Failure of Spill-Through Bridge Abutments during Scour: Flume and Field Observations
|
|
- Corey Johns
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Technical Note Failure of Spill-Through Bridge Abutments during Scour: Flume and Field Observations Robert Ettema, M.ASCE 1 ; Kam Ng, M.ASCE 2 ; Ram Chakradhar 3 ; Joshua Fuller 4 ; and Edward W. Kempema 5 Abstract: This paper presents early findings from laboratory tests and field observations on the failure of spill-through abutments subject to abutment scour. These findings show that geotechnical and hydraulic processes interact to erode embankment soil during abutment scour, producing lesser scour depths than predicted using leading abutment scour equations. A major failure location is the flow waterline beginning at an abutment s upstream corner where soil is exposed to the highest values of flow velocity and turbulence. Undercutting and toppling of soil blocks occurs sequentially along the face of the spill slope, eroding it back and eventually exposing the abutment column. Further erosion then may breach the embankment. The laboratory findings, based on uniform sand compacted to varying densities and thereby shear strengths, show that soil strength influences scour depth. DOI: /(ASCE)HY American Society of Civil Engineers. Introduction Spill-through abutments, a widely used form of bridge abutment, are prone to erode and fail during scour of bridged waterways [e.g., Ettema et al. (2010)]. They structurally comprise a compacted earth-fill embankment and an abutment column, which is enclosed by an earth-fill spill slope, and are usually located on floodplains or gently sloped channel banks as Fig. 1 illustrates. Although abutment scour has been extensively studied, the question of how spill-through abutments actually fail during scour has remained largely unaddressed. Prior studies focus largely on the depth and location of a scour hole formed near the toe of an abutment, but do not relate scour to abutment failure [e.g., Sturm et al. (2011) and Melville and Coleman (2000)]. This paper presents flume observations and data regarding abutment failure and shows that a prevalent failure mode has been largely overlooked: spill slope erosion along the abutments waterline, beginning at the upstream corner. It is also shown that abutment failure involves a combination of hydraulic and geotechnical processes that cause spill slope erosion and abutment scour to be influenced by the shear strength of the compacted earth fill forming the spill slope. Flume Tests Flume tests were conducted at the University of Wyoming using a 1:30 geometric-scale model of a spill-through abutment dimensioned for a standard two-lane road. Observations from the tests 1 Professor, Dept. of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Univ. of Wyoming, Laramie, WY 2071 (corresponding author). rettema@ uwyo.edu 2 Assistant Professor, Dept. of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Univ. 3 Graduate Student, Dept. of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Univ. 4 Graduate Student, Dept. of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Univ. 5 Research Scientist, Dept. of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Univ. Note. This manuscript was submitted on June 16, 2014; approved on December, 2014; published online on January 21, Discussion period open until June 21, 2015; separate discussions must be submitted for individual papers. This technical note is part of the Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,, ISSN / (5)/$ were compared with field observations of actual failed spill-through abutments. The scale-model abutment was located on a simulated erodible floodplain formed of compacted sand whose median particle diameter (d 50 ) and coefficient of uniformity (d 60 =d 10 ) were 0.70 mm and 2.7, respectively. All tests involved clear water scour conditions run in an 1.30-m-long by 2.44-m-wide flume, which included a 0.30-m-deep sediment recess upon which the model abutment was formed (Fig. 2). For each test the approach flow depth was set at 0.14 m and the flow adjusted so that the cross-section averaged bed shear stress relative to critical value for bed sediment entrainment was τ=τ c ¼ 0.0, with critical shear stress, τ c, determined using the Shields diagram [e.g., ASCE (2006), Chapter 2]. Two main series of laboratory tests were conducted: observations of spill-through abutment failure during scour and influence of abutment soil strength on scour depth. The tests used three model soils: a compacted uniform sand, a mix of 0% sand with 20% clay, and a weak, naturally occurring clayey sand. The same uniform sand was used for the model abutment soil as for the model floodplain. For the clayey sand, these variables were 0.40 mm and 175, respectively, while the 0% sand 20% clay mix had a distinctly bimodal distribution of particle sizes related to the uniform sand and clay particles used for the mix. Each model abutment was constructed with spill slope and side slope slopes of 1.5 horizontal to 1 vertical, as commonly used for actual abutments. Model soil was placed in layers that were compacted until the full height of the model was attained. The tests on soil strength influence concentrated particularly on uniform sand as the model soil whose as-built strength could be controlled via compaction, at least over a fairly narrow range. Additional exploratory tests on the influence of soil strength involved the two other model soils, although further research is needed to determine ways to better control and measure the shear strength of model soils used in scaled hydraulic models. For example, further investigation is needed on how clay type, particle grading, and moisture content can be manipulated to control model soil strength. Chakradhar (2014) and Fuller (2012) document the tests. Table 1 summarizes data from the tests. The duration of each test corresponded to the period needed for the spill slope to erode. As the erodible abutments eroded, the flow area increased at the abutment axis and scour ceased deepening. Because values of model soil strength vary with the model s length scale (ASCE 2000), the strengths of the model soil needed to be approximately 1/30th of the strengths of soils in geometrically full-scale abutments. Accordingly, the tests required a technique to
