that none of them were conclusive. But we did
More informationEveryone asks and answers questions of causation.
Chapter 11: Cause and Effect: Explaining Why Everyone asks and answers questions of causation. Cause and effect, like the two sides of a coin, are inseparably linked and together make up causation. Cause
More informationIntroduction. 1.1 Facets of Measurement
1 Introduction This chapter introduces the basic idea of many-facet Rasch measurement. Three examples of assessment procedures taken from the field of language testing illustrate its context of application.
More informationDRAFT (Final) Concept Paper On choosing appropriate estimands and defining sensitivity analyses in confirmatory clinical trials
DRAFT (Final) Concept Paper On choosing appropriate estimands and defining sensitivity analyses in confirmatory clinical trials EFSPI Comments Page General Priority (H/M/L) Comment The concept to develop
More informationPart 1: Comparative Case Studies Part 2: Causal Processes
Part 1: Millian Methods of Comparison and Case Selection Tommaso Pavone tpavone@princeton.edu November 19 th, 2015 Introduction Suppose you wish to explore the conditions under which a military coup will
More informationModern Statistical Learning Methods for Observational Biomedical Data. Chapter 1: Introduction to causal inference
Modern Statistical Learning Methods for Observational Biomedical Data Chapter 1: Introduction to causal inference David Benkeser Emory Univ. Marco Carone Univ. of Washington Larry Kessler Univ. of Washington
More informationEvaluation Models STUDIES OF DIAGNOSTIC EFFICIENCY
2. Evaluation Model 2 Evaluation Models To understand the strengths and weaknesses of evaluation, one must keep in mind its fundamental purpose: to inform those who make decisions. The inferences drawn
More informationAUDIT SAMPLING CHAPTER LEARNING OUTCOMES CHAPTER OVERVIEW
CHAPTER 7 AUDIT SAMPLING After studying this chapter, you will be able to: LEARNING OUTCOMES Define Audit Sampling as per Standards on Auditing 530 and it importance. Identify the Approaches to Audit Sampling
More informationQUASI EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
UNIT 3 QUASI EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN Factorial Design Structure 3. Introduction 3.1 Objectives 3.2 Meaning of Quasi Experimental Design 3.3 Difference Between Quasi Experimental Design and True Experimental
More informationRisk Assessment Terminology, Expression of Nature and level of Risk and Uncertainties
Risk Assessment Terminology, Expression of Nature and level of Risk and Uncertainties Professor Tony Hardy, Chair of EFSA PPR Panel Brussels 13 th November 2008 Comparative Review of Risk Terminology of
More informationPaper prompts Do either one but not both
Papers Paper prompts Do either one but not both The myth of Sisyphus appears frequently in the meaning of life literature. How have various authors used this myth to present arguments regarding questions
More informationThe Predictive Mind. Jakob Hohwy. Oxford University Press, 2013, 286pp, Hardcover, 65, ISBN
1 The Predictive Mind. Jakob Hohwy. Oxford University Press, 2013, 286pp, Hardcover, 65, ISBN 9780199682737. In his book, The Predictive Mind, Jakob Hohwy builds a case for the increasingly popular idea
More informationWeek 2. Outline 07/09/2014 I. PROCESS OF RESEARCH
Week 2 Outline I. Process of Research II. Ethics of research III. Concept of Science IV. Goals of science V. Logic of scientific reasoning VI. Approaches to science RJ_Research Method_s1_2014-2015pjj 2
More informationFaculty of Medicine. Introduction to Community Medicine Course ( ) Unit 4 Epidemiology. Introduction to Epidemiology.
