Using the media in tobacco and soda tax campaigns: the Mexico experience

Transcription

1 Using the media in tobacco and soda tax campaigns: the Mexico experience Luis Manuel Encarnación Cruz Member of the Mexico SaludHable Coalition Coordinator of the ContraPESO Coalition World Cancer Congress 2016 Paris

2 MEXICO SALUDHABLE COALITION Obesity Diabetes Cancer CVD Alcohol Renal diseases Many others >100 member organizations working on NCDs 4 main risk factors: Unhealthy diets Sedentarism Alcohol Tobacco TOBACCO TAX SUGARY DRINKS TAX

3 MEDIA CAMPAIGNS TARGETING DECISION-MAKERS WHO CAN BE YOUR AUDIENCE? - President - Key Ministers - Other government officials/agencies - Legislators - Political/interest groups - Parliamentary Leaders - Heads of relevant legislative committees KEY ELEMENTS OF YOUR MESSAGE - NAME YOUR TARGET - Include a concrete demand or call to action - Draft a concise message and in their language - Show the costs of inaction/wrong decision - Set the TONE OF THE DEBATE you want to lead - Be a step ahead! - Use of strategic media outlets (those that are relevant to them) - Analyze the perfect TIMING!! - Assure quick response - SUPPORT AND PRAISE YOUR ALLIES

4 WHY A TOBACCO TAX IN MEXICO? Tobacco consumption is the first cause of preventable death globally 21% of Mexicans smoke; 185 deaths every day related to tobacco use 10% of deaths by tobacco are on non-smokers (second-hand smoke) 30% of cancers in Mexico are related to tobacco use Tobacco taxes have not raised since 2011 (industry pressures). To some legislators, the tobacco industry is more important than you

5 TOBACCO TAX: POLICY OBJECTIVES Policy Goals: A $7 pesos increase tax on tobacco (Ad valorem + new fixed rate) Objectives: a) Raise awareness among consumers about the problems associated to tobacco consumption. b) Position the need of an increase in the tobacco tax in the political and media agenda c) Stigmatize tobacco and raise awareness of health harms and costs

6 TOBACCO TAX: Yes to the tobacco tax! Demonstration outside of the Chamber of Deputies (pressure those in charge) Demonstration in front of Philip Morris offices ( name and shame )

7 TOBACCO TAX: Yes to the tobacco tax! Online and Social Media Strategy: Development of web site online information system Key infographics placed on billboards and deliverables; as well as published in newspapers

8 TOBACCO TAX: OUTCOMES Policy wins: Approval of a fixed rate as part of the tobacco tax: ad valorem, fixed rate and other taxes now are 65% of price in total (excise + VAT) Stigmatization of tobacco industry and its products. Approval of a General Law on Tobacco Control (2008) Openness to strengthen tobacco control measures (taxes, packaging, etc). Pending issues: Assure an adjustment to inflation and increase it (75% according to the FCTC) Strengthen the fight on smoke-free environments countrywide Fight against industry actions on false allegations (illegal markets) Law enforcement

9 WHY AN SSBs TAX IN MEXICO? Nutrition transition: Mexico a global leader in SSB consumption; 70% of added sugar in the Mexican diet from SSBs Overweight and obesity: 1 in every 3 children and youth; 7 of every 10 adults Burden of disease: Diabetes one of the leading causes of death; 24,100 deaths each year from SSB consumption Collapse of Mexican productivity and the national health system Slide provided by El Poder del Consumidor (Mexico)

10 SSBs TAX: POLICY OBJECTIVES Policy Goals: A 2 peso per liter (20%) federal excise tax on SSBs starting in Earmark SSB tax revenue to obesity and chronic disease prevention, starting with the installation of water fountains in Mexican schools. Joint objectives: a) Promote an evidence-based tax: Health + Revenue + Future b) Create a strong, collective voice: a broad-based national alliance c) Stigmatize SSB and raise awareness of health harms and costs d) Position the topic and solution on the political and media agenda e) Find, inform and accompany our legislative champion(s) f) Convince the Executive and Congress of viability and feasibility g) Garner strong international, expert support and collaboration

11 SSBs TAX: MEDIA STRATEGY Framing of the lobbying and media strategy: Tax as a solution Obesity on the rise Congressmen need to act Balance of earned and paid media: Now is the perfect time! Name and shame strategy Revenue allocation Lobbying, advocacy and research

12 SSBs TAX: Who s side are you on? Objective: Compare health impact of SSBs VS water (awareness) Timing: During the beginning of the fiscal discussion Final audience: Both Chambers Objective: Show them who supports the tax (health-interested VS industry) Timing: During discussions on Committees (after approved in the lower Chamber) Final audience: Senators

13 SSBs TAX: Would you eat 12 full spoons of sugar? Public campaigns targeting SSB s and added sugar, to create awareness Public campaigns developed by the Alianza por la Salud Alimentaria (Nutritional Health Alliance) in Mexico.

14 SSBs TAX: OUTCOMES Policy wins: Strong partnership model (lobbying, advocacy and research) The difficult: social support for a tax (Fall 2013) The unbelievable: the tax was declared constitutional (Fall 2015) Defeat the undefeatable = industry twice (2013 and 2015) The Mexican tax becomes a global beacon with expert-advised, peerreviewed published research (INSP+UNC/BMJ) 6% (2014); 8% (2015); 11.1% (1 st semester 2016) Pending issues: Continue to stigmatize SSBs and increase the tax ($2 pesos or 20%) Defend tax against industry proposals to withdraw it or decrease it Further analysis on the short and longterm impacts/benefits Assure allocation of revenue to obesity prevention and potable water (mainly in schools) Put an end to the debate on its effectiveness Advocate for comprehensive obesity prevention

15 Luis Manuel Encarnación Cruz, BA INTA Member of the Mexico SaludHable Coalition Coordinator of the ContraPESO Coalition