2 prepare, quantify, and control a range of reduced soil strengths for the model abutments. The technique entailed a direct-shear box to relate shear-strength and density values of compacted sand, and then used a needle penetrometer to relate penetration resistance to sand density and shear strength. The representative overall values of density and shear strength of sand compacted to form the model abutments in the flume were estimated using correlation relationships with penetration resistance measurements. For the model abutments formed of permeable compacted sand, the actual shear strength of soil had to be adjusted to take into account porewater pressure associated with the 0.14 m of water depth in the flume. The vertical effective soil stress at the abutment base is σv0 ¼ γh γ w Y Fig. 1. Spill-through bridge abutment on a floodplain (image by authors) ð1þ where H = height of abutment earth fill; Y = average flow depth; γ = unit weight of compacted soil; and γ w = unit weight of water. A small vane shear device was used to measure the shear strength of model abutments formed of clayey sand soil. A scale effect that aided the present tests using sand as model soil was the capillary action of water in sand. Surface tension within water and adhesion of water to sand elevated the water surface within the dry sand approximately 55 mm above the elevation of stationary water in the flume, coinciding with the estimated meniscus rise for water in a medium having 0.70-mm-diameter openings (Batchelor 167). Capillary rise contributed apparent cohesion to the behavior of sand in the zone of capillary rise (practically the full height of model abutment above the waterline), and thereby enabled wet sand exposed to air to stand with a vertical face and fail in blocks. The shear strength of sand in the capillary zone is estimated as τ ¼ σv0 tanðϕþ ¼ ½γz þ γ w ðd zþ tanðϕþ ¼ ðγ γ w Þz tanðϕþ þ Dγ w tanðϕþ Fig. 2. Layout and dimensions of the model abutment for the flume tests; the abutment, with an erodible nose formed of model soil, was built on a sediment recess located in the flume floor ð2þ where D = depth of the capillary zone (i.e., 55 mm); z = depth below the abutment s top; and ϕ = friction angle of the sand. Apparent cohesion altered the as-built strength of the model abutments formed of sand and caused the model abutment to behave as if it had a layer of weakly cohesive soil immediately above the waterline. The model abutments formed of compacted sand and sand-clay mix could therefore visually replicate the main failure processes associated with riverbank erosion. The clayey sand was much less permeable and did not exhibit the same extent of capillary rise during the relatively short duration of a test. Table 1. Summary of Laboratory Data Model spill-slope soil Sheet metal Compacted uniform sand 0% sand 20% clay mix Clayey sand Unit weight of compacted soil (kn=m3 ) Effective shear strength (kpa) Scour depth (cm) Typical toppled block width (cm) Run time (min)
3 For several of the tests the model abutment was armored with two layers of model riprap stone; the angular stone had an average diameter of 16 mm. To determine a benchmark scour depth associated with a nonerodible model abutment, a test was run with the model abutment clad with a sheet metal and fitted with a protective stone apron around its toe. This test ran until equilibrium scour depth occurred. Flume Observations Scour development and spill slope failure were observed in the flume for two situations: Failure of an unprotected spill slope, a situation that is analogous to erosion of a convex section of exposed river bank; and Failure of a riprap-protected spill slope, reflecting the usual situation for spill-through abutments. The progressive failures of the unprotected and riprap-protected spill slopes are depicted in Figs. 3 and 4, respectively. For both spill slope situations, scour began on the channel bed at the toe of the abutment s upstream corner. As scour developed it began to undercut spill slope soil immediately adjacent to the forming scour depression. Scour also began along the sandy floodplain at a location slightly downstream of the abutment s centerline. Flow field contraction and turbulence cause scour to begin at these locations [e.g., Sturm et al. (2011)]. However, immediately noticeable along the waterline at the upstream corner of each model abutment were swift flow velocities and energetic water-surface oscillation and turbulence associated with flow contraction and separation at the abutment s upstream corner. The unprotected spill slope began visibly eroding at its upstream corner [Fig. 3(a)] as flow hydraulically eroded the model soil and undercut the spill slope at the waterline. What subsequently unfolded was the progressive toppling of blocks of spill slope soil, such that the corner eroded back to form a vertical face along the front of the spill slope [Fig. 3(b)]. A recurring feature of spill slope failure was the appearance of tension cracking above each undercut block of abutment soil, and the action of gravity eventually caused soil blocks to rotate about a point at the water surface where undermining was greatest. Blocks toppling into the channel were quickly eroded by flowing water and exposed additional spill slope soil to undercutting. The observed erosion cycle was essentially the same as often described for eroding riverbanks [e.g., ASCE (2006), Chapter 7]. No circular failure surface was observed for the spill slopes. The cycle of undercutting, toppling, and spill slope erosion continued until the exposed face of the spill slope retreated to form a circular arc at the waterline [Fig. 3(b)]. Arc radius, r, approximately fitted the geometry recommended for rounded orifices and nozzles; e.g., for bell mouth nozzles, Brater and King (176) give r ¼ 1.63d, where d = nozzle diameter (or, in the present case, the waterway surface width across the downstream transect of the bridge). As the spill slope eroded, d increased and the arc flattened in curvature. The model spill slopes formed of sand-clay mixtures failed in much the same way as the spill slopes of uniform sand, except for two additional factors that complicated the tests. For the 0% sand 20% clay mix, flow around the abutment bled clay particles from the failure zone at the spill slope face, reducing model soil strength to essentially that of sand alone. The greater shear strength of the clayey sand model soil resulted in commensurately wider blocks of failed spill slope soil (Table 1 includes approximate measurements of the block widths observed) and toppled blocks did not erode as rapidly as did the sand blocks; consequently, the flow area at the abutment did not increase as rapidly as for the failed weaker abutments formed of sand. The model riprap-protected spill slopes formed of compacted sand began failing when flow velocities and water-surface oscillation cyclically shook riprap stone at the spill slope s upstream corner, causing gaps to open between riprap stones and spill slope soil to be winnowed from between the stones. Fig. 4(a) depicts the observed failure sequence, starting with the failure of riprap at the upstream corner, and resulting in erosion of the spill slope back along the bridge