Can a U.S. company own your genes? Patenting DNA is at the centre of US law controversy

Transcription

1 Page 1 of 10 VIEW ALL SITES NATIONAL LOCAL WATCH LIVE EVENT 18 minutes ago Watch live at 10:00 am EDT: Chris Hadfield s first press conference since returning from space TRENDING JODI ARIAS CHRIS HADFIELD B.C. VOTES TIM BOSMA ALBERTA PIPELINE CANADA May 15, 20133:47 pm Can a U.S. company own your genes? Patenting DNA is at the centre of US law controversy By Carmen ChaiGlobal News Post 7

2 Page 2 of 10 This Feb. 26, 2012 file photo shows actress Angelina Jolie at the 84th Academy Awards in the Hollywood section of Los Angeles. (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello, file) TORONTO Can a company own the rights to testing whether you carry mutated genes that increase your risk of breast cancer by 70 per cent? The blood test that helped Angelina Jolie decide to have a double mastectomy is conducted by only one American company in the U.S. This is because the company claims to own a patent on the two genes that offer valuable insight into a woman s risk of getting breast cancer. The simple blood test costs $3,430 in the United States. Myriad Genetics is the only company in America handling the testing. The company told Global News the patent extends into Canada and Europe. Read more: Breast cancer and genetics: Angelina Jolie s double mastectomy On Tuesday, Oscar-winning actress Angelina Jolie turned breast cancer into a household conversation after she announced she had a double mastectomy, acting preemptively once she learned she had a faulty BRCA1 gene. How does this patent affect Canadians?

3 Page 3 of 10 For the most part, the patent hasn t affected patients in Canada, according to Dr. Kelly Metcalfe, a University of Toronto professor and cancer prevention expert. We, in Canada, have provincial labs that are accredited to provide this testing in the clinical situation, Metcalfe said. It s important to recognize that this isn t a test that any woman in Canada can get. You do have to meet the criteria, Metcalfe said. The gene is a rarity, but if women have the harmful BRCA mutations, it can increase the odds of breast cancer by five times. In Canada, about one in 250 women carry the BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation that puts them at an 80 per cent risk of breast cancer. The average woman has an 11 per cent risk of breast cancer, Metcalfe said. Read more: Breast cancer and genetics: Angelina Jolie s double mastectomy The cost of genetic testing is covered in Canada if the specific gene mutation is already confirmed in your family. If women meet the criteria for testing, it s done for free and results are returned within three months. If women don t meet the requirements for testing, they are asked to head south of the border and pay the $3,430. Testing via Myriad Genetics takes about two weeks. Myriad Genetics confirmed that the patent extends into Canada but did not respond to questions regarding how the patent is enforced in Canada. In Canada, if you test positive for the gene and you chose a double mastectomy the cost of that surgery is covered. A controversy before the U.S. highest courts RELATED STORIES Angelina Jolie reveals she had double mastectomy Right now, Myriad Genetics is defending its patent to the U.S. Supreme Court after it was sued by a conglomerate of doctors, scientists and patients. ADVERTISEMENT

4 Page 4 of 10 They accuse the Utah-based company of illegitimately patenting a product of nature that s found in all men, women and children. The company claims to own the rights to any testing of the presence of these two mutated genes: BCRA1 and BCRA2. Both dramatically increase risk of breast and ovarian cancer. In enforcing this patent, the company has a monopoly over testing prices, Marguerite Ethier, an American- and Canadian-trained patent litigator, who practices in Toronto. She s an expert in medical genetics. The murky world of patenting human genes is hurting research and development, she said. There are very many companies that have sought and achieved patents on various targets that are important in biology and diagnostics, Ethier said, pointing to patents on the HIV sequence and even hepatitis C, for example. It is a real barrier to the ability of companies to bring diagnostics to market, in my experience. It s stood in the way of some very good therapies for patients. Kerry Bowman, a bioethicist at the University of Toronto, said the company s patent lies in the gene sequence, not in the gene itself. You re not patenting genes belonging to humans, but you re simply patenting the sequence, Bowman said. The fate of Myriad Genetics patent lies in the hands of the U.S. Supreme Court, though. Metcalfe said that the bottom line is consumers may be missing out on important testing that could save lives. I think the danger translates into a cost issue, she told Global News. To say you can t have that test because someone has a patent on it and as a result of having that patent, they re charging a lot more than it actually costs is concerning actually, she said.

5 Page 5 of 10 carmen.chai@globalnews.ca 949 followers ANGELINA JOLIE BREAST CANCER HEALTH CARE SERVICES Post 7 Carmen Chai Senior Web Coordinator Carmen Chai is a national reporter covering health and education for GlobalNews.ca. MORE STORIES HEALTH Gene test helps predict which prostate cancers need treatment, which men can safely be monitored Breast cancer and genetics: Angelina Jolie s double mastectomy Target opens doors: U.S. retailer a hit for some early-bird shoppers, a disappointment for others Q & A: Angelina Jolie's double mastectomy Langley teens families, friends raising funds for sophisticated sonar search of Nicola Lake Physical by smartphone becoming real possibility Alexa McDonough says she has breast cancer Montrealer fights to raise awareness after hereditary breast cancer hit close to home FBI releases photos of Boston Marathon bombing suspects Officials hold press conference on Boston bombing COMMENTS

6 Page 6 of 10 0 comments 0 Leave a message... Best Community Share # ADVERTISEMENT FEATURED CONTENT

7 Page 7 of 10 WEATHER Gallery: Texas tornado outbreak A swarm of tornadoes unleashed on North Texas Wednesday, levelling two neighbourhoods and leaving up to 250 people homeless. Continue reading CONSUMER Parents call for change after product sample nearly kills toddler A bag containing a Sunlight laundry pod sample was delivered to a Calgary family s home, and their 21-month-old daughter ended up swallowing it. She spent six days in hospital, hooked up to a respirator and feeding tubes. Continue reading

8 Page 8 of 10 CANADA Anti-piracy firm behind Canadian ISP lawsuit under fire for using images without permission The company at the centre of a lawsuit targeting Canadians who have illegally downloaded copyrighted content has come under fire for using photographer s images on its website without permission or compensation. Continue reading NEWS Tim Bosma: A timeline of the police investigation A massive search for a southern Ontario man who vanished more than a week ago came to a grim conclusion Tuesday when police announced his body had been found. Continue reading HIGHLIGHTS Gallery: Sketches made by witnesses of UFO sightings in Canada in 2012 UFO sightings in Canada reached an all-time high in 2012, according to an annual report. Here are some sketches made by witnesses of UFO sightings in Canada in Continue reading

9 Page 9 of 10 TWITTER 6 minutes ago Globalnews.ca 44 minutes ago Globalnews.ca 1 hour ago Globalnews.ca POPULAR NOW Parents call for change after product sample nearly kills toddler 4661 BC Election results 2013: BC Liberals secure a majority government 1358 Ethics commissioner reviewing Mike Duffy affair 1032 JUMP TO A REGION BC Edmonton Calgary Halifax

10 Page 10 of 10 Lethbridge New Brunswick Regina Toronto Montreal Okanagan Saskatoon Winnipeg CONNECT Facebook Twitter Google+ RSS GLOBAL NEWS About Us Privacy Policy Principles & Practices Terms & Conditions Contact Us Copyright Media Advertise Open Data Shaw Media Inc., All rights reserved.