Faculty of Medicine Introduction to Community Medicine Course (31505201) Unit 4 Epidemiology Introduction to Epidemiology Disease Causation By Hatim Jaber MD MPH JBCM PhD 25-10-2016 1 Presentation outline
More informationA Hopeful Beginning for Malaria Vaccines
Transcript Details This is a transcript of an educational program accessible on the ReachMD network. Details about the program and additional media formats for the program are accessible by visiting: https://reachmd.com/programs/focus-on-global-medicine/a-hopeful-beginning-for-malariavaccines/4043/
More informationPolicy for Substance Misuse and Substance Misuse Testing
Policy for Substance Misuse and Substance Misuse Testing 1. Introduction Given a national backdrop of increasing drug and other substance misuse among teenagers, including alcohol, we wish to ensure that
More informationConvergence Principles: Information in the Answer
Convergence Principles: Information in the Answer Sets of Some Multiple-Choice Intelligence Tests A. P. White and J. E. Zammarelli University of Durham It is hypothesized that some common multiplechoice
More informationChapter 2 Research Methodologies Related to Pharmacy Practice: An Overview
Chapter 2 Research Methodologies Related to Pharmacy Practice: An Overview Parastou Donyai Abstract This chapter considers the research methodologies presented throughout the book in relation to their
More informationRealism and Qualitative Research. Joseph A. Maxwell George Mason University
Realism and Qualitative Research Joseph A. Maxwell George Mason University Philosophic realism in general is "the view that entities exist independently of being perceived, or independently of our theories
More informationRole of Economic Epidemiology: With Special Reference to HIV/AIDS
Role of Economic Epidemiology: With Special Reference to HIV/AIDS Senelani Dorothy Hove-Musekwa NUST AIMS Bulawayo Cape Town Zimbabwe South Africa Economic Epidemiology Workshop - Uganda: 3 August 2009
More informationApplied Analysis of Variance and Experimental Design. Lukas Meier, Seminar für Statistik
Applied Analysis of Variance and Experimental Design Lukas Meier, Seminar für Statistik About Me Studied mathematics at ETH. Worked at the statistical consulting service and did a PhD in statistics (at
More informationTo conclude, a theory of error must be a theory of the interaction between human performance variability and the situational constraints.
The organisers have provided us with a both stimulating and irritating list of questions relating to the topic of the conference: Human Error. My first intention was to try to answer the questions one
More informationLiberal Resourcism: Problems and Possibilities. Bertil Tungodden, Norwegian School of Economics. Peter Vallentyne, University of Missouri
Liberal Resourcism: Problems and Possibilities Bertil Tungodden, Norwegian School of Economics Peter Vallentyne, University of Missouri 1. Resources... 3 2. Wellbeing... 4 3. Advantage... 8 4. Liberal
More informationBehaviorism: An essential survival tool for practitioners in autism
Behaviorism: An essential survival tool for practitioners in autism What we re going to do today 1. Review the role of radical behaviorism (RB) James M. Johnston, Ph.D., BCBA-D National Autism Conference
More informationCausal Inference in Statistics A primer, J. Pearl, M Glymur and N. Jewell
Causal Inference in Statistics A primer, J. Pearl, M Glymur and N. Jewell Rina Dechter Bren School of Information and Computer Sciences 6/7/2018 dechter, class 8, 276-18 The book of Why Pearl https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/01/business/dealbook/revi
More informationMental Health Alliance. Advance decisions
Mental Health Alliance Advance decisions To move the following Clause:- (1) The 1983 Act is amended as follows. (2) After section 76 (visiting and examination of patients) insert 76A Advance decisions
More informationModelling Experimental Interventions: Results and Challenges
Concrete Causation Munich 2010 Modelling Experimental Interventions: Results and Challenges Jan-Willem Romeijn Faculty of Philosophy University of Groningen Contents 1 Overview 3 2 Interventions and confirmation
More informationSocial inclusion as recognition? My purpose here is not to advocate for recognition paradigm as a superior way of defining/defending SI.
Social inclusion as recognition? My purpose here is not to advocate for recognition paradigm as a superior way of defining/defending SI. My purpose is just reflective: given tradition of thought and conceptual
More informationThe Discipline of Behaviorology and the Postulate of Determinism
Behaviorology Today Volume 5, Number 1, Spring 2002 (issn 1536 6669) Page 45 The Discipline of Behaviorology and the Postulate of Determinism Lawrence E. Fraley West Virginia University Introduction to
More informationCausal learning in an imperfect world
Causal learning in an imperfect world Reliability, background noise and memory David Lagnado Neil Bramley Contents 1. Introduction to causal learning Causal models Learning a causal model Interventions
More informationHow do Categories Work?
Presentations Logistics Think about what you want to do Thursday we ll informally sign up, see if we can reach consensus. Topics Linear representations of classes Non-linear representations of classes
More informationSpirituality in the Workplace
Spirituality in the Workplace By Ginger Lapid-Bogda, Ph.D. The most frequently asked question about spirituality in the workplace is this: How can the Enneagram be used to bring spirituality into organizations?