axis. Spill slope failure occurred largely at and above the waterline. As Fig. 4(b) shows, the spill slope remained practically intact below the waterline. Riprap stone eroded from spill slope deposited in sparse concentration over the bed closely downstream of the spill slope. Influence of Soil Strength The effective soil strengths mentioned herein are the values associated with the model abutments surrounded by water immediately prior to beginning a test. Abutment erodibility and soil strength influenced scour depth at the model abutments, although the strength of the model soil was difficult to control and measure immediately at the start of a test. Capillarity effects, along with the bleeding of clay particles from sand-clay mixtures and the different time rates of scour development on the channel bed Fig. 3. Erosion and failure of the compacted sand abutment without riprap protection: (a) erosion beginning along the waterline at the abutment s upstream corner; (b) the eroding spill slope assumed a bell mouth curvature
4 Fig. 4. Erosion and failure of the compacted sand abutment with protective riprap cover: (a) time series of overhead photos showing erosion progressing along the waterline of the abutment, starting at the abutment s upstream corner; (b) oblique view of the abutment in the drained flume showing erosion along the abutment s waterline (compare this figure to the eroded prototype abutment in Fig. 6) and geotechnical erosion of the model spill slope soil, complicated interpretation of the influence of soil strength. Fig. 5 presents the maximum scour depths versus the effective shear strengths associated with the abutments formed of the model soil. The main results are as follows: The scour depths obtained with the compacted, uniform sand embankments were approximately 25 to 40% of the depth obtained with the nonerodible abutment. For the lower values of shear strength the measured maximum scour depths were practically constant for the uniform sand owing to the difficulty of controlling the compaction of sand forming the spill slope. Only for the most densely compacted and stronger model embankments was the soil strength in the spill slope appreciably greater than that for the weaker model embankments. For the compacted, uniform sand abutments, the tests show a 40% increase in scour depth over an 0% increase in shear strength of the model soil. The data in Fig. 5 infer that additional increase in the strength of embankment soil would result in scour depth increases that trend upwards toward the scour depth obtained with the nonerodible abutment. For the three higher values of shear strength, spill slope erosion by means of undercutting and soil block toppling failure occurred more slowly, thereby causing the flow to scour the channel bed more deeply. Also, it was observed that greater undercutting of the spill slope could occur, resulting in somewhat larger distance from the eroding spill slope face to the tension cracks and thus toppling of larger sand blocks. Flow bled clay particles from the spill slopes formed of the 0% sand and 20% clay mix, and essentially reduced soil strength to that for the compacted sand. The resulting scour depths therefore were in the same range as those for the model abutments formed of compacted uniform sand. The scour depths obtained with abutments formed of the strongest model soil, the clayey sand, approached 65 to approximately 0% of the depth obtained with the erosion-resistant abutment, and they were larger than obtained with the abutments formed of weaker model soil. Field Observations Many field observations of failed abutments reflect the failure mode observed in these flume tests. Additionally, the reported scour
5 Fig. 5. Flume data on maximum scour depth versus effective shear strength of model soil at the beginning of an experiment; the dashed line indicates the scour depth for the nonerodible abutment formed of sheet metal; rapid erosion of clay from the 0% sand 20% clay mix caused this model soil to behave like the uniform sand Fig. 6. Field example of spill slope failure at a spill-through abutment at Cottonwood Creek, Wyoming; the riprap failed, causing the abutment s compacted earth fill to erode by undercutting and toppling and expose the abutment column; the failure appears similar to that shown in Fig. 4(b) (image courtesy of William Bailey, Wyoming Department of Transportation) depths often are relatively modest, as are those observed in the flume tests. A brief qualitative comparison of these flume and field observations is offered here. Fig. 6 depicts a representative example of a failed spill-through abutment, where the riprap stone failed at the waterline, causing the spill slope to begin eroding along the waterline and continue eroding back toward the abutment column; the riprap was notably large and resisted entrainment by water flow. The abutment was left with a vertical back face at the abutment column. There was little evidence of substantial scour in the channel adjoining the abutment. Conclusions Flume tests and field observations regarding the failure of spillthrough bridge abutments during scour are reported. The observations show how geotechnical and hydraulic processes interact to scour the channel or floodplain bed on which the abutment is situated and to erode the abutment s spill slope. Hydraulic erosion of the spill slope begins along the waterline at the spill slope s upstream corner and progressively undercuts spill slope soil, causing blocks of spill slope soil to topple. Soil strength affects the rate of undercutting and subsequent erosion of toppled blocks of soil. This failure process is similar to that often observed for riverbank erosion. More research is needed concerning several geotechnical and hydraulic aspects of abutment failure during scour, including research on countermeasures for protecting the upstream corner of spill slopes and on laboratory and hydraulic tests involving combined geotechnical and hydraulic processes such as bridge abutment failure. References ASCE. (2000). Hydraulic modeling: Concepts and practice, Manual of Practice 7, Reston, VA. ASCE. (2006). Sedimentation engineering: Processes, measurements, modeling and practice, Manual of Practice 110, Reston, VA. Batchelor, G. K. (167). An introduction to fluid dynamics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K. Brater, E. F., and King, H. W. (176). Handbook of hydraulics, 6th Ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, Chakradhar, R. (2014). Laboratory investigation of geotechnical and hydraulic influences during abutment scour. M.S. thesis, Univ. of Wyoming, Laramie, WY. Ettema, R., Nakato, T., and Muste, M. (2010). Estimation of scour depth at bridge abutments. National Cooperative Highway Research Program, Final Rep. for NCHRP Project 24-20, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC. Fuller, J. (2012). Observations of scour at spill-through abutments with erodible spillslopes. M.S. thesis, Univ. of Wyoming, Laramie, WY. Melville, B. W., and Coleman, S. E. (2000). Bridge scour, Water Resources Publications, Littleton, CO. Sturm, T. W., Ettema, R., and Melville, B. W. (2011). Evaluation of bridge scour research: Abutment and contraction scour processes and predictions. National Cooperative Highway Research Program, Final Rep. for NCHRP Project 24-27(02), Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC
