Chapter 2. The Research Enterprise in Psychology 8 th Edition

Transcription

1 Chapter 2 The Research Enterprise in Psychology 8 th Edition

2 The Scientific Approach: A Search for Laws Empiricism Basic assumption: events are governed by some lawful order Goals: Measurement and description Understanding and prediction Application and control Goal of theory testing in science: refutation not proving Karl Popper

3

4 Figure 2.2 Five steps of the Scientific Method

5 The Scientific Method: Terminology Operational definitions are used to clarify precisely what is meant by each variable Participants or subjects are the organisms whose behavior is systematically observed in a study Data collection techniques allow for empirical observation and measurement Statistics are used to analyze data and decide whether hypotheses were supported Findings are shared through reports at scientific meetings and in scientific journals periodicals that publish technical and scholarly material Advantages of the scientific method: clarity of communication and relative intolerance of error Research methods: general strategies for conducting scientific studies

6

7 Peer Review of Scientific Articles The process of publishing scientific studies allows other experts to evaluate and critique new research findings. They carefully evaluate each study s methods, statistical analyses, and conclusions, as well as its contribution to knowledge and theory. The purpose of the peer review process is to ensure that journals publish reliable findings based on high-quality research.

8 Figure 2.4 The peer review process for journal submissions.

9 Experimental Research: Looking for Causes Experiment = manipulation of one variable under controlled conditions so that resulting changes in another variable can be observed Detection of cause-and-effect relationships Independent variable (IV) = variable manipulated Dependent variable (DV) = variable affected by manipulation How does X affect Y? X= Independent Variable, and Y= Dependent Variable

10 Experimental and Control Groups: The Logic of the Scientific Method Experimental group subjects who receive some special treatment in regard to the independent variable Control group similar subjects who do not receive the special treatment Logic: Two groups alike in all respects (random assignment) Manipulate independent variable for one group only Resulting differences in the two groups must be due to the independent variable Extraneous and confounding variables

11 Youmans and Jee ( 2007) Fudging the Numbers IV: Candy condition DV: Nine question evaluation of instruction form Overall rating scores Results: Significant difference in overall rating Questions? Other effects and limitations

12 Figure 2.6 The basic elements of an experiment

13 Experimental Designs: Variations Expose a single group to two different conditions Reduces extraneous variables Manipulate more than one independent variable Allows for study of interactions between variables Use more than one dependent variable Obtains a more complete picture of effect of the independent variable

14 Figure 2.7 Manipulation of two independent variables in an experiment

15 Strengths and Weaknesses of Experimental Research Strengths: conclusions about cause-and-effect can be drawn Probabilistic causality Weaknesses: artificial nature of experiments ethical and practical issues

16 Descriptive/Correlational Methods: Looking for Relationships Methods used when a researcher cannot manipulate the variables under study Naturalistic observation Table 2.2, Levine & Norenzayan (1999) ranking of pace of life in 31 cultures Case studies Surveys Allow researchers to describe patterns of behavior and discover links or associations between variables but cannot imply causation

17 Figure 2.10 Sample from a case study a descriptive research method

18 XXXXXX

19 Statistics and Research: Drawing Conclusions Statistics using mathematics to organize, summarize, and interpret numerical data Descriptive statistics: organizing and summarizing data Inferential statistics: interpreting data and drawing conclusions use of probability

20 Descriptive Statistics: Measures of Central Tendency Measures of central tendency = typical or average score in a distribution Mean: arithmetic average of scores Median: score falling in the exact center Mode: most frequently occurring score Which most accurately depicts the typical?

21 XX 2.11

22 Descriptive Statistics: Variability Variability = how much scores vary from each other and from the mean Standard deviation = numerical depiction of variability High variability in data set = high standard deviation Low variability in data set = low standard deviation

23 XX 2.12

24 Descriptive Statistics: Correlation When two variables are related to each other, they are correlated. Correlation = numerical index of degree of relationship Correlation expressed as a number between 0 and 1 Can be positive or negative Numbers closer to 1 (+ or -) indicate stronger relationship

25 Figure 2.13 Positive and negative correlation

26 XX 2.14

27 Correlation: Prediction, Not Causation Higher correlation coefficients = increased ability to predict one variable based on the other SAT/ACT scores moderately correlated with first year college GPA 2 variables may be highly correlated, but not causally related Foot size and vocabulary positively correlated Do larger feet cause larger vocabularies? The third variable problem

28 XX 2.15

29 Inferential Statistics: Interpreting Data and Drawing Conclusions Hypothesis testing: do observed findings support the hypotheses? Are findings real or due to chance? Statistical significance = when the probability that the observed findings are due to chance is very low Very low = less than 5 chances in 100/.05 level Other factors might account for the results

30 Evaluating Research: Methodological Pitfalls Sampling bias Placebo effects is not always uniform cost factors and perceived pain Distortions in self-report data: Social desirability bias Response set Experimenter bias the double-blind solution Research protocol of clinical trial for drugs FDA in U.S.

31 XX 2.16

32 The Internet and Psychological Research Internet-mediated research refers to studies in which data collection occurs over the web. Possible Advantages Samples that are much larger and much more diverse than the samples typically used in laboratory research Have the potential to yield more diverse and representative samples Potential Disadvantages Sampling bias resulting from self-selection may be a more troublesome issue in Internet-mediated research Web users tend to be younger, brighter, and more affluent than nonusers Data are collected under far less controlled conditions than in traditional studies

33 Ethics in Psychological Research: Do the Ends Justify the Means? Tuskegee Syphilis Study: The question of deception The question of animal research Controversy among psychologists and the public Ethical standards for research: the American Psychological Association Ensures both human and animal subjects are treated with dignity

34 XX 2.17

35 Using databases to access research articles PsychINFO psychological literature present To access at UNA

36 Research Issues Critical Thinking Use of anecdotal evidence in psychology I have a friend who p Urban legends?