More informationRepresentational Content and Phenomenal Character
By David Hilbert, Unversity of Illinois at Chicago, Forthcoming in Sage Encyclopedia of Perception QUALIA Perception and thought are often, although not exclusively, concerned with information about the
More informationGlossary of Research Terms Compiled by Dr Emma Rowden and David Litting (UTS Library)
Glossary of Research Terms Compiled by Dr Emma Rowden and David Litting (UTS Library) Applied Research Applied research refers to the use of social science inquiry methods to solve concrete and practical
More informationMoral Responsibility, Blameworthiness, and Intention: In Search of Formal Definitions
Moral Responsibility, Blameworthiness, and Intention: In Search of Formal Definitions Joe Halpern Cornell University Includes joint work with Max Kleiman-Weiner (MIT) and Judea Pearl (UCLA). The Big Picture
More informationSGCEP SCIE 1121 Environmental Science Spring 2012 Section Steve Thompson:
SGCEP SCIE 1121 Environmental Science Spring 2012 Section 20531 Steve Thompson: steven.thompson@sgc.edu http://www.bioinfo4u.net/ 1 OK this book has done it again... They have crammed WAY too much information
More informationWarrant, Research, and the Practice of Gestalt Therapy
Warrant, Research, and the Practice of Gestalt Therapy Philip Brownell, MDiv; PsyD An Address to the Research Methods Training Seminar European Association for Gestalt Therapy May 2, 2014 Rome, Italy Introduction
More informationEvolutionary Approach to Investigations of Cognitive Systems
Evolutionary Approach to Investigations of Cognitive Systems Vladimir RED KO a,1 b and Anton KOVAL a Scientific Research Institute for System Analysis, Russian Academy of Science, Russia b National Nuclear
More informationPropensity Score Analysis Shenyang Guo, Ph.D.
Propensity Score Analysis Shenyang Guo, Ph.D. Upcoming Seminar: April 7-8, 2017, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Propensity Score Analysis 1. Overview 1.1 Observational studies and challenges 1.2 Why and when
More informationTo: The Public Guardian 4 September 2017.
To: The Public Guardian Alan.Eccles@publicguardian.gsi.gov.uk customerservices@publicguardian.gsi.gov.uk From: Mike Stone mhsatstokelib@yahoo.co.uk 4 September 2017 Dear Mr Eccles, I am writing to you
More informationIntroduction to Research Methods
Introduction to Research Methods Updated August 08, 2016 1 The Three Types of Psychology Research Psychology research can usually be classified as one of three major types: 1. Causal Research When most
More informationThe SAGE Deaf Studies Encyclopedia Geographies
The SAGE Deaf Studies Encyclopedia Geographies Contributors: Mike Gulliver & Mary Beth Kitzel Edited by: Genie Gertz & Patrick Boudreault Book Title: Chapter Title: "Geographies" Pub. Date: 2016 Access
More informationThis article, the last in a 4-part series on philosophical problems
GUEST ARTICLE Philosophical Issues in Medicine and Psychiatry, Part IV James Lake, MD This article, the last in a 4-part series on philosophical problems in conventional and integrative medicine, focuses
More informationUNESCO EOLSS. This article deals with risk-defusing behavior. It is argued that this forms a central part in decision processes.
RISK-DEFUSING BEHAVIOR Oswald Huber University of Fribourg, Switzerland Keywords: cognitive bias, control, cost of risk-defusing operators, decision making, effect of risk-defusing operators, lottery,
More informationThe Rationality of Perception rewrites perception s rational role and its rational standing. This
The Philosophical Review, 2018 Susanna Siegel, The Rationality of Perception. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017. xxv + 220 pp. The Rationality of Perception rewrites perception s rational role and
More informationIntroduction to Statistics Design of Experiments
Introduction to Statistics Design of Experiments Instructor : Siana Halim TOPICS Controlled Experiments Observational Studies References Statistics,, David Freedman, Robert Pisani, Roger Purves 3 rd. Edition,
More informationPCT 101. A Perceptual Control Theory Primer. Fred Nickols 8/27/2012
PCT 101 A Perceptual Control Theory Primer Fred Nickols 8/27/2012 This paper presents a simplified, plain language explanation of Perceptual Control Theory (PCT). PCT is a powerful and practical theory
More information