Insights from Laboratory Experiments on the Failure of Earthen Embankments at Bridge-Waterway Abutments
Protections 2016 2 nd International Seminar on Dam Protection Against Overtopping ISBN: 978-1-1889143-27-9 DOI: Ft. Collins, Colorado, USA, 7-9 September 2016 ABSTRACT Insights from Laboratory Experiments
More informationIdentifying Number MPC-354. Project Title: Geotechnical Limit to Scour at Spill-through Abutments. University: The University of Wyoming
Identifying Number MPC-354 Project Title: Geotechnical Limit to Scour at Spill-through Abutments University: The University of Wyoming Principal Investigators: Robert Ettema PhD, PE College of Engineering
More informationAn Overview of Scour Types and Scour-Estimation Difficulties Faced at Bridge Abutments
An Overview of Scour Types and Scour-Estimation Difficulties Faced at Bridge Abutments Robert Ettema, Tatsuaki Nakato, and Marian Muste IIHR ~ Hydroscience and Engineering Department of Civil and Environmental
More informationBank Erosion and Bridge Scour
JULY 2017 NCHRP PRACTICE-READY SOLUTIONS FOR Bank Erosion and Bridge Scour NCHRP NATIONAL COOPERATIVE HIGHWAY RESEARCH PROGRAM RESEARCH TOPIC HIGHLIGHTS INTRODUCTION Bank Erosion and Bridge Scour: NCHRP
More informationMPC K. Ng, R. Ettema, E. Kempema, R. Chakradhar, and J. Fuller
MPC 15-280 K. Ng, R. Ettema, E. Kempema, R. Chakradhar, and J. Fuller Geotechnical Limit to Scour at Spill-through Bridge Abutments: Laboratory Investigation A University Transportation Center sponsored
More informationCHAPTER 11 APPENDIX D
OFFICE OF STRUCTURES STRUCTURE HYDROLOGY AND HYDRAULICS DIVISION CHAPTER 11 APPENDIX D SCOUR COUNTERMEASURES FOR PIERS AND ABUTMENTS MAY 2015 Maryland SHA Office of Structures, Chapter 11, Appendix D May2015Page
More informationCounty of Orange. Presented to the Flood Division August 13, 2001 by Nadeem Majaj
Using HECRAS TO Evaluate Scour At Bridges County of Orange Presented to the Flood Division August 3, 200 by Nadeem Majaj Approximately 575,000 bridges are built over waterways in the US. The most common
More informationNCHRP REPORT (2)
National Cooperative Highway Research Program NCHRP REPORT 4-5 () ABUTMENT SCOUR IN COHESIVE MATERIALS J.-L. Briaud, H.-C. Chen, K.-A Chang, S. J. Oh, X. Chen October 009 Transportation Research Board
More informationTwo-Dimensional Computer Modeling of Pomme de Terre River at Highways 12 and 22 in Minnesota
Two-Dimensional Computer Modeling of Pomme de Terre River at Highways 12 and 22 in Minnesota Kamal Saffarinia 1, G. Kenneth Young 2, J. Sterling Jones 3, and Stuart Stein 4 This paper investigates two-dimensional
More informationEAH 422 ADVANCED WATER RESOURCES ENGINEERING
EAH 422 ADVANCED WATER RESOURCES ENGINEERING Bridge Hydraulics Prof. Aminuddin Ab. Ghani References The Art And Science Of River Engineering Bridge Failure Pier scour Pier scour Pier scour Bridge Failure
More informationABSCOUR 9 USERS MANUAL
OFFICE OF STRUCTURES BRIDGE SCOUR PROGRAM CHAPTER 11 APPENDIX A ABSCOUR 9 USERS MANUAL PART 1: DERIVATION OF METHODOLOGY APRIL 2011 Preface ABSCOUR 9, Build 2.3 is the current version of this program as
More informationToe protection for spill-through and vertical-wall abutments
Journal of Hydraulic Research Vol. 48, No. 4 (2010), pp. 491 498 doi:10.1080/00221686.2010.492106 # 2010 International Association for Hydro-Environment Engineering and Research Research paper Toe protection
More informationProtecting Vertical-Wall Abutments with Riprap Mattresses
Protecting Vertical-Wall Abutments with Riprap Mattresses António H. Cardoso 1 and Cristina M. S. Fael, Ph.D. 2 Abstract: This study addresses the design of riprap mattresses as a scour countermeasure
More informationEVALUATION OF ABUTMENT-SCOUR EQUATIONS FROM NCHRP PROJECTS 24-15(2) AND USING LABORATORY AND FIELD DATA NCHRP 24-20(2)
NATIONAL COOPERATIVE HIGHWAY RESEARCH PROGRAM DRAFT FINAL REPORT EVALUATION OF ABUTMENT-SCOUR EQUATIONS FROM NCHRP PROJECTS 24-15(2) AND 24-20 USING LABORATORY AND FIELD DATA NCHRP 24-20(2) Stephen T.
More informationPRELIMINARY GEOTECHNICAL DESIGN
PNCC Manawatu River Pedestrian/ Cycle Bridge PRELIMINARY GEOTECHNICAL DESIGN 1 Introduction Opus has been commissioned by the Palmerston North City Council (PNCC) to prepare a Detailed Business Case (DBC)
More informationSEEPAGE ANALYSIS OF TWO CASE HISTORIES OF PIPING INDUCED BY EXCAVATIONS IN COHESIONLESS SOILS
ICCI2004, The First International Conference on Construction IT, Beijing, CHINA, August 12 th - 14 th SEEPAGE ANALYSIS OF TWO CASE HISTORIES OF PIPING INDUCED BY EXCAVATIONS IN COHESIONLESS SOILS Cai,
More informationDraft. Not yet Approved. Natural Waterways 2012
Natural Waterways 2012 3.1 General 1 3 5 3.1.1 Scope (2012) 1 3 5 3.1.2 Importance (1992) R(2012) 1 3 5 3.2 Hydrologic Capacity of Waterway Openings1 1 3 5 3.2.1 General (2012) 1 3 5 3.2.2 Drainage Basin
More informationEXPERIMENTAL STUDY ON RIPRAP PROTECTION OF VERTICAL- WALL ABUTMENTS
1 EXPERIMENTAL STUDY ON RIPRAP PROTECTION OF VERTICAL- WALL ABUTMENTS Cristina Maria Sena Fael (1), António Heleno Cardoso (2) (1) Department of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Universidade da Beira
More informationAssessing potential cracking zones in embankment dams
Southern Cross University epublications@scu 23rd Australasian Conference on the Mechanics of Structures and Materials 2014 Assessing potential cracking zones in embankment dams Ke He University of New
More informationDATA GATHERING AND DESIGN DETAILS OF AN INTEGRAL ABUTMENT BRIDGE
DATA GATHERING AND DESIGN DETAILS OF AN INTEGRAL ABUTMENT BRIDGE Abstract S. Hassiotis M. ASCE Stevens Institute of Technology, Hoboken, N.J. 07030 sophia.hassiotis@stevens.edu An integral-abutment bridge
More informationMatrix (Partially Grouted) Riprap Lab Flume Study
Matrix (Partially Grouted) Riprap Lab Flume Study Jeffrey D. G. Marr, Principal Investigator St. Anthony Falls Laboratory University of Minnesota April 2015 Research Project Final Report 2015-15 To request
More informationScour at Contracted Bridges
NCHRP Web-Only Document 83 (Project 24-14): Contractor s Final Report and Appendix A Scour at Contracted Bridges Prepared for: National Cooperative Highway Research Program Submitted by: C.R. Wagner, D.S.
More informationUNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO CRANE LAKE ROAD OVER HAWKINSON CREEK ST. LOUIS COUNTY
UNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO. 7883 CRANE LAKE ROAD OVER HAWKINSON CREEK ST. LOUIS COUNTY JUNE 21, 2012 PREPARED FOR THE MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION BY COLLINS ENGINEERS,
More informationAPPENDIX H. Limit Equilibrium Analysis of Dike 1 Abutments Prior to Failure
APPENDIX H Limit Equilibrium Analysis of Dike 1 Abutments August 25, 2016 Appendix H Limit Equilibrium Analysis of Dike 1 Abutments TABLE OF CONTENTS H1 INTRODUCTION... 1 H2 ENGINEERING PROPERTIES OF THE
More informationEffects of Contraction Length on Abutment Scour
Proceedings of 2013 IHR World ongress Effects of ontraction Length on butment Scour Xiaozhou Xiong Ph student, uckland University, uckland 1142, New Zealand. Email: xxia529@aucklanduni.ac.nz ruce W. Melville
More informationEVALUATION OF FIELD PERFORMANCE OF PREFABRICATED VERTICAL DRAINS (PVD) FOR SOIL GROUND IMPROVEMENT IN THE SOUTHERN VIETNAM
EVALUATION OF FIELD PERFORMANCE OF PREFABRICATED VERTICAL DRAINS (PVD) FOR SOIL GROUND IMPROVEMENT IN THE SOUTHERN VIETNAM Hoang-Hung Tran-Nguyen 1, Huong L.T. Ho 2, Hy H. Ha 2 1 Assistant Professor, Department
More informationNumerical investigation of the turbulent flow around a bridge abutment
River Flow 2006 Ferreira, Alves, Leal & Cardoso (eds) 2006 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 0-415-40815-6 Numerical investigation of the turbulent flow around a bridge abutment A. Teruzzi & F. Ballio
More informationSTRUCTURAL STABILITY ASSESSMENT
STRUCTURAL STABILITY ASSESSMENT CFR 257.73(d) Fly Ash Pond Big Sandy Plant Louisa, Kentucky October, 2016 Prepared for: Kentucky Power Big Sandy Plant Louisa, Kentucky Prepared by: American Electric Power
More informationUNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO th STREET OVER THE ZUMBRO RIVER CITY OF ROCHESTER
UNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO. 89188 7 th STREET OVER THE ZUMBRO RIVER CITY OF ROCHESTER OCTOBER 2, 2012 PREPARED FOR THE MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION BY COLLINS ENGINEERS,
More informationPermanent deformation of bridge abutment on liquefiable soils
Permanent deformation of bridge abutment on liquefiable soils Akihiro TAKAHASHI 1, Hideki SUGITA 1 & Shunsuke TANIMOTO 1 ABSTRACT Seismic response of a bridge abutment located near a river dyke is the
More informationSeismic Response of Piled Bridge Abutments in Multi-Layered Liquefiable Soils Deposits
6 th International Conference on Earthquake Geotechnical Engineering 1-4 November 2015 Christchurch, New Zealand Seismic Response of Piled Bridge Abutments in Multi-Layered Liquefiable Soils Deposits D.
More informationa.the Vetiver Network International b.vietnam Vetiver Network
Presented at the Southern African Association of Geomorphology (SAAG) 2017 Conference, 25-28 July 2017, Swaziland APPLICATION OF VETIVER SYSTEM TECHNOLOGY FOR RIVERBANK AND COASTAL DIKE STABILISATION IN
More informationSEPTEMBER, 2006 ROAD DESIGN MANUAL 7-0(1) CHAPTER 7 PAVEMENT DESIGN
SEPTEMBER, 2006 ROAD DESIGN MANUAL 7-0(1) CHAPTER 7 PAVEMENT DESIGN 7-1.0 INTRODUCTION 7-2.0 RIGID PAVEMENT DESIGN 7-2.01 Cross Sections 7-2.02 Ramps and Loops with Storage Area 7-2.03 Major Forks, Branch
More informationv Feature Stamping SMS 13.0 Tutorial Prerequisites Requirements Map Module Mesh Module Scatter Module Time minutes
v. 13.0 SMS 13.0 Tutorial Objectives Learn how to use conceptual modeling techniques to create numerical models which incorporate flow control structures into existing bathymetry. The flow control structures
More informationMONTANA FLUME. User s Manual. Montana (Short Parshall) Flume User s Manual
MONTANA FLUME User s Manual i Montana (Short Parshall) Flume User s Manual TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction to the Montana Flume... 1 Function... 1 Design... 1 Standards... 2 Accuracy... 3 Dimensions...
More informationNumerical analysis of the embedded abutments of integral bridges
Numerical analysis of the embedded abutments of integral bridges Ming XU Researcher, Dept. of Civil & Env. Engrg., University of Southampton, UK Summary Alan G. BLOODWORTH Lecturer, Dept. of Civil & Env.
More informationVETIVER SYSTEM FOR BRIDGE APPROACH STABILISATION
VETIVER SYSTEM FOR BRIDGE APPROACH STABILISATION Dr. Paul Truong - TVNI Technical Director, Brisbane, Australia. All materials in this document remain the property of TVNI. Permission must be obtained
More informationIntegral Abutment Bridges-Development of Soil Model for Soil Structure Interaction in Time History Analysis
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development e-issn: 2278-067X, p-issn: 2278-800X, www.ijerd.com Volume 10, Issue 3 (March 2014), PP.31-40 Integral Abutment Bridges-Development of Soil
More informationThe Structure upon which the ends of a Bridge rests is referred to as an Abutment
ABUTMENTS The Structure upon which the ends of a Bridge rests is referred to as an Abutment The most common type of Abutment Structure is a Retaining Wall, Although other types of Abutments are also possible
More informationIntegral Bridge Design - Derivation of the Spring Constant for Modelling the Soil-Structure Interaction
Integral Bridge Design - Derivation of the Spring Constant for Modelling the Soil-Structure Interaction Sergei Terzaghi BE(Hons), MIPENZ Gillian Sisk BEng PhD MIEI CEng Synopsis Integral bridges present
More informationFlume Installation Instructions
Flume Installation Instructions To ensure a successful installation, it is important to keep the following points in mind: 1) There should be no bend, dips, elbows, or flow junction immediately upstream
More informationEngineering characterization of Vetiver system for shallow slope stabilization
Engineering characterization of Vetiver system for shallow slope stabilization Apiniti Jotisankasa T. Sirirattanachat, C. Rattana-areekul, K. Mahannopkul, J. Sopharat* Kasetsart University, *Prince of
More informationIntroduction. Substructure Inspection and Rating. Introduction. Introduction 28/03/2017
Introduction Substructure Inspection and Rating That portion of the bridge located below the bearings Abutments Piers Rated separately Purpose is to: Receive the loads from the superstructure Transfer
More informationUNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO CSAH NO. 4 OVER THE CLEARWATER RIVER (DAM) DISTRICT 2 - CLEARWATER COUNTY
UNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO. 4992 CSAH NO. 4 OVER THE CLEARWATER RIVER (DAM) DISTRICT 2 - CLEARWATER COUNTY PREPARED FOR THE MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION BY COLLINS ENGINEERS,
More informationDESIGN CONSIDERATIONS AND ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF NEAR FREEZING SOIL TEMPERATURES ON SOIL COMPACTION
DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS AND ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF NEAR FREEZING SOIL TEMPERATURES ON SOIL COMPACTION by Michael L. Whelan and Sandy Snider Stahl Department of Civil and Architectural Engineering University
More informationPerformance of Vetiver Grass in Protecting Embankments on the Bangladesh Coast against Cyclonic Tidal Surge
5 th National Conference on Coastal and Estuarine Habitat Restoration Preparing for Climate Change: Science, Practice, and Policy Performance of Vetiver Grass in Protecting Embankments on the Bangladesh
More informationMonitored Displacements of a Unique Geosynthetic-Reinforced Walls Supporting Bridge and Approaching Roadway Structures
Abu-Hejleh, N., Zornberg, J.G., and Wang, T. (). Monitored Displacements of a Unique Geosynthetic-Reinforced Walls Supporting Bridge and Approaching Roadway Structures. Proceedings of the 8th Annual Meeting,
More informationASD and LRFD of Reinforced SRW with the use of software Program MSEW(3.0)
ASD and LRFD of Reinforced SRW with the use of software Program MSEW(3.0) Dov Leshchinsky [A slightly modified version of this manuscript appeared in Geosynthetics (formerly GFR), August 2006, Vol. 24,
More informationEFFECT OF BACKFILL SOIL TYPE ON STIFFNESS AND CAPACITY OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS
EFFECT OF BACKFILL SOIL TYPE ON STIFFNESS AND CAPACITY OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS A. Bozorgzadeh 1, S. A. Ashford 2, and J. I. Restrepo 3 1 PhD, Structural Engineering, Moffatt and Nichol Inc, Walnut creek, CA,
More informationLow-Volume Road Abutment Design Standards
Low-Volume Road Abutment Design Standards V.W. Robbins HNTB Corporation 7450 W. 130th St., Suite 400 Overland Park, KS 66213 vrobbins@hntb.com F. Wayne Klaiber Bridge Engineering Center 418 Town Engineering
More informationMBW3-45 ELR: No coring surveys have been found for this structure. There are no records of any previous inspections of the structure.
Scour Assessment Report Location Plan: Scale 1:5,000 MBW3-45 Score: 16.86 ELR: Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2010 Category: HIGH Assessment Date: 19/11/2010 Contract:
More informationUNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO CSAH 24 OVER HAWKINSON CREEK ST. LOUIS COUNTY
UNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO. 7685 CSAH 24 OVER HAWKINSON CREEK ST. LOUIS COUNTY JUNE 21, 2012 PREPARED FOR THE MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION BY COLLINS ENGINEERS, INC. JOB
More informationScour development and sediment motion at rectangular and trapezoidal abutments
Scour development and sediment motion at rectangular and trapezoidal abutments A. Radice *, F. Ballio *, V. Armenio ** and S. Franzetti * * Politecnico di Milano, Dept. I.I.A.R., Milan, Italy ** Università
More informationEffect of Pile Orientation in Skewed Integral Abutment Bridges
Effect of Pile Orientation in Skewed Integral Abutment Bridges RABIH NAJIB, Ph.D., PE, Alpha Corporation, Baltimore, Maryland and AMDE M. AMDE, Ph.D., PE, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland
More informationAppendix B. Shallow Foundations Report
12/10/2013 GEOTECHNICAL MANUAL Appendix B. Shallow Foundations Report PLEASE NOTE A sample foundations report is included here for reference. It is provided as an example of content, format, and organization
More informationFeature Stamping SURFACE WATER MODELING SYSTEM. 1 Introduction. 2 Opening a Background Image
SURFACE WATER MODELING SYSTEM Feature Stamping 1 Introduction In this lesson you will learn how to use conceptual modeling techniques to create numerical models that incorporate flow control structures
More informationFigure 3: Analytic procedure
International Journal of Scientific and Research ublications, Volume 7, Issue 5, May 2017 567 Investigation of Integral Bridge Effect under Dynamic Loading Haymanmyintmaung *,kyawlinnhtat ** * Department
More informationCavitation. Cameron Fritz, John Glover, Maia Griswold
Cavitation Cameron Fritz, John Glover, Maia Griswold CIVE 401, Hydraulic Engineering Dr. P.Y. Julien November 19, 2014 Table of Contents Introduction Page 1 Theory Page 2 Failures Page 5 Prevention Page
More informationEFFECTS OF SPATIAL VARIATION OF SEISMIC INPUTS ON BRIDGE LONGITUDINAL RESPONSE
13 th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering Vancouver, B.C., Canada August 1-6, 24 Paper No. 64 EFFECTS OF SPATIAL VARIATION OF SEISMIC INPUTS ON BRIDGE LONGITUDINAL RESPONSE Jiachen WANG 1, Athol
More informationBridge Office Trunk Highway Bridge Flood Response Plan
Bridge Office Trunk Highway Bridge Flood Response Plan Updated 7/18/2012 Purpose Bridges are vulnerable to damage and failure during flooding. Scour may undermine the bridge foundations or remove the protection
More informationDESIGN ASSESSMENT OF THE FOUNDERS/MEADOWS GRS ABUTMENT STRUCTURE
Abu-Hejleh, N., Zornberg, J.G., Elias, V., and Watcharamonthein, J. (23). Design Assessment of the Founders/Meadows GRS Abutment Structure. Proceedings of the 82nd Annual Meeting of the Transportation
More informationConditional assessment of Kiri Bridge in Shkoder, Albania
Conditional assessment of Kiri Bridge in Shkoder, Albania Gentian Rexhaj 1, Enea Mustafaraj 2 1 2 Department of Civil Engineering, Epoka University, Albania 2 Department of Civil Engineering, Epoka University,
More information2011 BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT
2011 BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT BYRD PARK PUMP STATION BRIDGE OVER KANAWHA CANAL April 2011 FINAL December 2011 Looking - from Abutment B to Abutment A Prepared by: WHITMAN, REQUARDT, & ASSOCIATES, LLP 9030
More informationv Feature Stamping SMS 12.0 Tutorial Prerequisites Requirements TABS model Map Module Mesh Module Scatter Module Time minutes
v. 12.0 SMS 12.0 Tutorial Objectives In this lesson will teach how to use conceptual modeling techniques to create numerical models that incorporate flow control structures into existing bathymetry. The
More informationIntegral Abutment Bridge Design with Soil Structure Interaction
Integral Abutment Bridge Design with Soil Structure Interaction Thursday, May 11, 2017 3:00 PM 4:00 PM EST Speaker Engineer: Suthichai Saelim Project Location WESTBOROUGH Railroad HOPKINTON Project Location
More informationCHAPTER 5 MODELING OF THE BRIDGE
62 CHAPTER 5 MODELING OF THE BRIDGE 5.1 MODELING SAP2000, a nonlinear software package was used for modeling and analysing the study bridge. The following list provides details about the element type used
More informationUsing the sharp-crested weir formula the outflow was:
Date: 2009 July 16 11:00 AM 14 Island Lake Dam Inspection Report Persons Present: Bryon Keene, P.Eng. Harry Stinson Brett Dark (14 Island Lake Association) Peter Peart (14 Island Lake Association) The
More information\\H\15\ PH9 Inspection Photos
SHOP SLIDE Photo 1. at cracking across the footpath at the end of the Hwy 2 EB to Hwy 684 SB off ramp at the 99 Ave. intersection. Drop in asphalt trail (background) has worsened since 2013 and is now
More informationRESFARCH REsuLiis DiGEsT
MOM coop RESFARCH REsuLiis DiGEsT These Digesns are issued in the interest of prosiding an early awareness of the research results emanating from projects in the NCHRP. By making these results known as
More informationEarthquake Resistance of Bridges With Friction Slab Abutments
Earthquake Resistance of s With Friction Slab Abutments J. H. Wood John Wood Consulting, Lower Hutt. ABSTRACT: 2010 NZSEE Conference Findings from experimental and numerical research on the force resistance
More informationGrade separated interchange at the intersection of U.S. Hwy 17 Bypass and Farrow Parkway
Grade separated interchange at the intersection of U.S. Hwy 17 Bypass and Farrow Parkway Jeff Sizemore, P.E. Geotechnical Design Support Engineer SCDOT Ed Tavera, P.E. Principal Geotechnical Engineer Geoengineers
More informationSTONY PLAIN REGION GEOHAZARD RISK ASSESSMENT SITE INSPECTION FORM HIGHWAY AND KM: Hwy 621:02, km 16.39
SITE NUMBER AND NAME: NC 52 Pembina River Bridge LEGAL DESCRIPTION: SE 1-50-9-W5M STONY PLAIN REGION GEOHAZARD RISK ASSESSMENT SITE INSPECTION FORM HIGHWAY AND KM: Hwy 621:02, km 16.39 NAD 83 COORDINATES:
More informationAN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION ON BEHAVIOR OF RC PARAPET WALL OF ABUTMENT UNDER COLLISION
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET) Volume 9, Issue 9, September 2018, pp. 1831 1838, Article ID: IJCIET_09_09_177 Available online at http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?jtype=ijciet&vtype=9&itype=9
More informationIntegral bridges and environmental conditions
Integral bridges and environmental conditions COMISU CLAUDIU-CRISTIAN, BOACĂ GHEORGHITĂ Department of Roads and Foundations Faculty of Civil Engineering and Building Services The "Gheorghe Asachi" Technical
More informationPillar Abutment Loading New Concepts for Coal Mining Industry
University of Wollongong Research Online Coal Operators' Conference Faculty of Engineering and Information Sciences 2 Pillar Abutment Loading New Concepts for Coal Mining Industry David Hill Golder Associates
More informationUNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO CSAH NO. 6 OVER A BRANCH OF THE CALDWELL CREEK DISTRICT 1 - KOOCHICHING COUNTY
UNDERWATER BRIDGE INSPECTION REPORT STRUCTURE NO. 36508 CSAH NO. 6 OVER A BRANCH OF THE CALDWELL CREEK DISTRICT 1 - KOOCHICHING COUNTY PREPARED FOR THE MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION BY COLLINS
More informationFINAL COVER SYSTEM SURFACE WATER MANAGEMENT SYSTEM DESIGN
DRAFT ONONDAGA LAKE SEDIMENT CONSOLIDATION AREA CIVIL & GEOTECHNICAL FINAL DESIGN BBAPPENDIX K. FINAL COVER SYSTEM SURFACE WATER MANAGEMENT SYSTEM DESIGN p:\honeywell -syr\ - lake detail design\ reports\.
More informationA Tale of Two Bridges: Comparison between the Seismic Performance of Flexible and Rigid Abutments
A Tale of Two Bridges: Comparison between the Seismic Performance of Flexible and Rigid Abutments A.M. Morsy. Department of Civil, Architectural, and Environmental Engineering, The University of Texas
More informationClay Sewer Pipe-Joint Infiltration Leak-Rate Testing
Clay Sewer Pipe-Joint Infiltration Leak-Rate Testing 1. ABSTRACT While numbers of small to large older cities are undertaking repairs and maintenance, several other newer cities are planning on installing
More informationThe UCD community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters!
Provided by the author(s) and University College Dublin Library in accordance with publisher policies., Please cite the published version when available. Title Reduction of lateral loads in abutments using
More informationHydrau-Tech, Inc. Engineering & Software
Hydrau-Tech, Inc. Engineering & Software HYDRAU-TECH, INC. H ydrau-tech, Inc. is an engineering consulting firm specializing since 1986 in openchannel hydraulics, watershed, river, and reservoir sedimentation,
More informationBengt H. Fellenius. Wick Drains and Piling for Cai Mep Container Port, Vietnam, and the true cost of 5 cent per foot. Amsterdam.
Wick Drains and Piling for Cai Mep Container Port, Vietnam, and the true cost of 5 cent per foot Bengt H. Fellenius Amsterdam May 27, 216 Fellenius, B.H. and Nguyen, M.H., 213. Wick Drains and Piling for
More informationEarthquake Design of Bridges With Integral Abutments
6 th International Conference on Earthquake Geotechnical Engineering 1-4 November 2015 Christchurch, New Zealand Earthquake Design of Bridges With Integral Abutments J. H. Wood 1 ABSTRACT Because of the
More informationFlaw Assessment Using Shear wave Phased array Ultrasonic Transducer
18th World Conference on Nondestructive Testing, 16-20 April 2012, Durban, South Africa Flaw Assessment Using Shear wave Phased array Ultrasonic Transducer Byungsik YOON AUTHOR 1, Hee-Jong LEE CO-AUTHOR
More informationThree Bridges at I-64/Mercury Boulevard Interchange in Hampton, VA
Three Bridges at I-64/Mercury Boulevard Interchange in Hampton, VA IRFAN A. ALVI, P.E., Alvi Associates, Inc., Baltimore, MD IBC-02-25 KEYWORDS: box girder, counterweight abutment, curved girder, high-performance
More informationFiled: , EB , Exhibit B, Tab 1, Schedule 1, Attachment 3, Page 1 of 8
Filed: 2018-07-04, EB-2018-0108, Exhibit B, Tab 1, Schedule 1, Attachment 3, Page 1 of 8 Stantec Consulting Ltd. 300-675 Cochrane Drive West Tower Markham ON L3R 0B8 Tel: (905) 944-7777 Fax: (905) 474-9889
More informationGeosynthetic-reinforced soil bridge abutments
Geosynthetic-reinforced soil bridge abutments Measuring the performance of geosynthetic reinforcement in a Colorado bridge structure. By Jorge G. Zornberg, Naser Abu-Hejleh, and Trever Wang The technology
More informationPotential For Fracture To Occur In Iowa DOT Steel Girder Bridges Due to Triaxial Constraint
Potential For Fracture To Occur In Iowa DOT Steel Girder Bridges Due to Triaxial Constraint Introduction The purpose of this white paper is to provide information regarding the potential for fractures
More informationDynamic Hollow Cylinder System Proposal
Dynamic Hollow Cylinder System Proposal from Wykeham Farrance Limited Weston Road Slough SL1 4HW England Tel:+44 (0)1753 571241 Fax: +44 (0)1753 811313 E-mail: sales@wfi.co.uk Advanced Soils Testing 2
More informationMEASUREMENT OF SCOUR IN BRIDGE PIERS AND ABUTMENTS
MEASUREMENT OF SCOUR IN BRIDGE PIERS AND ABUTMENTS By S.K. Mazumder Individual Consultant, ICT Pvt. Ltd., New-Delhi (Formerly AICTE Emeritus Professor of Civil Engineering, Delhi College of Engineering
More informationThermal Response of Integral Abutment Bridges With Mechanically Stabilized Earth Walls
Thermal Response of Integral Abutment Bridges With Mechanically Stabilized Earth Walls http://www.virginiadot.org/vtrc/main/online_reports/pdf/13-r7.pdf ALFREDO E. ARENAS, Ph.D. Graduate Research Assistant
More informationCRITICAL STATE BEHAVIOR OF AN UNSATURATED SILTY SAND
Six th International Conference of Seismology and Earthquake Engineering 16-18 May 2011 Tehran, Iran CRITICAL STATE BEHAVIOR OF AN UNSATURATED SILTY SAND M. Maleki 1, M. Bayat 2 1 Associate Professor,
More informationFour simply supported steel plate girders (appear to be an old railcar).
BRIDGE INSPECTION BRIDGE NO./NAME N4-005: Akolkolex Crawford FSR (19.0 km) Inspection Date: September 22 nd, 2012 Inspected By: M. Hanson, R. Veitch Year Built: 1982 Number of Spans: 1 Span Lengths: Superstructure
More informationNCAT Report Comparing Friction Reducers for Use in AMPT Testing. By Adam Taylor, P.E. Nam Tran, Ph.D., P.E., LEED GA
NCAT Report 15-01 Comparing Friction Reducers for Use in AMPT Testing By Adam Taylor, P.E. Nam Tran, Ph.D., P.E., LEED GA April 2015 1. Report No. NCAT Report No. 15-01 4. Title and Subtitle Comparing
More informationExecutive Summary RPT-GEN November 28. Bridge No Quartz Creek Bridge Inspection Report
Executive Summary The No. 01607 carries the Trans-Canada Highway over Quartz Creek, approximately 45 km northwest of Golden, BC. As part of an Enhanced Bridge Inspection Program, the BC Ministry of Transportation
More informationRetrofit to improve earthquake performance of bridge abutment slopes
Proceedings of the Ninth Pacific Conference on Earthquake Engineering Building an Earthquake-Resilient Society 14-16 April, 2011, Auckland, New Zealand Retrofit to improve earthquake performance of bridge
More informationHard Hat Services ph: hardhatinc.com 932 N. Wright St., Suite 160 Naperville, IL 60563
Interstate Power and Light Company Burlington Generation Station CCR Surface Impoundment Annual Inspection Report 154.018.012.001 Report issued: December 21, 2016 Hard Hat Services ph: 877-630-7428 hardhatinc.com
More information